Mani Ram v. Commissioner Hisar Division Hisar And ORS

  
   
   !

"#$ %$&'(')*   +
 



   

   



     
 * ,- .
. - ,- .
-/.- 0$($)#* 01"2"')3%4&"#$ 0#5$6$#'#')$0  "1$(5')%"7 5$0%$0(6"(($%82#5$"9#50'#'$(9)%$0#5$9)1"8:'77";$
<<)-")%( $;97"#')!&#3=>

0(50#3,#5$&#,!3"("667'&"87$ ##5$.#"#$ "02")"3?5$0$82$4'&#') #5$6$#'#')$05"(8$$)0%$0$%

0<#5$7")%')%'(69#$35"4$8$$)'<69;)$%')#5$60$($)#?0'#6$#'#') 5$$4'&#')6$#'#')?"( '7$%82#5$0"<")&5"2"#9)%$0 .$&#')

! #5$&#&7"'<');#5"##5$7")%'(0$&0%$%')#5$)"<$

0"<")&5"2"#")%"##5$#'<$ %$<"0&"#')3'#?"( 9)%#5"##5$ 6$#'#')$0'(')9)"9#50'($%6(($((') @")"7(")% <"07"( 7")% ("&)($A9$)&$35'($4'&#')?"(%'0$&#$%)#$0<( .$&#')

#5$ &#35$?"( 90#5$0%'0$&#$%#6"2"(9< 
 3 BC6$05$&#"0$6$0 "))9<"(6$)"7#2

 -$"0)$%&9)($7 0#5$6$#'#')$0(98<'##$%#5"##5$7")%'()# (5?)#8$(5"<7"#%$535$)&$3"667'&"#')9)%$0.$&#')

! #5$&# ?"()#<"')#"')"87$0<#5$1"<"8")%'(67"&$%)0$&0%3'#'(&7$"0#5"# #5$  7")%  '(  0$&0%$%  ')  #5$  ?)$0(5'6    0"< ")&5"2"#  ")%  0$(#

$6"0#<$)#'(')6(($((')#5$0$  $")');#5$0$823?)$0(5'6 0"< ")&5"2"#"((9&5'()#')%'(69#$")%#5$6$#'#')$05$0$')'(&$0#"')72') 9)"9#50'($%6(($((') "( ') #5$0$4$)9$0$&0%36(($((') 5"(8$$) (5?)#8$ #5$0$(# $6"0#<$)#)&$'#'((3#5$0$'()$000')#5$ 0%$0(6"(($%82#5$"9#50'#'$(%'0$&#');$4'&#') #5$6$#'#')$0 0<#5$ 7")%')%'(69#$3?5'&5'(')5'(9)"9#50'($%6(($((')5$6$#'#')$05"( )#8$$)"87$#60%9&$")2#5');)0$&0%#(98(#")#'"#$5'(67$"#5"##5$ 7")%')A9$(#')?"(;'4$)#5'< 0&97#'4"#')3?5'&5')'#'"772?"(6"0#

#5$15"0 ( "0"('<6('#') 6$)"7#2'(&)&$0)$%3.$&#')

#5$ &#604'%$(#5"#<')'<9<  
D3 BC")%<"E'<9< 
 3 BC6$0 5$&#"0$6$0"))9<6$)"7#2&")8$'<6($% 09)"9#50'($%&&96"#')

#5$7")%5$67$"#5"#)0$"()(5"4$8$$)0$&0%$%#'<6($<"E'<9< 6$)"7#2'(<$0$72#8$)#'&$%")%0$1$&#$% 0#5$0$"()#5"#"<9)#

6$)"7#2'(#<$";$05$&#?"($)"&#$%')#5$2$"0=>604'%'); 0 $4$)<')'<9<
D3 BC6$05$&#"0$6$0"))9<"(6$)"7#25$4"79$

7")%")%'#(9#'7'#25"4$')&0$"($%<")'

7%')#5$7"(#<0$#5")>D2$"0(3 89#)#5');5"(8$$)%)$#96C%"#$#5$7"?(<9)# 6$)"7#2 
 3 BC6$05$&#"0$6$0"))9<7$4'$%)#5$6$#'#')$0 09)"9#50'($% &&96"#') #5$6")&5"2"#7")%&"))#8$("'%#8$)#5$5';5$0('%$

 &&0%');723#5$?0'#6$#'#')'(%'(<'(($% $  0$&<<$)%  #  #5$  .#"#$  #5"#  '#  (597%  $E"<')$  "(  # ?5$#5$0"<9)# 6$)"7#2604'%$%9)%$0.$&#')

#5$&#)$$%( 0$4'(')')4'$? &5");$%&'0&9<(#")&$(?'#57"6($ >D2$"0("

#$0#5$ &#?"($)"&#$%
62 #5$0%$08$($)##
5'$ .$&0$#"023"02")"

"1$(5')%"7!

9%;$  -/.-!

9%;$   + <@ 5$#5$0(6$"@');B0$"()$%*

$(B 5$#5$00$60#"87$*

$(B