Asha Malhotra v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

   

       

!"#$#%&'&() 
 '*!!+*",!

#"&"&(#, '

-#,'.'

/"!"#!,0!(!!($"*#,'

#'1($#(" '

)  23  / 4 3/  ,#'#(")5 ,!6#'*.(67$8%!"#7,"*#1#"&"&(#, ,!8##(/*#,!(7#1."0$8%!"# #(#,!+7!,0!(!  *#"*#,"*##1,"#,'+%!+(#9'1!1#,:!0;#!++9#$" '##"*#6.$<:#("=#'
 ;#,##,,#$""*##1,"#,,("#'

 *#"*#,"*#6.$<:#("'*.+$;#,#1,"#$&("*#$&<#'"=#' 55 55 3/ 

3 *#  1#"&"&(#,  9!'   !11&("#$  !'  !    "#!%*#,   ( >>??9&"*,#'1($#("@5,0! &"07 9*&%*9!'!,&8!"#+0!(!<#$ 8#,(:#("&$#$/%*+7<#""&(<>@A <,!("5&(5!&$,:"*# 8#,(:#("*#1#"&"&(#,,#"&,#$,:'#,8&%#(



(!""!&(&(<"*#!<#'.1#,!((.!"&( "  %:#'  ."  "*!"  (  @>>>7  "*#  !,0!(!  8#,(:#("

,!:#$"*#!,0!(!&$#$/%*+' #('&(!($ (",&;.",0,8&$#("

.($ .+#'7>>>*#1#"&"&(#,*!$#!,+&#,&+#$ 5>B5
B7"&"+#$ !''*!!+*",!-#,'.'/"!"#!,0!(!!($"*#,'!($"*#'!:#9!' $&'1'#$;0!&8&'&(#(%*"*&' .,"78&$#,$#,$!"#$
B

((#C.,#55 9&"*!$&,#%"&(",#'1($#("'"$#%&$#"*#+#<!+("&%#

5
5 $!"#$
?
B ((#C.,#55 7'#,8#$("*#:7;01!''&(<!'1#!D&(< ,$#,9&"*&("9:("*',:"*#$!"#,#%#&1"%#,"&&#$%10"*# ,$#,(1.,'.!(%#""*!",$#,7"*#&'",&%",&:!,0 $.%!"&( &%#,7 :;!+!7    ,#'1($#("  1!''#$  "*#  '1#!D&(<  ,$#,  $!"#$ 
?
B

((#C.,#55 78&$#9*&%* "*#%+!&:"*#1#"&"&(#,,,#+#!'# 1#('&(  !($  <,!".&"0  9!'  $#%+&(#$  (  "*#  <,.($  "*!"  "*#,#  9!'  ( !<,##:#(";#"9##("*#'!&$ &"0!($"*#

8#,(:#("!($"*!""*#1#('&(!($<,!".&"0%!'#*!'(";##('.;:&""#$ !+(<9&"*1"&(.($#,"!D&(<;0"*#1#"&"&(#,!',#E.&,#$.($#,.+#

 !($#:1+0#,2''*!,# 7!',#E.&,#$.($#,.+# B "*#!,0!(!

&$#$/%*+ /1#%&!+#('&(!($ (",&;.",0,8&$#(".($  .+#'7
 *#,#,#7"*#,#"&,!+;#(#&"'.($#,"*#1#('&('%*#:#
 %!(("   ;#   ,#+#!'#$   "  %:#'  ."  "*!"  8&$#  ,$#,  $!"#$ 
 


((#C.,#55B 7"*# 8#,(:#("*!'!+,#!$0,#+#!'#$"*# ""*# 1#"&"&(#,    ."    "*#  ""!+  !:.("    <,!".&"0   '  > 7 57  "*#

8#,(:#("'*!,#7!:.("&(<"' ?>7
@ 57*!';##(,#+#!'#$;0"*#

8#,(:#("79*#,#!'"*#'*!,#!(!<#:#("&''
7
@ 579*&%**!'

(";##(,#+#!'#$'!, "!+' %:#'.""*!"(!%%.(":&'5 :!(!<#:#("&(,#'1($#("@5,0! &,+'&<*/%*+7:;!+!

&"07"*#/.;&8&'&(!+ &%#,

&8&+ 7:;!+!7*!';##(!11&("#$!'!( $:&(&'",!",      "*#   '!&$   '%*+7   8&$#   ,$#,  $!"#$  


((#C.,#55
71!''#$;0"*# 8#,(:#("7,!1#,&$(#0#!,*!"

!,,!(<#:#("&''"!"#$";#'"&++%("&(.&(< *#'#%($%+!&:"*#1#"&"&(#,&'"*!"'*#6&(#$"*#'#,8&%# 9&"*,#'1($#("@(>>??!($,#"&,#$( 

(!""!&(&(< "*#!<#'.1#,!((.!"&(#,E.!+&0&(<'#,8&%#*!';##(E.!+&&#$!'


0#!,'!($
:("*';0%:1."&(<*#,E.!+&0&(<'#,8&%#,:>
9*#('*#'"!,"#$%(",&;."&(<"9!,$'  *#+#!,(#$%.('#+,"*#1#"&"&(#,'"!"#'"*!""*# 9!'

