Simran Dhillon v. State Of Punjab Th Its Secretary And ANR





   
  



 ! "# $%  & "#
 



  
    

 

   
    



 '

( )%*+,% -,$-' .'/*'%'%  ( 0-- 1- -+,,  .*  ' "

( -+'-4 -'/- %-$-' .*  ' 
 

  



'%'%   5  6+-/% 7  .  '/   -' " # "#8 

9%+31*  ' ":/31'/ $ .*-% 7";"<-4% .4='-'. 2-3/-3

-3% 7'/.. % 7*%% -$$+ '. '/-% 7'/ 6+%%'6+-,%.%$-'% /-% 7'+%";".4+'%'/='-'.

2-3  '/ *'%'%   %  '  ,%-3,  '  3 $ %  .  '/  !>?

 2-3@+'--'% (%$-,<-4% . ("#%

'/+ A7-+-'7$+.(=B=.'/% "#A " /*,-.-$'.'/$-%'/-'*'%'% :-3

'/='-'. 2-3-'      " "&&! =/

*-/$,-"'/ <-4% .4  !"# $

% & %  & %   +   =  -  %  '/  1-  "C 8

<+  A9  +  '  + -%-3,  $%$+4'- $  /  : '  ' /-+ .% 7/";".4'#()'*

 +  *


'/1-"C'/:- +$/,%7%3%,%'1$ '/ ='-'. 2-3./-% 7'+%B*-";"<-4% .4'/ ='-'. 2-3.3% 7$ %,%7%3,':-'/ '- $''%

'/(%$-,='-4:/%$/:-3% 7$ +$'-.'";<-4%

.+ A7-+-'7$+ =//%.'3-$5..+'/'+% ''/='-'. 2-3- *-";<-4% 4%$-,'-4 .4  '/  -4  $/,  %     !"  # $ 

%  & % & :%'/4'/- &>?4-5- '/+,'.= %=$/, '%.%$-'%-** -  !"# $%*-% '/-%1-"#  /**$'+. ("#:-%+% '/4 '/.

*%,"#:/%$/*%'/-'3'/";"- ";<-4% /- '3 .4'/$7 %D$/,%'+-'% '/='-'. /+7//% '/-'/6+%%'6+-,%.%$-'% .";"$,-.4

2-3..%$%-,',/'-**,1.'/''-5*% %:'/ *%+  1-  $%7 +4  :-  ,%5,1  '  3  %+ 
'  :-  -, % .4'/'/-'$4*,%- $.'/-%$ :-'3'-5

% '$ %-'%  ,1-''/'%4.$+ ,,% 7 /:--,- %*+'7-% 7'/%+./,% 7.'/-'% -,,%7%3%,%'1'

89'/ (<-4% $$% 7,1/-**-% '/

("# "" # "#- $+4%'- 5#C8  !"# $&9 /  +,'  :-  $,-     # "#  %  :/%$/  /  7'  ''-, *$ '%,&! !>&#  /%%'''/..%$.*  ' A

%%'1:/$+ ,,% 7:-'3/,/:-','/-'/ $- %-'+':--4%% B$+ ,,% '/ 2-3@+'--' :+, '3$ %-'-,,% $//- '*-'/";"

<-4% .4'/='-'.

+,'- ',1  / $/-,, 7  '/ -%     '/ 7+ '/-'/%% '.='-'. 2-3/-% 73% 73 -  3+7/'+*% '/='-'. 2-3 .-'/-.-431*.% % /-% 7%44-3,**'1.4'/- -$-% '/='-'.

2-3 /:- +$/$ .'/-,%1-"

"C ">  -   /  '5  -4%%  +'%  ='-'  .  2-3  +  ' -%-3,$%$+4'- $-'/4 

,%- $:-*,-$+* '/*-31'/%$+'%

$-    

'%',-E 

   !"

 !!

