← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3365/2010disposed of

Punjab Alkalies And Chemicals Ltd. v. Municipal Council And ORS.

2016-12-14Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath15 pages

 

          

! !"

# "

'

()*+*,-.*/0  1 2 -3'

4*'

*5 6*,

4 0  !

 !"%7 !"

'

()*+*,-.*/0  1 2 -3'

4*'

*5 6*,

4 0  %  !!"!"

'

()*+*,-.*/0  1 2 -3'

4*'

*5 6*,

4 0   %87 !"

%

'

()*+*,-.*/0  1 2 -3'

4*'

*5 6*,

4 0   3 9  :/3  ; <;< 3  

   

   

  !"#$%$%##&$#$%%'

 () ( 

  #$ *%#$%% +*%#$% '

,,,,

9!9

<;< 3  5 =1*> -. /.

 !"#$%$#$ *%#$%%%##&$#$%% +*%#$%  .  ( 0/ 1. 2(  !"#$%$

-3( (4  (%**" *!#$$5 $+.4

    %' /6 %*! '%!

#$$+

2  %$'.4/ %    3  0 -2780 

4  (4.4+ #$$+   

4#"

+ #$$*  - ( /   (   4   9   4 (4 (    - (  /1:(4;

/109-40  <2 0  - 2  . 1 .1.4  21 0   5#     7 ##5## &"'  09  -4  0   5#   7 #5#*% &"'    <2   0   !     7 % #%$ "'

  - .4  2  . (4%*** #$$$. ((

9%9  (  7  2  .4 44  -  4%**+ **/= .4 . ;

     /    (        ;         /:.1   ..4  .

  .

   .

 /  2 

 + $ &%**$    (( -/

616  (6'

-> ( (   ( 2 / .4 (4 .4(4 /?.

 @ .;

/ (    /;

.1 

4  .;

:.

 /.1 ( .

  4  2  =.



%*%% ? @'

-.4  4 24%*** #$$$(  .

A 4 ((7A(.#$$$/  $ % #$$%/  ( 0 -24%*** #$$$;

((.4

 

     ;

(1(  2 =  (> (   B .;

  4  #$$$ $%    /     %  (   ( 2 =  (> (

99

 4 -.



44%*** #$$$// =       .

     

4         $

#$$!     

              2

7 %%5 + #$$!  >%5   1;

.  07

   (    (4    /(  ;   /     - #"

+ #$$! :

;

(4(  ( (  7 % %*!!

%% #$$5  >!5 '   (0 -2 %**" *!#$$5 $+.= - .( .=& %# #$$5 - 

4 (

+ #$$+ ./ (4/  4.  %$C ( .4(4    7 %5" +:  >!5 ' !

%% #$$54 %**" *!#$$5 $+ 

   4 >+& .  A 4  ((  2  /      A 4  ((     %*!/.4(

 #"

+ #$$* . /%*!. 

9&9 >                   .(      ((    .4    (4     (4/  4 ((4/ (        4  .

            /   (4/ /(( /4(   0  .(   .  > %'

'.

  / /;

:.

 /  (4/ 

  9   A6=  (A0  3 >  >  A'

37 A

3(%**+ #'7

7'&*5> 6=  ( > > 6  =.

 .>%*+% #'737"5% 9  .( >!5 ' 4.  >"+ (4.((9  4/. .

 4 9  >!5 ' /    D   



  



   

   

            

  

    

       !!"   



    #      #  #  #

 ## #

## 

  

##

 



  #

9#9

#     

 

#   

   #  



   #    #           

   



#

     

# #

  # 

   



  



#  #  #  #   #    

   #  $% 0  .((.  24;

(>

%'

.' (% & #$$%/ (!

%% #$$5 E >    .(4/(.  4(4  ># !# 5 /   D# !

