Prashant Kapoor v. High Court Of Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh And ORS
!"!#$% & %
'$()'*+
!
"
# !$ !
"
% !
"
&
'
$
!
"
&
( ) '* ') +* +'
+,+-
."/ !
"
!
"
&
1 '+ ', '- +++0
+, '
2
3 #
!"
'11'
# % " " #
% !
3 "
%$
4 "
!
#
5 4
+6 +***
+
2# 3 #" 4
$ +'
+***
" " !
!# 7
#
#
/ 3 '1114+***
(
2 "8
" 9 "+**' 3
'':';:; < 3 :
!"
;
'1-( : 8
9;
!"" 5
$3 =
3 # 0-" #
" # 3 (# ""
#"
#
# # ! 3%.
.
3
+
>
#
"
.
,
!
#3
3 #
?
#"# " 4
3
3 @# " " #"A# "
)
2
" "
2A# $3 = #
"
?
$
! ?
$ 3!
B
3 #
!
"
"
@ # 7 # "
# # " 4
2 ?
$ "
!"" 3 !
!
"
@
""
#
"
?
$"
#"
3%.
$3 =
""
# %
!"" !
""
3#
5 $3 = ! "
$ *'
+**': >4'
)+
4
%;# # # !
"
3 8
5 3 9
A
33
5 #
$ *'
+**'
#
" 3 "
2 " @ " 3
#
" # "3 !
"
! C" +( +**'
2
"
$3 =
?" #
# "
"
-
# 3
!"
3 / 3 *) +**'
#"#
3
#"
3
3 +'
+**+
3
$3 =
3
"+**'
A @ #""
% # ##
3 A !
$3 = 3 % !
3
!"
# ?
$ 3!
"
"
3
"
3
"
# #
.
-
3 & 3 ') +**+
" #
#
2 !"
$'( +**(
#4
! "#$%%& '
( ) #
* +&
( ) ! ' * + '
,$%% #
*!* * -./
' 01 2 '234' 5
0
2 2 2 3 #
2
2 6 2 # 2 2
2 ' 2' 7 2' $89$%%'234' 5 0 *:*7 ); 4"4 88$%%$'234' 5
0 "*7
); 44 *! 5 +
7 <%<=
A
## 3
# # ! !""
?
$"
#
"
!3
#" 3 @# 3
3
# 3 3 3
# "
#
"!
# " # # " "
# "
"
2
#
"!
3 # " 33
3#
3 3 "
"
.
#
! $ +- +**( #
:< 3 ;#
3 +'
+**+ "
3 3
2 " # "
!
!
D *, +**( 3
"
A
3 @ 3
3
#
3 " 3 # 3
3 !"
#
@
3 C" +- +**(
3 3
! C" +( +**'
3 " +**( 3
%
5 #
@ $= 3 # 3%.
#
A !
@ !"
3
=
!"
#
3 "3
$3 = 3
'':';:;
" "
" +**( +**, +**) D"
# ?" "
# !
#
@ # # 3 +**,
"
"
"
3
#
3 : 3 ;
:<; C" *'
+**,
# "
! #
.
#
#
5 & 3 '0 +**)
A
"
3
'':;:; +1 +**6
#""
#
&
+1 ()
3# ""
5 $3 =
'*
2 # # !"
#""
/ 3 *1 +**0
" # ?
$ # "
"
# "
@ $'6 +**1
& " 4
$ +'
+***
"
!
C
?"
3# !!
# "
#" " ''
!
"
D +0 +**1 3 $3 = #
$ *'
+**'E! "
('
+**6E " #
*0 +**0 #
@ A
@ 3
# 3 " # !
3
""
" >3
3 /
F
&
'(# " # "
3
# !
5
$3 = " " 3 3 "
3 #
"
" 3
'+
/ 3 " 4
"
@
#
# "
&
''
'+G+-E( 6E0 '*E', +6+0# 3 #
$3 =
'':';:;
3 3 '6 +**+ '* +**6 A
+1 ()
" "3 $3 = +1 +**6
. '(
2
3 D +**1 !
!
"
2
#
4
:; ""
" # "
3 "+**'#
3%.
"3 $3 = :;&
# % !
E:; "
3 " "
# "
#
$3 = #
# " "3 "
!
