← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14324/2015dismissed

Gurnam Singh v. Union Of India & ORS

2015-07-21Ms. Justice Navita Singh,Mr Justice Jaswant Singh10 pages

    



!"# $#%&'&()  *

 

        

 ) (+,-#./'"&%#0/.1!2!("

(+,-#./'"&%#!3!("4.&         ! "

    !

#          $

!

% & ' '()*    !3!("4.& 5  ,  *    -.

- "-/"

-/ "-/0)  *+

(1  20)+23(0 

4

56,

 

 78*

(     06  99/ 

 6 0

 &     "--    

         )  (   

:""

-# "-"( 

     

          ;

 

 

"  %8 

        

           

! " !

# $$  %!# & '  ( )'* +*((' (&&'

   #     &,&-  .  &,&      *          -    !

 !

# ((   /   *  !  0  123(4 &555!    *)'  4    ) ''( (        

  * (* ! 0  120'( (   

 (  )       *        ) * *' 4 6767 67 (4  *'6+ '74  855 

  

  

      

    !

  # $$

%!# & ' ( (&&'

5!,!)'* +*   (('   *!

 0  12        ( ()'( ((*  '(9(# #'

   :(' '('( 9 48&8! 4 6(8&5-(&&   '

       '*  (  ##

' ' 7   

    *    (*     !  

#  12)'((  

 ( )    *  )* * ' 4 6767 67(4  *' 6+ '74  855 

  

  

      

$!

  " !

  # $$

%!#        (  &  (     )'(&&'

 ) )' *(  :'

*(' ' ' )*'  )'(&& '

  ;

 9')&8- ) )'  ( '&8    )( )2* 9'( ,,5 ( 8&5 '* (## ' '     (9';

'

 ;

885  6** (48&<=45<7           

      (     )       *     )  *    *  '    4  6767 67(4  *'6+ '74  855 

   

  

      

!

  " !

  # $$

%!# & (       )'  (    6) >7    )

)'    *(    :  '

 *(' ' ' )*'?

<  

 

   



-.

-= "-"

    

  

   ,

 : -< -"

"-#( , 

 

   

  *             *   0, ( 

       

 ,

:

2    6  7                ,

:

2  +  



 +

   , :

2           "# -/ "-# )

*

   (    ))  "> -/ "-#

      2              

 0)+(0 

4

:# -/ "-#(0)+(0 

               6       

 0, (            *    *

  )

* 

            ( *   *      (  :

)

  0)+(0 

4

:-.

- "-/(:

) ? .9"-# 

     )

*

  0)+( 

-.

- "-/( 0? ##-9"-/   $ *   4

   

  0             0   "< -"

"-/            

          

/

              

    *      

  +

  * 

  0)+(0 

4

:"

-/ "-/(* 

   ?  -.-@---""@"-/    & )  -.-@--#"#@"-/  1   :

) ? .9@4@"-#3     0)+ :)) ,

 



  0 A            *                         (     *         

   

  

  0     "    



(     

  



 (   

*6  *  ( 

    * 

        **

(  

       B

 

  

* 6 *

 

B

      

 *    + ( 



 

  *  B



    ,

 

         

$  ( * 7    * 

.

   ;  ;     

  

*     8

     

*  

5  * 



 5     0    

  

    

    @**

             6       

    *  (    *   * 

 





     * 

 6

        (   ,   * 

 





 6     

          

 

   **

6  * 

      *





     *  

  *

 8  )             *    *

           8     + (               B

2   

>

  * 

(    8 ,  :         B



    *  B

    (

   5*     (   

                 B 

  (  

     B

* 

*      

&*B

          ?87  

$  ( *       

  

 , 

    



   

$  

*  (

$   

   ,

 

    ,

?   $ 



 * 7  8  ;      

;

  ;     

    

  

*      

     5*(    

      *  

*   

   

 0  

=    *   *    *    ( 2       *   *  

   *  0, (  

*     

  0 )"-/ 0/</                      

  

      

 ( * 7  )7   

   %8 @             (   )A+ '             ' '    '  *    * ' )(;

(('( + $ '' ) ' 

  )+B * )   $  '  '     A +  ''' ' (( A+  9'( 

 B'&&5!&&,(+ ($ 

    *       '  (   * 'A+ ' C ;

 )' D )       ;

      ''       ' ') )(D '*('(  :

'' '' D  * ) * (   '      (  ''   )   '   9       * '  

9 ('D  *  *) ( '  )  *    9 ' D ( ''   *('(  

  )    ''      )'  ***  ' '' D  '   (   ) * 'D     '            )* ' '( ' ( D ( ((') * ' E B'&&5!&&,(+ ($ 

A+ C 67 '* 'D 67( '' ;



  '        )  ' '   '' '  67 ;

'(* 'D 6*7)(* 'D 6*7( ()* '

'( '))  6*7''((' ** )D 6*7    ( 

'

'''?

2   

  *

(C :  (     8

 *  6     

 (

  

    

   6  

 

 

-     **

 5*    

  (       0)+(0 

(  

+      ?  0 2

  

 *