Harminder Singh And ORS. v. Lal Singh And ORS.
!"# " $%%"
&&''
("
*' $%%"
%")$%* &
)+%, $% &&'' ("
*' $%%"
%")$%* &
-" "#".
"+/, 0 % "10'23'/, "%&&'' "'+"")'/, " "-"+2)&/, "&&''
4
)&)"5%)%"3/, "" &
4
7%
"" # %''
& "# "$)'"
&&'
'% %
83%*
/0%"$$"
, %.)$# """ 83 %'0"&&''5)"/0%"83 %" &&'
+ ''0 $"'
/% 8 "/
/.)$# " %"
'5)"/
$% /% 8
! " " #"!$ %#! & ! $'!" '$! ('!" ! '!" $ ( ('!" "$!
# !" ! !( ('!" "!# "!# ! "#!" # %!"& '!" '!" $'!" #!"
#'!" '!" (( % !& " % !& ' %$! & !
$ $! #! # !" ( ! "'!" '!" '!
" !' !
!# #'!" !$ $'!# # %'!#& ! ( "! $ %"!& $ "! $(#! $' ) * + , - .
"#".
"+/'" ) '
83"10'
23'/'" ) '&&"
$8%'
&&'' )8# % &"
#"
'3
8 )&%)" %" " %&"&"3%%
2)"8)9 $%8 $ "'2)"8)9 $%)"
$%
'
#/% 9 )"$
"$
: ; ,)" % #) ;: %
"$"0 '
2)"8)9 $% ; ;;
%&" % 8
'
;;: 7% 2
8 $ "$
" / % 8 &",
"3, "
'0 , '8'
$)" 0
, '8'%" " %$
""0%
%% 89# 83 9&"&",%")$%% #3 < %" $% & &'
'&",%)" %" " %&"&"38 "'7%9 "& 8")$%" " %&"&"3
: %, $,',)&2)"8)9 $% "#%
$" %"1% $%/ "%"
'3 "#=
% $% $" %" %&'
/ %"
2)"8)9 $% &"&"
> )''?
!
)*0/ "
" $%"
$% %&"&"38 $ "'/%"% 8%" $" %&"
" $8 )"% -<:@" ' $%/0%%8")$%%9 "& ","% 0 "
'9 "&/ "
'9 "&
" $% #0
," )'" )")'$)$$ " ' "#. 8 $%8) . 8 $%% 89# /
/&'
%, '
%"$%) %"
)" %4 >, 7% )# %$
>9-0 %+0'$ % &'
038 + %3"; "
&3 % #0
&&'
83$ , $
"8+,')#)#8"3% % 8
'
%3";;:/%" "/ 0 % 83&",
"
' ; % * >,
"8 "),%% )# % #0 % "+0'$/%" "/&",
"
' 0)'%'&%# "$
" % )#0 %+0'$
%3"; 4 )&&" %
"$" $%&"&"38 "'/% "'
)& ''0 '0 & + )
% & /* "% &/0*'$ & 1 )
,2 ""% &-/* $ & 3 )
* 4 "#%#&*5* %56& ($ )"$ %
5)" " $
%
""83
%'0"&&''5)" %"
'5)" "9# $%, /
% )&)"5%)%"3/'" ) '&&"
$8%'
" &&'
)8# %.#8 8")$%" " %0 % &"&"3%,',)&2)"8)9 $% "#=
% $%/%" "/ &" )#& A) %"
"#1% $% 8")')7%$
% 8&",83% "
'% % $% %3) 8 88""83'0 '
%"
$"
,"# %% A)
%$
#%
'3%#
2)"8)9 $% %3%&&" %%
"$ $%&"&"3#)''% "
%,8+
" 83%'0"&&''5)"/%) %"
''$'
3 &","
3 4 / ") % 8 &'3 )& 2)"8)9 $% 83 % 8
"3 %$
7% )# %$
0
' %")$%)%'
# 2)"8)9 $%/%" "/ 8
88""83'0 '
%) )"$ %
5)" "
"# %
)" %''$ 4%,%"'" ) ' "%&" &&"
% &&"8+ %, 0%%"
"
#"
% )8#
""+/ "/9 "&%.#8 8")$%" "
""#'3 %0%%'% '' "#1% $%/% $"$" %" %&'
4" ' '3 "#=
% $% $" %">,%"
'9 "&0%
%
)"3"A) "# '0 &"%!
$%5)")' ""
/#) %'
/"
)'' ) 7 )
- ($ -/8 $ /
)'8'+ *0"&&''5)"8 $' 5)" '00 . )&8'
$ 9# ''% 8)%, ' / #3, 0/8
%) /
'"
$%&"&"38 "'
''
) &","
&"&"
/
8,/
%)''?
!
)*0/"A) "# '0% 8 #&'
0 % >,/
% &&'' %,+%&'
"$ ,)&/ : %* &" ')3 &"3"
%&' '
3 $ %#"7%
8, 0)' ",' % % " &&'
% &&'
"
"
&3 %$
038 + %3"; 3"#
' %
'% "
93"
;;:/%) / 0 %&'
'3 8""83'0 '
%" ''0 % %#8 %* 4
%
& ) %#"/"
' )"
% 8)%'0"&&''5)"
''% -<:@" ' $%'
& % 0 %"
'
9 "& 8) 0 $ " ' %")$% . 8 $% 0% % 8 9# 9 "&% '
89# 4#3, 0/" & &'
%, '
%"$%) /#) %'
/ ) % "
'" "% #" " ''% "
/ #3, 0/%,8 " /%) /%"
$"
''$'
3&","
3 )8/%
5)"/"'
"
%8 "# $%
)8 'A) '00% '
$%&&'
8) , 0 %"
)'')83
,'"@)$ %!?8')&"#5)"
0%" %&"&
" 0%%" , 0 % &",
;
5-5/&",
%-).8 5)" /;0)'&&'3"%&&' 0)'8
')"
5 5 , ' -" )"/ %"
"# %
)8 'A) '0"7%5 ) '= % !?8' )&"# 5)" %' % %
!"# ! $ "
%
&'
(
&&'
8 3 ;
5-5
"" '0/
/% &",
%-).85)" /;%8" " 8 + B"% + 8", 3/%"',&" %.)$#
,'"@)$ %!?8')&"#5)" -+.+ % ?
)&"" %) #-
40 9
2 6:
"" 464 + 6 42;7 15 $) * +,- ./ , 0 -
3
4 6 <= $> (?.
$ @6 0 #5
242 5
#-
45 0 ('6
A46 2 42/ 5
B
B 42- 6 /
'"036 B 0 (
4 7 B 2 4 36 B 0 (
42 ( B 5
B 420 ( 36 B 0 (
-
45 0 4 2 B 24 5
426 0 $ %&5
B
+ 4 0 #5
B 6
42/ 4 9 426 0 $ 5
B B 0 $ %&
2 42 / 2 C6 2 ($%&556- %0 &0 ($
# -
45 0
2 . 7%" "/4 "#% )8 'A)
'00% '
$%&&'
/ "# )''3/.)$# " %'0"&&''5)"
% %"
'5)"
" " &&'
/
" $'3/"''0 ! ""# $
%&'%& ()& *+,-.
& (/,&01 &(./ %&'%& &)/ &1 &(./