Janak Dulari And ORS. v. Jaspal Singh And ORS.
" #$%$ & '
( (
" # !
$
%
#"&'(&&'
%
) $ * +
% $
! ##,-&&&./
$
! % $ %
#-&-(&&0
!
!!
+
+ # % + ( + " ( * + !
%
%
% $ * !
%
#-&-(&&0 %
# %
( % %
% + "
+
+!
) *
1
!
$
+!
)
$
%
" 2
!
+$
$
$ + %
(#&&&./ %
+ (#33"./ 4
! +$
+!
! !
5
! "&6
+
$ %
+
* + 0
$ $ ! %3, $ !#" +
+$
$
#'#7&./
! ! $
! #37(&&./
!
$ $ 4
+$
$ +
+
,6 3 2
!
"/
$
$ 5 1
+
$
$ 4
! +$
$
! ,6 $ 5
! -6 +
+
$ 7 2
!
+$
!
+8
+
" *
+ %/
!"#$%&'()*+%,'-./-0 11 /-+*23 &
/-+*23 &
--('2 & &
--('2 & & 4
& & 5 & 67 & & !8
& &
&
& & 5
& 67& &
7& & & & 9
:
67 &
&
& &
4
&
&
4
67& &
67 &
& 7 & 4 7
&
&
4
67& &
7& &
7
& & 7
& & 5& &
67 & & !; :0 7 & &
7 & &
85<
- * )
!
+
$+!
+
%
% 0 * 9 :+ $ )
3( !
; < + / "% +*%,%$/,% */2. +*'+ +*% =(2+#>2#%, +/ ?% (7%. 7*/(2. ?% '7 =%-+#/-%. #- @/2(=- !0 /$ +*% '?2% '?/A% !>,%>',%. ?3 '>>23#-) (7'==' */='7& ,#2/B *'-.,' '-. *',2#%0& C*#@* 7+',+7 C#+* '- />%,'+#A% =(2+#>2#%, /$ !$/, +*% ')% ),/(>7 /$ +/
'-.
+/ 3%',70& ,%.(@%. ?3 /-% (-#+ $/, %A%,3$#A%3%',7&+*'+#75 $/, +/
3%',7&5$/, +/
3%',7& 5 $/, +/ 3%',7& 5 $/, +/ 3%',7& !" #$% &' () *' +, - +*%- ,%.(@%. ?3 +C/ (-#+7 $/, %A%,3 $#A% 3%',7& +*'+ #7& 5 $/, +/ 3%',7& 5 $/, +/ 3%',7&5 $/,+/ 3%',7'-.5 $/,+/
3%',7< +
% %
! 3, $ !#"
+ ' * 9 :+ $ )
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
.%@#7#/-#-'F%7*#7-/+'?#-.#-)>,%@%.%-+ "*#2% .%+%,=#-#-) +*% #-@/=%& '- '..#+#/- /$ : /$ '@+('2 7'2',3 +/ +*% #-@/=% /$ +*% .%@%'7%. +/C',.7 $(+(,% >,/7>%@+7& C*%,% +*% .%@%'7%. *'. ' >%,='-%-+ F/? '-. C'7 ?%2/C +*% ')% /$ 3%',7& 7*/(2. ?% ='.% / ""0*0'!