$#$.%"#$,:$!0(#;0,#'1($#("5!(!<#:#("7;."&(!(0%!'#7&( ,$#,"!8&$.,"*#,%:1+&%!"&('7*#&',#!$0"$#1'&"*#,'*!,#  ,:>>??"&++ >>
!+(<9&"*&("#,#'"!($"*!"*#,E.!+&0&(< '#,8&%#:!0;#%:1."#$,:"*#$!"#'*#6&(#$"*#&(&"&!+'#,8&%#9&"* ,#'1($#("@5/%*+&#>>?? ("*#,#1+07"*# 8#,(:#("*!''"!"#$"*!""*#1#('&(*!'

;##('!(%"&(#$78&$#,$#,$!"#$
 
 ((#C.,#55B "&'.,"*#, '"!"#$"*!""*#:!(!<#:#(",#'1($#("@/%*+1!''#$!,#'+."&( (
?
 ((#C.,#55 7,#<!,$&(<&:1+#:#("!"&("*#1#('&( '%*#:#,##,#(%#9!'!+':!$#""*#1!0:#("<,!"&"078&$#,$#, $!"#$
 
 ((#C.,#55B "&'.,"*#,'"!"#$"*!""*#$:&(&'",!", *!';##( !11&("#$!($"*!""*#:!(!<#:#("'*!,#&'";#1!&$;0"*# :!(!<&(<%::&""##9*#(#8#,"*#:!(!<&(<%::&""##&',#5%('"&"."#$ .,"*#,'"!($"!D#(&'"*!""*#E.!+&0&(<'#,8&%#*!';##(%:1."#$,: "*#$!"#%(",&;."&("9!,$'  *!8#*#!,$"*#+#!,(#$%.('#+',"*#1!,"&#'!($*!8#!+' %!,#.++0<(#"*,.<*"*#&+# /  !,  !'  "*#    %(",&;."&(  '*!,#    :!(!<#:#("  &' %(%#,(#$7&"&'("!$#(0&(<!%""*!""*#:!(!

<#:#("*!''&(%#;##("!D#( 8#,;0!($:&(&'",!",7!11&("#$;0"*# 8#,(:#(" *#,#,#7"*# '!&$'%*+&'(9.($#,"*#%(",+"*#'!&$$:&(&'",!",*#%(",+ .($'"*#:!(!<#:#("!+'+&#'9&"*"*#$:&(&'",!","*#'!&$ '%*+*#,#,#7(97"*#$:&(&'",!",&'+&!;+#"1!

5B5 %(",&;."&('*!,#"*#:!(!<#:#(",:"*#.($'"*#'!&$'%*+ %%,$&(<+07  "*#  /.;  &8&'&(  &%#, 

&8&+ 7  :;!+!7  9*  &'  "*# $:&(&'",!",,0! &"07&',$#,#$" 1!0"*# %(",&;."&('*!,#"*#:!(!<#:#("7!'&($&%!"#$!;8#7 !+(<9&"*&("#,#'"!""*#,!"#>A1#,!((.:,:"*#$!"#<,!(" '!(%"&(;0"*# 8#,(:#(" /!,!'"*#'#%($1!,""*#,#+&#&'%(%#,(#$7"*#+#!,(#$ %.('#+,"*#1#"&"&(#,*!'.($#,"!D#("$#1'&"*#,%(",&;."&(  !+(<9&"*&("#,#'",:>>??"&++ >>
 *#+#!,(#$%.('#+,"*#1#"&"&(#,*!'1+!%#$,#+&!(%#.1( "*#!."*,&"&#'"*&' .,"&(/&"!#8&9 !(*!,3!+-#,'.'/"!"# .(6!;!($"*#,'7
?  / ?>F /!"&'*!(&/$-#,'.'/"!"# .(6!;!($"*#,'7


/ B!($!*!8&,!$!8-#,'.'/"!"# !,0!(!!($"*#,'7
@ B / 

B79*#,#&("*#'!&$%!'#'7"*&' .,"

!++9#$"*#$#1'&" !+(<9&"*&("#,#'"!($!++9#$"*#'!&$1#,&$" ;#%:1."#$"9!,$'E.!+&0&(<'#,8&%#,1#('&( ";#&(<'7"*#1,#'#("9,&"1#"&"&(&'!++9#$#'1($#("' !,#$&,#%"#$"%::.(&%!"#"*#1#"&"&(#,!;.""*#!:.("*#,'*!,#

  !+(<9&"*  &("#,#'"  9&"*&(  (#  :("*  ,: "*#  $!"#    ,#%#&1"   %#,"&&#$%10"*&',$#,!($"*#,#!"#,7"*#1#"&"&(#,9&++$#1'&"*#, '*!,#    7  ,:  >>??  "  >>
 !+(<9&"*  &("#,#'"7  !'

$#"#,:&(#$;0"*# 8#,(:#("79&"*&("9:("*',:"*#$!"#,#%#&1" '!&$%::.(&%!"&(,:,#'1($#("' *#,#!"#,7"*#'#,8&%#"*# 1#"&"&(#,'*!++!+';#%:1."#$"9!,$'1#('&(!($"*#1#('&("*# 1#"&"&(#,'*!++!+';#!%%,$&(<+0,#5&C#$!($"*#,#8&'#$ 9&++;#

5@5 &''.#$!($"*#!,,#!,'1#('&(9&++!+';#1!&$"*#,

3/   

 
 '6D' *#"*#,'1#!D&(< ,#!'(#$ ) #' *#"*#,#1,"!;+# ) #'