High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23737/2011allowed

Deepak Kumar v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2017-09-13Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari31 pages

!"# $ %& !

'( ("# )

*# +,* ---,

!"#

$ !! % &'

!"# % (

" )"* !"# % +,

!"# % - &.

//// --, . 0

1 #

% ( 2 3 # # 4

.2 .5 '.&.)!6 7+* !

1 ,2. "## 8# 8 "

" "

% &( .- '..-)!6 7&* !

# % '7 # 9 # 1 1 # 1 '

0 : # 9 " "

" 9 1 % &, !

8 "

8 ; # 8 # 3 8#

13 3

3 "8 8# 8 %" 3 '..5 ##

# 1 #"&.

<0< 81 # 3 31 # (

= 3 #

.2 .5 '.&.)!6

7+* # 8 # # # +> ,> # 8 1 1 +5 ., 0 ""7"# 8 6 ', 8 # # ; # 8 6 ,. ## 1

1 < !# '..,) #

:0< '..,*8 8 1 +.

.+- 1

% .',('

# 3 9 # .( .5 '.&& )!6 7>* 8 3

" # 3"7

# # ## 1 1

# #

!## 1 # #

)!6 7&.* 38 - "8 ',# +.

.+ 1 # # ## 31" 8 ', 33 #

81 8 1 1 ## #8 # # # 8 1" 8 "8 # # ## 1 # # #

)!6 7&.* 1 # # 3 88 1'.(. # #8 1 11

&2 '' 8 8 1 1 # #31

"8 ? #

0 # # # 1 3 " 1 # "8# "8

# # 7 3 # 8

38 # # # # 3 6 3 9 8#" # # 3#

1 # 13 1 6 # #

% ( 8

# # 3; " 8

"8 3#1

## ; # " 1 # #

1 "3

11 8 17

8 3 3 8

% +, # "1

# # # # #

8 # 3; 1

08 1 ( 1 # 3

# 3 #

< "8 '> .( '.&2 1 1 " 3 !

# " &'

., '.&28 2."##8

1 " 9# 1

., '.&2 #

< 8

# 3## 1 "# 3# 8 # # 8 1

0 # 3 # 3 # 1 8 "8 &2 .& '.&- 0#

79 # .- .( '.&-

# 3 "8 '- .- &>>' .& &>>+ 0 # ; % + ; # 6 #8#3 # % &. && &' !6 7&. 8 # 3 #" .- .( '.&- ='5 .+ '.&- 8 #3 9 #

% (+ 3 '5 '5 '- '>

# " 3 1 '' # "8 # 8 1 ', 8

81 )*8 13@# )*9 #

)* 8 1 )"* !8 )"*<

< 8 ## 1 8 8 3 8 1 " 7

% (+8 3 3 9

## 8 3 0 " 1 7 % - &. 31 %1 8 9 8 ## #

'5 .+ '.&-# 3

=.& .2 '.&- # 3

# 3## " 3"

3 #

1 # " 3"

0 1 " 7

# 8 1 # 3 8

% (8

# 8 # 8 1 '. "8# #

" 3 ## " 7 " 3 0 8 +'# " 3" " 1

9 "

8 8 '.&& # 8 # ##

3# # # # 3

9 1

81 1 1 "# 1 !1 '.&. #

8 # 1 ; 318 # "

9 0<!# '.., 1 # 9

# 3 .( .5 '.&&)!6 7>* 8 3# # &,

0 ;

# # "3 8 31" #1 8 1"8 #

8 3 1 # # 3 8" "8 # 2. "# " 3 " 1"8 3" 9

# "131 1 1 "#

1 '.&.

0 3 8 1 "8 8 3#

81#

8# 8 8 # # 3 3 3 3 # 3 < "89

%"!(!%&

* (& '%!

/('

/%0 12& 34 "& ( /%0 12&34 &%6 /%0

7&%("

66 % , &>& '5 >'

',- % + '&& '5 '5 ''

'5 &'& % '&+ '> ., '& ,.

