Saroj Balram v. State Of Punjab & ORS.
! "#$%# &### #' #
(
)
*+
!
(
,
#
*+
! ( - ./
$% &'#& '
*+
!
( -
(% '#)
*+
!
.( /,0
$% &%* '#
*+
!
#1) 2$3 1 " 4 #1 3 ##4 ) !" "" +
# , !" , - ) # "
# ,
. /
0* + /
&
0* "
') % 1-
/ + (0* "
') % -
/ ! 0* "
')
% 23-2 314- -
') % 1-
/
(& 0 0* $
/ 0 0*
')
% 1-2 - -
#1 3 ##4 5"
*"
5 + " # + "
' " # !
67 " + + 2 /+ 2
"
+ " + $* 0 *'#
8')
- 1- 9 & " "
" *
" +
2 :
') % - " 7"
& *
# "
" * # *
## 7
7 ; 3<
$* 0 # $ % & * =
0 + " " # + "
' -
" # #
" $* 3 3
1 4 3 5 - 4 #
# # #+ " $* * >
=
*
"" " "
=
> *
>
" * " *
# 7
4+637 84 +96: .
(5 - 4 *
"
# #;<<=53+8 4 +96:3#/
( 0 # *
5" + " ?*
" * # #
# *
#
"' 3 8"
43:( .
#;<<=84 +96(@+*
"
?
+" &7 "
:
* &# ')
% - 1- * " 8
9 (% '#) #+ $% & '#& '
#+#
+
A+ ')
% 2- 23 - * + # " *+
* # 1 80
; 7
"
9
$% &*=
0
" ( / B 8 7" 9 + + *
# + " " #+ 2
$* C 1 4 3 ') % 314- $% &%* '#(" "#
#
+ " 7 # #
# "
# =
" # " + + 2
#
$ 0 31+ # " "
;
!
67 ;
#;
!
-67 :
" + 0 31 + #
"
.
" + "
*
" " + + 2 /
+ "
## *
:
" &
# #
&
# * " *
" + 2
" + ""
?
( % '#) #+8 9 324 - 1
# # "
+ " # !
-67
:
+ " 7 =
>
+
=
' 8 9+ #*
=
"
!
" $% &*=
0 323+ + "
#
:
' 71' "7B =
" + .7 D1
% 7$* '# " + 5 +
>
#*
# * 7
#
% $* '# =
E >
4 $ % & *
- =
' B7:B " + .7 D4
:
* F $*
# '#+# * 8
9
* # " + "
*
F
" 3 3
$* + "
*
"
#
#
=
#
=
$ '
0 "
;+ " 80
; 79 * +
.7 D$>BG!%/G% >F =% 0G 0!
/G% >F @:$@G!G='0 :>% 8G='0 :>%7:!0%'@9 %> :F:'0 :>% 3 % 6-637-G 6-- @*
##
$* :
"
=
$ '
$*
" *
" 5 *
#
+ 2 "
# * +.7 8 98 *9;;;;;
;;;;;
;;;;;
*
" ""
5 * =
8
# =
' # 9$* '# $*
, *'# '#
0 '
6 6 +
% 2 '
$* :
/
@ ! *" * % :7 -62F=::6=:8 9- 4
+ & +
+ * -
;;;;;
;;;;;
;;;;;
+
$* "
"" "
*
+ " $* + ""
$* "
*
" ""
5 * =
8
# =
' # 9$* '# $* *'# '#
2 ;;;;;
;;;;;
;;;;;
-
0 *
=
'# 5 * +
#* ;
#
$*
+ " F
** :
% 6637 FG632 3 :
% 6637FG632 3 3
' # (
# 3
" $* " @ # G
% 6-637-G 6--' # 3E
*
" *
"" " * # H * A - *
+
#* ;
#
$* # * ++
5
F
$* *
1 4 3 *
# !
67 " " + ""
=
# " 3 3
"
=$'
8 #
1 4 3
;+ " ""
9
$* " F
1 4 3
; 0
; 7+ " * "+
"
+.7 D'"
$* " F
8F
'9% -6-637 -F
'64131 39 :
*
F '
$*
" *
6 6# *
"
#"#"
.7 89
*
"*
" "" $* " + 6
:
28 "
#
" " + 6 :
29 )
/ "
6 "
6# 6 "
# 2 *
:
+ "
"7*
""
"
# "
*
* # "
* +"*
3 89 '
* * ! B7:
;;;;;; ;;;;;;
;;;;;;
9
! ! 7 7 # 6'!$
;
! 7 7$
" !