 #$%  !"-, 7:%'/3+ $/.*'%'% $%

  "C:/% -%4%,-%+/-3 -,':%'/31/,% 7'/-'

'/-4-4+ ''7%% 7'*$'%..$'% $'+ '/- '-5 -4%% 5*% %:'/'',*%'% -,%'/-''/1 :,%7%3, '/' 7'/./-% 7 ";<-4% .4 '/='-'. 2-3 /.'/='-'/-3 7% ,%3'1' % $*-''/,- ',%.5*% %:'/3-'% 4- -3 

'

'%.+'/-7+31'/$+ ,.'/*'%'% '/-'%

%:.'/-'$,-+#/-3 $*-'% '/ -' " # "# '/-' '/ $- %-'/-,, /- *- /%B/ "'/ ,- <-4% .4'/='-'. 2-3.=% "&A / $ '/+%4*:+,/-'*$'%..$' /*'%'%  $+/%7/- 5% 4%',%'3+':+,3 $-%,15*'+'

'/%7+ %',.  /'*,1/-3 .%, 3/-,..'/='-'. '/+7/%$' -$/F(%$-,+$-'%  2-3:/% %'

/-3 -'/-'*%% /-3 $*-'% $'/1- - '/,- '$,-+ "8%9.'/ -' C  /-3 -''-$/- &# '( $$% 7,1%':-4- -'1' *-";"- ";<-4% .4'/='-'. 2-3-   '+ ':--4%''% '/% ">://- ' ";"

<-4% .4'/='-'. 2-3 /*%% ./-% 7*- "'/ <-4% .4'/='-'. 2-3:-'+$5:

- '/ *%%  :/%$/  4-%   :-  .  /-% 7  *-  ";"  -   "; <-4% .4'/=-'. 2-3  +,'- ',1$,-+"#.'/

/-3 . 31'/='-'

+-,  .  '/   .  '/  ,-'  1-  -'

">8 &# ) *9:+,7 '/:'/-''/4- -'1 $ :-./-% 7*-";<-4% '/6+%-, '

<-4% /-%$,-+.'/-$-4%$1-">-- 

 ,#  

-    $    .   /01         2$     /01  

-

.+  
     

3-  3 $       4     3     2        

  .5  +       4 

3- - 3

  

 /$,-+% 6+'% .'/* '-$-4%$%

:/%$/%*-'.'/ -'" # "#/-3 %+ +*% 7'/-,% -'"!

"#--+  E"# /$- %-'/+,3-3 -.%% '.

2-3 /% ''-'+. 2-3'-'/-,,3 '-5 '4. 2-3 4 '*-'4 '.



,- 4% %'-'%.48

A

- $/9 ,'' "B B&>A



B&#"&-'#'/+ "&&#
  "BB&#A

AB!&#-''/ +,1"&&!- 
  "B B&>A

B

B!"-'"' - +-1"&&&- - .+'/  % '+$'%   %+  31  '/  *-'4 '  .



,  %.  - 1  -   '/  -4  /-,,  3  -/ - %-'  4+'  /-  *-  ";"  -   "; <-4% .4 2-3 - %-'4+'/-*- ";"- ";<-4% .4 2-3 - %-' :/*-/%B/";"- ";<-4%  '/  6+%-, '  <-4%  .4  -  $7 %D =$/,B
'%'+'%  %'+-'  %  /- %7-/  8

%

%'19:/%3 -.%% '. 2-3/-,, -,3,%7%3, G

4'/-% 7.'/-.-%':$,-+%':+,3 $,-  '/-'  '/  :-    +$/  6+%4 '  .  /-% 7  *-  ";"

<-4% .4'/='-'. 2-3.'/$-4%$=% ">

+'/%':-% '+$31'/ 2-3 4 '% '/1-"# .%',1% '/ -'"!

