High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14593/2015dismissed

Rita Jindal v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-05-12Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih9 pages

! " # $ %& '

( #)#& *+,- &' ( &"

-#.&+,/+$ % ( 01 +,- ' 222 && ' '' *%3

4& 1".*5 63 & ' 5

&& &1".*&"

3 ' &.5 222

,4 &" ' % 7"& & +8 9,:" ;+-4&&&< =

+> 39 ' ;& 7" &'

" &' *'

&? @+ 4& ' *+ . 4&& 4"

3 * &- 3 4& 4A 9,:" ;+ 4& 3% & '' ' 3% & ' 4 * 3% & ''

"& % 9 ' ;A BC 9,:" ;+-4&&& - "& %*- & -,4 **"+ .&"&

* " &4

& ' >& 7" 3 * 6&<=

+$D,+> 39 ' ; &"? @9?=@; ' " '

3 .CC+# 8+> 39*" .B ;& '

+ - ' +

B 6& * & ?=@ 7" & ' *' % 4& &

4. * 4&:*&

!" "#$ %&'(!)* + "#$ )!" '+"$& *$""!)*"#$ ' $,&$,'&$%+& "#$&$*!

"$&$% &-#!"$-" '&&')*$.

')+& "#$+!)')-!'.!) "!"

) *$" "#$ )!" &$*!

"$&$% (!"# "#$ $)$&'. ')'*$& + "#$ !

"&!-" )%

"&!$ $)"&$ - )-$&)$% @ * " &?=@+E &' 4 3 " & .4& &''

+ E4& % *& " ?=@F *"9C E;4 3 ' 4& ' *&+ * & " ?=@+& 7"

* ' C E4&&'"

*+ " & 4

* + +

8B&+

G8+ '- %F"+& '&3 ' ! 8 9,:" ;+ & 4 7" " & & ' *'

?=@+4&C%> . 4&&+43 -+&? @&

3*&-

3 4& 4 > + & ' - ' & 7" *"+ & 7"

4 , - % &

+ & *'

" # &"* ,+ 8+"&"& % -+ & - ' &

> + & "* > "* " & & ' & *'

%4&& &?=@+&"& "

3 & 3 % - ,+ - C89,:" ;+ &"& "& *"'3%&' ". E &' &'

+ * & &?=@,'' ' 3%&' .& 4*3%&# "* '" **+ - 9,:" ;+ &' 4& 3 "* 7" %+ & 3% & "* > "*4&*'

' 3%& ' 4 *>4&&+&' &

'' 3 &,* +> 3+9: .& '4 & & ,* + $D,;+ 4&& 4 * - 9,:" ; ?04+ - & - . & 4 * 3% & - "& % - 9,:" ;6&&4+3-+&' 3 & " ? " & ' "3* & & &

4 +

B&' &

' +C+ B C E & ' +

8 $ "3*+ &"& & %"&- '* 4 0

" '&% ' & + & ' 4 " % 3 . " & & 3 *"6&3.+& &44&

%"1" & "&

4& 4 & ? @ '

"' 3%&-F& &" ' !'&!-'&/')' &')$0$.

, $)" "# &!"/1223456

781<-& 4+&"3*&&?=@44& 4 4&"

. % '' "% & . & ' ,%-+ &' 44

& ". "+ ' 3 &

* , '' &+ " ' &+ &' & *'

%4& & * + "' 4&&+ & ?=@ 4 "+ & "& 4 & 3"4& 4&*>" & +& "3* &

' & ' ' & 4&&3 . &' "

& * "&? @@ +& +&&' 4-4

.'" "& *

*+ && -' % "3 & "* > "* &- & " & ' ' "&'' 30

@: &"& " + 4"

3 :' " & - " & ?=@+ 4&& &" 98

(!..$&$:

!&$%"

%$,

!""#$'.')-$;<= + "#$,&!-$ +,.

"> #$%(!"#!)',$&!

% +2 )"# +& "#$ %'"$ + &$-$!," + 1<= 4!$ (!"#!) 5? %'/ + "#$ !

