← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/30202/2023allowed

Surat Singh v. State Of Punjab

2023-11-23Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri8 pages

           !"#$ "%&'&#() ) *+, !*&(-.

)))))"!&!&#(", /",'+'

*! !"#$+(0 1 )))))"'2#(3"(!

 45)*** ,"'"(! ,))*)* (3.+637#% !" $#,!."2"!&!&#(",) ,))*)*&3.+66+(0 1) **  6)8, 9:

  ."2,"'"(!&' $&$!.2"!&!&#($&9"3+(3",*"%!&#( #$!."

#3"#$,&;&( 9,#%"3+,"$#,-, (!#$,"-+9 ,1 &9!#!."2"!&!&#(",&(% '" 1" ,&(-#)  3 !"3 <) )6+(3",*"%!&#(#$!." *%!6

< 6,"-&'!","3 !#9&%"*! !&#(=.+& (* ,> ,6 &'!,&%! ?&9@ ) ) !. '1""('+1;&!!"31A9" ,("3%#+('"9$#,!."2"!&!&#(",!. ! !."  2"!&!&#(", &'  &( %+'!#3A ;#,"  !. (  A" ,' (3  ;#(!.' (3 !."

2"!&!&#(",&'. 7&(-%9" ( (!"%"3"(!' (3&'(#!&(7#97"3&( (A#!.",% '" (3!."2,"'"(!% '"> '29 (!"3+2#(.&;1A!."2#9&%"3+"!#2#9&!&% 9 "(;&!A)"$+,!.",'+1;&!!"3!. !!." 99"- !&#(' - &('!!."2"!&!&#(", ," !. !."> '%#;&(-$,#; 0 '!. (&( % (!",$,#;>.&%.!.",". '1""( ( 99"-"3,"%#7",A#$ 9 %! 19"!'#$, ; 3#9)" 9'#'+1;&!!"3!. !!." %. ,-"'&(!."2,"'"(!% '">","$, ;"3#( ) ) 6>.&%.&';#,"!. ( A" ,' (3 ;#(!.' -#1+!#(9A>&!("''"'. 7"1""("B ;&("3!&993 !"6

 #+!#$>.&%.6#(">&!("''&'  *6>.#> '9 !",#(% 99"3$#,!."2+,2#'"

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

5" ,("3%#+('"9$#,!."2"!&!&#(",. ',"$",,"3!#!."0+3-;"(!' #$!."#(E19"*+2,";"#+,!2 ''"3&(G* !"(3",=+; ,(!&9/')"(!, 9 +," +#$(7"'!&- !&#( (3 (#!.",H68 :* 6G#.3)+'9&;I

 +'' &(/')*! !"8#$ "9.&:H68*: J <6*2"%& 95" 7"!# 22" 98,&;&( 9:#)JJ #$!&!9"3 'G ."", 0=+; ,*.+@9 /') ."  *! !"  #$  !! ,  , 3"'.H  (3 *2"%& 9  5" 7"  !# 22" 9  8,&;&( 9: #) J #$ !&!9"3 ' G 1&, @ './')."*! !"#$3&'. H (3 %#(!"(3"3!. !&(7&">#$!." $#,"' &3$ %!+ 92#'&!&#( '>"99 '!." 0+3-;"(!'2 ''"31A!."#(E19"*+2,";"#+,!>."(!.","&' 9#(-3"9 A &(!."!,& 9 (3"'2"%& 99A>."(&!&'(#!!."$ +9!#$!." %%+'"3 (3&(!. ! '&!+ !&#("7"(!.""$$"%!#$*"%!&#( *%!>&991"3&9+!"3&(!."

-&7"($ %!' (3%&,%+;'! (%"'#$" %. (3"7",A% '")

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

2, A",#$!."2"!&!&#(",&'.&!1A!."1 ,%#(! &("3 +(3",*"%!&#( *%!)*#$ , '!." (!"%"3"(!'#$!."2"!&!&#(", ,"  %#(%",("36  ."  '+1;&!!"3  #(  &('!,+%!&#('  !.  &!  &'  %#,,"%!  !.  !." 2"!&!&#(",&'(#!&(7#97"3&( (A#!.",% '") J) . 7"." ,3!."9" ,("3%#+('"9'$#,!."2 ,!

!&' % '">.","!."%+'!#3A#$!."2"!&!&#(",%#;"'#+!!#1"

  ;#,"!. (A" ,' (3 ;#(!.')*&(%"!.","%#7",A$,#;!."2"!&!&#(",&' 1#+! 9 %! 19"!'#$ , ; 3#9 >.&%.&'(#!#(9A %#;;",%& 9K+ (!&!A +(3",!." *%!1+! 9'# .+-"K+ (!&!A6!."2, A",#$!."2"!&!&#(",$#, -, (!#$,"-+9 ,1 &9>#+931"%#('&3","3&(!."9&-.!#$*"%!&#( #$!."

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

3!."2"!&!&#(",&(.&'% (!",(#, (A#$!."; !",& 9 >&!("'' #, !." ,"%#7",A >&!("''. ' 1""("B ;&("3!&99 3 !") !&' (#! +(3",'! (3 19" '!#>.A$#,9#(-2",&#3>.&%.&';#,"!. (A" ,' (3  ;#(!.'6 $!",!."$, ;&(-#$!."%. ,-"'6!."'"2,#'"%+!&#(>&!("''"'. 7" $ &9"3!# 22" ,1"$#,"!."#+,!)