2
!
#
. !"
33
?
$ /
3 #"
"
##
$3 = ?
? ?
?
!
>3 33
3 3 3
""
" 33
# ?
$ % #"% / 3 *) '116
$3 = "
!
>3 8
9 "
# 3
# #
"!
"#"
@ " #
3 "
" 3
#
3
"!
',
2
?
33
/ (* +*'+3 ?
" $"
7
!
?
" $"
!
$ '( +*'+ " " # !
= # > ?
33
!
')
2 3 "! ?
33
# "
3
3
?
? ?
?
'':';:;
#
! '':';:;
A#
?
33
?
$
" +**( +**,+**)
3%
A+**6
#
$3 = # @ >3 A#
"
#
+**'
#% !
3 #
!
3
" # @
"
3
3
3
3 <!
"
3
"
3
+**' 8 9 # " 3
" #
!#!
'6
#
#
!
3
#4
0 1
2$%%3 # #
'4 4> 2#
2
2'
'2 #:
?
5 6 ' '
$%%'
*!* ?*1 #+ '
3 5 #0*"
#+ ' <@
# '2 '
# ) )'
2
#<@' ( ' ' 2 2$%%<#$%% $%%@ 3
0 1
$%%,A
# -
2 ' 2
2 > #
+
# 5
5
# * /= '-
3 "
" ""3 " 3
3 "
#
@
" A & %
!
H A A'11* '10, !
# 2 #
" $ (* +*'+#
D +0 +**1# "
!
" 3 #" 3
#" 4+0 ''0 '+*
4
% '0
C "
"
" # C
#
'' " "
3
" !
3 D 3
'':';:;
$3 = #
# / 3 " 4
3 () " !
$3 = !
#" "
#
" ""
$=# % !
"
3 "@ "
# !
3 #
"
3
3
!
3 3
"
3 #
" "3 4 !"
"
4
4 !
"
# '1
C # "
3 /
F
&
'(
'+ # '))4')6
4
% % #
#"# "
#
#
" " # " " +*
2
" "
3 # !
!
#
#
"
@
"@ "
?
$"
!
3
"
3
2
"
D *, +**(: 4,; # # " 3
""3"
3 7 !
" " 33
# ?
$ : >4+6;# >
>
"
3
3 "%
#
#
#""
+'
2
" "
3 !
H
"
! 4"
3
!
3
"
# 3
! #"
"
#
!
#
3
"!
" # 3 !
3 "
3
%
"
#
++
33B "
"!
3 3
3 %
"
$3 = +**'#
'':';:;
''
:';:;
# # " #
#
:;:;
'' #
3 " 5 !"
"
$3 = :$ . ;5 # % /"5 /"G $ G H 2 !# % 333
# "
33 .
# % #333# !"
" A
4
:;
''
)*I
33 !# % " 333
#
3 4"34
'':+;
!""
$3 = #
3 # "
4
:;:;
''
% 4
:;
- " " 3 !"
.
3 !"
J /! K !"
3 "
++1 CA 4
"
3
4
:;
''#
4
:;
2 3!
" : >4+6 '*04''6;#
> 3 " "
3!
" #
4(,:';: ;
!" '')
4
%:
;
3
" 3 ""
!
" "
8
9 # % +**'
#
#
$= '
+**'
2 # " " "
""
"
""
2
# " $ +**( 33"
D +**(
A # %
% !
3
2
3 "
5
#
"3
+*'+
3"
# 4
:;
4
:;
''!
"
%
"
#!
!% !
3 "
3
A
3
%!
A :'10+;' (-1'10+:+; 61 A#
#
"" >
3 "
3 "
3
!
3 3 ! '6 '+ +*'( +*)4+'+
4
% !
"
3
''
:';:;
@ " +**'
+**( +**,G+**) 3 ""
!
"
#
% ""
@ "3 2 #!
#
"
"
3
$=
3+**'
" "
3 !
# "
" 3
"
3
"
"
"
"
"
#
"
"
"
"
"
# !
:+*'6;,7 F '+6
"- "
"
" #
3
" "
3
#
"
#"
> # 3 # 3 ##
% 3 "
3
A" # !
