Nitin Chopra And Another v. State Of Haryana And Another
! "#
$
!"#$%&!"!$ '"
%
&'! !($)* " '
&'+,!-('''(#'
&'!. $($)* "
$ '/'
"!$ '""() 1
", $ $ !
* 23/ '
#-"4 -" '555/$ $/'6'/5/6 $ !
* 72( (95:$958 $ ,* !(;.
!( -.,-<,,
*
$- - ". "*..
$ $67'9'/5//'
4
< - $1#*.,
$ '/ $ )
- *..
$ ' < ) ( <
) "
*1,
(",,#
) $
$ #
,)
$ (<* ". *..
'
.
)=- < "
1##-* "
$- < ,$1 " , *
$1
"*
$
$,,
*
$- - "..#1
4
"?
'
)$ $ $ $//'@'/5//$ *
1 " ,,4&- A #&- " *$-
( * $ $1 " $ ,,4&- A # &- < , $ * $
$ '
* .
(, $&( -.
$ $7'65'/5// '; , -, "*., ? *$? "
**
$A $! $ + . *$ $ 3'3'/5//,-< "B!!
. *$ $63'3'/5//' (, $&( -. **, $
$*..
), ,#$ " "
<,,$ .
- ' " $
< $ - ( ! $ $ .(< ) ( .< " $ * $*,,<
$,#4 **
$$ ! $ ' " 1. $ "
A**
$ 1
$ *, $ *,.
$ ""
$ *
'
) $, $*
,"
(
*$ $
1#, $&( -.'
1 ," #) " 23/'
''< ,$
< - .#.= *$ ( .#1 *
# -) ""
*#$ $ $ ) 1
"# <
* $ "?
'!
*7/5'
4 ,,# , )"* $ (<*
*1
$ " *. $-" ""
$ $
,$ '
+
-) < """
,, - $,#*.. $ "*1
.*1,#
$
* "*.,
* < ,$1 " , *
' C1,
! .1 "*
*, $-
B.S.Joshi and others ) State of Haryana *+( ,$-.(/-( 1",,< $1# ,, **
"2-)3*($4+* +(5$6-78*+(9 1) $ , < ),)
*
$
,<'
" (C1, ! Gian Singh :State of Punjab and another $-.(/-( " $ , <
$ , ,<
$1# ! "4 - " State of Haryana :Bhajan Lal9 ;;$-.. $
1'
:6" ? $-.
$ $ %
!
"
#
$
%&'
(
"
)*+ , #
- +
,
(
!("
, ( - "
-
(
(
.- -
(-
(
/
(
$
(
(-(
.0
1
(
.
(- *
(
2 ( 3
(
-
(
- -
-
-
.
(
(-
(
(
( -
(
-
-
(
.
# "
#
(
-
(
#
#
-
+ ,
-
#
4 ,#- ,<
$1#C1, ! , "? $-.
$ - ( <
$*..
* "
$- < ,$1
,#1
"*
$1#,,<-$** -
# " 1#4 - < ,$1
* - $ "
?
(<* .,# 1?
*" , , *- $ !
*23/'
,( "$ *
$ 4 ,#",,
< .1$.
$1#? $*, * $ (
'555/$ $/'6'/5/6 $ !
* 72(283 (95:$958 $ ,* !( ;.
!( -. $ ,,
*
$- - ". 4 $4
*..
'
$,
#
,, .1 $1# .
$*$ *..
$
*$ $1 " * 1 ,<'
$ ,,< $'
"!$ '" "# <!
, *=# ; =-A $%
A ;
1, %
A