High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10314/2017dismissed

Veena And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-08-31The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli12 pages

"#$ %

#&#'

"#$ (

)

#**#"+, - ) & /+*+ * 0*#**#"+, - 1#"

#+ 2$ 342/)/56/ 342/44

#+$ 2 /*#"

1/,* 7*6"!'*+ 6

+, 1 2 #8& 2.++*96 ""9 "!'*+ # *96 * 0*#* :.+, 2 /*& *;, 2*<6 + "!'*+ # *9 * 0*#*6 *#" 25&,*9"

152*#',*#"* 1#"

#+ , .#+*#+ 1 +.+.# ,* ;

# .9 " '9*.7.#< +,*+ +, *'=&..+.# 1 '

".#<'* .

"&+!."

#+.

.'*+.#.& "&#"

/ >? 4*#" '=&..+.# '+6 (% "*+ " @ %% *#" %%

'+.!

90A 99:

";0+, *:* ""*+ "@ %% 6+,

;0*'=&. .#< +, 9*#" *1&;9.'1& 1 6#*7 90 +, "

#+*#"&+.9.B*+.# 9*#" * ."

#+.*96 77 '.*9 *#" #"&+ .*9 *6 / '+ ( *<*",* .A =&* +, 9*#" 1 '71 .

" .# 5,* * %@CC

C7 *& .#<

=&* 0* ".+&*+ ":.+,.#+, #& +*+ ).99*< *<*",* .6 .+ .'+ *7&#**<* A,*9*1 ".#!.

: 1 !..# /

E .<,++*. 71 #*+.#*#" *#1* #'0 .# 4*#" '=&..+.# ,*;.9.+*+.# *#"

++9 #+ '+

, +6F+, GE

:.#<++, '#+ !

0 &1+ "* <* "+, .#+ +*+.# +, 1 !..# /

E 69.8 7*#0+, : .+ +.+.#6+, 1 '

".#<.#+, .#+*#+1 +.+.#:

8 1+.#*;

0*#'

*:*.+.#<+, "

'..# /&1 & +, '#+ !

0:* .#*990 1&+ *+ + ;0 +, #+.+&+.# #', /&1 & + .#

! #&9+.7*+ 1* *< *1, :,.',. 1 "&'

.#;

9:$ "# $ % & '

('( & ) % &

& % & % *+ %

%& % * & )- ) )) %% .& , & - % & + &,

& & '

('-(% & % * & % / % - * 0)"1 & '(- )

-"1 "1 0 % &2 &, & '(% & % * 3

&) & % %% &

& % & + % - 3&

- )+ & - 3+ &

- + % &

- + -

3 0 .

4 4 %

& '(% & % * & %&

& 0&2&%5 & '( & - ) & 6 % ,

-%& '

)( % %& % &2 & % & % /

- &

&&& ) % & % * & - , & * % &2 & %

/ -% %

+ & *% & &-, 75 %&

' & (

% &2

&, & % 5 ) &

6 % ,%% +&

& % * - 8 )8 % %& % &2

& % & % /

9 & - &

& * '

(% & %

/ + & &2

& '( 5 5 %&

& 0- , &

- , & * '

( ))% &&

) , %& % , &

+ & & &2 &,

& '(% & % * ! 0 & '(% & % * - % & '( % & '

('-( : 0 % 3, & % / &

& '( - ),%2 ; <&) - 3, & !% & % / +

& '(% & % *+&

- 3 & '( / 0 % & '( ,% % &,

&- & % & 3

% % -% & % *& %&+ &,%

&2 , ) &&

0 % - & %

-& -.& &

% %

& '(% & % * , ) & % & 2 , % && &, % &2 &

&, , %%& % & % *+ + 5- & &&

) ) 2 , % % 3, &,

% %&

% & &2 1

,*++, &7*#"&;+*#'

.#+ +*+.# /

E ;0+, /&1 & +.+,*++, . +*#" 7+ '#".+.# +

8 9*1.#< . +,*+ ;+, +, '#+.#< #'.