"
3 3
# % "
# ""
>
" #
#
3% .
#
" 3
"
" 3% .
#
5
3 "
!
3 3
"
@
"
3 #
"
.
!
H A +*',( 6-*
#" 3 #
+(
" " !
"
3 # "
"
3
% $3 =
" 3 "
3 # 8 9$3 = "
3 3
4 !
# "
"
$3 =
'':';:;
A
"
3 "
=&
+1-* +**)
&
%
$3 = @
"
D *) +**) #
#3 +1 +**) 2
" " 3
%
+**'
2#
! "#" !
3 " " A
!#3!
23 & :'1-);') ')+3
"
3 3
#>3 #" @
"
> !
"
3 # 3 !
" 3 C" +*'+
''
2 #
"
!
"!
"
3#
3
#
"
!
" " 3
!
"" !
# #
#
3
" 3 3 A %
7 !
2
:+**6;, (++
+,
A
" 3 !"
# "
''
2 "
> +**'!
3 3
3 3
"
##
"
$3 = 4
. 01
2 01 " 01
2 01 "
"!
"
4!# 2 5 6 "!
8!"
"#4
$3 = $3 = ''
:';
$3 =
3 3
# "
''
:';
$3 =
3 3
# "
;D
"
3 3 . $3 = :$ . ;5 # % /"5 /" $ H 2
! # % " 333
+ 3 .
# % # 333 + !"
% ""
!"
3"
"
;D
"
$3 =
#
!
>3 3
3% "
# 4 :;&
" "3 !"
5
+' 3 (*
3#
>
) " # # % .
3 3 5 3 .
3 3 5
5
;D
"
3 3 !# % " 333
+ 3 4"34
:;2 "
. @!
B !
:; 2 " !
" "
:=
;
:+;
!"" $3 =
3 #
"
!""
3 "
1; > 3 "
:; 4
:;
:!; 2 "
!
<
'+* = " +,=
'* 3 & "
!
@ 5 333 )I3%
! !"" "
3
3 3%
4 "
" 3 "
#"
"
" #
3 "
2 @ "
3!
3
>3
:(; & #"
4
:';@ " . 3
> ! " >"
3
;D
"
33 ! # % " 333
+
3 4"34 "
#"
4 :,; 2 4 $3 4=
3
#"
!""
:;
" "
. @!
B !
:; 2 " !
" "
:=
;
/ +)
2 #"
3 #
"" !
3 +**'
"
3 +**1 C #
% # #
" # #
" +**' # # 3 #
5 $=
+6
2 @ "
"" !
"% +**'# " 3 !
3
" 3 #
"
" 4 "
+-
2 3 3
"
"
!
>3 3
3% >
)*I
$3 = " "3 )*I 3 !# % " 333
#
3 4"34 !
" "
. @!
3 B !
" "
=
!
)*I
$3 = #
8
9 33 . $3 = :$ . ;5 # % 7 # /G $5 /G $ 33 .
# % #333# !"
% ""
!"
3"
"
A
3
3% # "
"3
+0
A!
"
!$
"
%
$
"
&
( ) '* ') +* +'
+,G+-
." /
"
&
1 '+ ', '- ++G+0
+1
3 # "
#" 3
3
" "3
#
"
"!
"
3 #
8
9 9
3
# "
'':';:;
'':';:;
" 8 9#
8
" 9 (*
A
" 8
9 #
A
# 3
#
"
3 " $=
"!
# !
>
"
"
"
!
! 3%
.
"
38
5 9
3 D 3 "
"
3 ##3 E
A# %
#
#
$3 =
" "
8
9 9 8
9 38
9 3 3
'' :'; :;
23
#"
3
" # !
8 !"
9
8 !"
9
'':';:; "
!
3"
"
!"
" #
H 2
$"
G "
++1
% " "3
3 # <!
"
++1
%
#
3 # !
$"
"
"
!"
3 # " 2
= "
# " 33
# ?
$ % / 3 *) '116: >4
+6;"
33
# 33
$3 = "
!
>3
# " ##"#3 >
>
"
3
"
#""
""
"
"
$=#
"
2
$ 33
3 (*
+*'+ # " 3
"!
" / 3 *) '116 #"
"
"
# "
##
3 !
