Vinod Kumar Dubey v. M/S Sarvotta Tubewell And Engineers And ANR

   

    


 


!"#$%&'(%)*+ *,!,!"*( -*(.%.

/.0'(-,,'&%)*1*22  "3!"**(.,4(%34(5'"#'",4*( *.5"#*",. 

  


!"#$%&'(%)*+ *,!,!"*( -*(.%.

/.0'(-,,'&%)*1*22  "3!"**(.,4(%34(5'"#'",4*( *.5"#*",. 6

 
 


',*7*8!.!"9
66
 !"#$%&'(%)*+ *,!,!"*( -*(.%.

/.0'(-,,'&%)*1*22  "3!"**(.,4(%34(5'"#'",4*( *.5"#*",.
  

  (*.*",

('#'&:'",!1*#!;#-8',*7(,4*5*,!,!"*(!"'22 (*-!.!"5*,!,!".

(**5': %5,';#-8',* 7(,4*'552!8'",!"'22(*-!.!"5*,!,!".

( '"!'&;#-8',*7((*.5"#*","
 !"'22(*-!.!"5*,!,!".

('.41!"#*(0!"34; ;'(+'"' <<<

    0!"8* '22 ,4* ')-* &*",!"*# (*-!.!" 5*,!,!". '(* )*,1**" ,4*.'&*5'(,!*.'"#!#*",!8'27'8,.'(*!"-2-*#;,4*(*7(*;)*!"3#!.5.*# 77)+,4!.8&&"(#*( 7(*&*",!"*# (*-!.!" 5*,!,!". 4'-* )**" 7!2*# '3'!", ,4* !&5%3"*# =%#3&*", #',*# 
; 5'..*# )+ 2*'("*# ##!,!"'2 0*..!". %#3*; '(!#')'# '77!(&!"3 ,4* =%#3&*",. '"# (#*(. #',*# /
;72*'("*#%#!8!'2 '3!.,(',*., 2'..;'(!#')'# 7(.4(, >  >; !" '22 8'.*.; 14*(*)+ ,4* 5*,!,!"*( 1'. 8"-!8,*# %"#*( 0*8,!"
6 7 ,4* *3,!')2* ".,(%&*",. 8,;

 7( .4(, >,4* 8,> '"# .*",*"8*# , %"#*(3 (!3(%. !&5(!."&*", 7( "* +*'( '2"3 1!,4 '&%", 7 8&5*".',!" 7 .?;?;/@; .;;/@ '"# .
6;;/@!",4(**8'.*.,)*5'!

#,,4*8&52'!"'",A(*.5"#*", "
1!,4!""*&",47(&,4*#',*75'..!"37,4*(#*('"#!"#*7'%2,; 4*1'.7%(,4*(.*",*"8*#,%"#*(3.!&52*!&5(!."&*",7('5*(!#7 ,4(**&",4. B!,4,4*8".*",75'(,!*.;7'8,.4'-*)**"",!8*#7(&  7
 *,!,!"*( '55('84*# (*.5"#*", "
/ 8&52'!"'", !" ,4* &",47-*&)*(;1!,4'&*&('"#%&7%"#*(,':!"3,4',4*1!22 ,':* .&* )(!"3 &'84!"*(+ 1!,4 5(5*( 8"-*"!*"8* .+.,*& " (*", 7 .;;/@5*(&",4;'"#"'88%",77'!2%(*,7%27!224!.)2!3',!"; '" '&%", 7  .
;;/@ )*8'&* %,.,'"#!"3 '3'!", 4!&  4* 8&52'!"'",@ (*.5"#*", 
 #*&'"#*# ,4* &"*+ '"# '7,*( '#&!,,!"3 4!. 2!')2!,+; 5*,!,!"*( !..%*# ,4(** 84*C%*. )*'(!"3 D6 #',*# D

 7( .

;/@; 84*C%* "D66 #',*# D

 7( .

6
#',*#
?

7(.
;;/@#('1""EG!.'":H,#; *24!F; ,,'2 '&%",!"3 , .;;/@ !" ,4* 5(*.*", 8'.*  4* ')-* 84*C%*.1*(*5(*.*",*#7(*"8'.4&*",)+,4*8&52'!"'",)%,,4*.'&* 1*(* #!.4"%(*#  1!,4 ,4* (*&'(:. E5'+&*", .,55*# )+ #('1*(F

".*C%*",2+;'.,',%,(+2*3'2",!8*#',*#6
1'.!..%*#,,4* 5*,!,!"*()%,7"*77*8,'"#,4',2*#,,4*7!2!"37,4*8&52'!",%"#*( 0*8,!"
67,4*8,