1 !."

" . *;&++, 1,0.'*91 .#*#"+, 1*07 #+ '71 #*+.#* +;

&9 .99 "67 *#.#<+,

;06.

.+, '#".+.#.#+*+.

"6+,

:&9";

#9*1.#< * *+, ;9.<*+.#+7*8 1*07 #+.#9.

9*#" *'=&.

" . '#'

# "6 .+ ,* ;

# '9* .

" +,*+ &', ;9.<*+.# + 1*0 . '719 + ;0 + #"

.#< +, '71 #*+.# :,.', :&9" 7 *# +,*+ +, '71 #*+.# *7&#+ :* 7*"

*!*.9*;9 + +, 9*#":# *#".

, ,*#+*''

1+ "+, *7 6.+:.99#+;

*!*.9*;9

+, 9*#" :# + '9*.7 +,*+ +, '71 #*+.# ,* #+ ;

# 1*." /.7.9* 906 +, : " H"

1.+I ,* ;

# .#+ + " + 7 *# "

1.+.#< :.+, +, 4 +, *& 0 +,

& + *:.#< 1*#',#*7* ,* ;

# '#."

" + ;

* !*9." 1 +*8.#< 1,0.'*9 1 .# *#" #'

9*#" +*#" !

+ " .# +, /+*+ 6 +,

. # ".!

+.#<1 !."

"&#"

E , /&1 & +,* & +, '9* .

"+,*++, 1 ." :,.',*#0.#+ .7 "

:* .# 1 *+.#6 :.99 ;

J'9&"

" :,.9 '71&+.#< +, <*1 1 ." .!

* /.7.9* 906.+,*;

#'9* .

"+,*+/

" #+<.!

+*# :'*& *'+.#+=& +.#+, 9 <*9.+0 '#'9&"

"1 '

".#< 9*#"*'=&..+.#*.+*119.

+#90+, '* :,

.#+, 1 '

".#<:

1 #".#<#+, "*+ # '

1 '* 1&+ +,;0+, 1 6+, 0* :# 9*#" 7 *& .#<

=&* 0* " '71 .

" .# 5,* * %@CC

C .+&*+ ".#*<*",* .6 .+ .'+ *7&#**<* , *."9*#":**'=&.

;0 +, !

#7 #+ * 0*#* ;0 .&.#< #+.

.'*+.# "*+ @ %% *#" %%&#"

/ >? '=&..+.#'+6 (% 99:

";0*:* ""*+ "@ %% +, 1&;9.'1& 1 #*7 906

#+*#"&+.9.B*+.# 9*#"* ."

#+.*9677 '.*9*#" #"&+ .*9 *6/ '+ (*<*",* .+.+, '* 1 +,*+ "

1.+ ,*!.#<*##&#'

"+, *:* "#@ %% 6+, 1#"

#+,*!

*.9 "++*8 1 .# 9*#".#=& +.#& +, 6+, 0,*!

@ '#+ #"

"+,*++.99"*+ # .+, '71 #*+.# *'=&.

"9*#",* ;

#1*."++, 1 # ,*;

1.+ ":.+,+,

& +.#*'' "*#'

:.+,9*:,

6+, *'=&..+.#1 '

".#<=&* +, 9*#".#=& +.#+*#"9*1 ".#!.

: /

, 1 ,*!

*9 *.

"*!*<& 19 * ".' .7.#*+.#;0 19*'.#< 9.*#'

## "

* 1* 7 9*#".+&*+ ".#

.+ .'+* ."*;*" @ '#+ * 2 #8& 2.++*96 9 * # " '&# 9 *11 * .#< +,

1#"

#+ /+*+ 6 &;7.++ " +,*+ +, .#+*#+ 1 +.+.# "

+ ;

".7.