  ?1@A6B1 .  01B1 .. %'  -  >  (    A 4

((             > (.. ;

  ((.(4///   4((. .  =. 4/((  4

#'  -  >  (  (4  2    / 4( 4(4(

     .4      /        (4  

9C9  /(4.(4/ //  / /         = 4      .4   +A 4

(( ># #

'  -* A 4  ((  (4  / %$FG = ( 2 /(4 .  %%F(G.4 (..4 >( # 5  1*4?16B1 . B11  / 4  >( / (4 4 >(   .         .  /  .4 2 44   

>(2%  /  0  .(./ .// %$ % %**$/ <2 E

 /   ;

. (4 (4   ((%$C.4  9 .(4 (.(/.4> (    4;

/.4 1 .

 //../

.4> ( /.

. .. . 4 9  .(.4(



2  %".4A 4 ((. 1  ./(4. .

      9 .( 1 / .;

/

9.

  .(/     4  (   (.         (4  

.4 ># !  > ( 3 04  9(-2E64%*5% 97 > ' 9 %$ % %**$ .(

(  (4 (44   %$C.4.

  .  .              2         (4(4. (4 (  (4(( .4(  7 .(((4   (/(4(4(

(4  9.   ./. B( (

./ ;

/   =   (4  '      /    (       

(4/;

:(( (4 I '( >!5 '

.I  '//(. .4(4 ># !# 5

I -. /9//;

 4(.4/  (4 >   >(/ .4A 4 (( ># #    .4

 .

 .( /.(/ . =  (

- /4 #$%%/( .* %% #$%#  .

    ( ((

( (

(.4.  (.4///4 /D (H.

 3 04 ' > ( 0  /

"9 (/ .= (    (.. .4 (4 >(4A6=  (  )7( >04%*+&37"$&/  ( .= /(/ . //4/ (     (4

-     /       ;

 (      1    . (.4/  /( (.  /9/ ;



- (       (.((

 :;

:.

 / 4(4  ( /1(   -  (4/:( 4 ;

(  ((

>(((4  3> >  A'

 37 'A0   (4  4: ;

     (4  /  .  9 2  0= (4

# # %*&# $ %$ %*+"

0/;

.4  (4/((4%$: // / -( / . ( 4  ( (4 (

(4 (    - (4   //=  (> .

J  / .A0    9.1 / ..(.4 /    D%#  -       .(      4      9 .( (4%#$$;

;

 /(4.  ;

(4 B (;

( .  .4(4 -  (.24 ( 2(( 4 -    ( 4     (.   (  ;

 ;

/(4 4/               ;

     (4 9 .(.4        2      @   

!9 :;

. % - /;

/ ..2(  (.(4    (4  '

> 6A 6B 6 0@. > (  2( 4         (4      ( (4(4 (. 9 (4.  // .4   9> > 6 '/ =.

 .>.//?

@4;

  -4/

    ((   -          / (4/1;

(.

4       - /

>"#<( .  D%$ ((/ 44 ((

9((4  / -.47 +7 (.4 >64( .  ///.  /.(;

( 

%9 (;

(44 4> 9   // 0// . . . ((         (( /  ( .(//( - . (( - 4. ( -4/4 4   ( 4(  -4..>#

%'< =.77  . 4  ( =  (4.4 ((.4 (4 /( 4  4 (4    /4(4( (4(4  4 ( .4(4 (4(    7   

  .(/ ./ //. 

( 1  (;

(2

(4//((.  ( (4(4 ((/.  . (4((/   4(((   //. (2(4DE /4  / /H -;

   2 .4  %$ % %**$/2//  /(4  4. 

2  &. /94(( =  (  /;

/ .;

 #/ .4  >!5 '/> "+   .4  (4 9 

(.4    4 .1.

. . (   -

(.4   .=   ( 9/  .4  . (.4

&9 ( 4  >!5 ' .(.   ;

  /(

/ .  9(4 

4 1.=.4  .=4 .

 

4 /.=4  >((.4



4   /.= /   ;

49 (

((.1 

4              1       .(.4 1 /   -.  

4#$ % #$%5

.)1 5!"

# = <;< 3  > 1 '

   >1 : K 7. K