"
"
('
# 3
>3
'':';:; :;
""
""
#
3 3 "+**'
" #
3
'':';:;
# ""
&
3 " 3"
3
# !
# 3 3%.
# # 3 "
5 $3 = $ *'
+**'
>"
3 3# " #"
3#" "
# " #
$= "
%"
"
5 = #
!
""
# ! # 3 A
!
3 #" (+
3 4"3 #"
@ "
"
', 2
!
3 3 # "
" >
!
3 " "
A @
%
+**1 3
# 3 3 #
? #
"%
"
$ *'
+**'#
# "3 $3 = A3
#
3 "
" @ "
"
',
# # 3 !
" ##
D3 "
',!
3"
!"
"
((
2
"
3#
!"
"
3 +'
+**+ 3 $3 = !
3 % !
3
#
%
3 3 !
3
C" +( +**' "
" #
3 <!
3
% 3 " 3
"
# % !
"
- " ""3"
A# ""
" 3
A# #
!
"
# 3
"3 >"
" 3
&
# #
(,
2 # # 3
3
"
@
# "
"
% A@ C"
"
"
+**1# #
"
3 @
#
!"
"
" # ?
$ 3!
A
"! 3
"
3" "
3 !""# !
"
# A!""# !
#
#
?
#
3 3
()
=
3 !
A 3 " +**) 3 ?
$"
$ .
""
" 8!""3!
!
9 =
#
"
?
$"
7 8
3% .
9 A
3" $"
" ?
$ !""3 !
!
" ?
$
# C
"
"
#
3 #
"
@
"
3
@
2
"
!
! " "
"
" 3
# " #"
!
A #3 3 ! ""3"
#"
*, +**(
3
"
""
# "!
3
#
A
3 ''
+**+
% # %
!"" !
3
!"
2#
3 @ !
<!
#
"
% # ##
@
" # # @ "
"B
"
3 +'
+**+
" "
"
# "
% 3
#" 3
%
"
" A # 4
"
3 "
"
# " 3
"
"!
"
#
" >"
""
@
# (6
C @
" !"
!
3
" 33
?
$ "
#3
>"
%
@ 3 3%# @ 3 3 3 3 3% #" !
"%
? " " "
"
> " " A"
# 3 "
3
"
""
# "
"
+**( "
%
!
"
2 %
""3"
3"#
"3
!
"
"
& >"
+**) " 3
# #
3 > 2"
"" ! " 3
-'B "
#
" "
3 @
# 3% .
# 3 3
#
# 3 "
"
"3 !"
"
3
"3
3 "
" !
"
" A4
4 !"
>"
"
'6 CA
"
" 3
3
(-
" " AH A !
$%3 :'11';, '*1 !
33 "
"
"
3
"
3
"
3 # "
#
5 $= ""
5 5
3 "
%.
# 83 9$="
@
#
# 3
5 !
.
" """3"
"
" ? # %
?
#
#
%
# 2" " 3 " " "
0- "
# 3 "% # !
3
#
#
.
!
23 & :+*'(;'' 6,0J
#8 3"
9# 3
@ K . !
$" :+*'+;'( 1,J"
"@ E 3 @ 3 " E #"
@ %
#"
3 "@ "3
<
5 "
3
3 "
3 # K
"
3 #"# ""
"
(0
2
"
"
"
/!
" " 3
# 0- 2
!
L!
:+**);A7' ,1(E 3!
'11-:+; $ ,'6E ! !
'110:'; $('-G % !
'11):(; 2-0)
/
" 3!
+*'):+; 2'(*
#"3 @
"
(1
" ! #
"
!
""
3 ""
=
" ?
3 33
#" 3 3 (* +*'+
"
""
3 +, +*'+
3 3 "
@ $ '( +*'+
?
" $"
D +0 +**1 4
%
!
# % ""
,*
@ 3 ?
" $"
"
7
3 A 4"
>
5
3 # 3 % .
$=
@ # !
$3 = ! " " # " 3 "
3
$ *'
+**'
('
+**6 *0
+**0
"!
"
!
3
"
" " #
3 "
!"
$'6 +**1"
"% #
3+7 % & % 3 =
%5 L 5&
=
L 5&