← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/397/2018dismissed

Vishwanath Jha v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2018-05-29Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa15 pages



     

 

     

   

 

 

     

  



 

     

  !

!



 

     

  "

!



 

     

 

-

!

!

 

     

  

!

 

     

   

!



 

     

  $'))+.,.%/  "

 / 01  2  22

   

    

       !

"

    # $%

 

        # &%  "

''''

 22 3 (   ""      )  "  

"

 *     )   )  +

 

## ,- $, &,$.

  *     

/*   

)    " "

 *          

  +

          &$ ,0 &,$1  &2 ,0 &,$1   "   *  

 "

) $ 3" /*  *    *

  

 $-4   )*"

5

   $44$ 6  7#

 78      "")    

   

   

   -2.  &,$4 2-9  ,.

,.

&,$0 94-$&4  $, ,- &,$0

 9, ,,,%  "

 

  ,.4  5%'(, ")       ,"3

6#  

    )    

&2 ,0 &,$1

-24  &,$4 2&1  ,.

,.

&,$0 2&444&  ,$ ,- &,$0

 & &9 ,,,%  "

 

  ,.4  5%'(, ")       ,33"

6#  

    )    

&2 ,0 &,$1

-22  &,$4 2&2  ,.

,.

&,$0 0-2,.2  ,- &,$0

 $ ,, ,,,%  "

 

  ,.4  5%'(, ")       ,3"

6#  

    )    

&2 ,0 &,$1

0,,  &,$4 2-0  ,.

,.

&,$0 0-2,4,  &,$0

 $ ,, ,,,%  "

 

  ,.4  5%'(, ")       ,3"

6#  

    )    

&2 ,0 &,$1

0,&  &,$4 2-$  ,.

,.

&,$0 0-2,4&  ,2 &,$0

 $ ,, ,,,%  "

 

  ,.4  5%'(, ")       ,3"

6#  

    )    

&2 ,0 &,$1

0,0  &,$4 2-&  ,.

,.

&,$0 0-2,4$  ,.

&,$0

 $ ,, ,,,%  "

 

  ,.4  5%'(, ")       ,3"

6#  

    )    

&2 ,0 &,$1

0$.  &,$4 2-,  ,.

,.

&,$0 0-2,.4  ,$ &,$0

 $ ,, ,,,%  "

 

  ,.4  5%'(, ")       ,3"

6#  

    )    

&2 ,0 &,$1

0&$  &,$4 2--  ,.

,.

&,$0 0-2,4-  $& &,$0

 $ ,, ,,,%  "

 

  ,.4  5%'(, ")       ,3"

6#  

    )    

&2 ,0 &,$1

5  " 

 

   )    "

#!#

 ""  "   0&.   3

 " *

"

        )    ""



:           ;

  

     

 ;

  3 # -2.  &,$4

<          " 

  6  # &8  

   %

  "" /*

3 "  *

  ")  )    " 

"   

   "  "  "  

 

 

( " "           

%  

)    

        " * )  

   )  "*"      

  "  )     $& 0& &42%         

 ,$ ,0 &,$$  $- &,$0

       



 * 

"" *       

 ( "     

) 

 * ) # 94-$&4   $, ,- &,$0  )   9, ,,,%     <;

> <  #5( /*

    

; ? 

 @  

   $- &,$0 (  "    A )" #   &- &,$0  )  )     %  "")

   ;



  

   $9  

    "

)" 

(  

  

    "*"   "    

   & ,& ,,,%       )  "*"  

)

#"#     $, 0, &42%  "

) 

    9, ,,,%   

  %    ;) 

   "   "   $$ ,1 &,$0 648     )" #   &- &,$0 64-8

)  "  "

" * ) # 2-9   ,.

,.

&,$0

3 " 

   "     3:$      3:$%  "      "") 



   



         !"

