Rajinder Singh v. Tara Bai And ORS
!!"#$#%& '"()*+
,#%-!'#%.($#%"!-!"!$!- ('/.(0 $ 11!22% $ 3!'$/$ '#$#%"!-!"!$!- ('/.(0 $ (!'$ !$1%-!% $
!"#$%& '( $(')#
'!$!% &
'$42*-5" !* ' (!11!22% $
' 6-*-5" !* ''!$1%-!% $**7# ###
'#1/%3!'8*-5" !* ''!$1%-!% 7## 99999 (')#*% (!11!22% $*4('! (!2!.2'!1'!$!% #5!$-!!%-% ,#%-!'#%.(*'!#% !./2'!"%-11!2.#%$ (!,/-.8!% %--!"'!!- !-7*4(!'!:; (!$/# '!$1%-!% <12#% #' #$#%"!-!"!$!- %4'!1'!$!% !- :;(!'2!.2(!#'$*4$*#%1' * -!"'!!-%--!!%-% 4$#%,/%" !-% #% !'!'!#% 1$$!$$#% (!12#% #5!' (!1' #% (!(/$!#%-#$1/ ! (!' (% (!1' #% $(4%#%;!224"2/'#% (!$# !12%= '"#:2;%-#22!.22;%- (!
,/-.8!% %--!"'!!- !-7>?*4(!'!:; (!11!21'!!''!-:; -!!%-% .#%$ (! '!8!% #%!- ,/-.8!% %- -!"'!!* 4$ -#$8#$$!-:;/1(2-#%. (!,/-.8!% %--!"'!! (! '#2/'
2#% #<'##%$ # / !- (!$/# $!!@#%.#%,/%" #%.#%$
(!-!!%-% $'8#% !'!'#%.#%(!'1$$!$$#%5!' (!(/$!#%-#$1/ ! :!'#%. /%#"#12 %# <7>$$(4%#%'!-"2/'%-8'@!-:;
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
')B !'.! #%. (!$# !12%$%" #%!- '8 /%#"#12/%"#2*(#4%#(!$# !12%4$1'!1'!-:;6'% #%.(*A$(5#$(!%(!2! (#4%#%-$ ' !-'!$#-#%.#%3#22.! 6(/',*#$ '#" /2%-((' ' '-!$( (!12#% #4$ (!4#!
(#$:' (!'%--!!%-% $%-74$ (!'!2%!1(!4(!6 ( 4'-$%' (!'%<4!$ !'%"'%!' (!(/$!#%-#$1/ !4$.#5!%:;(#8 (!%-!'#%.(*(/$:%- (!12#% #''!$#-!% #21/'1$!$%-# 4$.'!!- ( (!4/2-5" ! (!@ ($%-4(!%$@!-(!!2!" '#" 8! !'*4 !'$/112;"%%!" #%%-$!4!'.!"%%!" #%4!'!2$#%(#$ %-#% (!%8!8#2;8!8:!'$ !!%-% $%-711!'!-%-#2!-$!1' !4'# !% $ !8!% %--8# !- (!"2#8 (!12#% # (! '#2/' *% (!:$#$ (!12!-#%.$ (!1' #!$*
+
'8!- (!224#%.#$$/!$&<
!
"
!
!
#
2#% #'#*-/'#%. (!"/'$!1'"!!-#%.$*-#!-%- (!'2!.2'!1'!$!% #5!.!%-!'#%.(4$:'/.( %'!"'-.!%-!' 11!'!- #% (! 4# %!$$ := $ C %- 2$ !=8#%!- C< @2 /8:!'-' (!5#22.!%- (!'! !' (!!5#-!%"!4$"2$!-:;/' '-!' % (! (!'(%-*-!!%-% !=8#%!-6'8#%.(*A$( 5#$$C<*'# 8*/#2-#%.%$1!" ' /%#"#12/%"#2*(#4%# C< %- 8 '@$(* 2!'@ * (#4%# $ C<7 %- (#8$!2 11!'!- $ C<? (! $/# %- (! 11!2 4!'! -!"#-!- #% (! '!8!% #%!-8%%!'
'$42* 2!'%!- "/%$!2 11!'#%. % :!(2 (! 11!22% $$/:8# !- ( (!#%-#%.$ (! '#2/' ""'-#%.$ /$ (!12#% ##%%#%,/%" #%$/# #$% 1!'8#$$#:2!#% (!:$!%"!%; -!"2' #% % $/11' (#$ "% !% #%* (!'!2#!- /1% (!,/-.8!% '!%-!'!-:; (#$/' #% , -.. /0*1234#%
3
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
A/!$ #%$'! :!-! !'8#%!-:; (#$/' 4(! (!'#% (!:$!%"! %;-!"2' #%#%$/# '#%,/%" #%*/' "%""'- (!$ /$ 4%!'$(#1 (!12#% #%-D 4(! (!'#% (!:$!%"!%;-!"2' #%* (!#%-#%. (!/' 4$'!A/#'!- :!"%#%!- #%,/%" #%%2; '
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
% (! :$#$ (!$$!$$8!% '!.#$ !'$#% (!$/# '#%,/%" #%*%2;1$$!$$#% ($:!!%$/.( %-% (! # 2! #%"! (! /' (- .'% !- (! #%,/%" #% .#%$ (! -!!%-% $4# ('!.'- #% !'!'%"!#% (!1$$!$$#% (!12#% #5!' (!1' #% (!(/$!#%-#$1/ !!="!1 (!1' #%$(4%#%;!224 "2/'#% (!$# !12%'4(#"( (!11!2($% :!!%#2!-$-8# !
'-*8 (!5#!4 ( (!#%,/%" #%.'% !-:; (!/' $#% 5/' (! 12#% # $#%"! -!"!$!- %4 '!1'!$!% !- :; 2!.2 '!1'!$!% #5!$*#$1!'!" 2;2!.2%-,/$ ##!-%--!$% "22'%; #% !'!'!%"!
8
(! 11!2 4# ( (! '!8!% #%!- 8-##" #%* 4(#2! /1(2-#%. (!#%-#%.$#%,/%" #%*#$-#$1$!- $ (!11!2$ %-$-#$1$!-*%$!1' !'-!'#$'!A/#'!- :!1$$!-%#5#2 #$"112#" #%$7B<%-7?7>< 7 ,1*2 (')# 0., %&9:$ ),7,.;6 <.
=.<
),7, 7> =.<