Mangat Ram @ Manga v. State Of Punjab & ORS




  
  

 !"#"$%&' ( $)

*+( $) ,

-#.# /

.$0 1 2# , #3$ $  (%  45(  /
///   45(  /
 //


#$ % (#2.3"$ 

67 . 8 9!

 2 "$ (# . .$08 68 .$0 1 2/

 ::: /// $8 23 "$( $)

*+( $) 1;< ; 23#$ "$ .$   "!6   2 $# .

"$ 
$ "

 #=# #

"$)

#"   2  

    >$$?. @A 3 ##  1; "#  (

 >#3$ $  A <21; #"? <=# 63 ; 1; "$2 #1$0!

  23 "$2 #1$!$9"!

 1; 26 $  "

"$ 6 /##"$#. )8

$C 2$!#.$ /!

"$# @EDC
$ "

6 >F
4G#2 AH1#" #8/!

"$C

 "$  2"6 $ * /?.

6 $!# !

8  >F /  !

4G#2 A2 #1$#$ $!  .$ )6""*3"#$*$

6# 3 ;  "$  2 3

 3#$  "# .$ )"$) 2"# 6" "*3"#$*$

"#  "68/"(.= # / 2"1) "$# 2# "   !$9"!

$ #$ $!8 !"*"$ 6 6" @'@ 2 #1$"6 1; "$<2"!2"#3$ "$)"$ 2"#. 

IJ ."$) 3$ $!;  68 336"   #"?<=#3 6 * 2"# *"6;**1#<2"!22 #1$ !6"$  1; 2 "*3.)$   

    >$$?. @A  2 # "   8 6 ;$ "! 8"# ## "6 "$ 23#$ 3 "$

36;2 #1$"6 1;< ; "

9"

/* 
#2 7 6"

"#  (

 >#3$ $  A 
 "# #.1*"

#3$ $   !"9  6

 ''K

  '& * /.3"$ $ $ 8"#  "6/"(.= # / 2"1"$<2"!2 L.# < * !**$ 3 6 "$3 < ##.)2 $

2# " L.# * 2/$"/.3"$ $ $ 6"!8

2

 9"  6

  KE@D

  KK >$$?. @EA #

2 < 332$#"$  1 !2  3 !8 1#" #8 6!

6 36"! 10!

2 6 #  "$ $ 3 6 28 ; 6 #  "$ $ 3 6 < # $ !**$    "# 6# #.1*"

"$  66# .$ 

);   F2  ! 3"#$4 # 2 2 # 1$ !$9"!

   $!.$  / !

28"$ *#/!

"$'

.$0 1   $ .!

"#$# >*3 ; #A !

8 K >F !

4@#2 A8 F2  !3"#$4"#$ 16 # $3 6 $  !.$#6  "$ #.1*"

"$$3 62 #1$0!

 "$9"< 2 3

  KK >$$?. EA  2 /$" /.3"$ $ $ 6"!
"##.1*"

2# " 3 * =# *$

$  2"#  *"6; #"  "$ 2 # * 9"66 ) (.0) 2 2)"6" 2)"6<"

2<2* "$"# 66) 

2 9!**"

2$!8"## "66.$* " 

"$ 29$ 6 "$8 2"# 332$#"$1 !23 !

IDJ
$ 2*

1 <3 "#" 9"!

"* 2 # 1$ !*3*"#   !*3*"#

  &' >$$?. @A< #$  "$ 28 2"#$L.# "$

$; 332$#"$  1 !2  3 ! "$ 2 9$   1"$)6 # $3 6
$ #3$#8 6 $  /

 !.$#6 2 # #.1*"

$ <"

2#

$ "$) 66) !*3*"#>$$?. @A8 "#$9 26## F2  !3"#$4 # "$ .$ /!

"$>

A

2!

  2 9 )"9$ . 2.)2 .6 !$#" 

!$ "$# 26 $ !.$#6 "$) "# 2 "$2 #1$ !6"$  $ 2 ).$ 

 "$ 2 9$   2"# 6 #8 2 "# 6"=6"2   1 !23 ! 2)"6 ) "$# <2*2"## "  2 9!**"

2 $!# "# # "66 .$* "  $  "# #" "$) "$ 2 # * 9"66 )H 1#" #8 "$"# F2  !3"#$4/!

"$' 2!

<2"!2 "#$ 6#  F2  ! 3"#$4  ; 6 # * ; 1 $ "! 8<2"!2 #.$ %@ M' "#$ $  $ 6   1 6 #  "$ !

"$ ##  <"

2#

$ "$) $;

2"$)!$

"$ "$/!

"$#D C8@ > A$3"#$#2 661$ 6  16 # .$ 

2"# !

 <2*

2 #$ $! 2 # 1$

<   "# 2  !83"#$H >1A <"

2#

$ "$) $;

2"$)!$

"$ "$!6 .#> A8  ! 3"#$ * ; 1 66<   1 6 # 

"6; $ 2 ).$  #3!""  "$ !6 .# > A 

ICJ !6 .#>1A#.1@#!

"$ >A/!

"$D<98 ?

 !$ "

"$# * ; 1 "*3#  $ 2 3"#$

"*  ; 6 #  .6.)2   !$#" "$) 66 2  $  !"!.*#

$!#  #M  "# 1$ "! 

/!

"$'>1A 2!

$9"# )#

 $ <"

2#

$ "$) $;

2"$) !$

"$  "$ !6 .# > A8  F2  ! 3"#$4 * ; 1 66<   1 6 #  "6; $ 2 ).$  #3!""  "$ !6 .# > A  !6 .# >1A  #.1@/!

"$ >A  /!

"$ DH 2<98?