#  $ %&%   &'

&  ()   *+

'

  





 



 

 

 



,   $

   & '

-  .    /

(     

   

"             *"

 $-4       "

   ) "  "

 "    "

   

 &1-6)8 3

  

 "   $096&8        * "   %    "")  "    B    "   B      % 5  

%      C: $  

  "") 

  

 

0

/1   $



0 .    /

#-#  

 

0&  0

0#

$ 

0,  



  " 3    ;

    



 "   

     $-4  

       *

))   ) 

  "      * 

      *     

/* 

  68

  3  "         )



     *  *  3  * "      $

( 

 =

     

 *  %    )   "

)""  *"

*  "*"   

 =

  

     

D &

( 

 "  "  *  # &%  "        = " 

  +      ) 

* #   $4 ,- &,$0 $, ,0 &,$0  &$ &,$0 64  ' 4"8      # &%  "      "

      





 * 

-

(    ""    "")  ;



     "          #    "   

   & ,& ,,,%    # &%  "   

)      ,2 ,1 &,$0 64"8 "  *  "

    )   *   

  )     *   *"

## E       3  "   # &%  "          * "        *  3  * "    "  "     

  3

 =

   )  "

)""

 *"

*%"*"  

       * <;

  

    )" #

"

 

;)  

    

 $-4     

 

 ""   )  "

)  )

         *  3  *    68

  "

  3  "          *;

"   +

   * *    3  " "   "     ") * 

 *     ))     &,,2  $1 $$ &,$&       )  *

  ) &,   +

  *     

/*

        # &%  " " 33 

># -$ 

C& 

 "      

 

     

      "  "

   )      *  "         

 ,$ ,0 &,$$  $- &,$0      $& 0& &42%  ) )  /   ""

)     )    *  "*"  

)      

            # &%  "  

   *   )        )

 

 "" *

          ""   *  ) 

) # 94-$&4   $, ,- &,$0 64 8       9, ,,,%     <;

> <  $/ &, #5( /*    *  # &%  "   

  )  <;

 

   * ;    

; 2 

 @ 

  $- &,$0 648 3

"       $-4 6*8   )" #   &- &,$0 64-8   )     

       ;



  



    "    

   & ,& ,,,% )  "  )     $& 0& &42%      ,2 ,1 &,$0     " A   64"8    "*"

       $, 0, &42%   ,2 ,1 &,$0  

"" *          

      "   ")  )  "  "

)   

)  

 =

     * "

 3  "      "

     

 

   

 

   *

 5         $-2    "" *

"

       "   

  

  )   *  "*"   "

         $-4  



  $-2      *  *    )       $$4   

       # )*"

5

   )   

         * )""     



##

        

      +  )    $-2  $$4     )  

  "   

     )  "

)""  *"

*  "*"  *           

  $-2    $$4     * )    

       !  "

     #$   #  3 4  # /+    1  /5 

        5          

 &%     6   /  1 #     # 

1   

%"

     &  



 37

 

 1  /5  6  /+/

  # + '( #     )   51 

#  + 6 +  6   

   51  

 + 6

 # 

/   

  

 6 

/   

      

8 '

(   )  51 

#  + #     6 +  6     8 '(       #    )   51 

/  #     6 

/  6

   #

+  

    #

 + 

'(    #  #)  51    

#

 + 6 + #

 + 

'(  #   ) 

 +  // /  

#  + 6 +    6



1 // 8 '#(  

)    /+ 1   #     

  6 1  +/8 '&(      ) 

    

#  +

      .5   6   +  # #   +

6 6  + 1 /  6  1  #1

# +         # #   +  +)  

/   #1 +         6

 

  #  /5 

         /  + (     64 !      

,$ ,0 &,$$  $- &,$0   " "

  * 

    ;

 "  $1 $$ &,$&     )) <"" # -0-,       $0 $49%   ,$ &,$0      $& 0& &42%  ) )                 & ,& ,,,%   "")     

* ,!,!'

& !"

(1  -!,!'

  !"

(1   $--'

  () %!,!'