., &(2> % ( ''.

'- ,> ''

+> ,> &->&

7777 +.

.+ .- +- .+ ',('

&2 ! # # # "8 3 ### # 3 3 9

# 8 " 8 8 1"- ', "88 3 !# #

1 3#; # ; # 88

# " 7 8#8 3#

3 #3" 0 "8# #3"8 ', 31 8 1 3@# # #

1 8 1 1 8

1# # # # # "3

3 9 8 # ; 3#; # # A'8#8 #.

# 1 8#" 1 33

' <0< #

# # # #4 # # " 8 #.

.+ # 1

8 3# # +.

8# # 8 8 # 9

0 # " 8 8 ', 8 "8 #

0 # #8 1 ## ,>. !

8 # 18 8 1 # "

&( .5 '.&. 3 "8 %" 3 '..5 0# # 8 1

8 3# 8 #

# 11 #

%1 B # 7

5# 8 8

11 # @ %1 B

% > 3 11 "# 1 4C9 494=

# 9

18 # 1 1 # 3 8 3 9 1 ## 8# (, 1 # #; # 8# ? 1

8 1 "8

0 8 31 # 8 3#

3 3 8 @ # 81 (, # #"3 1" &, "8 #

% D :% 0 4,.

# 3 ; #7

"4 ',

0 4-, %89%6 -:

-("8:

;

....5 1 1 '+ ++ '+ ( ...'. <8 81 ''

&& ''

+ ...'(

% '- - ++ '- , ...'+

81 +5 +5 ...+, 13 ,+ ,+ - ...,& " @ &2 ++ &2 ...,'

31 -2 ++ -2 ...,( "

+& +& ...2'

$8 1 &+ &+ && ...2, @

B .& ++ .& &'

...22 $" @

(> &, - &, &( ...-.

++ ++ &+ ...52 E

-& ++ -& &, ...>' !@

8 +( - ++ +( &2 ...>,

1 ..

+- ..

&- ..&.& !

'- '-

&5 ..&.' 31 ('

+( ('

&> ..&&.

..&&& @ 9 ..

+( ..

'& ..&&+ $ 1 = 2& && +5 2& ''

..&&5 !@ >5 +( >5 '( ..&'+ !

+& +& '+ ..&(' 8 1 5& 5& 3 < :%/7( -2=(& ;

3<;

'2 ..&+( 8 @

., ++ ., '- ..&++ !

+- && +- +- '5 ..&+,

E1@ ,> ++ ,> '> ..&+5

'5 '5 (.

..&,2

< .- +- .- (& ..&2& = .> ++ .> ('

..&22 1 < @1 +.

(( ..&25 $

1 %9 ', ', (+ ..&-(

8 1 +5 5 ++ +5 ..&5(

"1 ''

;

) -2"(6>2/% >( :%"-("8:

$ 3

..&>+

% .( .( $ ); %

:>2/% / %0% :

;

3 (> ..&>>

,- && ,- +.

..'.. @

,- ,- +& ..'.& " "

&2 +- &2 < %=

:>2/% ::%=2 %/ 3)

$ 3) +( ..''2 !@ (+ (+ ++ ..''-

9 >.

- >.

..'(&

..'((

0 ''

+- ..'(-

(> (.

&+ ,( (.

+5 ..'(5 $3 9 - ++ +> ..'2+ ! .+ +- .+ ,.

..'25 B31

9 >, +( >, ,& ..'-. 3 -( -( ,'

..'-& "1 81 ++ ,( ..'-( "

,& ,& 3< %/=(& "!

-("8:

3<< ,, ..'-5 B

5> - ++ 5>

,2 ..'5' = 8

&& '.

,- .'5,

@ 1 >+ - >+ ,5 ..'>> !8

$8 ', ++ ', ,> ..(.5 B

>( +( >( 2.

