High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14425/2015allowed

M/S Marc Technocrats Pvt Ltd v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2016-01-28Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih5 pages

!" # ! $"%& ' (

) *+&*$%%, %$& -.

&/& 0$"$1$ $$ .,&

& ' * 3 .$50 .%$6, * 7$ .20,$ 5.%$5",2 * $,/0 8,52/1.%$ $5$1$ $5 ",&2 & 9999

,$&&/8,$6"%$:/$&,$ ..$.

#( ;1 6,%, , &2 & ,$ .;$. , 2 "7 "/, 8 6, $1$ $ 0$ $.& $ . .8& 27 2$ -.

<0 =$ < =2$7 "61$&

$87 .$. ( ##(6$& . ;6 , 2$& ;1 6,%, , 2 6$& $22 . $& $ % " , 22$$ "$>$ ?% 2@<

= &2%"$/&$.& ,$??$ &%5 $1$ $ , 2 22$.,

$ . "6$.. ,&$7,&2 & $&"6$..$&/227 $1 $22$&$ 2 A#B " , 2$17 6$& $&.;1 , &2 &

##( ,;$$ %2$17 6$&$&. #( ##($"," $ 22$$ ",

E$1$ $ 0$

$.& $ .8& 27 2$ -.

<0 = ;1 $ .$. #

&$. ,$ $/& $%,& 6, , 2 ,$& 22&. 6. 8+& 8, 8",$.$,F& 8

5,$. ,$& ; $&. $ . % &/%. ./ $.& & % . & , 2 6$& :/&. ; 8 , .$& , ;$&& " 6,%, 6$& 22&.6. +& 8, $,&$7$ 86,,.$&

1$.$. D #&2 !E0 &$. ,$,$.; ;&.,$,6$ /7;"%,$ 8&

&/;7.;1,2 ./ 8,7"$22$&$$ .," $

,;1 %$& 8,%&"," $

& 6$&%$./2 &/;7 $ F2$ $ 6, ! .$1& , $& & " , ."" % ;6

&$,7"$22$&$$ .," $

&"$ 86,%, $% 6/.;$G $&2,7&$ .% . &",$87 %21",&6$& ..;1,&2 & / !

, 2 &/;7. $ .$. 21 ,& ;1 & .$. # #A 3$/& %, %$ $&2%& $ ". ,& & %&&$1",$/&%, %$$&2%&$.. &5 ,65 72$ ,$ , 2 &$. ,$ ;" %72 8,

&5,"$%&$ . &8$ 2&62.., F%/ $&6$&,0/2 8 5,$??$6, ,$. ,7&& &. , & $ . .%.. , 22&. $7 $ 86,,2 6$&$&&$.,$$22&$6$&22$.$ "6$..,

$ . & .$-.

<-="$22$&$ ,& 8$ H$ & / $22$&.,26,7 $7 .7 & ", $22$&$ , 6$& 22$. ;1 &2 ! $& 2 , :/7 ! 7.". , $7 22&.

, 2 &$.,$ :/&,$.; $&.$,$ 7

) &72$ ,$&2 !&2 ..,& $"$7& I1$&;1&.$. #D ! &$.,$,$.% &..,$$ .$%%. 8,2 ..

1$&&&&,&$222$1$ .,$../2 &$72&$8/$ $& " .7 8 , .&8 2$$7& , 2 7$. $72&%E$&$72&/&6,2$&2"7$ %$ ... 1 F$7 $/&$ $&&%,$222$ ;/2%.. 2%G $ $ $ . % . ,$ ,

! &$.,$,6$&&/""% 8/ ..;$,2 ;/6,$6 7,:/7 &"?/&%8$ .,2 $ 1 &,6%$/&6, .$1&6,1&,/. ;.;$."7 8" 61$& 67 .&.$.

D$ .#( D ,&8$. 6$&& ;1,!,&2 , 2 ;1 & .$.

D % $8$ &/;7.$.$.21 "$%7 ., $7&", F%/ $&6$&,0/2 8 (

7$15 , 72/8 . . .$. #

#( 6$& 2$&&. 6,/$"". 8,2 $ 1"; 8,$.

$$8$2,E<= ",72/8 .712$&,&,6%$/& % $$8$2,&E<= <=",.$.$&/ .'E J<= ,$ ,

6$& $22$&. ;1

$ . - & " $.$ $8 , ;%$/& " , ."% %1 &2% " .&8 " &$72 8 &%,7 $ . 2 8 , &$72 &/& $8$ & 2$& 2"7$ % " , $.