-
;;;;;; ;;;;;;
;;;;;;
0 ""
+ 8 # + +
+ ;# " 9 &
$* + *
"
8
"
"
# 9 2
" "
2- 3 &
+ 3 "
" -
*
+ +
;
#
$* +
# " "" =
# ' 7- 3 3 "
*
$* - 4
; 7-9
#"
# 2 - 1 3 + ""
.7 D% -667-F
'632 $* " F
8F
'
' # -
0@ " '
*
!#
@ # ' @
# "'
.7 :"
'
#
#"
:
* $* % -6-637-F
'6413 1 0# 3
5
* % -667-F
'62- 2 / * $*
" " #
*
" '
* * 8!*
9 3 "
+
# " 2- 3
"
I 67 > & = F
89
"
*"
" # * 3 2 1
:
+ =
" ( / B 1 +
+ + .7
" ( / B
/ 0 "
* 0
( &
#" '# "
"
" #
+ *
$*
0 1 3*
#
$* *
# + 28 "
9 I5 &
"
$*
I 67
!#
8'# F '#*"
60 * % -3-7- .1 E -
"
#" *
# + #
'184>+$<84 +96:
///: ( 4.(5+
+
+&
#
" *
# ! " *
#
+<<=
8=+<8'1<: // :
(4 0 (
7 "
"
# "
# "
#8 9 " # %"
=
8 -9 #
"
" * #
:
" " * #8
9 " " # # !
67+
/
$ 80 90
#
# $* 3 3 7- + *
=
# 5 * +
#* ;
#
$* " #
"" " "
* + 1 4 3 "*
# "
'
"" $* "
& + # - 4 8 "9+ #
$*
@ " " # + " " + + 2- 1 3
2
# *
#
" +
*
#*
# * + * + "
) #" " *
" + 2 * " "
* + # # * $*
*
0
#
"
"
,
1
#
+ # " # * &
"
&
') % -
4
"
" "
?
31-
# #2 $% &'#& '
- 1 1 3
#
+ #
#
+
* +
A "
#D 5 E ' +
+
& +#
#
# *
"
" 7 #
" / #
#'
## #
" ="
"
*
"
# +
*+ # 2 4 4
"
:
8'# 9 &
# # # "
* + "
'"
') % 24411 :
+
" #
4
" # +
# ' 0 " * " 4
+
# #+ :
" 5
# 5 174 * # 8 $* 9 + &
#6
" # *
:
#
# #
"
!
# :
0 7 # 1 4 3 " * 3<
# 7
7 "- 3 " 0 "
;+ " 0
;
"
#
# 7
7 $*
.
:
" " * 3 7 # &
#
5 # "
2 3 @+* + " #
4 3 + #
0
#
" + " '
5 "
*
:
3 3 *
#
# * + # 7" # : "
* % -- 4 &
#
#
7 # " +# * 1 1 1- 1
+ < # * *
# "
+ + + # "
# +
* ' :
" "
+ #
*
"
* ') % -12
'+ +
3 +
"
+ + +
8 "9 + " +
""
#+ "&
# "
*
2
- + "
7 #8 5
#+
# 9
# " C * #
# " C" ; * "
*
:
8'# 9 "
'
5
"# " *
# * % - + #
" # * * *
# +
5
# " #
# * + "
') % -12
'
" C" +
'
#
7 #
+ " C + "#
@+* " # * " -
> +
" #
&
(% '#
')
% -
$*
"" " " * # =
*
" * #
F
" # *
# !
67 + /
, 0 31 "+ " + # # !