/'1" 2 %,3 0& */ 4 '& */ "
" 5 2 *5
! (, *'
+, - - @'7% +*% .%@%'7%. C'7 ?%+C%%- +*% ')% /$ +/ 3%',7& +*% '..#+#/- 7*/(2. ?% : @+('2 7'2',3 7*/(2. ?% ,%'.'7'@+('27'2',32%77+'H - @'7% +*% .%@%'7%. C'7 7%2$5%=>2/3%. /, /- ' $#H%. 7'2',3& '- '..#+#/- /$ : /$ +*% %7+'?2#7*%. #-@/=% 7*/(2. ?% +*% C',,'-+ C*%,% +*% .%@%'7%. C'7 ?%2/C +*% ')% /$ 3%',7 - '..#+#/- /$ : C*%,% +*% .%@%'7%. C'7 ?%+C%%- +*% ')% /$ +/ 3%',7 '-. : C*%,% +*% .%@%'7%. C'7 ?%+C%%- +*% ')% /$ +/ 3%',7 7*/(2. ?% ,%)',.%. '7 +*% -%@%77',3 =%+*/. /$ @/=>(+'+#/- *% %7+'?2#7*%. #-@/=% =%'-7 +*% #-@/=%=#-(7+*%+'H@/=>/-%-+ /, .%+%,=#-'+#/- /$ +*% =(2+#>2#@'-.& +*% .%.(@+#/- $/, >%,7/-'2'-.2#A#-)%H>%-7%7&+*%+,#?(-'27'-.+*%@/(,+77*'22 ?% )(#.%. ?3 >','),'>*7
+/
/$ ',2' E%,=' C*#@* C% *'A%,%>,/.(@%.*%,%#-?%$/,% +6) /
*0'! '& 1*070 / 2 0!"0 * " 0! */
2 0! " 50*/ 747/ (8 '& */* 91"4
!* +6: / 4 '& */ "
" /'1" 2 */ 2 0 &' 77-0!4 */ 1*070 +6; '!2 &041 '! '!< !*0'! / " !
- '
'& ** ' '& '! '*01 !" &1!
=7 /'1" 2
$+,,,># (,,,,># !" $+,,,># *0< - /
&' 0" '1!* /'1" 2
!/!
" * */ * '& $,3 0!
< -*/
- *% ,%$%,%-@% #7 '-7C%,%. '@@/,.#-)23 '++%,7 ?% >2'@%. ?%$/,%+*%'>>,/>,#'+%1%-@*<
) +
8 $ % %
%
+ 9 :+ $ )
! $
$
% !
% 1
+
%
!
%
% %
$ .% !/$
!
5 *
3( 8 $
! ; < %
$
! 0&&&&./
$ !
$ ! 5 % $
%
1
+ !#&6 , * 9 :+ $ )
4 ?
! 1!
'
7!- 0* "
17 ! +
! !
$ !
+ %
$
! !
$
$ *
%
%
$
+
8 $
+ %/ /-7+#+(+#/- 1%-@* /$ +*#7 /(,+ #- ,'-'3 %+*# .%'2+ C#+* +*% A',#/(7 *%'.7 (-.%, C*#@* @/=>%-7'+#/- #7 +/ ?% 'C',.%. #- ' .%'+* @'7% -% /$ +*%7% *%'.7 #7 /77 /$ /-7/,+#(= - 2%)'2 >',2'-@%& @/-7/,+#(=< #7 '
@/=>%-.#/(7 +%,= C*#@* %-@/=>'77%7I7>/(7'2 @/-7/,+#(=J& I>',%-+'2 @/-7/,+#(=J& '-. I$#2#'2 @/-7/,+#(=J *% ,#)*+ +/ @/-7/,+#(= C/(2. #-@2(.% +*% @/=>'-3& @',%& *%2>& @/=$/,+& )(#.'-@%& 7/2'@% '-. '$$%@+#/- /$ +*% .%@%'7%.& C*#@* #7 ' 2/77 +/ *#7 $'=#23 "#+* ,%7>%@+ +/ ' 7>/(7%& #+ C/(2. #-@2(.% 7%H('2,%2'+#/-7C#+*+*%.%@%'7%.7>/(7%
*
>/(7'2 @/-7/,+#(= #7 )%-%,'223 .%$#-%. '7 ,#)*+7 >%,+'#-#-) +/ +*% ,%2'+#/-7*#> /$ ' *(7?'-. C#$% C*#@* '22/C7 @/=>%-7'+#/- +/ +*% 7(,A#A#-) 7>/(7% $/, 2/77 /$ @/=>'-3& 7/@#%+3&@/5/>%,'+#/-& '$$%@+#/-& '-. '#. /$ +*% /+*%, #- %A%,3 @/-F()'2,%2'+#/-<
',%-+'2 @/-7/,+#(= #7 ),'-+%. +/ +*% @*#2. (>/- +*% >,%='+(,% .%'+* /$ ' >',%-+& $/, 2/77 /$ >',%-+'2 '#.& >,/+%@+#/-& '$$%@+#/-& 7/@#%+3& .#7@#>2#-%& )(#.'-@% '-.