..(&. %"

2& ..(&' 9 '5 '5 2'

..(&, 9

2( ..(&- "

.2 .2 2+ ..('2 %31 9

.> +- .> 2, ..(+, 9

- +- 5'

..(,> 901 .> +- .> 2- ..(2, $

'+ - +- '+ ;$ ; %5%">2/%

:%"!

3$<

) 3<$< 2> ..(-. @

< % ("!

>2/% -%!:2 %/ <;

$ 3$; -& ..(-> 3 &( - +'

&( )

%6>( :%"

;

)3 %5%">2/% 5%6>( :%"

;)) 3;)) -+ ..+&> 0@"

1 2.

-, ..+'& $

F 1 ++ ++ ++ -2 ..+'(

5- - ++ 5- -- ..+', @

-5 ..+(' " = -.

++ -.

) <3 :%85%"

%/>2/% 3 3 5.

..+(2

5& ..+++

1 2( 2( 5'

..++- 8

F 1 '+ && '+ 5( ..+,& %

9 '> +( '> 5+ ..+,'

9 8 1 (.

++ (.

$3 <3; -%&( :>2/% *%:% ( 3;

$ 3; ..+,- $% ., +- ., 5- ..+2.

! % &5 +- &5 ..+2'

5> ..+2+ !

&& && >.

..+2- @

"1 5.

>& ..+2>

1 +& +& ) <3 :%"!

0:% -:%/ -2"!

- &:(

$ 33 >( ..+5. # 5, 5,

>+ ..+5& B % +'

++ +'

)3 <$3 -%&( :>2/% 27%?,%6 ;

3 );

<$) -:%"& :%:

-%&7(-("8:

33<

>- ..+>.

" 2, 2, >5 ..+>2 "@ B .& .& )) <) :0>2/% :%6 %/ 3$

;

3 -"2 %(9%6-("8:

$ 3$ &.& ..,., G? <8 (+ +> ++ +> &.'

..,&'

1 2.

++ 2.

3 < 9%6>( :%"

/(:%"!

;

< 3 3 -20:

*:("!

-("8:

$ 33<

&., ..,&-

9 '.

+( '.

&.2 ..,&5 @

,, +( ,, &.- ..,'( 3

+( +'

&.5 ..,',

,> ,> &.> ..,'2 !

3 '> && '> &&.

..,(> $

++ &&& ..,+5 @

1 -& &'

+5 -& &&'

..,,+ "

9 &&( ..,,,

&2 &2

&&+ ..,,- 1 5.

&& 5.

&&, ..,,5

= (.

++ (.

&&2 ..,-'

181 1 >.

3$ :5%"(>2/%

%/ %&%9 3)

$ 3) &&5 ..,5(

1 (> ., - .,

) 3) %0% :

-2/ -("8:

$ 3<<

&'.

..,>' !@

'5 - ++ '5 &'& ..,>- 8

- ++ ,.

&''

..2.- @ 39 >+ >+ &'( ..2.5 8

" &'+ ..2&& @"

1 "

>& - ++ >& &', ..2&( @

3 >'

&'2 ..2'' @

% ''

&& ''

&'- ..2+5

8 55- &'5 ..2,'

9 1 2+ 2+ &'> ..2,5 @"

1 (> (.

+- (.

&(.

..22'

;$$ %5%">2/% -%&7(-("8:

$ 3; &('

..2>. 311

(> +5 - +5

&(( ..2>&

81 2( ++ 2(

< ;)$ %7(-("8:

> %/ $3

333 &(, ..2>> ! 10

', ', &(2 ..-&( 9 +& +& &(- ..-&, !

% 5.

- 5.

&(5 ..-&5 1@

2( ++ 2( &(> ..-', 9

-- -- &+.

..-'5 @

++ ++

< (& "!

-("8:

) 3<$ &+'

..-+& " ,- ,- &+( ..-,, %31 (> ++ (> &++ ..-,2

9 '- '- &+, ..-,5

% 5'

++ 5'

; *20

:2&& -27% ::%"!

2&& ; )

$ 3< ) &+- ..-2& >( ++ >( &+5 ..--, "

9 +( +( &+> ..--2 @

- +( >.

