Regional Provident Fund Commissioner v. Employees Provident Fund Appellate Tribunal And ORS
!
"#$ "% #& !
'()*+,-./0+)) , /'0
! "
# !
$ % & #
'(
)
* +
,')*-.&/&0%0&%+1
2&3. % %
4
# ( " ( &55/6 ( ')(
7 ')6 ('
(8 (
%90%%003
(
(
%00%
%003
#
" / '(
7
)
&5:%+
,') -. (')(
;:;;;/92< 03&0%003 *
(
%
4
(* ')
# ( # ( " /= &;> ') %909%005 %
4
# %909%005
?
( # ( &@/%0:;+ .@&/%5332< +( . %
<
&@/%0:;2< &905%005A (
%
<
')*
# ( &/03%0&&
?
%
4
# ')* # %
7
&/&0%0&%#
@
(%
4
')
( ')(
(
(
%00%
%003#
%
4
#
( (')(
# ')
#
# ( # ( " /=&;> ') %909%005# # %
4
1
1 #
( # (
( ')(
*
%
4
(
')*
%
4
( ')(
(
1 4 #
( ( ')(
# ( (
') (
) > !"!#$%&'& ($)&* #$
+ (( +,+
# < .
-' . /0# )& /. %% 1%$ $ ' "#2 ,/
,4 2'! )$' 1%$ ..&&' )& 56$$-.7')($
3 (7# ,8' 4 2'! )$'1%$..&&')&9& "!1$&($$': 3
$';$'$75&% ; 8
%
4
#
( #
?
( (
# %
')(
( " / ') #
')* &0# ?
"
(
7 ( 0.< 5''&= /'#&%;' <)& >-($$' 3 / +*')* !
?
# # )
%
<
1(
')* ( %
! %
#
')*7 &/&0%0&%
%
# < .
& '$; '!' $ 6 '. >&< (%$$'&)&2'! )$' 1%$..&&' $!$'& /%< / +4 "&&& )$' 1%$ ..&&' 01 $ ')&-'!'.' 2/(-'? '&#$) ($%!& '; /4 9&'& ' #$($)&-'2'! '; $'
/%< /, 4 ) 0.< 5''&/'#&%;'<)&>-($ '
3 / +& $ :
9 >
" &;> ') # <
@ 6' ';)'5 $.!'& @ ! " # ! !!
$
%! &'( )! *+ %! &+( )! *, !
! )! # ! )! ! !
)! *,"
! ! -
. "
! / ! .-" !
+ 0 ! " 1!
" ! )!2 )$'$7'
' ')5!$';)'!&%; $.!'
' '.< 5' & 7' !)' '&7 ' <<%5 7'!'$A )$'$ %' ' ' $ .5 '$%;'6)''$.!'& ')'$%$'&&'; ' '&7 &.' 6; & &;B $%& ;.<5$'&<'; 6;&;'.'
'7 &7''&;'$75'$ #$%& $ 1; 2';&%; '&7 &'$ %$' /'; ' /;B #$%& .<'& /<'; )&&"; 3+ 3, &%7'; &%;'.&$;$&&.57'&<'; '$'
/;'.'3 " &;<> ')
#
( (
(! (
)
(
)
> (
# ( " &;<> ') (# !
# (
>) " ; " &53: /
( ( " &;<> ') # #
%
<
# %
<
( #
%
<
( #
(
!
# ( %
<
*
%
,
4
!# ( * # %
" &;<> ') 3
')
# (
(
(
%00%
%003
%
4
(')
#
%
4
# " &;<> ')
#
B
( 1 C #
( (
#
# %
" &;<> ') ( 2 # " &;<> ') %
4
%
4
( 1 # " &;<> ')
(
/<
#
# ( (
" &;<> ') %
( 0.< 5''&/'#&%;'< +
. +.+.+. %
4
%
4
B
( 1 # " &;<> ')
%
4
(
# (
# %
" &;<>
') ')* ! # %
4
7 #
%
" &;<>
*
( %
" &;< > (
# * ')*
%
<
1 #%
" &;<> ') 5
A "
(
';
0 ;'.')&-<)($$'&
, /%<'.'%&'& /3&@ <
, 45 4 6 !
0" ! 4 4 4!! 4 ! 4!
4 ! 44 ! !
4 !7
! . !"
*89, ! 4
0 !4 ! )! ':&*(&( " *9;, 4 < ! 4 ! ! 4!
! 7 ! ! = ! 1 0
! 7 < !7 # " ! 4< !4 0 <! 1 ! " 7> 7 4 4 7!! ! !" !1 $%< ! !
