Gurwinder Singh v. Union Of India & ORS

  
  
  

!"# $#%&'&()*+

 

       


) ,-.
.- ,-.
.. /#'#(") /.!"0&/!"1/#2$3%!"# /"1#4#"&"&(#/ /&'1&5!6'1!72$3%!"# //#'4($#("'!($  '6(&'1!!($1&2$$7$3%!"##(#/!726(8!0  !8#'1&($!7 1#7!($2!'9#("&(#$&("1#:/&"4#"&"&(2:!'!%;6&/#$6($#/ "1#!"&(!7&<1:!='%"2>+?

/'1/"2,"1#%",  /:&$#(&(<

!"&(!7&<1:!=1#!:!/$:!'4!''#$0="1#%94#"#("!6"1/&"=1# </&#3!(%# "1#4#"&"&(#/&'"1!":1&7#!''#''&(<"1#%94#('!"&(2"1# 0#(# &"'!'!3!&7!07#6($#/.#%"&(' *!($ @ "1#-!($%;6&'&"&(%"2 @>A2'6%1!''7!"&69!($&("#/#'":#/#("</!("#$#7&!(%#:!'47!%#$ 64(86$<9#("  "1&'%6/"&( B'7$#(/(!($."##7/<&(<'3 (&( ($&!!($"1#/'2  A 

&3&7 * +-#!/(#$%6('#7 /

 "1#4#"&"&(#/1!'!7' /# #//#$"3!/&6'/$#/'4!''#$0="1&'%6/"2 :1#/#&($&/#%"&(1!'0##(<&3#(""1#%94#"#("!6"1/&"="%('&$#/"1# %7!&9 "1#7!($:(#/'&("#/9' "1#86$<9#(" "1&'
6/"&( B'

7$#(/(!($."##7/<&(<','%!'# '64/! 1#/$#/4!''#$&(
  +@A? ?C<&($#/.&(<1!($!("1#/3(&( ($&!!($ "1#/'2$#%&$#$(A  ?:!'!7'47!%#$0# /#"1#%6/"2&(:1&%1&( !$$&"&(""1#!

/#'!&$86$<9#(" "1&'%6/"2/$#/ $!"#$@ ?

4!''#$0=(,07#"1#.64/#9#
6/"&(
&3&744#!7 +** C .6(&"!#1/!!($!("1#/3(&( ($&!!($"1#/'21!'0##(/# #//#$" !($  %#/"!&(  $&/#%"&('  1!3#  0##(  <&3#(  /  %!7%67!"&(    !96("  !($ $#4'&"&(<"1#'!9#&(!(!"&(!7&'#$0!(D"0#$&'06/'#$'608#%"" &(!7 /#'67"&("1#4#($&(<!44#!70# /#(,07#"1#.64/#9#
6/"!<!&('""1# 86$<9#(" "1&'
6/"&(B'7$#(/(!($."##7/<&(<','%!'# '64/!  -#!/(#$%6('#7 //#'4($#("'!($ $#'("$&'46"# "1#!

/#'!&$ !%"6!74'&"&(  "#/1#!/&(<7#!/(#$%6('#7 /"1#4!/"&#'2:# &($"1!""1# 4/#'#("4#"&"&(%!(0#$&'4'#$ &("#/9' "1#/$#/4!''#$0=!

&3&'&(#(%1 "1&'
6/"&(<&($#/.&(<1!($!("1#/,'%!'# '64/!  1#/#7#3!("4!/""1#/# &'#E"/!%"#$0#7:) F1#4/&(%&47#'7!&$$:(0="1&'
6/"&(7$#(/( !($."##7/<&(<',' %!'# '64/! 2!/#6($&'46"!07#1# !%"

"1!""1#0#(# &" '7!"&69!($&("#/#'"1!'0##(#E"#($#$" "1#/'&9&7!/7='&"6!"#$7!($G:(#/'3&$#/$#/$!"#$

>

&( 1!<.&(<1,' %!'# '64/! %!(0#1!/$7=$#(&#$("1#'# %&/%69'"!(%#'2&"!44#!/'&94#/!"&3#64(/#'4($#("'* !($A"%('&$#/"1#4#"&"&(#/',%7!&9 /"1#</!(" '7!"&69