$ + 6 !) "#&$$ $:

'"$% !) "'.. $)"

)"$&$ " @ 13= (

.% $ -#'&*$% ) "#$ '

)" % $ !) -'

$ + %$.'/!),'/ $)"

&"#$&!)"$&$ "@13=(

.%'.

$ -#'&*$'.$ )"#$'.')-$'

)"+& "#$%'"$ + ++$&

+ ,

) ,$)'. !)"$&$ " + 71= (

.% $ .$0!$%

)%$.'/$%,'/ $)"

'+"$&"#$ ++$& +,

)#!

,$&!

% (!.. $ ',,.!-'.$ "

"# $.+ +!)')-!)* ')% !) "!"

)A+!)')-$%-'

$ BBB BBB BBB BBB BBB BBB BBB BBB 2

(!.. #'0$ "

!" "#$ ,&

+ + "#$ - ,.$"!

) + '

0$ + & '.!"!$ (!"#!) ' ,$&!

% + !B

)"# +& "#$%'"$ +!

$ + )-'

+'!."

- ,.$"$ "#$ '

0$ + & '.!"!$ (!"# "#$ '

0$ $)"!

)$%,$&!

%"#$.$""$& +!)"$)"(!..$%$$ $%"

#'0$$$)(!"#%&'()!)"#$$0$)" +) )- ,.$"!

) + + & '.!"!$ #$ '

)" %$,

!"$% / /

(!.. $ &$+ )%$%'+"$&%$% -"!

)<= +,&!-$ +,.

"C <: + * " &?=@+&' 4 7" " & & 3 C E & ' & 4& ' *& * & " ?=@+ & 7"

* ' + +

7" *" 8 %+ ' '&3 ' &@"&

+ ' & ' +C+ B

8 .

B & 4 7" 3 ' 3% <- - 8 9,:" ;+ & 4 7" H ,$& "#$ "$& ')% - )%!"!

) + /

($&$ &$:

!&$% "

- ,.$"$ "#$ + & '.!"!$ (!"#!) !B

)"# +& "#$%'"$ +!

$ +

'&$&$:

$ "$% "

!""#$,&

+ +- ,.!')-$ +"#$- )%!"!

) 2

+ (!"#!) $0$) %'/ +'!.!)* (#!-# "#$ .$""$& + !)"$)"(!..$%$$ $%"

#'0$$$)(!"#%&'() &$'"!"

" &*$)" %>A "'"$ ++!-$& '&!%''%C @+- +&-%&"& 9 ' &$:

$ "!)* "

,.$'

$ !

$ &$* .'& .$""$& + '..

" $)" '

'.. + & '.!"!$ &$:

!&$% + & "#$ ' $ !

'.&$'%/- ,.$"$%!)-$) %$0$.

, $)"!

#',,$)!)* '" !"$ /

'&$ ) " !) ,

!"!

) "

++$& ,

) '.')-$,'/ $)"(!..$% )$(!"#!)"$&$ "!+',,.!-'.$ '

,$&"$& + '""#$"! $ + ++$& +,

) #')D!)*

%>A !"'.!)%'.5157???C > + & 4 '' 3 & " & ?=@+ 3% ' " + & * 4& 4 "*

% 1" &+ - % &

+ + ' *'

3 & "* > "*+4& & & &*

3% & "& + - 4&& " & * 4

+ 4& - '%* * 3 7"- E &' & "

%+&' %

C 946 %!&$-""#$&$ , )%$)""

%$.!0$&"#$,

)

+ "#$ ,.

" (!"#

" ')/ + &"#$& %$.'/ ')% "

"&$'" "#$ - ,.'!)')"'",'&(!"#"#$,&

,$-"!0$'..

""$$ )%$& "#$)$( -#$ $')%(#'"$0$&$)$+!"

>&$'"$'&$$!)*

++$&$% "

"#$ $ '.