".#!.

: 9*:9*."":#;0+, /&1 & +.#+, '* #"

#+ &+, .+0 D&1 *E * ## '#+.#< #'.

' .;

".#/

E * &9 .99 ", . +*#"

7+ =&.

#+ + '9*.7 9*1.#< *'=&..+.# 1 '

".#< . + 1 !

+,*++, 9*#":# ..#1 .# 9*#".#=& +.#6:,.', .# +, '* *+ ,*#" :* +*8 # ;0 +, /+*+ !."

*1*+ B#*7',* ("*+ "@ %% 6*#"*7 ,*;

#, 9"+;

*!*9."7"

+*8.#<1 .#& +, 7&+*+.#% "*+ "

,**9 ;

# *#'+.# " .# *!& ;

.'.* 0 "

1* +7 #+ #'

&', 1 .#.+*8 #6+, 9*#"!

+*;9&+ 90.#+, /+*+ *#":,

+*.# 7*.# .# +, 1 .# 9*#"6, . * + 1*

& +, &;7.++,*++, ;9.<*+.# /+*+ +1*0+, '71 #*+.# +*#""&90".',* < "*+, #+.

'71 #*+.#*7&#+:*+ #"

*+ +, +.7 *##&#'

#+ *:* " *#" :* 7*"

*!*.9*;9 + +, 9*#":# &;7.+ +,*+ &+ ++*9 *7&#+ '71 #*+.# . 6 %6 6%C6*#*7&#+ 6 6 C,*;

#".;& "+ +, 9*#":# *#" + *7&#+.*!*.9*;9 ".;& #+

<* "+, 19 * ".' .7.#*+.#,*!.#<;

# *.

";0+, 1 6

? 2 2.++*9 &;7.+ +,*+ +, 1 * # .+, .7.9* 90 .+&*+ " + &', 1 #6 :, 9*#" ,* ;

# * 7 +, *'=&..+.# 1 '

".#<# +, 1 ,*!

19 *"

#*.#<9 : ",:.#< *+,:+, 0* .7.9* 90.+&*+ "++, 1 #:, 9*#",*;

* 7 +, *'=&..+.# 1 '

".#< *#" * &', +, 19 * ;

.#< *.

".!*<& #!.

: 9*:9*."":#;0+, /&1 & +.#+, '* #"

#+ &+, .+0 D&1 *E , ,* 1 *0 ".7.*9 .#+*#+: .+1 +.+.# ? *!.#< , * " +, '+.!

* <&7 #+6 <.#< +, &<, +,

'+.!

19 *".#<*#"*;!

*99+, J1.+.# #"

#+ &+, .+0 D&1 *E6 :

* '#."

" 1.#.# +,*+ +, .#+*#+ +.+.#.9.*;9 +;

".7.

7 +,*## *# , 1 .# +, .#+*#+ 1 +.+.# ,*!

'9*.7 " + ;

.# +, 1,0.'*91 .# 9*#".#=& +.#.+.!

'* +&1;0+, .+,*+ #+,&<,+, *:* ":*1* "#@ %% *#" +, 0 "." #+ 7*8 ',*99 #< + +, *'=&..+.# 1 '

".#< ;&+ +, 1,0.'*9 1 .# ,* #+ ;

# +*8 # 7 +, 7 # +,. <* "6 +,

1#"

#+,*!

.9 "+, : .++ #+*+ #+&;7.++.#<+,*+1 .# :* +*8 # ;0 " *:.#< 1*#',#*7* .# +, 7 *1*+ B#*7',* ("*+ "@ %% :,.',,*;

#, 9"**!*9."7"

+*8.#< 1 .# 9*#"/ '+.#? (% 1 !."

+,*+* + +*8.#< +, 1 .# 9*#"6 .+ !

+ .# +, /+*+ 6

7 *99

#'&7; *#'

,&6:

* '#."