" & 2"7$ % & 2. 2. %%1 , .%/7 &, ,$22$&$$/,1%/. &2,& 7$.

,$&6,1& 16, ,% ""%& &.,&;"+./ 8F%/ ,$%/." ./, & ,

$ . ,$. $.2 $ $ F%/ &$81

<= / $%%/$

22$.;11/5-E ;%$7-E $ ," $&$8%$/& 8$" $ %$72%$ "$;/ & D ! %& <= /&/;7&& ,$2<

=&$&2%.$:/7 $ . &$ .$. & 2%./ &$. $ %. .&

,.8.

&$&./1",

% %% $ $ "7$ < G. - % = $ . .%. , 2& & $%%. 81 $& 2 $ %. / ,$. "$.""%1%%,"..$$6,%,,$.&/. %,$ 8& &%2 &7 $%,& "7 6. 8 $ & 8, 8$& 8+% &/%

<= , % ,$ , 2& ,

6 7$. % &/$ 6, F%/ 5 %$ & 5,$??$$ .0,$??$$&.& ,.8.

, 2&

&,/.;&%1 E7 $&2& :/7 % "7 8 %.$ /& "$7. ,& 8$.

1 "7$ 8$,.$&$2$".&%/&& 6,""%$& ",.2$7 .& 8$&,, 2/&2 &;1"22$$ " %%

, < =.2$7 & , ."% %& ,

$ " 1 &/&

$/$ .. $1../% &6/.,$; 7$."7 , % %& $$.1 2$. $ . %$ %$ " , % %& $$.1 $6$.. 6/. ,$ ; ""%. ;/ G2 8 6,"$%&$61/72/2 1/ 6G 8$ .,/&$G 8$ 6,$&; .%.. .;$1/""/, 8 0 $ .2$7 "

< ="$2."61$& @ 6",2/2&",&?/.87 $&&/7,$& $6$1& %&&$1$"".$2$1$ 1"; 8,$. "& 22&..;$ 65 ,"$%&$ .%%/7&$ %&",&%$&5 ,/&" $/$?/&%6$$ .,&2 &$"". 8,2 $ 1"; 8,$.

$ 1 5,16$$ .,&2 & $"". 8 , 2 $ 22/ 1 " .$ 8 6, , " 8&+$8$ &7$.$8$ & ," $.57$ 1"6,%,. " . 2$% , &,6 %$/& % , &% . $ . ,. & %& "

2$$8$2,E<= " , 72/8 . . 71 7$G $ 8 $ ;&$ 8$. 8,6,

&;22$.

2$$8$2,E<=&$8.,$ ,

6$& $%%/$ 6,/ "/ &, 8 $ 1 $& & " , &$7 *5,$8. $%%/$%1$ .,%$/&&",&$76 & / , &,6 %$/& %& $/& 8 , 6 7/& 7 ,$ * .$5 $ . & %/ & $22$ 8 ;,$" " , 2 % .. ,$, &$7 6 &,6%$/& %& 65 ,65 2&/7,$,1$ 6/.7$G ."" % $$8$2,E<=", .$8&,$,2 ,$."$.""%1%%,"..$$ $8$ ,& , 8 .%$, $/","$/ ,$&,$ ,&2 &/8,,$. 6$& .%$, $/","$/ , &,6 %$/& %& $; , 2 .$ 6, , &$7 &&/7 8 ,$ , "$/ ,$& ; $8. , &,6 %$/& %& , $& &",. 8,$,6$&"$/$$;& ...,&&, "$%5,$,72/8 ...& .$6,,$/&%, %$$&2%& $&.;1,2 &2&.$.# #A #$

"$% ,&%$&6$& %&&$1",&2 &,$ $""..,2 $ 1"7 8$,&$8$ &$&, &,6 %$/& %& 6 &&/. "/ 1$& $" , 6G ,$. ; %72.

,&2 &.. $G,/;"% &/ 8,6 &6"6,7 ,$; $7. ,21, %&

,%%/7&$ %&5,2 &$6.$ .,72/8 . .&:/$&,.$ .&E$&. <0 3K = 0 (

) <

--= >$ .L