← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13357/2016dismissed

Bhupinder Singh Hira And ANR v. Prem Chand Guleria And ORS

2016-09-14Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary6 pages



     

    

 !"# $ %#&& !& '

"# ( )"#* * #"+ & !, -"#&& !'

"#* ( (./ %01.(232453.(.1 %01.(23(.(2 #"*" ' .#)5 &#+&6!78&'"6

#'

"'' "#* .#%& 6!78&'"6

##"*  !" ' 999

   "'' "#*

 !"# $ %#&& !%&# !"#5& #6:

&#"

#"*"#7"!8&'"$#;"+ -;""* "*',#&!

&'" *''

'" ."!8&- !

8&' & !("*"&#8 < #* #' =,.(0>6 & !$&# <#"*  !" '

 "#" >6  &7"  -"!  '

*  "''  !"#  #'8-"* 

?

   *''

'   !&8 &--" $ $'

 ?   < "@ #"  / >  #" !"#"!  A;  '

"  " '#&-  !+ *'#&'7"  #A &-6  & !$&# " 8 6 & !$&# < "#" & '"##"

"##"!'&*='

"#A &-0>6 "#"A;'

"#$ &-

-8&' <?B ? > -"!A;

#"+ & !, -"#&<#"*  !" ' "#" >6&$" "#&-8&'"$#;"+ -;""

",.(6*""C $'

0&'8

-"0 &*A"" &--:"!

#"

-;*'&'"!6#"*  !" 'D "!'

"*"#78" ,.( &*2 #8&-"'" $#&

"#  B& !:&* #+'"!&*" #

8&-"'" $#&

"#  B"'' "#D "!&*2 #8&-"

'" $#&

"#  B& ! &7 $E &- "'"*'6 ":&*&

 '"!

&*" #8&-"'" $#&

"#  "'' "# D "!&* " #  8&-"  '" $#&

"#        "#"& '"#6    7":   ("8# '+" '( -"*67!"#!"#!&'"!  6A'

"'' "#*:"#"

#+'"!''

"#* &-***'& ' !"#'

"#"*"#7"8&'"$#;6 "#"&*#"* #+'"!''

"*&! *'7!"#!"#!&'"!

B  "*" #';-*'  "#* &-***'& '*:&*8#8 -&'"!  * : $'

"'' "#*&**" #'#"*  !" '%:"7"#6

 '

-"+" '&'  !&!#"("7": ",.(:'

"

"8'

#+    6  !"*$ &'  *'    "#* &-  ***'& '  :&* & $"!'#7&'""8#"'&#; '

""@*' $ &;*8&-"   /  <" '#&-&;8&-">& !  /< D&A&;8&-"> "!&'"

"-$A-'; #* #"/!"*$ &' :&* @"!&*  #'

"!&'"

#+' &*"#* &-***'& ' &7 $B;"&#*"@ "#" 8" 8- ! $'

&'

" # 8&-" '" $#&

"#6:

"7"# * -&'"# 88#! $-;67!"#!"# !&'"! B  "'' "#*& ! :"#"#"/!"*$ &'"!&*#7&'"

"8#"'&#;:'

"

"8' #+ B& ! B6#"* "8'7"-;6& '"# "#8+ -"' $B;"&#* #"$ -&#*"#78" 8- ! $'

"*"#78" " # 8&-"'" $#&

"#6:

"#"&*#"*  !" ':&*#"/!"*$ &'"!&*#7&'"

"8#"'&#;:'

"

"8' #+B "!&'" * #+' &*"#* &- ***'& '    '

"  *&!  #!"#  !&'"!  B  6  '  :&*  +" ' "!  '

&'

##"* "8'7" "!&'" #"/!"*$ &' &*#7&'""8#"'&#;6'

"#":--A"

8 & $" '

"*" #';-*' $#&!" "#* &-***'& ' "#"& '"#6

6:

" '

",.(8#8 -&'"!'

#7* &-*" #';-*'

/ / "#7&'""8#"'&#"*6* : $'

"'' "#*&**" #'#"*  !" '

6-&''"#* A+''"!#"

#"*" '&' ?AD"8' *!&'"!  --:"!

A;&#"+ !"#!&'"! 6#"E "*' $'

"& #'"*'+!

;'

*&!*" #';-*'!&'"! & !A;$7 $ +'

=&'8

-"06 **" #';A"#"/ @"!7"#& !&A7"'

"'' "#*)!"#!"# !&'"!  6,.(  &-*"!'

"& #"*&! #7* &-*" #';-*'

!&'"!    ("*  !" '    * A+''"!  +& ;  #"

#"*" '&' *?

#"+ !"#*  &$& *'  '

"  *&!  #!"#   A*"E " '-;6    '

"  A&**    

#8""! $*!&'"!

  67!"#!"#!&'"!   6'

"'' "#* :"#" #+'"!''

# 8 &-#7&'""8#"'&#;$$#"7"!&$& *'

"*&+"6#"*  !" ' -"!?B ?

8 &--" $ $'

#!"#!&'"!    &-* $'

#7* &-*" #';-*'6& !'

& #"*&!#!"#!&'"!   6#!"# $ #+'  "'' "#* %:"7"#67!"#!"#!&'"! 6#"* "#+''"!' :'

!#&:'

"*&+":'

-A"#';' -"  '

"$# !*&7&-&A-"'

+  88#! $-;6  #"*  !" '    -"!      ?B ? 

&--" $ $'

"*" #';-*'!&'"!  6 #8""! $*!&'"!

  & !'

  #"$&#! $ #+' 

"'' "#*  "'' "#*  & !  '

"  

8&-  #"*  !" '*  -"!  '

"# "8'7":#''" *'&'"+" '*   '"#  "&# $  -"&# "!  8 &#'"*6  '

"  -"&# "!