&,.

..--- @ = -2 - +( -2 &,& ..--5

&,'

..-5& H 1 +'

&& +'

&,( ..-5- ! $@ 5.

&,+ ..5.( @

'+ '+ &,, ..5&,

>- >- &,2 ..5&2 E 3 (> - &,- ..5'2 = +.

&,5 ..5'5

2( +( 2( &,> ..5(> $ +.

(& - +- (& &2.

..5+, #

2, +( 2, &2& ..5,'

B@ '.

; $3) %=

:>2/%

22 :&&%/ 3

3 &2( ..52- @

,2 ,2 &2+ ..5-+

&2, ..55. 0 ,.

&22 ..55( 8

,+ ,+ &2- ..55- " ?1 >> >> &25 ..5>' ! !

.2 .2 &2> ..5>2 $% 5, - 5, &-.

..>.'

# 3B

', ', &-& ..>.> !1

"1 &, &,

&-'

..>&& @

3 .5 ++ .5 &-( ..>&' 1 = 5.

&-+ ..>&( B6

(> '- - '- &-, ..>&, 3 +( +( +( &-2 ..>&- "

(( (( &-- ..>'. @

,- ,- &-5 ..>', @ -2 -2 &-> ..>(-

+( +( &5.

..>(>

9 '.

&5& ..>+5

$1 5.

++ 5.

&5'

..>,, 1

2> && 2> &5( ..>,> " 9 &+ &+ &5+ ..>2. F 3 5+ 5+

$3 );< :%%/ ( -("8:

%/:%"!

33 &52 ..>2>

++ ++ ++ &5- ..>5. %

(> 2- &, ,+ 2- &55 ..>5( %

>+ >+ &5> ..>55 @ >( && >( &>.

..>>. ! @

+> +>

&>& .&..( 31 @1 (> 5.

+- 5.

&>'

.&..- @ $

>> - >> &>( .&.&+ @3 B3 9 +( +( &>+ .&.'.

" !"

.& .& &>, .&.'( "

3 -, -, &>2 .&.('

'> +- '> &>- .&.(+ ! -.

&>5 .&.(, 1"

(> ,'

+- ,'

&>> .&.(>

$3 && '..

.&.+. !

'2 ++ '2 '.& .&.+'

1 5.

'.'

.&.+( % !3 '.( .&.,- @

$ .> ++ .> '.+ .&.,5 @

% 2( ++ 2( '., .&.2' "

31 2( 2( '.2 .&.-, !@

$13 5> 5> '.- .&.-5 8

1 >.

++ >.

'.5 .&.5( # % =@ =@ -.

'.> .&.>' %

" .> .> '&.

.&.>( !

% 9 +-

%5%">2/%

%/-("8:

3) '&'

.&&.> B 9 @B

&5 ++ &5

%0!(-("8:

%8%&-("8:

;

3 '&+ .&&'( 81 $1 5, 5, '&, .&&(. 0 @

@ 2- ++ 2- ;

%5%">2/% %(:%85%"

;

$ 3<

'&- .&&(( "

1 2- && 2- '&5 .&&(, 39

'&> .&&(2 1 @1 5+ ++ 5+ ''.

.&&(> % 1 ''

++ ''

<$ % ("!

>2/%

%6% %/ $$

33$ '''

.&&,- 81

3 +.

''( .&&5( !

-( - -( ''+ .&&52 8 ! >- >- '', .&&55 @

&, ++ &, ''2 .&&>. @

1@ 5+ ++ 5+ ''- .&&>'

>, >,

''5 .&&>2 3 1 &2 && &2 ''> .&'.(

'5 - '5 '(.

.&'&2 1

9 &2 &2 '(& .&'&- 8 ++ ++ '('

.&''.

< .& && .& '(( .&''' %3

+- ''

'(+ .&''> "

>, >, '(, .&'(( @"

,, ++ ,, ;

; *%"=>2/% @(:%"

3))

3)) '(- .&'(>

,& ,& '(5 .&'+( $3 3

-+ +( -+ '(> .&'+, @"

"1 ., +( ., '+.