"#:/%$/:-+*31'/

-'" # "# 
'% '%*+''/-''/*'%'%  /-

'+%/";"$,-% '/1-">.4/-+ :/%$/:+,3 $,-.4 &# ) ''/-'*% '/:- '6+%'/-  /";".4 2-3- '/+:- '-:-'/-'/-% 7'+% /, '/:+,4-5/% ,%7%3,31'/='-'31'*$'% ..$' /-$'% .'/*  ' "-+$/31% '+$% 7'/ 6+%4 '.";"$,--''/%'-7-4+ ''7%% 7'*$'% ..$'- 4-5% 7* % ,%7%3,'*$'%,1-'/1/--,-1 '+%'/%";"$,--,%  /+32$'4-''.'*$'%%'1:--,$ % - -,':%'/31'/%+'% $-   

'%,- 

   !"

+" !!

 #$%, -, 7:%'/3+ $/.

:%'*'%'% $%   "C8

<+ A"9 /- %+ .  /-% 7  *-  "'/ ,-  .4 '/ ='-' .  2-3  :/%$/  :- % '+$.'/.%''%4-- :/'/%'-4+ ''7%% '*$'%..$' H*% %:'/% '%4*-31'/% +'  '/  ='-'  /-  % .4  '/-'  '/  -%  $,-+  :+,  '  3  .$% '/1-"C /='-':-'/+7% ,%3'1'.,,:

'/+*$+-  +'/-''/%7/'.'/*-'%:+, '3 ..$'-,131- 1'*$'%..$':/%$//-3 '%$ -3% '/* '$- :,%3'1:-7% '% $*-' '/  ,- '  $,-+  .  '/  +36+ '  1-  5*% 7  %  %:  '/ 3-'% 4-3,: /,- '*'% --+  ,#    
 % %    3  %         

    $3      2$

 "  

(

 $"   "   

-"  "    .

   &  "%   
 

3  

  -         $ "  "  "    $    3      $   4 
      3 %    

3       

    $

   - 

  4 5 7 # '-      +"

 $ !

  #

.

!"

 /

 " $ # - -  8 4 "-    
 

%  
  4  $3 

3"$ &   # 5 # 9: -$3     $        3                -    -- 



 3    "%      +  $3           
 3      "     7"

 # 

  $    

 "-   " 

 

  "        #  +% 3$%

   
3

 " 

   $  $   2  " -   $3     $      $  +    

   $     
3

  "    "     #    "    "        "

  

- "6

'%4-''..-$'-,%+* 31,- $+ ,.'/ *'%'% %',.'/-'5*% %:'/-%2+74 ''/$%'%-.

*-% 7"'/";"- ";/-3 *+'% .$.4'/-$-4%$ =% "&A /%:+,3$,-.4$,-+"#.'/

:/%$/--+  ,1;

+$3  -/1 /< 1/ = #> ?

;//@ 1/ =

  "  7       5"  5-  # %   

&  - "     1/ @1/1/

3 

 ,4   

 $ .  /  #  '  /0  /01   
 6 $  '/  ='-'  %',.  /-  '-5  -  $%%  .  /-% 6+%4 '.";".'/1-"&A  :-% %:.'/ *-31'/%+''/6+%4 './-% 7*-";". '/% "#A"-3,+',1+...4'/-4-%,4 ':/%$/ /-  3 '%$ 31 '/% +' % 

 1"

2" 8+*-9 .

'*$'%..$' /'+ ':/--**,1% 7.-4%%

(%$-,'-4:+,3-,1..$'31'/6+%4 '.

/-% 7*-";".4'/='-'. 2-3 

+,'- ',1'/-%$ %,%-3,'3'+$5:

- -$$% 7,1'/* '*'%'% %-,,: /$%'%-./-%  '/$,-";"-*%% $,-+"#.'/ -' " # "#8

<+ A""9.4'/='-'. 2-3%'+$5:

.'/* '-$-4%$% /*'%'% /-,,3-$$% 7,1 ,%7%3,' 3 $ %. -4%%  '/ ' 7'/. /-% '+%";<-4% +32$''.+,.%,,4 '.'/6+%4 '   ) *+,*-*./*0 "+1  & "#   I/'/*-5% 7B-   B I/'/ *'-3,  B