-67
+ " " -
# + "
>
# *
" + 2 "
+ " ?=<<= 84 +96 8') % 29 + +
+ $* & "
+ + 3<# 7
7 " * #
" *
"
+ 2 :
$* &
#
7
#
# + "
" " 5# * # *
" + 2
* " " 7 *
" $* %"
" 7 2
:
" " "
*
+" " -
# " " "
" *
"
# # !
267
" 8&
# !
679
"
; #+ # *
8 "9+
+ + .7 #
" *
#
'
+<<= 8= +< 8 "9
7$* # #
"
$ 7
"" # #"*
5" # # # # & 5
+ @+*
*
:
" + 7$* #
""
+ "
# # +
* "
# # !
- & !
&
:
" *
5
#
"
" # *
+<<= 8= '
!
"
""
# " " * " ""
) "" " # " * "
# #
"
8G"
"" 9
*
#
" " *
/ )
"
+ +
" 0";' #
' " + # 7
7
" $* * 0";'
# ""
#
" + 7$* # $*
+
# " " * +
) " & ""
$*
@*
## 0 /
!
"+ "
""
+ &
#" " * +
" * + " "" 7 #
*
##
* + ""
+ "
"
:+ +* " 7$* #
*
#
'
?
0% 3 J #$ %
&
'
"$ (
K
" " '
:
" + 3< " $*
;
$* :
" "
* ""
""
+ " *
* * 6 "
84 1 4<8 5 :
(.4+?
+.0 (%
" # "" &
"
$*
""
*
@ C '
:
@4? 8 4 +965 : .0
,(E 0
# * +
#
+# *
*
.
D809 )
"" &
" " *
$* + "" $*
89
$* ;
*
"$ 7
&
# "
+
+ "
""
8'9 )
"# 7
7
" *
:
"
" &
# " " :
" # C* C
" "" " *
+
# #
" ""
1 : #
#
# + " *
* "
+
8 "9 - 4 A +
7 #
80'#7""
?
03 9 "" " # # * + " $* # &"
+ "
# #8
?&
C 9 +
#
"
"" + " "+ #
+ + * *
0'# C .7 D:
"
#
#
" *
+ "
+ + "" $* # + "" < + ; " @ ! 0+ * +*& 7
!
!8 9 ) " $* # +
+
" # 7
7 #
# * " * " +
+ # 7$* # "
* C
C
+# * "
+
+ #+
L
3< + # @+* 8 9+ + *
* + #+ + # " " * # + #
*
# + *
"
8 # 7
7 $* 9
#
* # #
$* 8
9 "
*
#+# *
+
7 "' ) # "+ +
$*
" *+# *
- ./
4
" $% &'# & '
#+
') 1- + *
*
# #
1
=
8
" 9
" ( / B
# " ( &0
*
#
$*
1 4 3 3
"
# #
*
" " 7"
') 1- 0
; #+ "
=
" #* # =
#
'
+ " $* 1 4 3 D
# -
#
" # " " #
#"" " * # + 2
"#
" ( / B
-
F B 7:B $ % &*=
' 1+
>
* "+
.7 D8
9* ' '#
+
#
#* * "" "
7#* #
#
*
+
" ' 74 D* >
E
" +
>
4
') % -8" +
# "
-
@+* #
!#
6>
"*
" # "
#" # +
D # E "
" # 7
7 -
:
0 31 + " * #
# $*
# *
" * "" # " +
"
$* "
" =
*
#
# #
# !
- !
* +
--
:
* "
:
8'# 9 -
"#
$* =
" #
* 3<
# 7
7 $*
#
"
" + " =
D" $* 17473
; 9 +
"" + 2
.
" 7 #+ 2 # E -
" " *
#
8 "98?