+,&(-!."%#+,'"#$ ,-+;"(!'6 '2"%&$&%K+",A> ', &'"3!# 9" ,("36+(0 1 '!#>. !&'!."0+'!&$&% !&#(>&!.,"- ,3!#(#( 22" , (%" (3$ &9&(-!# 22" ,3"'2&!"(+;1",#$!&;"'61 &9 19"> ,, (!' >","&''+"3 - &('!!."2,#'"%+!&#(>&!("''"'!#>.&%.."%#+93(#!0+'!&$A !."' ;")

."#(419"*+2,";"#+,!&( * !"(3",=+; ,(!&94'% '"

  8'+2, :3&'%+''"3!.&'&''+">&!.,"- ,3!#3"9 A&(!,& 9 (3&!'"$$"%!#(!." ,&-.!!#9&$"+(3",,!&%9" #$!."#('!&!+!&#(#$(3& ) , #)

#$!."

$#,"' &30+3-;"(!&',"2,#3+%"3 '+(3",

)*+1'"%!&#(8 :; (3 !"'%#+,!'!#%#(!&(+" !."2,#%""3&(-'#( 3 A!#3 A1 '&'!&99!."%#;29"!&#( #$!.""7&3"(%").","$#,"6#(%" !,& 9'! ,!'6&!'.#+93 ," %.  !."  9#-&% 9  "(3)  / ,&#+'  3&,"%!&#('  . 7"  1""( &''+"3  1A  !.&'  #+,!  (#!  !#  -&7"  +(("%"'' ,A 30#+,(;"(!',"'+9!&(-&(!.">&!("''"'1"&(->#(#7",) #>"7",6!."(#(%#;29& (%"#$*"%!&#( %#(!&(+"'

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

>&!("''"'6 ' &(3&% !"31A!.&'#+,!#(K+&!" $">#%% '&#('6!."A '. 99; @"'+,"!. !." %%+'"33#"'(#!'+$$",$#,!." 3"9 A#%% '&#("33+"!#(#$ +9!#$.&'#>()H ) ."#(E19"*+2,";"#+,!&( #.3)+'9&;I+'' &(4' % '"8'+2, : 9'#3&'%+''"3!."&''+">&!.,"- ,3!#3"9 A&(!,& 9 (3!."9#(- %+'!#3A#$!." %%+'"32",'#(7&' 7&'!."1 ,%#(! &("3*"%!&#( #$!."

J  *%!).","9"7 (! , '#$!." $#,"' &30+3-;"(! ,","2,#3+%"3 ' +(3", )    29 &(  (3  9&!", 9  &(!",2,"! !&#(  #$  !." %#(3&!&#('+(3",*"%!&#( 8&)")6!. !#+,!'.#+931"

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

 0+3-;"(!'  #$  !.&'  %#+,!  . 7"6  !.","$#,"6 ";2. '&?"3  !.  !."  ' !&'$ %!&#(  >.&%.  %#+,!'  ," "B2"%!"3!#,"%#,36&)")6!. !." %%+'"3; A(#!1" -+&9!A6&'#(9A2,&; $ %&"61 '"3#( ," '#( 19"," 3&(-6 >.&%.3#"'(#!% 99$#,;"!&%+9#+'"B ;&( !&#(#$!." ; !",& 9'%#99"%!"33+,&(-&(7"'!&- !&#(8 '."93&((&#( #$(3& 7) !! ( 9&@:), (!#$1 &9#(-,#+(3#$ +(3+"3"9 A&(!,& 96% ((#!1"' &3!#1"$"!!","31A *"%!&#( #$!."%!6-&7"(!."&;2", !&7"#$*"%!

J>.&%.&' 229&% 19"!##$$"(%"'+(3",!." * %!!##8,"$)* !"(3",=+; ,(!&9'+2, :) 7&(-,"- ,3 !#!."'"$ %!#,'!."%#+,!&'#$!."#2&(&#(!. !&(!."$ %!' #$!.&'% '"6 !." 22"99 (!3"'",7"'!#1""(9 ,-"3#( 1 &9)H

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

&#(",&',"9" '"3 #(,"-+9 ,1 &9!."(."; A,"2" !!."#$$"(%"#,; A 1'%#(3#,$9""$,#; 0+'!&%"#,."; A&($9+"(%"!.">&!("''"').","$#,"6!."1 ,%#(! &("3+(3", *"%!&#( *%!>&99(#! 229A!#!."2"!&!&#(",&(!."9&-.!#$ ,!&%9" #$!."#('!&!+!&#(#$(3&  (3 9'#&(!."9&-.!#$!." $#,"' &3 0+3-;"(!'#$!."#(E19"*+2,";"#+,!

#('"K+"(!9A6!."2,"'"(!2"!&!&#(&' 99#>"3 (3!."2"!&!&#(", &'#,3","3!#1","9" '"3#(,"-+9 ,1 &9#($+,(&'.&(-1 &91#(3L'+,"!A1#(3 !# !." ' !&'$ %!&#( #$ !." !,& 9 #+,!L +!A  -&'!, !" %#(%",("36 &$ (#!

,"K+&,"3&( (A#!.",% '")

#>"7",6 (A!.&(-#1'",7"3.","&( 1#7"'. 99(#!1"!," !"3 ' ("B2,"''&#(#$#2&(&#(#(;",&!'#$!."% '" (3&'#(9A;" (!$#,!." 2+,2#'"#$3"%&'&#(#$2,"'"(!2"!&!&#() ) )  8**: