Himachal And ORS. v. Chandigarh Administration And ORS.

   
   

 

   
   

 

   
   

 

   
   

 




 


 


 


  




 

 

!

"

# 

 

 

!

"

# 

 

 

!

"

# 

 

 

!

"

# $%&'(&)*+,-&$&+.-(/0*

/-$-$+/0* /0*,*
(&+.$1&0( .%$+$*-0&-$+#"$+$ /'0/-&0$&-#
(&+.$1&0( &+.-(/0*

/*2+./+-*
 "!3
 "!3
 "!3
 "!3 

 "  
  5

 

 "  
  5

 

 "  
  5

 

 "  
  5

####
 
 

 
 

 
 

 
  

 

 

 



 "  
 

   



 "  
 

   



 "  
 

   



 "  
 

   

0/*/+-!

0/*/+-!

0/*/+-!

0/*/+-!

"0

&)6&11&# .7'&-/0-(/2/-$-$+/0* "0   ($+.*&# .7'&-/00/*2+./+-*  #8 "0 +.0/*(/)# .7'&-/00/*2+./+-  :;:;:;

:;:;:;

:;:;:;

:;:;:;

 

   

#  

   

#  

   

#  

   

# /-$-$+/0*  <,/*-$+  -(/  ./'$*$+    -(/ 
(&+.$1&0(

.%$+$*-0&-$+$+(&7$+1&))--/.--(/%=*(/.*>&*22*/.- =?,$)-,2?-(*>$+-(/ &@"&06/-# /'-0#
(&+.$1&0(  + -(/ @/&0 #
(&+.$1&0(  .%$+$*-0&-$+-6 & '+*'$,*  ./'$*$+  -  ?,$).  &+.  /0  '+*-0,'-/.  ?-(*  $+ 7&0$,* /'-0*$+
(&+.$1&0(?@A&@&))-%/+---(/(&A6/0*B -0&./0*2)@$+1-(/$0-0&./$+7&0$,*0/(0$%&06/-* //'-$7/)@ $%2)/%/+-*,'(./'$*$+#0,)/*A/0/0&%/.'&))/.= ))-%/+-B 0&+*/0 ,$)-2 -(*$+&+@ /'-0+/&*/B$0/ ,0'(&*/



&*$*$+
(&+.$1&0(,)/*#>C0*(0-=,)/*>D (/0/ $*  +  .$*2,-/  -(&-  -(/  20/*/+-  2/-$-$+/0*  &0/  -(/  (&+.'&0-B (&A6/0*)$'/+'/()./0*A(A/0/'&00@$+1+?,*$+/**$+-(/ /(0$"&06/-# /'-0#
(&+.$1&0(&+.#&**,'(#A/0//)$1$?)/ 0  &))-%/+-    ?,$)-  ,2  ?-(*  ,+./0  -(/    ,)/*   (/ 2/-$-$+/0*.,)@&22)$/.0&))-%/+-,+./0-(/,)/*&+.&-/0 1$+1  -(0,1(  &  20'/**    *'0//+$+1 ?@  -(/  .,)@  '+*-$-,-/.

))-%/+-
%%$--//#A/0/2/0%$--/.-2&0-$'$2&-/$+&.0&A )-*&+.(&7/0/%&$+/.*,''/**,) (/*(0-10$/7&+'/-(/2/-$-$+/0*$*-(&--(/@A/0/ /+-$-)/.-?/&))--/.&'%2)/-/?,$)-,2?-(/&'($ A$-( A&))*,2--(/'/$)$+1+-(0//*$./*&+.&0))$+1*(,--/0+-(/ 0+-*$./#A(/0/&*&*2/0&))-%/+-#-(/(/$1(--(/-(0//A&))* (&*?//+0/*-0$'-/.-E4&+.-(/0/&-/0&+
&&)$CA$0/%/*(D$* -?/&$F/.,2--(/'/$)$+1 
+-/+-$+0&$*/.+?/(&)-(/ 2/-$-$+/0*  $*  -(&-  *,'(  *-0,'-,0/B./*$1+  $*  $+  '%2)/-/ '+-0&7/+-$+-(/,)/*  2)/&.$*'0$%$+&-$+(&*&)* ?//+0&$*/.?@*-&-$+1-(&--(/0*$%$)&0)@*$-,&-/.-0&./0*A( (&.&22)$/.,+./0-(/,)/*(&7/?//+&))--/.?,$)-,2 ?-(*$+7&0$,*-(/0 /'-0*-(/'$-@&+.A(/0/$+-(/0/(&* ?//++0/*-0$'-$+&*0/1&0.