",4*)'.!.7,4*5(*2!&!"'(+*-!#*"8*2*#)+,4*(*.5"#*", "
/ 8&52'!"'",; ,4* 5*,!,!"*( 1'. .%&&"*# , 7'8* ,(!'2 7( ,4* 8&&!..!" 7 77*"8* 5%"!.4')2* %"#*( 0*8,!"
6 7 ,4* 8,; '"# ,4*(*'7,*( ",!8* 7 '88%.',!" 1'. .*(-*# %5" 4!& )%, 4* 52*'#*# ", 3%!2,+'"#82'!&*#,(!'2 "(#*(,5(-*,4*8'.*;,4*8&52'!"'",A(*.5"#*","
 .,*55*#!",,4*1!,"*..)G'. B
;*G'&!"*#0',!.4 !,,'2'. B'"# 5(#%8*# ,4* (!3!"'2 84*C%*. !" C%*.,!" '. G
 , G 6; (*,%(" &*&. G ?, G D;'2.,*"#*(*#!"*-!#*"8*,4*(#8%&*",.7(& G , '.1*22'. '(:
,'"#82.*#4!.*-!#*"8* 7,*(82.%(*7,4**-!#*"8*7,4*8&52'!"'",;.,',*&*",7 5*,!,!"*( 1'. (*8(#*# %"#*( 0*8,!" 6
6 ( ; 14*(*!" 4* 52*'#*# 8&52*,* !""8*"8* '22*3!"

3 7'2.* !&52!8',!" " #*7*"8*; 5*,!,!"*( '55*'(*#4!&.*27'.B
'"#5(#%8*#8*(,'!"#8%&*",. 7,*( 4*'(!"3 ),4 5'(,!*. '"# 5*(%.'2 7 ,4* (*8(#.; ,4* 5*,!,!"*( 1'. 8"-!8,*# '"# .*",*"8*# -!#* =%#3&*", '"# (#*( #',*# /
 5'..*# )+ 2*'("*#    %"#*( 0*8,!"
6 7 ,4* 8, , %"#*(3 (!3(%. !&5(!."&*", 7( "* +*'( '2"3 1!,4 8&5*".',!" '&%",7.?;?;/@;,)*5'!#,,4*8&52'!"'",A(*.

1!,4!" "* &",4 7(& ,4* 5'..!"3 7 ,4* (#*( '"# !"#*7'%2,;, 7%(,4*( %"#*(3.!&52*!&5(!."&*",7('5*(!#7,4(**&",4. 4*')-*=%#3&*",78"-!8,!"'"#(#*(7.*",*"8*1'. '77!(&*# )+ 2*'("*# ##!,!"'2 0*..!". %#3*; 14!2* 5'..!"3 ,4* !&5%3"*#=%#3&*",#',*#
;4*"8*,4*5(*.*",5*,!,!" %(!"3 ,4* 5*"#*"8+ 7 ,4* (*-!.!" 5*,!,!"; ,4!. %(,; -!#* (#*(#',*#
6
;3('",*#!",*(!&)'!2,,4*5*,!,!"*(",4*3(%"# ,4', 4* !. (*'#+ , .*,,2* ,4* #!.5%,* 1!,4 (*.5"#*", 
/8&52'!"'",

".*C%*",2+;,4*&',,*(1'.'2.(*7*((*#, *#!',!"'"# "8!2!',!"

*",(*7,4!. %(,"??
7('&!8')2*.*,,2*&*",7,4*#!.5%,* )*,1**" ,4* 5'(,!*. '"# (*5(, #',*#
D?
 7 *#!',( 4'. )**" (*8*!-*#,,4**77*8,,4',,4*&',,*(.,'"#.8&5(&!.*# H*'("*# 8%".*2 7( ,4* (*.5"#*", 4'. ", ('!.*# '"+ )=*8,!"!"8'.*,4*5('+*(7,4*5*,!,!"*(!.'88*5,*#)+,4!. %(, *'(# 2*'("*# 8%".*2 7( ,4* 5'(,!*. '"# 5*(%.*# ,4* 5'5*( ):8'(*7%22+ *(%.'2 7 5'('3('54 "D 7 ,4* 0*,,2*&*", 3(**&*", ',,'84*# 1!,4 ,4* (*5(, 7 *#!',( (*-*'2. ,4', " 8*(,'!" ,*(&. '"# 8"#!,!". '7,*( (*8*!-!"3 '" '&%", 7 .
?;;/@ '. 7%22 '"# 7!"'2 5'+&*", '3'!", ,4* *",!(* 82'!& 7 (*.5"#*", 
;  5*,!,!"*( 4'. 8&52*,*2+#!.84'(3*#4!.2!')2!,+'"#,4*.'&*!.#%2+'8:"12*#3*#)+ (*.5"#*",
'"#"15'(,!

