← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4482/2008allowed

Krishana Devi And ORS. v. Rakesh Kumar And ORS.

2025-10-15Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma14 pages

 

  

    

   



 ! "#$#%  & '

 ! %# #% ( ) *

 )# ######++,,- .

# ()  )# ######+  . /!

 01 /)# )  )

)/  

       



 

    !"  # $

%%%% )

)/

#

&

' (  )* )+ +)),(-   .

' (   /0' ( 12    

 &**   &3,,    4 +5)$3+678   9:

5;         &5 )& +)):

+

        < (- ' ( 

   < ( (

-

 )/ ))  ) 

1   )1 





)

$

'   8

 (- ' (     ( '- (

  ( 

            ' (           -        =              ' (    -  - 

            # $   

 - (

    >8&,*,8+)),      ?

  



    (- ' (  -   

* =         (  

)

1 12 

/ ) 

:

1( .  Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 34$5 "

)&+ 6 & .

-  7

    8 @30  

      

      

   

         

  

  

     

 

 



  

8   

  

        

    !"#$      

 %#  !"&$       

 &'    !"($      

 

 31)

      

         *              (+,      

    







                 

  -

 

           

        

   

         $         .  /

 

     

    

            

  *  

 

              



         

      32 

     

          (+,           

           (+,    



                  

  

                                           

 

             * * * * * * 42.)     

    

       &$        

     0

 1    $        !2    !(%+ %!%(

 $ 

    

  3!4 %'#+

 3!'#!#(

 3!(#'&+

 3!&&!&(

  3!#&'(+

   

    

  3!!(!((

 35(''+

 34 '!'(

  3(''4+

 ,

1(     .         National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 34 95 "

) "7   

 &**&*$8&*,   &3,, 

8 /2 ?        

 A      

B

% /!2         

          B /.2  (  -   

B /?2 4( 

    -

   A

  B /C2 

     "(B 8 - A  - '  "  8 @52. 6  conventional heads



  

   

 7/

8 *   7 %(+++   

7

!+++++    

        7  !+++++  

   

    

  

       

 

 7/

  0   9 

 



         



             

  



   



  :    

  

    6                 

 

     



  

      

   

  

  

 

"  

; 

  

    

  

 

  

       

    

        



                    

      

  

  * 

           

 

         

  

  

   

 

      

   7 !(+++ &++++ 7 !(+++

            

   <       

   

 )       

     

 

 



   

  

 !+,   

 )   

  



  

 

 

  = = = = = 59.3)   

  (+,    



 



 /      &+

    

   #+, 



 

&+(+

 * 

  

9   (+'+

     !(,        

 59.4* 







 $       &+,

 

  

  

 &+

 6  %(,

  

 &+(+

  !+,

  

 (+'+

 

 



  

   

   

     

  59.5.              

    

     #+#%0> ?

    

    59.6.

               0  > @         &%     /

 59.7 

         59.87   

        

 



 

     

    7  !(+++  7  &++++     7  !(+++

  

    

   !+,  

 A



1(     .         /-:6-   -,

& - ' 6+- ;

1<6<.

*#

- & -6 -,<- =&= & -6  .=  3 4 5 ) 87    )- ,- * 6- 4&+ -5   - -;

).=< 4)&+ -5       4  8 B216  <

  C  0 8        

 

    

;

  

     *     

  D  D    

      



 D  

 D  D    D     D

 D    

           

  

   

 

  

   )

 

 

 



 

%!!Spousal consortium 

   

         

    



      

  

    /  D %!%Parental consortium     



  

D  

   

     

   

     D

$ %!# Filial consortium     

  

 

  

6 

      

         

  

   



   

      

          

  22  



 

     

       3  /     

 



  E   

  

   

        3   /                 

      

 

         

 

  

       

  23 3> 

6  

    

     

  

  

  

* 

  

          

     

 

      C  

   

    

    6 6   

   

       

      

       

   

           

   

 24         

         

     

 

   D

  D   C  0 8*  







    

  7 &++++ 

  &)

 5$-    -. >   !

# 4  4 $56+678  -  

  

 -.  /CE 62  D

' (     

  - 

     =    -= A (  -

    

&&

4(" (- . FAO-1335-2007 titled as United India Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Smt. Sharda Rani & Others,  $) )6 +)+5 ' A " 8 B2       

  

  6

F <

  E 0

 Vijay Kumar Rastogi v. Uttar Pradesh State Roadways Transport Corporation AIR 2018 SUPREME COURT 819     



    

    3

  > 

6  

 

  



         

         

   

       /



   D*          



    E   

   

7 44&2+     &&5'   E     

 7 &&(!!   

  



 

     



   

    

    

/ 

  H * 

 I    *   0        ;  * 

   I    F      J  

 







           

  



    





 

    

     D 5  3      E  0

       

  Meenakshi v. Oriental Insurance Company, 2024 INSC 583    

   

6  

   

   

                  

 



        



 

   G D!+          

  

  

   

               

   



    

 



 



       6

   

    

/     

    

     (+,

  

 



         

       !!      

              

    H  !

* 

            

       ₹

 !+&+!+++"7

;

            $       

   

      &5(4+#("

7

.   

        $ !%)                   

 

 

 



                            

      

 

  

A &+

=

( "  A  ( -  - 

(#8 >?/$56+686+))2



F A

&$

 D ' (    &7$  A  &76 6   A (&76 

 8 &6

    ' (    -   '      

    %@ ( -     (     

A    ( ' <  

 .

 1) 

&5

=

  (- 1( . ( "  

 '  )* )+ +)),        

-  '  

8          8 Sr. No.

Heads Compensation Awarded &  -= 4 $&++678 + 9&5;

4 6*,678/&5;$&++62 $ ?  A  &76 4 ,3::/$53),E&762 ' = 4 +*3$&/$53),8,3::2  

 && *  ?- 4 $556,3+78/+*3$&E&+E&&2 :

DC 4 &,&5)78 ,  CA 4 &,&5)78 D.  4 &3$*))78  4 6,6))78A&  4 6,6))78A$ &)

.-, 6+ -.< #89>>9$? &&  &'.<

(-' (

#%>8>$? &+  =- '

-6& .

# >>"? 489>>9$%>8>$5

  &*

   (- 1( . Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma  $  8 9"R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation (2022) 5 Supreme Court Cases 107 > 

8 

 93; 

   

 

G 

&:

'=.-8# $         ' (

   - "  ' ' (   (  

   7

   (-      ' (  

        )* + +)),  ' 7

   (

 ' (

&,

 

 /2 -  

%# #%

4)

)/5 



 H 78  I7# H(   I