*-(/-(0//A&))*?/$+10&$*/.,2- '/$)$+1)/7/) (&-&2&0-#$-(&*?//+'+-/+./.-(&-+&'',+- $F&-$+&G&&)$B$0+%/*(&?7/-(/(/$1(-E4+-(0// A&))*,2--(/'/$)$+1)/7/)#$-A,).?/$%2**$?)/-,-$)$H/-(/ ?-(  A($'(  $*  20$%&0$)@  &$%/.  &-  *-0&1/    .  &0-$')/*B 7/1/-&?)

 &7$+1(/&0.)/&0+/.',+*/)&-)/+1-(#A/&0/-(/

'+*$./0/.  7$/A  -(&-  -(/  10$/7&+'/    -(/  2/-$-$+/0*  $* '%2)/-/)@,+,+./.

 ",'(/%2(&*$*A&*)&$.+-(/./$+$-$+&?,$)-,2 ?-(&*'+-&$+/.$+,)/9C'D-(/,)/*&+.A($'($*$+ -(/))A$+1-/0%*!

=9C'D!

9C'D!

9C'D!

9C'D!= ,$)-,2?-(>%/&+**-0,'-,0/&*2/'$$/. ./*$1+/0/'-/.$+-(/.$/0/+-0/(0$%&06/-*0&+@ -(/0 /'-0 >

*2/02/-$-$+/0*#*2/'$$/../*$1+(&*-0/)&-/-& '%2)/-/)@?,$)-,2?-($ A$-(-(0//A&))*0&$*/.,2--(/ '/$)$+1&+.&*(&.?//+&))--/.?@-(/ .%$+$*-0&-$+$+7&0$,* ?-(%&06/-*$+.$/0/+- /'-0* (/0/$*&+$+(/0/+-&))&'@$+ *,'('+-/+-$+   /-$-$+/0*&0/'+*-0,$+1-(/-/0%=*2/'$$/. ./*$1+>&*'+-&$+/.$+,)/9C'D-(/,)/*-?/*-&-$'$+ +&-,0/ (&-'&++/7/0?/* -A,).&)A&@*?/2/+0-(/

.%$+$*-0&-$+  -  $%207/  ,2+  &  ./*$1+  -(&-  (&.  ?//+ $%2)/%/+-/.$+-(/2&*-207$./.*,'(./'$*$+$*-&6/+?+&$./ &+.  $+  2,?)$'  $+-/0/*-   (/  '+'/2-    =*2/'$$/.  ./*$1+>  $+ 0/)&-$+-&?,$)-,2?-(&*./$+/.,+./0,)/9C'D ,)/*%,*-/7)7/B$%207/A$-(-(/2&**&1/-$%/    +-(/ '%%,+$'&-$+  .&-/.  9    &-  ++/F,0/  I#  A(/0/?@ $+&)$H&-$+    -(/  ./*$1+    -(/  &@  "&06/-#  /'-0  #
(&+.$1&0((&*?//+'+7/@/.#$-$*&22&0/+--(&--(/(/$1(- -(/-(0//A&))*(&*?//+0/*-0$'-/.-E4&+.&A$0/%/*((&* ?//+.$0/'-/.-?/&$F/.,2--(/'/$)$+1A($)/6//2$+1$+%$+. -(0//  '0,'$&)  2&0&%/-/0*  $  +&-,0&)  )$1(-#  7/+-$)&-$+  &+.  $0/ *&/-@   +  -(/  0/2)@  *,?%$--/.  +  ?/(&)    -(/ 
(&+.$1&0(



.%$+$*-0&-$+#$-(&*?//+ &7/00/.-(&-*,'(./*$1+(&*?//+ $+&)$H/.  A$-(  -(/  &**$*-&+'/  &+.  (/)2    -(/ 
($/  0'($-/'-#

/2&0-%/+-0?&+ )&++$+1#
(&+.$1&0( .%$+$*-0&-$+  / 2**$?)@'&++-$+.&,)-A$-(*,'('(&+1/./*$1+&+.-(/ ?&*$*+&'',+-A($'(-(/'(&+1/(&*?//+&2207/.  ,'( $%207/.  ./*$1+  A,).  &)*  &))  A$-($+  -(/  /F20/**$+    & =*2/'$$/. ./*$1+> &* '+-&$+/. $+-(/./$+$-$+&?,$)- ,2 ?-(  $+*&0  &*  -(/  &@  "&06/-#  /'-0  # 
(&+.$1&0(  $* '+'/0+/.

