Satvir Singh v. State Of Punjab

 IN TH HE HIGH COURT FOR THE E STATES OF PUNJAB AND HANDIGARH HARYANA AT CH
)* +, ,-

  12/ )#)*# )*

   ###  
.// /

     ###/31 








 !"  # $% &'
"  

 &
Mr. *


*%
+)" 

$ 
,
-%
+
++*
 .&


 &( $#


/

$

&
 
&

$

"

"



 


 

 

    


 



0
1+ 2
 89
$
&

4 


! "
,
3
4 
%

"



36:













 #
 

0

 
"


0


64 4

 "
 
7&
7"

(&

$

& &
" 

$" %
$

/
$
$

& 
 
&

$



 


&

&

"

"


$

& &
  
% %$ "


"
/
$ 


( 
& 

$"


"

%


(
)
)
(

"'( 

&


 
4
-
(
&
 
 )
% %
,


$

& &
" 

$" %
 

 (
  (

$$
$"
$ $"&

"

4

-"

 



%$


& 

&



  


"  
(

)"
"
 

$
 





% 




$
(
)
 
( 
&

$"

"





  
)
 
$$"
&

 

4
/

(
 
"

" 

$" %
$
- "





$ 

& 

& 
% 6
)


"
 

$

"& 
 

)
  



%
$ "

"

;
)

 & 


"

 
&

" 


$



)
$



$ 
&

 

4
%




$"

"

"

4




$

 


" 
%

$" % %

6
%


"
$ 


%$



0

%
%
   


& 

&

( (


"  
$"

 % /

"

. %


-
4 
" 

 %
"

"

$& " 

$" % 


&"

 "

4


"  
%


$ " %
$'
/ 
 %
)
&
" 
%
%

%



1  !  (  * 4



        



!"

#$ %$  ' 



(

)* +

, -(.

/0

4 5 5$

  

  ()* #6





-  2323+2.

( +(  .

 ! ,$ #$ 

7,

+ 8-.

234 +0.

( +9  .

6 1 

-      23

+ .

( ( +( .

: 1 

5 

; <
 /

()* *
 !  40

()* 4 %$  !,  '     

( )* /0



# $  ; 44 ()* *

0 +



% 
$ "

"

(
 

"$

< <%

$
&

 

4


) 
 


0
"

"



$
(
")
& &"
)
( (

$



 
&



4


 
"

$" %
 
$& "

($$ 
 = 
/ &

%


+
$



) ) 


$ 
(

 

>
%

"

$$ "
&



4


(
 


%
$ 



 


$$
-"

%
(

" 
) 
 

$)

"
 9
4 

$ 
("

$"
%





 

 

&
)


""
%



$&  
"
$"

%
("

%



: "


 "
&
$ "
 $
Gurappa Gugal and other rs Vs. State of Mysore : 1969 Cr riLJ 826 and Sh hokat Ali Vs. State of Haryna :

2020(2) RCR (Criminal) 339.
3

$
"
 19

4 

4
%
  



 
"

"$


$"  %

&
$& 


 
($$ 
"" 


$ "

( "
"
$
 
 

5 -()

$




0
( 
 
)



 
4

(
 

$& "


($ $
(
 (

$"

$) 

"
 919

4

-"
 
%
(


$$
"%$  "


$)

" 
 
4 +
$


"
  
(


(
$
& 

)
$  "
"




4


$

 
&


6 

)


$
 
%



4



 


&
-() 




"

 (


 
(
%
&

4
" "

(
&

 


$ 

&
(

$" 
" 
&


%

 

,
 
=2
+

)"

"

"'('$" % 

 
$

(

)
& 
(
&



4  +
"
 
"
& 
&
$%


$"
)
" 

$

"



"" 

""
% 
+
"

"

 

4
&
("

 
$" %
$"
 
"


4
"
 
&


& 
&




(
: "

"


"2 2
"
&
$ "
$
7

1  "

7, 23

#((

=  + 8-.

+"" 

)(


"

%
&)

  

)(

 


(


(

&)
"


$ 
$

 (


%$
 


0
1+2
  89
$
&

4


!"
, ,
3
4 
%

"

 

36:
 #


0


"



*


64 4

 "

7&
7 "

(&

$ 

&
" 

$" %
$


(

"  
$" 

%

-()

$

 "


&

4 4
""
(

$


( 
&."



 

"$ 
& 


$


$ 

&
 

"
0


6

&"




 

"$
&


 "


$

&
& 
 
&
%

."
" 
&."






 
&

&
$
&

"" 
4

"

"""
(
(

 

&)


"

"

$$ "

 
& 

"" 
4



 
& & 


""
4
 
&
&
 
$


%
2$  





 

&
 

2$


$ $

%



& 

 "
 
""
4

$
 

%

/

$$"


$
&



4



%


6

%
" 


"

$
 

$$
& 

 

4
(

$

 
(
%


$ 

&
 %

&
% )#)*#)* * +

 &- $%06"



Yes/No Whet ther speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whet ther reportable