Davinder Kumar v. Kulbhushan Kumar And Another




   
     !

!"#$% &%




  

 

  

 $  '( % )
*
+)( ,-"./,* !

""#0 - # #/ 

  ! "  

#  $ ! "   %

 & #  ' (((( *
+)(1% -23      ! )*+ ,  , " - & "

 !&  $ "!  !   %*  +* .) +..%  ! %/* "  & 0

 !   1

 

 


1    -  !& & "

,&       '

   " !  %) .2 +..*  3   ! & % , #   $   '

  .5 .* +.%+     .% .6 +.%2  3  4 & 7     " !  8" "! "   !      %

 

  "  !   ! %/* "  & 0

 !   &    

    !-   //.659  +.

%% +... "  

"  6% ...:;  "  "  ! ;  %    !&  3   !-  $    8

   $   $     10 ""! < 1 "  ! "  & ! $     $    !  $ "    
 4 ! & #    '

  %) .2 +..* !!     ! %/* "  & 0

 !  !   " $ 3 " &     & $ " "

 2 ...:;

  "   "   4 & 7  $! $  "  .5 .* +.%+  &  !     "    $  $      !  $      % " "

  "   " 

5. ...:;   " $!  /6 ...:;    3       %  ,    3 "

0 $ "

     $ 3  3 %2= "  !-        "          "

 9 %2.:;  %2= "   !-     "  6% ...:; $ 
! < >& !3 <     "  + "   '

 $  $   !   !    !  $    !   3  !    "  /) ...:;

     -    !   !    !      ! ;  %   ! "  "  !&    $!  

  "

&   !&  &         "  9 2..:;   !   3  !  !        ,    9  .2 .6 +..* $           $ ! 

& ! "        3   ,    $       ! 3          ?3        !

3 ! .* .9 +.+% " & "     .% .6 +.%2 !    ""! $   $!   ?  ?

 ;) $       "   !    ! $

@
 

    

  







    !"  !  #      $

#

!%"&"'
  !(  #  

  )*+, -.

, /  0  / 1, 
  ( #  2  

3   452 ,"6789)))65



 

 !   !"  +  #       $

 / 
 : 1 ( 

2  

3  452 ,")676)))5   

    ;"66*) ""  #"*  <            

  69 , =   >? ? $"

(<  ? >     +

  ,"9    9"7"    < @ 7"8"9       

4     

       #"8             

 

    "

   @    

 

 

 

 >(< ? $"? ? > +   

 ,")    8"*"9    

  

<         #"     

                 #"6*     

 <  "9" !":"?"(  - !0



 

     1        #"67 ; 

 #"8          8A  ;   #"*  ( B - B 

 #")8      "=            



     

<    - 
 + "

   <                   

 



 

<<     <   

<  +   / " ,"8  *"6"6  <  "*"8 !"

! ?  - !0

 

    



       "

      



          

           +  0  

    

 "

    <      <

 <

   



 

"

             <                           

   "

"

  ,&@       

      >   %@   +    @    7"8"9     

    1     + @  ;       

        <     

    "

6"

  

         ;    <  ; 

               <  



"

7"

 



 



 

  

<    

      "

 

  



            

  <   <   

  ;   

   

 "

 



 

 !

 !

"


# "

 

#4    "    !  $  $   !  3  !   !      3   '!  !  '

 " !!    0       !   &   $  $ " $  $  3 !!      > !  "        !   &   "   "   '

 "  ,; 8! "  ,   , ;

;%5+5+;+.%2  +* .% +.%6   # % 1 $"! %@

    !     !!

!    ! )*+ ,  , $    <0 $   -  !& $ -     '

 " !! $      " !  > !  "  !      "" "   %; !  $!     ! 