.&'+2 # 1 1 &2 &2 '+& .&'+-

1 2, 2, '+'

.&'+>

1 .5 ++ .5 '+( .&',+

% '++ .&',5

+> +> '+, .&'2. !8

H 1 (> ,> - ,> '+2 .&'2+

= +( ++ +(

'+- .&'2> !

(& (& '+5 .&'-,

= &5 +- &5 <) (&%/>2/% %72,%6 3$

3$ ',.

.&'5. %

$3 (67%8 /%,%6 3 <

;

< ','

.&'5> % 9

+- && +- ',( .&'>'

1 1 2( 2( ',+ .&'>( "

-& -& 33 ; *%"= >2/%

%&:

%:"2

%&:

333 3;

%/%"!

9 %"!,%6 ;<

$ 3<<

3 ) ("

:>2/% &&%-("8:

$ 3<<

',5 .&(&.

(> +.

- +.

3) < -%"=%A>2/%

9:%"!

3$ '2.

.&(&, $3

1 +- +( +- '2& .&(&5 @1 1 (> +- '2'

.&((( G? (> &'

- &'

'2( .&((2 @ .- .- '2+ .&(+& = 2> - 2> ;3 <3 %/

:>2/%

%"7(-("8:

;) 3;)

'22 .&(+- 3

(> - '2- .&(,-

(> 2+ - 2+ '25 .&(2.

(+ (+ '2> .&(2& ! % (.

++ (.

;; -:%662

%/%

3$;

'-& .&(-& ..

%5%">2/% :%/7( $

33 '-( .&(-(

1 &( +- &( '-+ .&(5.

'-, .&(5'

9 &+ &+ '-2 .&+.>

<8 +.

., - +- ., '-- .&+&+ "

18 2, +( 2, '-5 .&+&- $1 +'

&& +- +'

'-> .&+'& 3 ,5 ++ ,5 '5.

.&+(. !

&( +- &( '5& .&+((

+- ++ +- '5'

.&++. @

22- '5( .&++& "

.5 .5 '5+ .&++5

1 &, ++ &, '5, .&+,-

-2("!

>2/%

%& :-("8:

;

3 '5- .&+2+ 18 $1 ,.

+( ,.

'55 .&+2- @

1 ,2 ,2 '5> .&+2>

81 .- .- '>.

.&+-2 $

1 &+ &+ '>& .&+5( 0 1 1 +- +- ) 3< @(= "!

%( %/ ;

;

3 '>( .&,., @

(> -5 +- -5 '>+ .&,.- &( &( '>, .&,&. %

1 '2 '2 '>2 .&,&+ 9 5, ++ 5, '>- .&,&- 0 +.

'>5 .&,'5 8

2, 2, '>> .&,(& @

$1 % >, >, (..

.&,+& 3 <8

>& >& (.& .&,+5

-> - +- -> (.'

.&,+>

1 22- (.( .&,,& "

1 (& ++ (& (.+ .&,,5 "0

++ (., .&,,> &( ++ &(

;

3;3 %67(-("8:

%/:%"!

3)< 33)< (.- .&,-+ 3 E && && (.5 .&,-2 " &> &> (.> .&,-> !

+( +( 3$ % "!

>2/% *%/%" %/ ;$3 3;$3 (&& .&,>( %"

&& +- (&'

.&,>- $ $% >5 ++ >5 ; -2

:>2/% @(=%A-("8:

) 3;$ (&+ .&2'2 ++ ++ (&, .&2'5 " 1 2'

(&2 .&2'>

,2 ,2 (&- .&2(( "8

39 5( 5( (&5 .&2(, % -2 -2 (&> .&2+, 1 &'

;33 % ("!

-("8:

:%"-("8:

;)

3) ('& .&22' $

91 @91 >, >, (''

.&2-. !8

&& ,.