"1.#.#+,*++, 1,0.'*9 1 .# 9*#".#=& +.#+*#""&90+*8 #*#"9*#".!

+ ".#

+, /+*+ ,

.# +,. <* " . 7*"

+ +, 99:.#< 1* *< *1, 7+, K&"<7 #+$

! "

#$ % & !

( "

) !

$% * +) ,

( "- "

" ! "

$% ."

)

/ ."

! )

" &

)

) )

" 0&."

! !

( "

%%& +) )&

& % / + - 3,

& % 03,

& % * )

3, & % =

> &2 )

% 3, + 3,

& % < ,&3%

))&&2+ >

&%& &

- % %)& -&2 &

& )

" ") )

( ! ,&6+, 19 *;

.#< *.

";0+, 1 ;

.#<.#1,0.'*9 1 .# 9*#".#=& +.#.:,9907.'#'

"*#".9.*;9 +;

K '+ "

" " # $ # % , 1#"

#+ ,*!

'*+ < .'*990 19 *"

" .# +, : .++ # +*+ #++,*++, *7&#+ '71 #*+.# +, #+.

*'=&.

"9*#" :*7*"

*!*.9*;9 +*99+, 9*#":# +.+, +*#" /+*+ +,*+ &+ ++*9*7&#+ '71 #*+.#. 6 %6 6%C6*#*7&#+ 6 6 C,*;

#".;& "++, 9*#":# *#" + *7&#+.*!*.9*;9 ".;& #+,.,:+,*++, '71 #*+.# *7&#+ :* "&90 + #"

"6 ,:

*7 :* #+ '

" ;0 +, # +,. <* "6 2 2.++*9 ,* * + " +,*+ .# !.

J1.+.#.##"

#+&+, .+0D&1 *E+, ;9.<*+.# /+*+ + 1*0 +, '71 #*+.# . ".',* < " .

*7&#+ '71 #*+.# . + #"

" :,.', ,* ;

# .#+ + " + 7 *# +,*+ +, *7&#+:*7*"

*!*.9*;9 ++, 9*#":# *;

".#* *

:,.',. 1 "&'

.#;

9:$ 2*+ & !

' (

+ $ %

3 3

" 4

?) +& % -

) ) -&,% - ,

3 & & - % %

3, - "

" )

+ ++$! "

5 "

)

" ) "

+ %

)

) " )

+) !

* * +

6 "

7 8 "

) 8 " ,

+ $%)

?) + & ) , + -

& *+

& 6 "

7 8 " )

+ 9 !) ."

1 5 , * +*+ *'+ '9 * 90 *9 +,*+ +, ;

!*+.# 7*"

.#*;!

" #+ 9 *!

*#0 '1 "&;+ +,*+ +, /+*+ ,* ".',* < ".+;9.<*+.#+:* "7*8.#<+, '71 #*+.# +, 9*#" *'=&.

" ,

6 +, '#+ #+.# 1 +,*+ # '71 #*+.# *7&#+ ,* ;

# 1*." . 7 .+9 *#" +,&6 . ,

K '+ " ##% &'(&) &*+,# , /&1 & +.##"

#+&+, .+0D&1 *E,* '9 * 90 ;

" +,*+ "

" 9*1.#< *'=&..+.# 1 '

".#< &#"

E 6;+,+, '#".+.#. 1*07 #+ '71 #*+.# *#" +*8.#< 1 .# 7&+ #+ ;

&9 .99 " . .

.+, '#".+.# . &9 .99 "6 +, 9*1.#< '*##+ ,*11 # , /&1 & +,*;

"+,*++, : "H I''& .#<.#/

E 7&+;

*"*H*#"C# I !*#+1* * 7+, K&"<7 #+* 1 "&'

.#;

9:$ 2- 8 " 5

$%) !