* !($&("#/#'"&(!%%/$!(%#:&"1"1#$#%&'&( "1&'
6/"&( 7$#(/(!($."##7/<&(<','%!'# '64/!  1&7#%('&$#/&(<"1#%7!&9 "1#4#"&"&(#/'&("1#7&<1"

 "1#!03#G%&"#$$#%&'&(2"1#/#'4($#("''1!770#/#;6&/#$"

77:  "1#  /#%#("  $&/#%"&('  $!"#$  @ ?  &''6#$  0= "1# (,07#.64/#9#
6/"&( 
&3&744#!7 +** 

.6(&"!#1/!!($!("1#/3#/'6'(&( ($&!!($"1#/' 2 ""1# 77:&(<#

#%")G F "1!" "1#!:!/$  '7!"&69 !($ &("#/#'" ( '7!"&69'167$0#9!$##

#%"&3#(7="4/%##$&(<'

4#($&(<("1#$!"# "1#&<1
6/"/$#/&(7$#( /( ."##7/<&(<'3'(&( ($&!!($"1#/'2&#

@* @
(%76$#$%!'#''167$("0#4#(#$' /

6"6/#4/%##$&(<'2"1#4'&"&(:67$0#%3#/#$0="1# 4/3&'&('    "1#  &<1"  "  !&/ 
94#('!"&(  !($ /!('4!/#(%= &(  -!($  %;6&'&"&(2 #1!0&7&"!"&(  !($ #'#""7#9#("%"2 * %!9#&(" /%#( A 2 :1&%1  %"  1!'  0##(  9!$#  !447&%!07#  "  !%;6&'&"&(' 6($#/"1#!"&(!7&<1:!=' %"2>+?0=3&/"6#

("& &%!"&(B/$#/&''6#$6($#/"1#4/3&'&(' "1#%"

 * &"1"1#!

/#'!&$9$& &%!"&(!($%7!/& &%!"&(&( "1#  /$#/    "1#  &<1 
6/"2  "1#'#  %&3&7  !44#!7'  !/# $&'4'#$ H 1#:/&"4#"&"&(&'!%%/$&(<7=$&'4'#$ &("1# 77:&(< "#/9')

A

& 1#  4#"&"&(#/'  9!=  !447=  "  "1# 
94#"#(" 6"1/&"=G%69G-!($%;6&'&"&(
77#%"/:&"1&( !4#/&$ (#9("1 /"1#</!(" !

/#'!&$ 0#(# &"'I

&& 1#'!&$
94#"#("6"1/&"=:&77&''6#("&%# !($%!77 /"1#/#%/$'B/#47= /9"1#!"&(!7 &<1:!=6"1/&"= ($&!

&&& 1# 
94#"#("  6"1/&"=  '1!77  "1#/#!

"#/ $#"#/9&(#"1#4#"&"&(#/',%7!&9 /"1#!

/#'!&$ 0#(# &"'2#'4#%&!77=&(3&#: "1#$#%&'&(' "1&'

6/"  !($  "1#  (,07#  .64/#9# 
6/"2  %&"#$ !03#I

&3   "1#  4#"&"&(#/'  !/#  6($  #("&"7#$  "2  !  '#7

'4#!D&(<'6447#9#("!/=!:!/$""1&'#

#%"'1!77 0#4!''#$:&"1&(!4#/&$ 6/9("1' /9"1# $!"# &7&(< "1#!447&%!"&(I

1#  !"&(!7  &<1:!='  6"1/&"=    ($&!  &'

$&/#%"#$"$#4'&""1#!96("4!=!07#&("#/9'

"1#'6447#9#("!/=!:!/$2&(&("#/#'"G0#!/&(< &E#$ $#4'&"!%%6("

' &(!(=(!"&(!7&J#$0!(D:1&%1 '1!770#$&'06/'#$'608#%""!""!&(&(< &(!7&"=

"1#  7&"&<!"&(  &(  "1# 7$#(  /(  !($  ."##7 /<&(<','%!'# '64/! H

+ -#""1#(##$ 670#$(#&("#/9' "1#!

/#'!&$/$#/4!''#$ 0="1&'
6/"1#:/&"4#"&"&(&'$&'4'#$ !%%/$&(<7=

!8#'1&($!7 6$<#  !/&($#/.&(<1.&$16 6$<# *+

9D 1#"1#/'4#!D&(<B((G'4#!D&(<)

#'B 1#"1#//#4/"!07#)

#'B