Rattan Multispecialty Hospital And ANR v. State Appellate Authority And ORS






      


  

  !" #$

% &''()' * 
 "  +"  " ,"&

-''-&+"(.

-""-&+"($& /! +" %      


    
 "   &"(0"*$-1

"+ " "-  2"$-0$& /!

   
 3+ ""**"1* +""4+5&'($

!(6++' '!(+ "

 +"  0  
& * 
 ".0   7!""(.0
' .8'"& 
' .9 * *
 "+! '   "    6  "*"    0  
& *
 ".0 7!""($0 
'  "  +"1  ":

      ":

'  *   3+ ;&  "+!   <

' -$==> "+"?+-@ "" 1("$  * +5&'($

 #+-&*&$

4$"   $' *6++    !"  '9    " *
 9
  + "+' *  "  & "

" 96$ ":'$ & ++ "" 1'1

* *   *"+(     +"*"+(   &  +"&*+  "  , + $6+6   +6 "*"" " ";&"  & "  +  "1     +  -   3+  9  * 
  ""   ##

4'

 1"" +  '+&'"&  +  + " "+"  + -  ' & "   $#$=$ $ >$ 4  = +-"6+ %&'=  +":

'* 3+ ;&"+! <

' %&'$== "+"?+%&'@6' '* !++  " +
&" 
+ 5&'*"$7&+  3+ "+'' *+"" #+-&*&$

4!( 6( &"('"1& "   +-3+ '6 

+ !"$

4 +"" ' *+ &'"  &   +   6  &+'   )61"$  1  ""    + 1 !"$

4$+''&+"(+"" :' *

+&'"&  +  " ' +"  +

 + "++"*" "" 1 ("  * + 5&'($

$+" "$' "+"

"*" "  0  
& * 
 ".0   7!""(.0
' .8'"& 
' .9 * *
 " " -$ "  %&'>  # +%&' 3+'  + 5& $

6 +61"$"/ 4+5&'($

 6*"&  & "%&'#:->  +%&' ' 6  *A "+01"

 

  '"    =

     " *    +    -1"(
 +' >

-**"1* +""4+

5&'($

$+"  +! " "" 7"

  & '  "  +   "  +  &!   +  + ' +! ''*''(' !& +"6 1' %&'#:-> +%&'$ * B  +! C  + ' !(+59
$7&+ $ +" "" +"" + 5& $

 6++  ++' "*&++'" = ="'& !(+"    '!'!&    "     '     ""("*" $ 6+"+ " "( * "+  ++ &"+""*& +%&'# +%&''(6 +"&" $ 6+++'!'C 6+''( *%&'#:-> + %&'9 +"*"$++"'& 1 D +/&*   + D !(  )*+ 
&"   "  D'  )+  D+  ,"&  3+    

+"+" +"" 7* 

 

4

  +"+" D" + 9%9- D9%9-$& !,"&  9  +"" >> #

4

44

4 ++!''("*&+ "& ( +" *+&' +1! *" ! " *+ &* "" "'($'"

& ' "+"  +&! + + &* "" '' " ( "

" +!  "'( "  +%&' + "& &!(+01"

  9 $1'" =+5& $

9 &"+"&! + %&'#:->    +%&'# +%&' $&+$+  ""  ' "& ( +" * 9+1+"'"

& ' "!++" "&

> +""6++"!' 
+"  ,9    +  -  '  6+  "*"    * & *   "$  *   '!""     *   '     6++

  =    "1  + ?E1"("     +''  ! " 6 &+ 

"  "&+"  (   &+   (!""!@%&' '6++1'( 6++ "1+?1"("  +''!1' ""

1(" " + &@%&'#" +"

"*" 96&'!""   %&'# ";&C*'  :

 

   


  

 



    



     

     



  
  

!

    "   



  

 

 

  "  

  #  

#

# $ 

   



  %  

  #     

  

&' "     

  



 # 

#

 # $ 

 



 



 

 

"  

  

   



 

 (







 (



 



 $

! 

      ) 
  *

* +    

 

  

         



    (

  

 

  



    

  

      ,

 $    $   ,

-

  ,

 $

  .

    $

  '  $ 

/' #   







(







         





 

# 1 2)








   )  

3
   

            

 

 
  

  

4 5

4)



   # 

  $ 



  6)
  

  4 5

4)



    #

  

  



    

      



 6)

 







     $ 

  

  #



    !

 

 7  89/

  

    )  6) 34(

6  1     

     

 

:; '     

 

      

  <

 = 
:

><5!69/:*?? ?

9/ 9/  #

 (





     





   

 >$@ ><5!

           

      

 4

2@71  * /?22


 



 

>$@><5!

:1 



1 2











     

'

       

 

  

         



        



1 2
  

  "  



    "  

 1 #

 

# 

#

# $ 

  



   



 %

1  1 2
&  



   





  # 

#

# $ 

 

   

 

 

" 

 1 

  

  

 (









 $ 1  2)


  

  





     $    

#





 1  '  "



 1 2 1 

    1 2)


 

 +"+" D" + 9%9- D9%9-&"$+-  '"

0 "' 9 $  "& $&! ! "+
&"+%&'#:- >+!  ""6+

 "  #

4$6+++'' !  "&'"+! +""&+"("1

' 6'" "+"*" 3+' +! "1 " " 6+%&'# +%&' +  +" +''! & + "

"  "    "D')+ D+&"   "

$ ++" & %&'#:->

+%&'$ + '(''* * + "6++ +' " 6+'(  + "$+
&"++'+ '

&'!"/& "%&'#  +%&'$ +""&+"(

  + ";&"   +-   +%&'+1  !

 '6+ %&'#:-> +%&'*"&  ""/ 

' "C *" $6+"%&'#  "&"6++";&"! ''6! "'( *+*"& 

"/   +"&""1+ "& ( +" * +&' ! *"    +'  ! " "/ *+ ' "

"  3+&$ 16 + "& $+6"  ''6 + &* ""4+5&'($

+"!(  + ""  !C+"-""-&+"(:& :
1'

&"* $7&+ $6+++ &* ""$": "+ " "/ +' %*" 0
& *
 " + "$ "*1 * "& ( +" * + "  "+"""" " 6+'6 3+  "  "  "    "  ! "  +  " -""-&+"(:& :
1' &"* $7&+ $ 



!"#"$%& '

   
(

 !"#$ ++"C *."  F. ++"""!' F.