0% 39
# *
" # # *
" # # @ $* "
-
# + $% &*=
8 9 +*"
'
# =
" "+ +
" * # " # " + 2 * !#
=
+ "
* " % 1 $%=
* 3 $%=0 323 % 1 "
# :" >
48 "9 >
$%=8#
*
"*
0 3239"
# * # "
* =
>
+ " $%= ' 1B7:B
- >
-389 >
$%="
# * 7
#
#* # " + .7 D-389G* 7
# * F =+;
#
#
# " # + 2 *
* "*
-2
: >
4 " "" " # * " 2 # " !
678"
>
49 +
" # # # !
- + " $* @ + $*
!
- !
* " 1 3 +
=
#
" -1
* #
" # *
8 "9
-4
=
# +"
#;
!
- + # $ 0 31 " $*
# # D>
% 4E8
, * 9 -3
*
5
=
'+ # "
* F " =
" +
# "
* + " * "
' * F "" " =
@ =
* " #
# +
# =
# " # + 2 =
#
71B7: =
' 1 >
4B7:B 0 " =
"*
+
=
* + "*
$%=0 323+
##* 3 0 " " 0
#*
4 3
" .7 D4
"*
0 "* +
# .7 9
"+ 0
'
""
"+ =
A
"
"*
0
" =
9
@ #
9
+ +# "
9
" #
#9
+ #
" * # =
+ + " * #
+
"
"
"
;
" M
0
0 +
0 "*
3 89 =
$*
$M
89
& + "
8-9 ;;;;;
;;;;;
;;;;;N> 89 ;;;;;
;;;;;
;;;;;N0 0 89 ;;;;;
;;;;;
;;;;;N31
G* + " 5 ""* ' +
+
E
48#9"*
#+
# " * # =
* !#
" # * "*
+ #*
>
A +*"
/ 0 323 + >
*
#*
"*
"
+.7 D
"*
0 >
"* +
# .
9
=
+ # " =
# "
+ =
5
&
# #
#
# 9
#
=
;
# " =
9
+ +
"
"
"
;
" M
9
;
#
""
;
# ;
#9
"
# =
=
* =
9
# #
=
&9
"*
" '#
" * # =
0
9 0 +
0 "* >
89>
"
* >
.
9 0
#
"
# ;
#
5 * =
;
A
#
""
;
;
=
>
"" 0 '
9
* "+ >
"" 0 '
0 '
+
"# + +
##
E
> >
=
0 323 "
#!#
+
"* .7 D89 =
& !#
+
0 >
.
9
#+ " *
# 5 5A "*
# +
0 >
" !#
9 G* =
& !#
"*
# # *
#
#
# &"
# "
#
#
E > * !#
#
# # " *
- % /,0
-
"
( % '# ) #+ $% &%* '#(" " * "
$% & '#& '
#+8') % 23-9
"
" :
') % 314- *
:
8 -
" 9
#
0'# C #
" # :
*
# 7
7
=
+ #
!#
#
$* + "" # *
" C #
:
"') % 2-+ *
* :
3 - - 1 - "
#+ +
&
" "
%"
=
/
'
""
# "
') % 1-
"" * # + *
+ ?
0% 3 80'# 8 "9 " # * " " C " '
#;<<=84 +968?
O% - -9 *
+ .7 " ?*
@+*
" *"
+
+" #
"
+
@ # ' E
"
# " " #
# + "
')
% 1- - # & "
+ # " 7
+
" +
+ # @ /
/ + (
"
') % - *
#
"'
#
#
+ "
" 7"
/ 0
""
# 7 =
"" & =
+
* !#
@ " 4 * >
" "" =
>
* + +
$* * 1 4 3 "
'
#
# "" # + !
8 9 1 4 3 " # + * 2 8 * " 1 4 3
"
" 3
# 9 / # " *
>
4!
A *
"*
>
# !
?
"
1 =
+ + 7#* # " + 5 +
>
#*
# *
#
=
# +
# " # *
# =
7#* #
+
+
2
( & 0 0* $ # " # " " *$* #
+
$*
# * " # 7
7 +* =
"
$* ;
# " " !
+ 2 * #
"
@+* "*
+ * "
"
# * "
' * # "
+
# * " " "# 7
7 " $*
@
=
" + "
#
1
/ !
