High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17510/2019dismissed

Amanpreet Singh v. Government Medical College And Hospital Sector 32 Chandigarh And ORS

2019-07-15Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary,Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal7 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()**

!"# $% & '( (( )*

(+ '

, + &

& * "*& ) +,

-* - +,

* -- , * - . $/(+&%' +

00000 - ,.* 1

*2* 3

. &.* &

4& '.* ***

5 .5/

$% & '( (( )*

(+ '

, + &

+ * %' & 5/ 4 2 5

&/ & (( '*6.

* (& *+

'( * 77 '.* $% & '( (( +

(+ /

7 &* .* & 48'.*+ 2 ((9& 1* 23*!!1$+

&6.(

*)*'.&((9&

) *.5

* ( '

& 48'.* $% & '((( )*

(+'

, &

& *&

6. * *3*:

'& *

(&;< ,:;

(&*=-/0!1"!2($" /!0'3'*

(&"( !00& "01 "# /($&40/ ($ (" /!0++ '((

% '& *3%* .& #1&

+ &

%/*3* *%* && #1&

%/* (* *.5 ( '

&(* *3(& %5( / &

%/* &

1 '(( *.''&& & (.**

.* 3 * .'2 &3 % & >.& & ,:

1 >.& 3* '(( & 5/

( ? % (; @;

(& * 5(6&!/23'*-/0!1"!2($" /!0'+&% &&& &

4 % 7'>.&

*. 3** /&

(( A 3 (+

* '.*( 2(' :

+5.

& & * & ' ' 4 & ) 3*

& & *'

( * * +"& / '+5.

.*& *''. &'/ (

+ *'&'.*( 3*&(/&&3*(&

+5.

'.(& ' ' 4& %/A &/ <

+. .& 3* (&+ 5.

3* .*.''** .( 3 (+ *.( & * * ;

&. '.** $9!"+ &

3*&'(& <

&*('

&'& (/ 4 & *.''&&

* * &

) %' * 4 & *.(

* ( ( '

* 5 %

& % &

'* &

& ,

.*( 3*(&,

( * &3**3

:1* 3%+3 4 *

, $ +33*

+% .

+3* ( ' 48'.** $% & '((( )*

(+'

, +&

)3*

%& 5* * ((9&

% .

+ * *'

.*+

(( . (

% * *+ '3* 5

% '& *5(

( )3%+

& & '(( *('

* &4 * $ 1

+425

&/&

'.* 4& +%' ** &*

* 7 (1 3 **

( & '.*( (&,

+3 * * %' & 5/ 4 2 5

&/+ * / & (&/ *'.& & & *'

( * $/ & & '*

*& .*+

3* (/'& (

+33* (

5(&6.(

& %' * * , *+ . * '** '.*( 3*&(/& ''. (

*. & ' )B5(.. 9& )& '.*( 5'&.'

&* *'&.(+ * %' &5/425

&/3.(& %5% (5(5 ,

3.(&% & *

%''/ *+

*.5

& *

4 $% & '( (( )*

(+ '

, + &

+ 5.

* 5

2 .1* 3* & .*+&

% &

: : ?& '.*(

*.5

* ((/

. &'& (/ & &.3*& && 5/ (& (7'

*. % &>.& &@

@**&

;@@,;

(&*5-&$/0 / "/&($073'*/!&0!% "0

0&(%&82."6!0(9!( !$&%2"22!4!($"'8& 2./($&40/*+ ?

*(3*

(&5/ &'& &&

% (& 3*

%5/4 % 7'

*. & & & &

+ * & ? % C

(& * 5-&$/0 / "/&($07 3'* &0!% "0 0&(%&82. "6!0(9!( !$&%2 "22!4! ($ "'8& 2. /($&40/+ 3* & * **& * % 5 && .'

..* * 3 (+ '& & '( '.* 1.*+

&*%* 5 & * ( ( "( ' * (* 5 ('& >.& &

@+ **& 5&9(& -/09 3'* &0!% "0. "6!0(9!( !$&%2 "22!4! ($ "'8& 2. /($&40/ ($ " /!0'+ * 3(( * >.& &

<+ **& % ( ( :,,

(& * 50* 3&(1:3093'* !$&%2"7('!2&(4"99& !!($" /!0'*+

1*.5 *&5/(&'.*(

' 5'' &&

&(/+*% *&*'&.( '.*(

(* & 3*,

&'.*( *5(&

&& & *'5&'5& 5 &

(* & + *' 5& 5/ ''& .

*+ * **&?3

* & *3((*

(&95 !$&%2"7(%&2"#($& 3'* $/7-&(4/ -;+. .. &&

& '(.'

( 9& *. A 5& *

*'&.( 2 & * & * *.(& 5 * (/ && 9 5 0&$72 /0 9&("0 3'* (&"( "# ($& -<.+

>.& $/7-&(4/+'%'! '780 * 5 ((3& & &

* % 5

% (( * & # 1

* *.

*'&.(+% &&5/ .

2 & * .* 5 * (/ && 1 * '

( * 5

5 0&178 3'*- !"#// &'/40/($" /!0' -=>>*1( * >.&

* & *& @

+ **&

% ( :

(& * 5$7% &"(

0"9" &"( -"%&! 1 #"0 ($& ($ (" /!0 3'* (&"( "# ($& ($ " /!0'*+''& (/+* ' * 5 '( &5/

3* %' &

+ &

* ' 5 **.& $% & '( (( )*

(+ '

, + &

&* @ 1 4 % 7' & ?;

(& * 5-&$/0 / "/&($07 3'* &0!% "0 0&(%&82. "6!0(9!( !$&%2 "22!4! "'8& 2. -!% "0 >. /($&40/+. (* &* (

*(3*5( &&3% & &&9 '

* 5'(

&5/ )B5(D.& * &*(( 5 &* '& 1'* &9(&-/09 '780 *&

*5(*

&'*+

&( &5 '.

&3*

'& 33*

%& "( '5/ (&'.*(

0*3&(1:309+'%'! '780

* *'' %&9 &'*+* && * ;$&. !&.'

& " .(

<+ (( 9& E.

@ %'

/+3 5'% 6. * * 1

5 . . (/ 4 /2 + '& ''& )

. @

< &

&& &<

<+3***&+2 & %* (( 9& E. * *.5>'

' 3

& '& *&

* *3 &''& (/1

+ 4"F'& )

. &% &&& ,

<+ )

. &

(( . %' * .

((9& !!1

+% .

*% && * .

((&((9& E. 6. ''& (/+ . . (& % .

+ (* & & ,

<&5'**&+

'.(& 5& *.

* & 5 '

& 5/ )

. % & & & <

< ''& (/+ A'

( .( 3* & 2 % 3 '.( '

*&'

'.* '* &'*1 . (&'.*(

*5 >.& '&''. &(/ & '**(*' 5 '' &. *& **&* 5* * *.*

*1 '

%''/*.

*(/

(* 2 & *&

*(/

*& *52

& .**

*'*9&5(** 3 3.(& % & '* '** & & 5 &(/&+ ' 5 2 '* &

((/+

' & %/5

4 *$ 3*3 (/

%& & *&

3* ' / .(* ( & &3 *'

.* 1 &

4 *$ +* 5'(( &

'((

+ 2 . * (& '.*(

+.*.* 5( < G

&**+ 3

& *& * **&+ ( - , ** "& *2 8*& H*8 " 5( H*8