+,'#-#-)<
#2#'2 @/-7/,+#(= #7 +*% ,#)*+ /$ +*% >',%-+7 +/ @/=>%-7'+#/- #- +*% @'7% /$ '- '@@#.%-+'2 .%'+* /$ ' @*#2. - '@@#.%-+ 2%'.#-) +/ +*% .%'+* /$ ' @*#2. @'(7%7 ),%'+ 7*/@B '-. ')/-3 +/ +*% >',%-+7 '-. $'=#23 /$ +*% .%@%'7%. *% ),%'+%7+ ')/-3 $/, ' >',%-+ #7 +/ 2/7% +*%#, @*#2. .(,#-) +*%#, 2#$%+#=% *#2.,%- ',% A'2(%. $/, +*%#, 2/A%& '$$%@+#/-& @/=>'-#/-7*#> '-.+*%#,,/2%#-+*%$'=#23(-#+
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
*% /+/, E%*#@2%7 @+ #7 ' ?%-%$#@#'2 2%)#72'+#/- '#=%. '+ >,/A#.#-) ,%2#%$ +/ +*% A#@+#=7 /, +*%#, $'=#2#%7& #- @'7%7 /$ )%-(#-% @2'#=7 - @'7% C*%,% ' >',%-+ *'7 2/7+ +*%#, =#-/, @*#2.&/,(-=',,#%.7/-/,.'()*+%,&+*%>',%-+7',%%-+#+2%.+/ ?% 'C',.%. 2/77 /$ @/-7/,+#(= (-.%, +*% *%'. /$ #2#'2 /-7/,+#(= ',%-+'2 /-7/,+#(= #7 'C',.%. +/ @*#2.,%- C*/
2/7% +*%#, >',%-+7 #- =/+/, A%*#@2% '@@#.%-+7 (-.%, +*% @+ $%C #)* /(,+7 *'A% 'C',.%. @/=>%-7'+#/- /- +*#7 @/(-+ /C%A%,& +*%,% C'7 -/ @2',#+3 C#+* ,%7>%@+ +/ +*% >,#-@#>2%7 /- C*#@* @/=>%-7'+#/- @/(2. ?% 'C',.%. /- 2/77 /$ #2#'2 /-7/,+#(=
*% '=/(-+ /$ @/=>%-7'+#/- +/ ?% 'C',.%.
'7 @/-7/,+#(= C#22 ?% )/A%,-%. ?3 +*% >,#-@#>2%7 /$ 'C',.#-) @/=>%-7'+#/- (-.%, I/77 /$ /-7/,+#(=J '7 2'#. ./C- #- ,'-'3 %+*# !7(>,'0 - +*% >,%7%-+ @'7%& C% .%%= #+ '>>,/>,#'+% +/ 'C',. +*% $'+*%, '-. +*% 7#7+%, /$ +*% .%@%'7%.& '-'=/(-+/$7 &
%'@*$/,2/77/$#2#'2/-7/,+#(=< 4 +
8 $ $
! 3&&&&./ % %
!
$
$ %
% $
$+
$ .
#& * )
+
%
+ +$
+!
!
+8
+
!
"
%
% * )
$ %
5 %
,6 $ %
+
+!
4
$
$ 5
!
"/
$ +
$ %
!
!
$ +
= $
%
1
+
#"
! 0 % 3, ! >
)
! '6 + * + +
%
$
##
% +
!
$ %
%
#"&'(&&'
$
/ $
$
! #70#"#7./ %
! '6 $ !
$
! !
$
%
! %!
$
,- ./ 01
234
( 'A#-.%,G(=', > .
?.
>
+ ?.