""
# " * #
+ "
# + * $*
" * 1 $% &*=
" '# &
.
# " # "
# =
=
$*
"+ # "" # +**
#&
+ " * :
# " # " '
* <<5 1' 8; * " 4=5 # *
'
@+? *4 ;89'
221 4
?
?
"#
# + "
# * " A #
" "
# @ #
""" * #
3
/ " + " 7"
') % - 1-
>
4
#
&
+ "
#
@ *
& >
4 $%= ' " - 1+ " +
@ "
+ ;"
- @ ; &
"
#
# # + + + $ 0 31
@ " "
"
# +
?
""
# " * #
*# *
'+
"3<# 7
7 #
@
+ "
* +
+
# " " =
" " # + " * 2
:
# + *
' " / *0*
" "" *
# *
=" "" *
# + + +
" 7
@+*+ ""
# '/ * # *
#
?
0% 4 324 - 31
+96 8; 8 @<<<=#? B # *
+ "
# #
# # ! 1 ' "7:::809 7G =
, ' B 7:+ "+ " =
=
0 318
0 319
" #
# #
0/ /- 8 ( '#0 *
9 3 - 324
"
.7 D1
:
# * * F ! # #
* # 5
C *#"8"
"C *"
" + + 9* * *#"+
"+
# "
*
"* # # * + " + C
*
!"* " # " * #
"*
!
*
+ #
#+
#
# !
" !&
# "+ =
" - 0 31+ "* .7 D - '
.
9
+ $* &#
+
0 "*
# =
9 :
" + " # #
#"+ #
"* 7 P P P P P P P 9 5 #
* # =
A 9 5 # ""
# $* '#
=
! +
# 1 0 31
+ # "" =
" + #
# #.7 D 1 0 .
9 0 # ""
# =
"" !#
7 9 P P P P P P P 5
# # "
#*
# &"*
& #A P P P P P P PE :+ *
=
1 & "
#
# # &
#
/
" # -
"+ & #
6 + "
# "+ & 6#
#*
#* " "
-89 "+
"+&"*
# "
# " "
7 #
:+ D5 #
* E
" # # + * * +
@ # *
# #
'+
#" *
*
#
" *
# # # "
#
+
:
#
*
*
?
0% 3
# # +"
"# * " * " "'
#;<<=84 +96 8?
8'9% --9
*
# # + # "
+
'
@+*
""
# " * #
# *
" C "'
# " *$* # +
+"
')
% 23-2- 314 - # + "
#
+" "
#+ ?
% 3 + " # * + " 7
"# 7
7 -
*
#
?
0% 380 '#9 " * +
# #
') % --8?&
C 9 #
" " " * # ?
0
#+ # *
# )
8 "9 :
#
"9 *
4#1+74=++ 41 *4 14+8* +:# /0/4 - ,(
+ .7 D=
" * #
"
" "
#
"
+ "
"
*
"" + + #
$*
#
+ " 3< "* " * ##* # +
# " # "
:
""
# + C C
; *
* # +
# & #
+
%
+ ;"
C C C# C * +
#
#"
+
;"
C C
* * "'
*
; $* " * # # " " + 0";'
# #
#" +
"
; " "
#
#
"
* + *"
#
"
$* " 3<# 7
7
'
# + # " # *
# *
+ "
$ 0 31
7=
#
"
+
"
$% &*=
'
/
0 C# 74 ' "7:BB 7:B ' =
&
;+ + *
31
*
$ 8 "9
' 746>
4"
" "*
* F # +# * # " + " *
#
* !
- * !