- !"

(1  (

) *"   )     $, 0, &42%   )   "  "

  A    64!8 ( "

 )  C:$       

B     )     ")   "  &,,2 " )   "      A  64-8         ,$ ,0 &,$0  ,1 ,1 &,$0  )) 

* #    $4 ,- &,$0 $, ,0 &,$0  &$ &,$0 643!"8   "   A     

 

 *     ,$ ,0 &,$0       "  )     ")   "  &,,2 5  " 

  *      *  C * #  64'"8 

    ))  <""        &1 ,.

&,$&  $1 $$ &,$& ( "   <""  "" 

## * #     (  $- '

  ,- (  $9   ,% (  $9-%    % (  $&'   &9 (  $&%   &9 (  $&%   9 (  $&

  99 (  $&'&   ,

"   "  <""  C * #  64'"8 "   "  "    ;

 " 

     $1 $$ &,$&     )) <"" # -0-,   C * #     &$ &,$0 64!8 

  $ F   

"" 

* #     )   )       ""  *



 *   *    " 3    ""

 C * #  

       "D      "

"

 )  C:$   ""             * #  

       # &%  "

(       3  "     

 "  "  *  "     = "  "           *

    

 "

   

  *    "  "    %  A ; 3   

  +  *  3    )         *

      %  A ;

# 3   *

 

    D    "  *

* )     ))     +    "  * )   " *  3  >   

  "

       )   *   *     

)

>     "   $$ ,1 &,$0 648   )" #  &- &,$0 64-8      "

   *       +  "

     "%  # &  " " "

( )

      ,2 ,1 &,$0 64"8   )   *   

     *D   

        )     $, 0, &42% *          +, -   + ./.-.+

  :   #  /1  ' %9 ;<    1 < 6      / 1=  .

> < ?@ /    9,'  

+/    +  

  .

> < ?@ :  /1 # )    +

 .

1   6 1 @!"

 6     " 64"8  *

     

   /  

)  *    "  ;"

  "*"   $, 0, &42%   "

  

 )   *   

  *     "*"

 * +

      "     " D     

 ;

   3   "  ))  )   *   )   ,2 ,1 &,$0 64"8       "

  *

   *  "

)   

 &1-6)8   3

##       ))   *

 )    " 63:$8

3

"   )

    )     "      "

   *  *  3  * "  

 "*"

 * +      3       

 =

  

   )  "

)""

 *"

*%"*"       

 

    "

   

  

"   $-2  

5     *   ""  )  "

   





.%





.%

 





.%





 

.%

!







.%

!



 - 

.%

!

!



"

.%

!

 -

.%

!



(   " "

 *

)    "

 ""  "   0&.   3

      

  ""    *        "    

 "

( "

)

   *    3  "   " %            

 ,$ ,0 &,$$  $- &,$0  

  $& 0& &42%   )  

 "

"     "" 

) 

  

      )"

  (  " *        "    

 "%  "   3 " # 2&2  &,$0

#!# G    "  " *   3 # $29-,  &,$4  3 # $4&.&  &,$4  3 # 0,,  &,$4  *

 "

*   # &%  "  "

  3  "    # &    

"     "  ""   "  "

 * 

5         * "    # &%  "  

 "   "       5 <""       

 "  "

    64!   

    ")   "  "   %%)48*) #3         )"

        5        "" 

    )"

 *

  *                  

 0&.  3

  * 

"  4  !%%)48*) # ;

   "   

 "   "    *""    &,, 6   8         

   

 ,$ ,0 &,$$  $1 $$ &,$&  

 * 

   )"

 D          )    ") * 

            "   ;



   D  "")  )  " 

       

 "*"  " * ))   B 7  "

 

            #         

#"#    ")         ) *   

       ";

       "" *

  

 ""   "" *    

    

3

"  

    "  

;)         ""    



""  *

) "   "  

      * "       68

$9 3

  22  !)    :  /) ! ? :  / # ?