← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21191/2012dismissed

Suresh Jain And ORS v. Ut Of Chandigarh And ANR

2016-01-11Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih5 pages



       ! # $% &!'( )

"* +,(-& .-(

( (,(

 /0-& .1&-& .-( 

(2 (  

     

  



-- 2(!'&2&2(3&/4&5.(-6,.13 7

--4!.- 2( 7 ---6,.13 (-,.42. -1(7 ( ) $ +,3$&-&6& 0+ .'&5- $ 39-&0.'&0!-2 ( $ +& 6+-&3&0+ .'&5- $ 4-/ &+ 1-0.'&0!-(2 ::::    -2 ((;&5<,&(-& ..&.

4/ 5-'- (2   8>+,2 0 (& !!'0

  /0 -& .1&- -&( '&. ,2  -3  .2( & (,3 !  = 0808*8?>  &'', !@, & .2!A&(&' 2'. -' (.& ! - 2 (A <,( ! ((,& ' ! & @ 46'  !'&A ! & (! ! &( -. 1-( -. 4/ 2  (  &    !&, ! 8 (2'!& .,(&2 -2 (-&(,1- -' (<, &!.' 1-(2 (((,&@ 46' !'&A ! & (! ! &( -. 1-( 4/ 2  (  &   !&,!2 -2 (-&&((,1-&.'&& -&

,B#%!--& .1&-(& ,(0 ""B&(&3 ..4/-& .1&- (&#3 .3 % ,(0 "" (1&0&4&/& ..('3 &/

- '&(   & ,(- ( -(  - 32,1 . .3& . ! , & . 2!( (   &''.& ' 5- &,( = ! & &( .. .&.



 B= . 45 2 ( .-(2 -('&,(('-& 1.&!="/&( -1, .-&-! &3  ..  '  (,'- & 2(

  -& 6'. - '     5 1, .( (/0 &,( C ! -  ! &3 <,.-2&(D',&&(.. (,'-3(&(3&/ 4.'.4/-(& !!'0-& .1&- -&(..5&(D',. 5-, 2(  .3,  - '&,( (  1&   (  2   - (  '-& 1 -( '&,( &!  =" /&(  +' ./0  &((,3 1-&-3(!-!&3 & !-&(.. & &22'&40  5,. 3&;  .!!  &,( C ! -  ! &3  2-4( - 2 ( !3 (,4> 1 - 4,.   ! - ( &1  &D -( '&,(0 -/ &  .  . (   (,'- 3(& (&(-/.(  .,(&25&(&(.,4/-(2 ( !&, !2 !&3! /&( -3(& ( ' . &!&3 .&.

&,((C080& .C! -!&3 &.&(, .)>   

   

  

   

      

  

    !

 "#    $% &        

       $               '   

         (                   " )       

   

               (          $ &

                

  *    +  

   ,                  



         

- =

,(,&   '&,(>C0 - 2&( D',. & &( .. .&.

 B= &,(=#&%-!&.(&(, .)> .* +                                                

    (                /        ) *   +    

              #    

            0

              !

      

  



      #  

    

         - - &( .. -&( 4    D( ' & . 2&. 45  - -& .& .-(2 ( --!  =" /&(    ! - '&,((-! 546'. 4/ 2 &-3!  1 -&13 & . -&!  '-& 1'&,(=#&%( 5(,1-4&(.&!="/&( *

"B

"0 - 2 ( 3&. &  &22'&    8(; 1&@ 46' !'&A!-& (!!- &(-.1-(!2 !&,!2 - (-& 1 &; /.'( (2'-!0-2 ( !.&  =* ! 5-'-5&(.(2(.!4/& . & . 6,.13  ! & (   '- .&.

 .' 1 -

 (.'.-2 (A&22'&

-(2 (.'.. -&22'&

/ - 32,1 . '33, '&  .&.

 - ('&.,2 -2 (.2(&(,3!= 0808*8?> &'', !, & .2!& .!, (-& , .&; 1-&-/5,.4 4, . 4/ & /  '&( 5-'- ( '&',&. & & & 2  ! 3 &( & '  2'.  ! ' (. 1 - &22'&  ! & @ 46' !'&A  (  .(2,. -& '&,( =#&% ! - &( .. .&.

 B= .-(2 (/&'-&1!E"F!-, & .  '&( -&,!-& .

(' ..0-50-&-('&,(( ' &/  - 3( ! -  ! &3  5-'- (2,&.-&-25,.4&(.-2 ( -3(& ' ( ' . -

  ( ' .. -& '&,( =#&% ! - &( ..(' &/'&,(8!-!&3 .&.

 5&((,3-&( 3&;( .!!

&,(C!-!&3 .&. <,.- 2&(  &1,&&(..

5&(2 -2&(   &&(.. (,'-3(& (&(-/.(.

.. 46'& /!-3(& (!-&( ..

!-/5 (&(!.5-& /!-3(& (-!  ',. 1'&,(=#&%5&(2 -3-&&(.&.(2, -& 1&.& .-&(,1- !'3 !-!&3 -/..

.( -/, &/& .5-2 /(&''2.&-3(& ' (!-&(..

-( - 11&&4,-(&3 (  ' ..-&-&(..5&( .  &'', !'' 0!&,.

  , .,  !,   .. (,'- & ' 0   ! &(.0 5,. 4 .!!',&''2(2'&/ &'&((,'-&(-(5-!="/&( -2&(&(. .(2, -/ 5(;&.-3( -(  &.4&(( 5-'--/'& 423..(   & /   '&,( C ! -  ! &3

2-4.2 !3(,4 1& /2 ! -4,. 1'. -(&.2# 3 -/&(4&((%& /- 2&/?2(

-,( / 0 &((,3 1-&-3(!-! &3  & 2& 45  - 2&(0 2  &  '&

 (,4&( - 22/ 5-, - 23((  ! -  -& -(2 (5,.4 .32((,'- 3(& (&(-/.(0!-/.'.&D'&,(C   - '',3(& '(0  3&;(  .!! ' 5-'- & 1 -3&(;.& !-2 .(& (! 1- &(-.1-( -22 8-/&4, .'32/5- -<,(3(& (' . -32,1 .'33, '& .&.

  -( 5 !- 3&0  (  '((&/  ' (. - '-& 1-&./!,B!--& .1&-(& ,(0 ""B&( &3 ..4/-& .1&-(&#3 .3 % ,(0 ""

-52 (&''. 1/.(3((.

#+ GH  %   +

"*   #

 II% @& .A