'%$ '0'!.'.$ "

"#$ - ,.'!)')" &!)"#$'."$&)'"!0$"

&$+ )%"#$'

)" %$,

!"$% / "#$ - ,.'!)')" (!"# !)"$&$ " @ 78= ,$& ')) +& "#$ %'"$

+ %$,

+ &$ ,$-"!0$ !) "'.. $)"

"!.."#$%'"$ +&$'.!

'"!

) +"#$'

)" 46

&"#$& "

- ,$) '"$ "#$ - ,.'!)')" + & "#$ $)"'. '* )/ ,#/ !-'. #'&'

$)" +!)')-!'. ')%

!)$

"#$"

)$ +

1?????>AC #. %+ & ' 4 4

. " & & 3 ' - & . ,+ & & & &' '3

& "'& *4&& &'

+" &4#&*+4 3.

&*" '3%& 3 " %&44

.'" " & *

*" &? @+

9,:" ; *'"+&1"" +& 3. 4 34&' +4 %? @&4"&' =& 43 I4

3 & & * ?=@+&"& "

4% %3. &'4&& ' 6& 3 - 3% & $J3 #"' * " 'E'

"#')

,$&'"!0$ '!&/ $%$&'"!

) "% - '#' 'B ! !)*&'"$ '&D$"!)* $&0!-$ 0" "% ')% "#$& 122F41?68?<+ %&'

8 9; #$!*#

&"('

) "&!*#"!)! , &"!)* "#$ % -"&!)$ + '

%! '."$&' ,'&"$ !) "#$ $ -!&-

"')-$ +"#$- )% -" + $ , )%$)"1('

-# "#'" !" %!% ) " !) ,!&$ ')/ - )+!%$)-$ !) "#$ ',,$..')" "#$ ',,$..')" ('

$)"!".$% "

%$-.!)$ $)"$&!)*!)"

')/.$*'.&$.'"!

) #!,(!"# $ , )%$)" 1 '

$..!)* '*$)" #$ $""$& + )"$)" $&$./ $B,&$

$% ') !)"$)"!

) "

$)"$& !)"

' - )"&'-" + "#$ - )%!"!

) "!, .'"$% !) "#$ $""$& + )"$)" ($&$ ) " + .+!..$% / $ , )%$)" 1 ')% !+ "#$ - )% -" + $ , )%$)"1('

"#$&(!

$) "

-#'

(

.% *$)$&'"$ - )+!%$)-$ "#$ ',,$..')" ('

$)"!".$%"

(!"#%&'("#$$""$& +)"$)"#$&$('

) !)%!)* .$*'. &$.'"!

) #!, $"($$) "#$ ',,$..')" ')% $ , )%$)" 1 '" "#!

"'*$ ')% "#$ ',,$..')" ('

$)"!".$%"

D'""#$"

"'.!"/ +-!&-

"')-$ !)%$-!%!)*(#$"#$&"

$)"$&!)"

'!)%!)*- )"&'-" (!"# $ , )%$)"1 &) "C 6& ."*A &"& & %" &- '*4 0

'+&' 4 3 .'%&3 ' + 0-!

+ ' 4 * 3% & "& &

&*&'& ' +&"

3 - ' &' 'F&*%+ & " &? @- * %".. & & ' "

4&& '%* % &

*%"&. "6& 4 34

" &. & ' & ' '

3% " & ' "' 3% & - F& & "

9"' ; - & "+ & ' & &'" &'

* 4 " & -" ' & ,'' %+ & 4 "* 3% & "&

4. & ' " "#C &$ %D 3- '* ,+ CC+" '%* #"&& '&* &6&"3*A&&' 4

"."&"&' ' *" 3 & -" + 0 3& * & 3 #. %+' % &.3%& " ? @

+& ."*+ &- " & & * ,+& + &*'* %'"

- &".& 6& 3. + 4 " 4& & : 3% & "& " , & " @3.- * .

% * ( S.J. VAZIFDAR ) ( ARUN PALLI ) ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE JUDGE 12.05.2016 Rajan