/.+-$+.-(&--(/0/(&*?//+&+@'+-0&7/+-$+ -(/,)/* I +*&0&*-(/?,$)-,2?-(*&))--/.$+-(/00/(0$ %&06/-*$  /'-0*##I#&+.&0/'+'/0+/.#-($*
,0- (&*?//+&220$*/.-(&-$+*,'(%&06/-*#-(/'00$.0*$+0+- -(/?-(*&0/2/+--(/,-.0/+7$0+%/+-&+.&**,'(#-(/ /+-$0/%&06/-$*20/*/+-/.A$-(&',0-@&0.2/+-*6@&+.&* *,'(#-(/0/$*+2&,'$-@+&-,0&))$1(-&+.7/+-$)&-$+$+*,'( %&06/-* (/?,$).$+1-(/ &@"&06/-# /'-0#
(&+.$1&0( A$-( A($'( -(/2/-$-$+/0* &0/ '+'/0+/.# 20/*/+-* & .$/0/+- *'/+&0$  ,'(?,$).$+1?/$+1&*$+1)/*-0,'-,0/'+-&$+$+1*(2* &+.  '00$.0*  A$-($+  -(/  ?,$).$+1  $-*/)#  -(/  +//.  A&*  /)-  - 207$./  +&-,0&)  )$1(-  &+.  7/+-$)&-$+  &+.#  &''0.$+1)@#  -(/ *2/'$$/..

/*$1+0*,'(%&06/-A&*$+&)$H/.?@0/*-0$'-$+1-(/ (/$1(--(0//A&))*,2-E4&+.$F&-$+
&&)$BA$0/%/*( -(/0/,2+,2--(/'/$)$+1  +-(/)$1(-*,'(.$*-$+'-$+#-(/ 2)/&.$*'0$%$+&-$+0&$*/.?@-(/2/-$-$+/0*./*+-*,07$7/  $+&)$H$+1-(/./*$1+&?,$)-,2?-(/-' ?

.%$+$*-0&-$+A,). ?/&6$+-&2)$'@%&--/0  -A,).?/

 A$-($+-(/.%&$+-(//F2/0-*$+-(/$/). (/
,0-*A,).

+-$+-/0/0/$+*,'(%&--/0*,+)/**-(/./'$*$+$**(A+-?/ 2&-/+-)@$))/1&)0$00&-$+&) -(&*1+/,+'+-07/0-/.-(&-,- -(/9&))--//*-(/?-(*$+-(/ &@"&06/-# /'-0#
(&+.$1&0(#E(&7/0/&.$)@&''/2-/.-(/'(&+1/$+./*$1+&+. $-$*+)@-(/20/*/+-*$F2/-$-$+/0*A(&0/&1$-&-$+1-(/$**,/ /A,).'+'),./-(&--(/./'$*$+-(/ .%$+$*-0&-$+A$-( 0/1&0.-$+&)$H&-$+-(/./*$1+?-(*$+-(/ &@"&06/-# /'-0#
(&+.$1&0($*A/)),+./.

(/0/A,).?/+*'2/ 0$+-/0/0/+'/$+/F/0'$*/,0/F-0&30.$+&0@G,0$*.$'-$+  /-$-$+.$*%$**/.

C   5

D C   5

D C   5

D C   5

D C 

   

D C 

   

D C 

   

D C 

   

D    
 
  

 
  

 
  

 
  

 

 

 

 

"

#

"

#

"

#

"

# " " " "

-/!

-/!

-/!

-/!

(/-(/00//00/.-/20-/0JC/*B D (/-(/00//00/.-/20-/0JC/*B D (/-(/00//00/.-/20-/0JC/*B D (/-(/00//00/.-/20-/0JC/*B D