!$ "

"$#* ;1"*3# $ 23"#$

"* ; 6 #  .6.)2   !$#" "$) 66 2  !"!.*#

$!# 2!

#

N  ! 3"#$N 2 # 1$ "$  "$ /!

"$  >

A 

2!

#66<#%@ M>

AM2  !3"#$M* $# 3#$!$"$ "$ 3"#$.$  #$ $!"*3"#$*$ 8<22 1$!$9"!

 @ >"A $$! 3<"

2*. .$ #!

"$D  <"

2#!

"$D 2
$ "

6 8&H >""A $$!3.$"#2 16.$ #!

"$C

 "$2"6 $*/?.

6 $!#!

HM  "# $ 2 ).$ 

"$ "#  F2  ! 3"#$4 21"$) 2

1 !23 !$2"#6 #8 2 2 # 1$ 26  "#$ 6   ; 6 # <98 !*3*"#

  &' >$$?. @A 1 < "#" 29"!

"*< #$ 1.)2 2$ "! 2"# (

>#3$ $ A 28"

I'J < # $ 9  1; 2 
#

2 "#  !*3*"#  "$ 1 <3 "#2!

2# *"# 1 !$#"  1; 2"# (

>#3$ $ A"$2 !"#"$* ="$)3!## *"$"#

"9 !"#"$3.# 6 !*3*"#

  &' >$$?. @A

 2 # 1$ 36 !  $! #2<#

2"# 3 ;" 12. ;

682"#<"/ 9"

"

2"*"$ .)2  2.)22* 2 $ 6) 6).

 "

$2 9 #.1*"

2 3#$  !

# ) "$# 2 #!$  3 ; < # ) )"#   . *"#.$ #

$ "$)8<"

2.

=$<"$) .

6 # $  2* 2  #$ 2 *9"8 3 .!  "$ 2 !

#  2

$!2 ;

$  #3!

16 3#$# 2  ) 2 *

 !*3*"#  <$1 2 "#!! "$) 2!*3*"#8 2)"9 $! 2"# 3 ;2 1$ ##  $ $< 2< #$). ) $*"

;1 "# 2" "$!#2 1$#69 
"# 6##.1*"

2"# 3 ; #$ <

= $;

) "$# 2#!$ 3 ;2# " !*3*"#< #$  "$ $ &' 2    #$ $! $  !$9"!

"$ < # 3 ## 

2   $ C 
 "# $  #2<$ <2 2 2 !*3*"# < $  "$9" $!"$ "

6

< #!$ .!

 <98 !"#"$ 3"#$$3 6"# 1

=$ "$ 3$ $   2    !$9"!

$  #$ $! # "

 "#

*"$"#

"9 !"#"$ "#<66@=$<

*"$"#

"9 !"#"$"##.10!

0. "!"

69"<"$?!"##.39"#;<"

0."# "!

"$ 2"#. .$  "!6 2$# .

"$
$ "

2.)2 2"#. "#$

$ 3366

 .   <98  0. "!"

6 9"< 

*"$"#

"9 "$ * ; 6

 "

2  #

.

; *"$"#

"9

"$9$ $$@#

.

; *"$"#

"9 "$
$"

2

IJ 9$ .

6"

"#8 9"6

"$  !$# .

"$ 6 39"#"$#  $; #

.

; 39"#"$<.6 "$9 6"

*"$"#

"9 !"#"$  2 "!

  6 < $0"$#

 9; *"$"#

"9 !"#"$*.# 1 #$ 1623"$!"36 #$ 16$##=$<$

#F $#1.;3"$!"3642 26*$ #" .

2"

;#2.6 

= 66 69   # "$  !$#" 

"$H "

 #2.6  ?!6.   "69  #*!$#" 

"$H 2 !"#"$#2.6 $"

21 39# $ "

"$ 6 F 9#48 * $# "*33  !$ "!

; 1.

"$ 2!$ ?

*"$"#

"9 !"#"$#;*16"B#  !"#"$$ #.33  1; $;9" $! $ F"

"$ 64* $# 1#. "66)"!

6 !"#"$<2"!2$3#$336; 9"# $ 2 #<.6  !2


$ 2 3#$  !

#8 2 69     2 1"$) !*3*"#1 "#" 29"!

"*

2 !"*"$ 6 "$ 2 # $  1$

=$ "$ !!.$  1; 2 "# (

<2"6!$#" "$) 2!

"$2"#

#$3 62"#8 28"#"$!*36 9"6

2 "!

  6 < "$ #3!

  *"$"#

"9 !"#"$ <2"!2 $!## "6; <.6 

"6

"$9 6"

# * 2

*"$"#

"9 !"#"$

  >$$?. @A

=$1; "#  (

 >#3$ $  A8 28 "#   1 "$9 6"

  "6"$)

="$ !!.$ 2!*3*"#>$$?.

@A 1 "# " 2 9"!

"* !"*"$ 6 "$ !! "$)6;8 2 6 "

 3 "$ "# 66<  "*3.)$   

    >$$?. @A 3 ##  1; "#  (

 >#3$ $  A "# L.

#2  *

 #2 66 1 !$#"   1; 2 "#  (

>#3$ $ A # #$ #3##"161;

="$)"$ !!.$ 66

I J $!## ;*

"

6<2"!2 69 "$ 2 !"#"$* ="$)3!##

$  ?!6. "$) 66  # <2"!2  "69    2 !"#"$ #2 66 23.66;1

=$ #?3 "

".#6; #3##"16 $ 3 16;<"

2"$ #"?<=#*!"3 !3; 2  >/// $A . ) > #2 $/"$)2A   . ) &'

*"

 % >A
2 2 2 "##3 ="$)E #$ % # >A
2 2 2 "#3

16 % #