← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13516/2016allowed

Krishna Devi v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2018-03-12Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan7 pages

Gurbax Singh 2018.04.21 13:04 

                       

 !"#"$%  &  '("#)$ *"+,-

.)(""#) $.

(/0(#" $ 1"22 3 $  #  "!4) 56)#"24) 56"# ("!

 )

768 )9:          ;;

"

"$(    1#  .

 (< $  $  )(#             ; #0$ $ #   4% =-4  .'

4 4-    =-4  .

 . -  

  

   !   "#!$ %  > <'/5 (4"

26    &

'

      (      )* + &,-&.&,./0&,12-&,./1&,13/42&.         5 ( 67)*+ &,-&.42&1 

'

)*+ &,-&.42&. 44. )   8 !  9    7

   2& 42&. 6 &2  (!    + & 5 (!  (!   2, 2.

42&-6 /  (!   7 :  7     !5 7 !   ( ;

  (

  7  7! 

   ! 7 7    && 422. 2422/  &1 422/  (!   7    ,& 242&4 &2 & 42&4(! + & '

!      (  7 "  !  7      ,

5  !    )* +  &,-&.  42&. 7! (   8   ! &//, + ,$ ")77  7  < 7   ! 7  (   (       +5  "    8 5 ! 7        7 5 ( 9  5   "   7  5  ! ! "     '

(  ((  5# + &- 7  &4641=+5 "  77  2, &//, 6 &  '

   5    7!  5+ ,7!   # 9   <5     (   ")77         5    5  *        5       21 4224 7      " )77 

 7  9     " )77   6   ( 7   5  ! 5      7"           7  '

   7    21 4224   + ,     (        55

   5  ( 5 7"   

5         '

     (7 2, &4 4224! !      ( 7   5     7 6               + , 5   !         ( 7     7  7      6   5         7     75 6&47!   !77&& 422.(+ 4  ) 7 >&& 422.6 0  55(!

 ) 7 855  &- 4224      && 422.   ! 77 (7!   ,     7!  7!  7 7(+ > 2.

422/6 - ) 75 + , 5  24224   5 !5  "    7  6 ,/ 7!  !77 5  (   7  >   &1 422/ 6 .    5 5  5     65  24224  5 !  5     ! 422-  *      &1 422/ ) 7 !  (7!  +5> (

"  75     75  7!  

 (!   ( 7     (  + &    7   6    && 422. (!   7  >   &2 2& 42&4 6 1     5 5     7 7 + & 5 ,& 242&46   3  7!     6   7   *   + , 7  7      7        (  +  >   2.

42&-6 / 57(! + 4

 57 5  5    7 5   ( (        !

5  5  5 721 & 42&.6 &2    (! 

 5 7  (  (! ! " )77  7( + 4?,5  (  7 7(7 5 55(!

7) 8   !777!     7    7 5  !

 8  (      (  !(    !&//,5 (   7 ! @ 7! 7 

(7 

-

A   (7 

 ( 2, &//, (  ( !422- 857     7  !     (    5    6 0 3 5 5

 + ,5  7!

 .

A      (77(   "(!   

*     

8        + ,$ " )77 7    ! &//,   7    (    (   +5 "  85 ! 7       (  "   75 !!5( '

 (  ((  5# + &- +5 "  772, &//, '

    2/ 422&  5  7!    9      

7    (   5  ( 7 5   8   77 7 7!      7  6(! ( ) 75  55 && 422.

855 &- 4224   @&1 422/,/7!  (   7 5   5 5   

&1 422/6 . 65 (!)775  !76 5   7- 4224  5 !5  +5 > ( "  85!   7(  7!  +5 "  75   8            (!    5 7(!   A  

  ( (     !  7  !   7         7    7

7   ! (  (!   )     && 42&.)*+ 0&2342&.  

       

   5   67  7  5   $ BThe respondents, who are government functionaries, cannot be allowed to treat two sets of similarly situated persons in different ways. Once vide order dated 30.06.2011 (Annexure P-9), the revisional authority ordered to charge simple interest @ 15% per annum from some of the allottees of the same Mandi, and waived off penal interest on the instalments, besides waiving off the extension fee till 31.05.2008, the day when all the basic facilities were completed in the Mandi yard, action of the respondents to discriminate the petitioners and decline the same relief to them, who are similarly situated, cannot be appreciated at all." /

85 ( 55 '

7

 2, 2.

42&-21 2& 42&.6  / &2!  9     !          !

  !  7 5   24224      !422-5  (75(! 7 8> <'/5 (4"

2:          / 3  (!)6 &    8$/0"$ (."$3)(+ 2:   ?3#=       / 3 *  " < # *  ( #