&")

)

* +

" & ) "

( ") '

( " '

( ' ( ,,,, ,,,, ,,,, ,,,,

* - :; 7 & <

- =##) 8

> "

) ,

(

" " " - !

@ '$ +%- !

)

" - ")3 3 3 33 3 - =, 4

3 3 3

$ %!

) " ! ! 3 - ) 3& ,

(

) 6-&9673 ) !

" 3 )33 3

-) ) "

) ! !

)

! !

- " " ,

7 )*** $ %-) !)

)

3 3 ! "!

" "

& "

" - "

" " " " !

" ,7 )***5 $ 0% & ."

@ - "

A - " & "

( $ " % 0+ % % &2 &, )+ & '(%- - 3+ + & 3+ &

+ &2 &,

#1 #+, '* *+,*#"*

'+ 7+, 190 .9 "6.+. !."

#+ +,*+ * + *:* " :* *##&#'

" # @ %% 6 +, 1,0.'*9

1 .# :* +*8 # ;0 ' ".#< *1*+ B#*7',* ( "*+ @ %% *#"+, '71 #*+.#*7&#+:*"&90+ #"

"/.#'

## '#".+.# 1 ' .;

" .# /

D E '+ *

&9 .99 "6+,

6*."1 !..#'*##+;

"&1#;0+, 1 +'9*.79*1.#< *'=&..+.#1 '

".#<

2 #8& 2.++*96 # +, + #<+, *'+ 19 *"

" .# +, : .++ #+*+ #+6,*!

, #+90'#+ #"

"+,*++, /+*+ *'=&.

"+, 9*#" +, 1&;9.'1& 1 . "

#+*#"&+.9.B*+.# 9*#"* ."

#+.*96 77 '.*9 *#" #"&+ .*9 *6 / '+ ( *<*",* . , 9*#".#=& +.#.!

07&',

#+.*9+*',.

1&;9.'1& 1 *.+ *

'++, "

#+ *"*#"19+*1 9*0&+19*# ,*!

'#."

"+,.1* + * <&7 #+ *.

";0+, 1#"

#+*#":

* .# '719 + *<

#+ :.+, +, *7 * +,. . *#.71 +*#+ *'+ +;

1+.#7.#":,.9 "

*9.#<:.+,+, '* * ..#<&+ *'=&..+.# 9*#"+*',.

1&;9.'1& 1 *#".+.+, /+*+ C.+*&+, .+0:,. .#+, ;

+1.+.#+"

'."

*;&+&+.9.B*+.# 9*#"*'=&.

"6* + .+,*!.#<;

+ ".#/+*+ We have also considered the contention of the petitioners seeking parity with the release of land. The plea of the petitioners on the ground of discrimination is rejected same being vague and baseless. 13.

* =& 9 *;!

".'&.# *#" .# !.

: 9*: &77* .B " .# 1* * ?

#+ &+, .+0 D&1 *E6 '.

.'*990* + ,*!.#< ' "

"+,*+.#+, '* *+,*#"6+, 1,0.'*9 1 .# 9*#".#=& +.#,*!.#<;

#+*8 #6+, ;9.<*+.# 1*07 #+ '71 #*+.#+*#"".',* < "*#"*9'#."

.#<+,*++,

9*#".#=& +.#.!

07&',

#+.*9+*',.

1&;9.'1& 1 6:

,*!

# , .+*+.# + ,9" +,*+ .# +, .#+*#+ '* 6 +, /+*+ ,* &990 ".',* < ".+;9.<*+.#=&*;+,+, '#+.#< #'.

''& .#<.#/

E *#".+;

.#<6.#+*#+1 +.+.#.".7.

" *!.#< ".7.

" +, 7*.# : .+ 1 +.+.#6 1 #".#< *119.'*+.#6 .

*#06*97

++, *7 *+ /+*+&=&.

*#0+*#"!*'*+ " D)/5E / D44E

(

#"K , +, 1 *8.#<C *#

C , +, 1 +*;9