#A &-7!"'

$ "!#!"#!&'"!  ?   &*&--:"!

"*&!F& ! &*E &* "*" #';-*'!&'"!  6

#8""! $*!&'"!

  & !'

#+' #!"#!&'"! 

// &'

#"*" ' "'' "#* "

8&-#"*  !" '* &7"A"" !#"8'"!' #"/!#&:'

"*" #';-*' #7&'""8#"'&#"*A;&

-; $=&'8

-"0 & !' -!#"7":'

"#"& '"# # #+' ''

# 8 &- #7&'""8#"'&#;& !'$#& ' #+' &88#! $-; #+!

"!&'"*:'

&--8 *"E " '&-A" "

'*' &*&-*A"" #!"#"!'

&'#"*  !" '

"#" +&;&-*A"8 *!"#"!&88#! $-; # #+' & !A"$#& '"!

#+' 6 ! ' #'

"*&+"%" 8"'

#"*" ':#' "'' 

1"&# "!8 *"- #'

"'' "#*&#$ &'* 8" #+' "'' "#*  '  '

*'    "#* &-  ***'& '  7!"  #!"#  !&'"!   & !8 *"E " ' @&'  *" #';&*   :&* '

&--" $"!A;#"*  !" '6'

"#"

#"6'

"#$ &-

-8&'  -"!A;

 !" '      '

"  ;"&#   8 &--" $ $  '

"  *" #';  -*'  !&'"!

  :&*'+"A&##"!1"&# "!#A &*:# $-;$7" A" "

"=&'8

-"0'#"*  !" '6&*'

*( -": -!A"&

-8&A-"

#+  "!&;:

" #'8-"<> " *''

'   !& :&*  *"#'"!6& ! '

"'' "#*  '

" *'& '8&*":"#" #+'"! &* "#* &-***'& ' '

";"&#     '

"  '

"#  & !6  -"&# "!  8 #  #"*  !" '   * A+''"!'

&'& '"##"/!"*$ &'  "'' "#*& !#"*  !" '&* #7&'""8#"'&#"*7!"#!"#!&'"! B  6+" '  $'

"#" '

&'

##"* "8'7" "!&'" "##"/!"*$ &' 6'

"#":--A" 8 & $" '

*" #';-*' $#&!" "#* &-***'& '6:

" '

",.(8#8 -&'"!

#7* &-  *" #';  -*'   "  #7&'"  "8#"'&#"*     !" '    * A+''"!  AD"8' *  '  '

"  *&+"  A;  * A+'' $ #"

#"*" '&' !&'"!  --:"!A;&#"+ !"#!&'"!

%:"7"#67!"#!"#!&'"!  6:'

'8 *!"# $'

"AD"8' *?

#"

#"*" '&' *    #"*  !" '  6  ,.(   &-*"!  '

"  & #"*&!

#7* &-*" #';-*'!&'"! %" 8"6:'

"#!

-+'&' 6 '

";"&# 6#"*  !" '8 &--" $"!'

"& #"*&!#!"# !&'"!  A; - $?B ?

6:

:&*!*+**"!

&*:'

!#&: 7!"#!"#!&'"! 6:'

-A"#';'#"*  !" ' ' -"  '

"$# !*&7&-&A-"' +88#! $-;6  ?B ?

 8 &--" $ $  '

"  *" #';  -*'  !&'"!    6  

#8""! $*!&'"!

  & !'

  #"$&#! $

#+'  "'' "#*:&* -"!6:

8&  'A"*&!'A"A&##"!A;

-+'&'  "*&! &*A"" #$ '-;&--:"!A;'

"-"&# "!#A &-6 !"* '#"E #"& ; '"# "#" 8"

 '"#  $7 $   #  '

$

-  8 *!"#&'  '  '

"  #7&- 8 '" ' *    -"&# "!  8 &#'"*  & !  $ $  '

# $ +

$ "!#!"#6:"  !+"#' '

"* A+** *+&!"A;-"&# "!8 *"-

##"*  !" '6A"8& *"'*'

": 8&*" "'' "#*'

&''

=&'8

-"0: -!A"&

-8&A-" #+  "!&;:

" #'8-"

  <>   "   *''

'     !&  :&*   *"#'"!  !+''"!-;6  '

"'' "#*& !#"*  !" ' '

*8&*":"#" #+'"!&*"#* &- ***'& '& '"#'

"*&!8

!&'"("* #+'"!:'

"8' #+B 6:

"#"&*'

"'' "#*:"#" #+'"!&** :'

"8' #+ B& ! B%" 8"6'

"-"&# "!#A &* #$ '-;  $7"  '

"  A" "

'    =&'8

 ( -"0  '  #"*  !" '    #'

"#+#"6* 8" '

"

8&-  #"*  !" '* !!  ' #"

&#"'

" 8##"8'

*" #';-*'A;$7 $'

=&'8

-"0'#"*  !" '6

// & !   &-*"!  '

#7* &-  *" #';  -*'  !&'"!   :'

8 *!"# $'

"#"

#"*" '&' ** A+''"!A;#"*  !" '6'

"#"

#"6 #   6'

" -"!A;#"*  !" '8& 'A"*&!'A"A&##"!A;

-+'&'  "-"&# "!#A &*#$ '-;&

#"8&'"!'

"+&''"#& !:"

! '  !& ;--"$&-';# "#7"#*'; '

$ "!#!"# B *+**"!  !

   "

'"+A"#6  "  #!

!D    "'

"#* "&C $?#"&* "!

4"*?  "'

"#("

#'&A-" 4"*