+ "
74
" >
=
0 323 8 0 =
"+
>
"*
* =
/ "
7 +
>
8 9
# #
=
@+* 7& "*
>
+ #D "*
" #
" * # =
E D0 +
0 "* >
E " *
# #
+ #
#
""
# # "*
# 8 8&99+
&
" # +*
7
+
D E
" + >
"*
0
= 48#9 0 323 "+ =
#*
#
" # & D " * # =
+ + " * # :
71' "7B =
+ D% 7$* '# " + 5 +
>
#*
# * 7
# =
E 2
"
' "*
=
0 31 #
+
*
$ 8 "9 + +
4 $% &*=
0 323
"
48#9 + "
+
"+ =
+
+ #
" * # =
+ + " * # @
48#9 =
71
' "7B 5
# #* # "+ 5 +
>
#*
# *
74 ' "7:B >
=
'
+ # + " # " # *
74
=
* !#
& # ; "
"
>
1
& =
+
#+ 48#90 323 1
4 >
#
0 + " +
8 19 @ :
" * #
"
"++ =
" * # "# "
"
+
"*
:
74 >
+ "" # " =
# / 0 !#
* # #
# # !
$*
1 4 3 )
#
+
# # " #
# & " # @+*
# "" "+ =
#
+
.
* > # "
" =
+ +
@+*
* ++
* =
+ * +
# + +" * # #
# + =
# 6" * #
4
'
#
=
"
# "" # + 2
+ $* "
"" " *
#
#
"
#
+ 8 "9
:
C "'+ +
* "
# " " / =
! & )
# + !# 2 !#
/ =
0 31 + 0 "+ G; * '
=
!#
" *
#
;
* # " /
#
# $ "8 *
'9
#
*
" " *+
# " * +
- + " *
# #+ / + +
'
""
# " +*
"
+
+
" 0 + " * ! 6!#
#
"
"0
# "" &
+ +
#* ;
#
>
4 $%='
;
+
# + " =
0
>
4 +
"
# # "
" : + " :+ $* "
# $* # +#* $* " "
# "!
- # " " * # + "
# + " =
* *
" ( / *
* 1 8 "# '# 9
"!
$* 5 + " + 2 :
""
#
# "
>
4 5 " * # "
$%=0 323
, >
+ #
=
#*
@ =
"
'
* "*
$%=0 323 >
#
#
*
3
*
# 5
+ *
" # + *
8 "9 8?
0% 39+
+# * # "* "
@+* + # *
+ $* +
* *
+
"
"' @+*
# 0";' #
'
# + * *
+
# *
#
#$ !
8?
0% 39
# *
"
" # 7
7 " :
* "
$* + #
+ *
*
" " " * "
# 8" 9.7 + * + ;"
C" + C
-0
;::
- 313 +
* ) * + *
"
" " "
* :
+ * * " * ' " "
# + * *
*+
?* ; "*
F ""
+" 1 # @ C "'
/* * + " "" * *
#
""
* + " 7
+ *
"
#
'
*
##
#
* # " #
" + $* " # 7
7 ; 3<
# #
2
) # " *
6" + 2 " *
"
C 0";' :
#
# *
"
/ "
; " $*
> * # & " " ')
% - 1-
" +
*
" +
2 0#
# #
# + $*
" "
#
* & " # $* 2
%;
#+ #
" 7"
') %
- 1-
# 5 " " + *
'A +*
* + # * * # =
&
# # "" #
+"
') %
- 11- @ 5
# " +
" #
"
# 8+ *
-9
" ( / * 1 # =
*
#
#
#
$* " >
4 $%='
+ " # :
#
+ #
.
2
# /
" " >
4 $%='
"*
"
') % - #
') % 1- @ #
# "
# *
' 2-
'
5
* ++ ')
% - 1-+ "#
')
% 1-
0
; 7 2
5
7 #
+"
"# * *
" +
2 " #+ 3<
"
# "
" +
" "
=" "
# # + * "" 7 ; *
2
$* + +
"
# 7
7 "
2 :
* #
' "" +
* + + # +*
#
* + # + * +
.
"*
0 323 >
+ &"
+ +# =
@ 7" 6" " +
# "
* " ""
#
'
# " "
6 " #
# "
:
>
71
74 >
* # #
+ "
#+
* + "*
0 323 2
@*
# *
"
" ')
% 1-
* + " # *
"!
- + - + !
67
')
23-2- 314-
+
:#?< 4=( * ##6
"+=