 ;

   "  "" $  $      3  !                 ! 3   %  "

  "   "         '!  !     $

>  !      !       ! %/* ,  ,      '!  !    $  '

   " !  %) .2 +..*  3    4 ! & % , #   $   '

  .5 .* +.%+    .% .6 +.%2  3  4 & 7      ,      !  "    " "! $  $   &     "

3 !  $    "   !        " !        "3  !3 A  "

   !  $ & !   3 $     !  3

 , 8! "  ,     1 !

5 B

C  $    ! )*+ ,  ,

   !!

!    "   '

   ! $

@%      79+ "%+  ; B=#,"87"9"82. %5 ! 6667788*797)=%+2;  !   69    66*  =%+5       %   !  ! ,  ( ,   

   *""82.   %75    

   ;

  

@        8")"6    "!0!'!,   

     """

...C......

D          B=#          

@     8")"6    "!0!'!,   

*""82. % 75        

  + " .........

+     $    %   &      '()*"+# , ", # )(' 

 

   

    <    <    

       

        !  +            

      +     <  

  ! 79+ "%+;



   @  <

38"
   <1  6 + %+   <             +  

    79+ 

%  + 

     @ " *"  .

 

  ! 0     79 +  %  +;



  

   

<1< 

  

  +    
-  .   - -  & /   0 - '((1"'# -,-- ", # 2)( 3 "'((1#4 ,, 52+  

       

25   7)9=% +  9 >

 

     

  "
 .+  ;   



  1     <  

                       @  <E  



   

  E     <1        

  7     +"!   +     

1  

7 +      << +    1

" "
   @  .  +  79+  %  + < 

<      @  <  

 ;

  

               ! 6+  %  +     < .  <  .

 <1    

 @       " 9"...... )"...... "...... "  =               

                 



<2

      ,"5< 

      

&   <  



 

F   



         <  @  ",

  

   

  

@   <     @    <    "  !                 <1       !   79 +  %  +   

   +     

 



  <1  @       1      

  @   

  " "+;      

 @   *"6") +  +,"78    + 0  /  

9"9"

<    

  ,"2!

"# (<5

  #@  ;        "        





    ,"  ;   <

"  #      

 

    

       <       *"6")     

 

  

+  "4 !

         .$ $ %   &

6 '()+"*# , ", # 451  

 

 6*=%+   

   

                  

    

"
+  

 @  7 , %   &   '((2 "4# , ", # 1*1  ,  $ %   &

6 )225"'# , ", # *2'



         6*=%+

        <     

          

                    

"

  GGGCGGGGGG 

   B=#  ,"8    7"9"8 2. %5 6667788*797) =%+2; ! 6966*=%+5   % !! ,  ( ,  

; 

        ;    



      ;         

   *""8  2.   %75  @             #"8   %@!- <   + " +;     @                    8")"6           "

!0!'!,  @      "4  ,    '

  .9 ./ +.%5   ,  /9. " +.%5   8

 $ - %6

   9     ;

@#   

   
 / - 

:    '()) "'# , ", # '21 


 -  -   . ; '()( ",# )(25-


< @   + 

 ! 7 + "%"+"      @  

<  

      "



;   <<

   <         < + "
 < .     

  ! 7 , =  "





   


 -  -   . ; '()( ",# )(25  ;      

;

       < + "

=<    

@ )""

 !0 !

 /1 !<

         ;"


 < 

@   8A   ;     


 -  <  " # !- <    

      

       ; "  ,  

;  

"4 !    '

 $  !   '

 "  71    ,  


 -  < ! " #       $  ,    $     '

 " !! &      "   !   !     !  &      &  $  "!     !    !   "  &   "!

"

 !       3   !  & "   %;!  $  3 "  ""    ""!    !!  "  "!          " %2= "  !-      ,  $     ! )*+ ,  , " - & "  !&  $ "!  !   %*  +* .) +..%  ! %/* "  & 0

 !    -  !& & "    " !   '

   " !  %) .2 +..*  3    4 !

& % , #   $   '

  .5 .* +.%+    .% .6 +.%2  3  4 & 7     *
+)( % &%     /1 D : &E F: D E F: