Sakil v. State Of Haryana And Another



   


 



  


   

!"

#$

"%&'&#()  * * 

+ ,&-












 

+! !"

#$  ./ ( (0 (#!1".

 

 )  2 3 * +
  + +      
 
 




   + + 

*

. -



  



 

!
"#$

%&!! #'#(

) *

+,
&#--

-'$#'#.

!
/.

 ((#


("

(
%&!
*  


 
!
0 
1  
 2  *2


 )
 *

# 
*
+,
2



3

 2

  


4 
5


 

 5


    

      

        

     ! 

 "#"

$% &'  $   !()*+,-  -.//  (01(0  +23'4/56*0(-7/ (8(-7./(9-0.:52,(2&-6;5,650'./-78(7)6(9-78;5,4';+00< -00'8(0*&<.-4(0,'0(/-571-/&0(/'7-8&/(7)(0.5/&,'(/'7-78/5 9-00  (7)  /5  /(9'  0'8(0  (4/-57  -,  /  -.  ,'=+'./')  /&(/   456*0(-7(7/,.&-)(#:5>+2(,-9:5'(,>(.3-)?-00(8' >(7)*+,- '&.-0(7) -./,-4/ (01(0><$+.2(7)>+2(,-9



15,9.(/ ,-/&0((7)&'15,9(/7-8&/57(0/',7(/-@')(<. '(,/55+,&5+.'(9-0:52,(&-6A.*05/-..-/+(/')7   

-7/&'(2.'74'5;6<&+.2(7)(/  >(9-0 '7/',')-76<&5+.'(7))-)52.4'7'(4/.1-/&6'(7)(0.5 &'

;5,4';+00<  405.')  6<  65+/&  1-/&  &(7).  (7)  ;5,4';+00< './(20-.&')-00'8(0,'0(/-571-/&6' +'/5;'(, )-)75//'00 (7</&-78/56<&+.2(7)>+2(,-9(9-0/&,'(/'7')/59-006' (7)6<;(6-0<(7),(7(1(<2<./(/-78/&(/-;1-00/'00(7< /&-78/56<&+.2(7)5,6<;(6-0<6'62',./&'7&'1-009-006' (7)6<;(6-0<6'62',.,'6(-7')=+-/'2'4(+.'6<4&-0),'7 (,'.6(00(7)1(.(057'(/&56'+/7511-0075/2'=+-/' (7)+7)',456*+0.-577(,,(/')/&'-74-)'7//56<&+.2(7) >+2(,-91&'7&'4(6'2(49;,56&-.)+/<51(6;5,4')/5 /(9'0'8(0(4/-57(9-0.:52,(&-6&+.

-/-.,'=+'./')/&(/ (**,5*,-(/'  0'8(0  (4/-57  2'  /(9'7  (8(-7./  /&'  *',.57 6'7/-57')(25@' %5+,9-7)7'..1-002'(**,'4-(/')B ( 6 
 
 *




 




  3
 


  
 
3
  
3
 *
 
 *
* 


 *

 3


2
 

 
 
7




 *
*
 


  


+,

2 
  *
 
 
+,






 
2


  3
*



3
2 



*


 * 


 
 3
 8
2 8

  



2 8

*
   
3



''$#'#.


 


 


('




 

 


 


 

2




 
   3
  


2






   3
   
 
 
2




 


 
3*


 
 




 

8
  7



 
 *
2 
 
 

  



''$#'#.
 *

 


 

2



9



4 
5#
2


 3
 

 

3

 3

':('


'/('



  3




 
  
* 
 *





''$#'#.




 


 
2


3

'/('


  *

 

 *


 


('

 




 


 
2

  
    






+,

 


) 
7

 




 


 


 
2 


!!
1    2


4 
5(







3
2 * 
 




 



**
 
 

* 
3

 
 

2 
7



2

  


   

 


  

  * 

  


   

+,

 


)  . ,

 

 
 


  " 
 
 *
2
2
 
3

 
 


2




 *



+,
  


 
2



3
 
'/('



 *  

8
 


('







'$#'#.


   




  


 


  2




; 


  
2


8


 *
 
3

 
 




 





9
 






 3




 
3
23


*




; 
2 
4  *
2


! "#$

%&!

 

*


2

 

  
2
  




  3


 

  4 
5#
2

*
 


  
* 
 3   *




3


 


 
  *
2
2
 
3

 
 




2



 
2
 
3*



3






 





 *


 
 

 


 
 


9
 


 

9



 



; 


4   3
2
) 

+,
  

 



3



 

  
 *

2
2
 
3

 
 


 2



 





8*

  


 *

 


3
 
 

 
) 3
2
 
 
 
 





2
3
+,

 *  







2


 


3
  
2

 

3
2

*

2



 






   

 *


   





 
 


9 / 
2
2
* 


) *


+,

2
  7< 
! 
; 


  

    



   
  

2
* 


 

2

+,


) 



 
 

 5

 

= 7/&'2(49),5*5;/&'-7/',*,'/(/-575;/&'@(,-5+. ,'0'@(7/*,5@-.-57.5;/&'5)'+7)',
&(*/',C?(7)5; /&'*,-74-*0'.5;0(1'7+74-(/')2</&-.5+,/-7(.',-'. 5;)'4-.-57.,'0(/-78/5/&''D',4-.'5;/&''D/,(5,)-7(,< *51',+7)',,/-40'

5,/&'-7&','7/*51',.+7)', .'4/-57 5;/&'5)'1&-4&1'&(@''D/,(4/')(7) ,'*,5)+4')(25@'

1'8-@'/&';50051-784(/'85,-'.5;

4(.'.2<1(<5;-00+./,(/-571&','-7.+4&*51',45+0)2' 'D',4-.')'-/&',/5*,'@'7/(2+.'5;/&'*,54'..5;(7< 5+,/5,5/&',1-.'/5.'4+,'/&''7).5;3+./-4' /&5+8&-/ 6(<75/2'*5..-20'/50(<)517(7<*,'4-.'

40'(,0< )';-7')  (7)  .+;;-4-'7/0<  4&(77'0-.')  (7)  -7;0'D-20' 8+-)'0-7'.5,,-8-);5,6+0('(7)/58-@'(7'D&(+./-@'0-./ 5;6<,-()9-7).5;4(.'.1&','-7.+4&*51',.&5+0)2' 'D',4-.') #&','/&'(00'8(/-57.6()'-7/&'-,./7;5,6(/-57 '*5,/5,/&'456*0(-7/ '@'7-;/&'<(,'/(9'7(//&'-, ;(4'@(0+'(7)(44'*/')-7/&'-,'7/-,'/<)575/*,-6( ;(4-'457./-/+/'(7<5;;'74'5,6(9'5+/(4(.'(8(-7./ /&'(44+.')

#&','/&'(00'8(/-57.-7/&'-,./7;5,6(/-57'*5,/ (7)5/&',6(/',-(0.

-;(7< (4456*(7<-78/&')5 75/  )-.405.'  (  4587-E(20'  5;;'74'

 3+./-;<-78  (7 -7@'./-8(/-572<*50-4'5;;-4',.+7)','4/-57  5;

/&'5)''D4'*/+7)',(75,)',5;(>(8-./,(/'1-/&-7/&' *+,@-'15;'4/-57



5;/&'5)' #&','/&'+7457/,5@',/')(00'8(/-57.6()'-7/&' 5,456*0(-7/(7)/&''@-)'74'4500'4/')-7.+**5,/5;/&'

5

.(6')575/)-.405.'/&'4566-..-575;(7<5;;'74'(7) 6(9'5+/(4(.'(8(-7.//&'(44+.') #&','

/&'(00'8(/-57.-7/&')575/457./-/+/'( 4587-E(20'5;;'74'2+/457./-/+/'570<(7574587-E(20' 5;;'74'

75-7@'./-8(/-57-.*',6-//')2<(*50-4'5;;-4', 1-/&5+/(75,)',5;(>(8-./,(/'(.457/'6*0(/')+7)', '4/-57



5;/&'5)'

#&','/&'(00'8(/-57.6()'-7/&'5,456*0(-7/ (,'.5(2.+,)(7)-7&','7/0<-6*,52(20'57/&'2(.-.5; 1&-4&75*,+)'7/*',.574(7'@',,'(4&(3+./45740+.-57 /&(//&','-..+;;-4-'7/8,5+7);5,*,54'')-78(8(-7.//&' (44+.') #&','/&','-.(7'D*,'..0'8(02(,'78,(;/')-7(7<5; /&'*,5@-.-57.5;/&'5)'5,/&'4574',7')4/+7)', 1&-4&  (  4,-6-7(0  *,54'')-78  -.  -7./-/+/')  /5  /&'

-7./-/+/-57  (7) 457/-7+(74'  5;  /&'  *,54'')-78.  (7):5, 1&','/&','-.(.*'4-;-4*,5@-.-57-7/&'5)'5,/&' 4574',7')  4/  *,5@-)-78  ';;-4(4-5+.  ,'),'..  ;5,  /&' 8,-'@(74'5;/&'(88,-'@')*(,/<

#&','(4,-6-7(0*,54'')-78-.6(7-;'./0<(//'7)') 1-/&6(0(;-)'(7):5,1&','/&'*,54'')-78-.6(0-4-5+.0< -7./-/+/')1-/&(7+0/',-5,65/-@';5,1,'(9-78@'78'(74' 57/&'(44+.')(7)1-/&(@-'1/5.*-/'&-6)+'/5*,-@(/' (7)*',.57(08,+)8'  #'(0.58-@'(75/'5;4(+/-57/5/&'';;'4//&(//&' *51',  5;  =+(.&-78  (  4,-6-7(0  *,54'')-78  .&5+0)  2' 'D',4-.')@',<.*(,-780<(7)1-/&4-,4+6.*'4/-57(7)/&(/



/55-7/&',(,'./5;,(,'4(.'.F/&(//&'5+,/1-0075/2' 3+./-;-')  -7  '62(,9-78  +*57  (7  '7=+-,<  (.  /5  /&' ,'0-(2-0-/<5,8'7+-7'7'..5,5/&',1-.'5;/&'(00'8(/-57. 6()'  -7  /&'    5,  /&'  456*0(-7/  (7)  /&(/  /&' 'D/,(5,)-7(,<  5,  -7&','7/  *51',.  )5  75/  457;',  (7 (,2-/,(,<3+,-.)-4/-5757/&'5+,//5(4/(445,)-78/5-/. 1&-65,4(*,-4'B

  

 *


 
 





2

 
2

2
3

7> 
! 
; 

; 




2


* 
8
3





2
  
 


2
3

7> 
! 
; 

  2 
 
 

 3

  
  

 
  ; 



 
 


 
,


 

2



 


2


 

 
 2
 




2


 

2
3

7>  ! 
; 
,










+,

 

 ) 





































$ ; ) 3

  


 

 : 72 
3*
  
 



 



4 






 

 




   

*

  

 3
 * * 

 + +  ,(9'.&

  ?
8*  @ A& ?
    @ A&