← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15881/2022dismissed

Sheela Bathla v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2025-09-05Mr. Justice Tribhuvan Dahiya6 pages

  

       Serial No.213 CWP-15881-2022 Decided on:-05.09.2025 Dr. Sheela Bathla

...Petitioner

Versus

State of Haryana and others

...Respondents

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA

Present:

Mr. R. K. Malik, Senior Advocate with Mr. Anshul Labana, Advocate for the petitioner.

Mr. Aakash Singla, Additional Advocate General, Haryana. Mr. Anil Kumar Sharma, Advocate for respondents no.3 and 4.

TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA, J.(ORAL)  

       

           !  "    

" " 

#"  ! 

$ %   %        &'()*( +  , ) - . /        ,  # "$  &"$ 0  1, &23 4   



 

 "         "     " $ 

     

 #$     

 

 )"   &

        , 5     

!6 !

+# $  $$$7#

 $     %%  % & .  #"   %    $  , 

   

"

 "

     " 

    !    $  +# $ 8 

" $9 % , "

$

  

  

! 

     %%)   $  #        %9%    "      , "$     "$

$% %   , & 

." !:" #$                  

  

! 

", " "  "  , &

    %;%%

  "

 

$     2  "#

$,."        )     "  "           

."       

          

!+# $  $$$  "    $  $  %%  "

,

  

!  !     ! 

    ""   " $     

 

!  ! $  $     $  #   "            , &     "     " 

   "    .$    9<=   ! , ,> %;;; #   

       &  "     "          ! ,

  

"   # $  

  

!

" $    ? # ! +  ,$$

  0  1?+,23      , &

 !& +# $ #     %;%%

    %<%   #      #      !     " 

"         "

      $  9 )   "             +#  @! ,  "  "#!"    !   $      

"     & $

 $ !  "     "  ; ?  !   $%  %    ,    

       $  +# $   $   "#    "

  ! "   

)"

 $  6  $   !

"  

  5 

6 !

+# $  $$$7  !

  $   @     "    $         " 

! 

 # #"      !"  !"$   "  !  : $  

   #"   

   $  ;%  "A



 +# $ " A+# $  "  #  ?+,     !+# $  %;%%"    

"B %< ,   

 &#"  :" ("$ 

$  , & %<% #  #"     





"  

 

 #    

? # !





"  "A

  , '

  )

      "  "A

  C D  "

  ,&8(8, (:(:C?+,8,&&(8,6(8,-(:@ "   ! & A,   +# $   "  ""$  $  , &

  "





"  





  !  $ "       "

   888

'88# B 

  

                        " !  ?+,





"  



"

$ 

     A

    #          #    

    



0)"3

"  

0( 3 

 "

  !      

   $   "   

$ , &   $   #  

 $



A)" 8     "



  "

   "$  "

   

  $ !"    )" !

  

    "" !  " "

  $ ." "

 =  .$     "

      # "   2 "





     "          

#"   , &  )" A     

 ,!    

 #

!-

$ +# $ !  "#

  "  $%=% 99 

" 

      !  # #"      # ,

   "    , &  $ 

#"

 "  $  

 !?+,    !& +# $ # %=%  "   

  "$    )"   

!8  ""$ ,"     

    

! " #

#     



 $

 % % &  '    (  ' 

       

  )   

78  ""$ 

      

$   

%  *   

   

%    %  +    '

$

, =%      "

     2  $   !$ 

! " "    !

  $ "  !$  

   E !



"   !$ 

!   , 

  #$  #" "   "

   "         "

E      2  $  

        $  #"

    ! $      

    " 

!    $ !"   "  

$    , &$     <   

"    $       # $ 

$   , &

 $     #" 8 

  !

 $    %%     " $    $        %9%  6#

      $! "

 "   $ A$    $  % 8 #  "

   $   

 $

 0  



     *$ -$'(  . /(0

- . /(0