! 4 4 4 3 4 < ! 7 # ! "
4 !! 4 ! 4 !
4
& !( !
! 4 4 ! 43
! 4! 7
0 ! 4!4 ! ! 1 43 0
0 !! )" ! ! ! 1! 0! ! ! ! 43
< ! ! " 4 < ! ! 3 0 4 !4 4!! 3 ! 4 !4 !
" ! 43 ! 1 )! ':&*(&(" !
)! !
4 < ! 3 4!
3 !
< ! ! ! !
! ! 8 #
! 4! 4 0! ! 44 )! ':&*(&( " *9;, $ ! )! *?" " *9;, 0 ! 43 )! ':"
! ! 0 ! 0 0 4 4
" !
!" 0 4 !4 4!! 4 !
0
$ 4 3 ! ! 0 0! !
!
! !" = ! !" ! !
)! *? " 0
! 0 0 4 0 ! !4
$
0 !
)! *?" " *9;, # $! 0! 4 0 4 ! !" ! )! ':&*(&( " *9;, 0
1! 4 4 < !
)! ':&*(&( " *9;," ! ! ! 0" 0 ! ! 0
! '?&'( # ! ! 0 ! ! 7 !7 )! ': ! ! 7! 7 ! 0 *:
0
0 " 0 41 $!4 $ 4 0 4 ! !
! " *9;, "
" & !
0(
$ )! ':&*(&( *9;, . ! )! *? " *9;, ! 6 )! ':&*(&( ! !
)! *?&*(&( @
4 0 ! !4 ! $ ! 4!
!"4"
4 0 ! !4 < ! !
! ! !"
0! )! ':&*(&( !
! ! 0 !
! 0 0 /
0 $
"
" - "
(
0.< 5''&=/'#&%;'<)& >-($$'
3 /%<'.'%&'& +
&9&3%0 <
*A # 0% 0 ! 0
! B ! )! 8+%C !
# # ! ! $
!
*8 )! 8+%C ! 0
7
! 7 B 0 < ! " " 1!
:*% " "
" ! 0 B ! '? # 0" 0 " ! "
! ! 7
< !7 !
# !" 0 !! "
" 0 $
!
$ 0!" "
! 0 0 < ! !
1 !
! 0 ! 7 ! 7 0 0 ! 0
! # 0 !! 0 ! 3 "
(
>$%&-.'&($)&* #$$ '&
3 /%<'.'%&'&
%:%9 %/%5 <
'+ .< @ . ) D 5 B "
D E*98, B # A+9 &.<(F & 0!" 5< " > 0 ("
0 ! 7 < !7 !! ! 0 0 4
4 0
)! *;%C" !
! = ! " 0
" ! # 0
4 $ 0
0 ! ! !! !" 0 ! ! !
0
0 ! 0 !
< !
! ! 0 ! !4 & # 0 ! !
< ! !! " 0
0 ! !
! <!
= " !
@ ! ! ! < !
0 .< @ . ) D 5 B &.<( 0
C @ ) ."
= 5
E*99A &,'( B 8': &C(FG )
! 6 # E*99' B #8?8 &C(F 'A ! < ! 0
)
! & ( B 6 # E*99* B #*9;A &C(F ) > C @ # 0 ! !
< ! !!
! )! *;%C"
! !
!! !! !! !$ 0 !
! C !
! # ! ! ! !
< ! ', #
! 0 &= " )C E*9,9 B # *8, & (FG # ) ! E*98: B # 9;? & (FG ) <
E*9,? &:,( > 9' & D@(F 0 " " !
! '9
!" 0 ! ! )! *;%C ! ! 0
! !
0 ! <!
G
! " " $!
0 %!" !
!$
"
! < ! G !
!
! )! *;%C ! !
!
0 ! 0 0
! )! *;%C 0
G ! )! *;%C ! < ! ! " 0 0 0
! 0
! @0 "
! ! < ! 0 !
)! *;%C" ! ! 1 ! " < ! 4
4 2 ! < ! !
H % 0 0 " !
!
0 ! ! ! !
! !G
0! ! 4
4 < !G " ! ! 4
4 < !"
! !
0 ! ! !! 0 !! G <! " ! @ ! 0 !3 '
(
!
#( %
" &;<> ') *
%
4
!
! ( (
') # ')*
# #
')*
&/&0%0&% 1
2&3 &0
A # #& !
1))#2#$3
! ,56 A ! 2 D A
D