; >%%/( :5%-("8:

;

('+ .&25+ @ 2- +( 2-

3 ;) %/(5%

%67(-("8:

;

3< ('2 .&2>+ !

@ &- &- ('- .&2>5 5> ++ 5> ('5 .&-.& @

1 &, &, ('> .&-.+

>> >> ((.

.&-., 9

$19

'2 '2 ((& .&-.2 @

-5 -5 (('

.&-&' @

"1 .> .> ((( .&-''

,, ,, ((+ .&-', % 1 ++ ++ ((, .&-'-

&- && &- ((2 .&-'> !

9 ,2 && ,2 <$

%=-("8:

% :9%6-("8:

3))

;

)) ((5 .&-,+

(> &- - &- ) ;3 8 "!

-("8:

-27 -("8:

;

; (+.

.&-2- @

31 ,5 && ,5 (+& .&--( 8 (+ >( ++ >( (+'

.&--+ %"

(& '+ &+ '+ (+( .&-5' !8

2, ++ 2, (++ .&-52 ,.

(+, .&->(

B ('

(+2 .&->5 1 $1 2, 2, &5 0 # 3 1 3" (+2# &->># 1 8 "8 9 1 8# (, 8 1 8 "3## 8 8 03 # 1 8#3 3# '>,# 8# (, "# &, ,& 3 # 8 8 &, 0 #

% &5.. +&-5 # 1 '(-5# 3 8 1 8

(2+# 8# (, "38 &, +(# 8 8 &, 3 31 # 3 " &>

<"8 3"# 3 ##3 8 8" # 8#8

3 # 9

8 8 3 # 1 "1 ? 8 #

8 3 3 ##3 #

# 8 G # 4 1 4!

6 < 8 # ##8 #

(2# 8#8 ( 3 &' 8#3"

0 ; # 3 # +2 && 8

? # 3 1 &( &+ 8# 8 ; 8 # 7 8 8 8

# # 3 #

% +,8 # 81"

33 "1 I&, < #

# "88# < # " 83 9

! E") *3; # 3 # # # # #

3 8 #" 08

#33 ! 1!

? G8 6 # ? 8 #

8J0 1 "

! "

!<&>->9+'>J)&>->)&*B(,& )9*K @3 C # # "

H 1 = )'..,*299--2

= )'..2*(99,5&K L '.

0 1 3

1 # # # 3

0 #

11 # #3 3 < "89

8 8 1 8#3 3 36 1 # <

'5 .'

'.&2 '+'2 !

"3 7"

% '('.&2 3 11#83

"## " 3 # 0 1

# # #8

8 #

1 # 8 3 # #$%

(

8 3 # " < # # 8 8

"88#

1&. # 1

# 8 8 #

1 # 0 #

11 # # 3 8 1 #3" 3## 1 @#8#3 # '&

1 "8 # " 7

# 78

8 3 # # 8" 3 88 33 8 #

3 3 3 8" # 2.

"### " &'

., '.&2

# 3 @ 1 "## 8 31 # 88 - 3#

< # # # " #

8 3 1B !7,,,7'.&,

&5 '.&2 1 8 # 8 1 "8##

# 1 3 # 8 3

!## 1 # # 8 3 8#8 ## # 38 1 &. # # 8 #

1 #

# 81" #

81 I&- * 01 #

1 # # ## 1 7 )*0 # # 8 1 3

M )*% # # 8 ; # M )*0 1 # # 1 #1 # 9

## 1" 3 #3 9

M )"*0 8# # 7 #3#

8 # # 1 3 6 @# M )"*0

1 3 8 3 : : :## :# M )"*0

3#1 M 8

8 M 3

1 $1 # #

" 3 G 8 8

# #

&5 *<

# # 3 8 1

"# G L '(

!## 1 1"8 3" # 79 # # 1 2." 3 "##

# # # 11#8 ' <

# # " 3 1 ## #

1 1 #

## # 8 "11

3 " # 1 1 8 3

1 "1 33

8 3"7 0 # 4 # 3 9

&( .> '.&- 1--,4