High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21051/2012disposed of

Doaba District Co-Operative Milk Producers Union Ltd. v. Industrial Tribunal, Jalandhar & Ano.

2018-11-02Mr. Justice Girish Agnihotri9 pages

!"!

#$

% &'

()*

+,-.

!

"#$$

/$ 01/2

23

% & % ' & '% '

$ "( )

*+ ' $ (

& &

$ '

,,-.,,/$

$ " ((& 01,,211

!

3$

4 56& !& (3 !6& $

'

178/3$

4 56 $ &

$

&

"

! " $! ((*"( , 9 $ $ $

" $ ( :) ,12;1),21, !

,3 $ $

(56& '

,;1,170; & "

" ! $ < 122.) ( '

) "(

( ((

"

(

$ & &

&

,;;1771& ( (

! &

(& $

$

!& (&

" ,</1771 (

= !& "

(>= (

"

( '

)"(

& (& $$

&

" " (

"$ $ !

( $

! "(" & ( $

"$ &"

(

& ( $$

#

$ = !

" '

!

/,1773'? .;6 ! ( " ( < )& (

" $ $ & " & 01,,211 3'? .-6 )

( /,177- $

$

"$ &

(

& ( $$

) & (& (( !

&

= $

;2@!$ $

;2@ !$ ( $ ( $& $

$ !& 8 """

$ &

)"(

$ :),12;1),21,:)/-28),21< $ ! & ( ( "

$ &" ; '

( $ "(

$

)("( (

$

(& " ,<2/1771

(

" = !&

!

>= & (" !

!

!&

"

>= ! #$$ " &

$ & (

$ ( $

( - $

)"( $

!

"

"

& $ "

!

& !

") ( &

"$

&

(

& ( $$

/

(

& &

$ !

.

$

$' )

"

$ >= & ! !

!

! &'! " ( $& $$

$ ( !&! " ") $(

! "

"( " & $

$ ( & " $ (

"

"$

( &

& 0 >

& $ "

"

!>=

)

&

!

& & "

& )& !'?

#!

# #5!#5

("6"7#"

8(#) 9:2,;3(# 8#81 56"1/ 4# ),9:2 ,.;"4(

/<5

(2#=46"/#= & # />""4(

5#5#

() *9 :2 -; &?@ ("/#= & #

"

8( @@!

(A

21 56" # (# 5B (8&#)& (% "42!#=4)*9.:2+C 7 : " "

$ (

$

(

$= !

! $

! *

(

>=

! (

!$ (

>= $ " $ "&

"

(4 !

($

"

& &5 12 $

& &&

&

& ?

"& %

11)'$ '

" !?

& &

$ !

)"( (

&

$& ( & 11 A " (

(! $

$

& $

(

& &

$ !

& ?

"

&

*

$

$' )

" $ >= & &!AB'?

#!

# #5!#5

("6"7#"

8(#) 9:2,) & AB'?

C) 41< &)

$!

" A "

!

!

) " $

!$$ $ " "D &

!

!

!&

!

'(

!

A "

$$

A "

?

$

&

'

,,-.,,/ $

$ ) $ A "

! & C)

! ! (

!E

!

"

$E

$ $ *

" E

( $ ( "$

! ( ?

(

E

& ( $ !

?

E $

!$ $

&!

!

E "

!

!

!$ ( (

( E

!

!

! (

(

& $ $ "E

$ "$$

'

,,-.,,/$

$ A "

C 3 6 ) E 3 6 & !

(

& &E 3 6" = E 3 6" E 36 $ (" & $ "

3 6

$$

& "

(! E

3 6"

!$

5 1,

2

#54((5 "4#5("%22(

& C,.2+.

AB'?

C) 4/ A "

"

'

,,-$

$

$

"

( = ! "

C ( & ! !

! ( $

"

$ & $ *

: (

&

!

& ! !

& (! !

= $$ " "

$

$ A "

$ &

'

,,- &

$ "

A "

(! ! &

(

"

= (

& $ *

$

!

" ($= !

&

( $ ( " $

! ( ?

(

$ ! & " ( $ !

&

!$ $ &!

!

( "

(

$ !

& ! *" $$

$

(" & $ "

= ! (

& (

$ A "

$ &

'

,,-$

5

1<

! $ $"

*

( "

! $

$ ! >=

(& "

! $

!$ >= " $ $ "

& ( & " " &

" "

! "

)"(

" & $

&

$ !

) $ "

>= ! #$$ " $ " " "

!$ " "

( 18 $

( !( ( " $ " $

& ! "( & & " ) & (& ") $ ( )

"

"

" ,<2/1771 & ! ! & "& "

" $ !

!'

! ( !

& $

!'

! = ($ & (

&

*

$ & "& $ & ) "

&

! 1; !

:),12;1),12,$ ! "(

& 01,,2113'? .-6

!

(" &

) = !

:)/-28),21<$ ! (

(

923 :

% &'

()* : ".

F C G :

F G