*.#",1'",,8",!"%*1!,4,4*2!,!3',!" '"+7%(,4*( ,!.",!"#!.5%,*,4',0*8,!"
?7,4*8,5.,%2',*.,4', *-*(+ 77*"8* 5%"!.4')2* %"#*( ,4!. 8, !. 8&5%"#')2* '"# !, !. 1*22 .*,,2*#5(!"8!52*72'1,4',"8*,4**((!"35'(,+4'.&'#*,4*5'+&*",7 *",!(*'&%",;,4*"),4,4*5'(,!*.1!,4,4*!(7(**8".*",;'(**",!

8&5%"#,4*77*"8*;'"#,4*.'&*!."&(*(*.@!",*3('4*">)2* 0%5(*&* %(, !" 8'.* !"#$%&%'(%' )* %+%,-( ./$.*.',.0 #1 2 2!%3(%//%' 

 4"/$.&.
"$,
%*.*54 4'.4*2#,4', %"#*( .%84 8!(8%&.,'"8*.; ,4* 5'(,!*. )* 5*(&!,,*# , 8&5%"# ,4* !"#!8',*#77*"8*'"#,4*(*2*-'",5'(',4*(*7(*'#.'.%"#*(9@ E'-!"3(*3'(#,,4*.'2%,'(+5(-!.!".70*8,!"
? 7 ,4* *3,!')2* ".,(%&*",. 8, (*'# 1!,4 0*8,!" 6 7 ,4* #* 7 (!&!"'2 (8*#%(*; ,4!.

%(,!.7,4*5!"",4',!"-!*17,4*8&5(&!.* '((!-*#',)*,1**",4*5'(,!*.;,4*5*,!,!"*(.4%2#)* 5*(&!,,*# , 8&5%"# ,4* 77*"8* 8&&!,,*# )+ 4!& %"#*(0*8,!"
67,4* #*F ,!.5(-*#"(*8(#,4',,4*),4.!#*.4'-*8&5(&!.*# ,4* &',,*( 1!,4 ,4*!( 7(** 8".*", '"# ,4* 5*,!,!"*(@8"-!8, 4'. '2(*'#+ &'#*,4**",!(*5'+&*",,(*.5"#*",
 4%.; !, 1%2# )* !" ,4* !",*(*., 7 =%.,!8* ,4', 5'(,!*. )* '221*# , 8&5%"# ,4* 77*"8* , *"')2* ,4*& , 2!-* !" 5*'8* '"# 4'(&"+ -*",4*(1!.*;,4*(*!."2*3'2!&5*#!&*",!",4!.8'.*'"#,4* .'&*!.8-*(*#)+,4*(',!72'12'!##1"!",4*=%#3&*",7">)2* 0%5(*&* %(,!"!"#$%&%'(%'*6%*.*"/$% "-!*17,4*')-*;'55(-'2!.3('",*#7(8&5%"#!"3,4* 77*"8* %"#*( 0*8,!

"
6 7 ,4* 8,  0!"8* ,4* 5'(,!*. 4'-* '2(*'#+ .*,,2*# ,4* &',,*( '"# 7%(,4*( =!",2+ .,',*# ,4', ', 5(*.*",; 7!"'"8!'2 8"#!,!"7,4*5*,!,!"*(!.-*(+5(;,4*(*7(*;:**5!"3!"-!*1,4*2'1 2'!# #1" )+ ">)2* 0%5(*&* %(, !" %0-1% 2$%0.*- ,%,. .7%3 ",-$(,182$%,..9%('%'0%',-.

: 

; '22,4*,4(** (*-!.!"5*,!,!".'(*'221*#'"#,4*!&5%3"*#=%#3&*",.5'..*#)+,4*

%(,.)*21'(*.*,'.!#*'"#,4*5*,!,!"*(!"'228'.*.!.'8C%!,,*#7,4*

84'(3* 7('&*# '3'!"., 4!&; .%)=*8, , 5'+&*", 7 8.,. 7 .;/@ !" *'84 8'.*; , )* #*5.!,*# )*7(* ,4* !34 %(, H*3'2 0*(-!8*.

&&!,,**1!,4!"7%(1**:.7(&,4*(*8*!5,78*(,!7!*#85+7,4!.(#*( 
66
   &%&,%   <-.,-.$*/.%9('7=$.%*'.0 >.*= <-.,-.$$./$,%#3. >.*=