Suman And ORS. v. Chimana Ram And ORS.
!"! #
$ %
$ &''(( )* + CHIMANA RAM AND ORS. &!
' ,
% %
$! &''(( )* + SUMAN AND ORS &!
' ,
% %
$! &''(( )* + NIRMALA AND ORS. &!
' ,
*- ./(%*!+ !$!0( * %*!12$*+'3,1*4''(( 5!! (- 6 !"7 8! %*!%4 *93,1*4''(( 5!!,*1* :
*6 !7"# ,7"#; 8! % ! -<%4*3,1** ' , !#=
2! >>>
!
"
?@ 4 *,* 4(( ,, !"73 7"# , 7"#; 8! !7"# ,7"#; 841/ (,/24,*1* :
*4 , 914(:4'*2**-, :*, ,,7!! 8'
,/24(* ,%*, (- */+ (3 * /2 *,* 9 4
2 -< '2- -'
4 (- 1: 4 , 9 14( / 9
+*, ,4*/ 9 1( 4*- , ,
4 '(2 :4( !"7 8 4 / (, /2 4 (-
< 9-, 4:*,4A ,* 94
2 -< '2- 4 -'
:*,, 4 (- ,4**3*1*4 -*-4,*1* ,:
* 4 , 914( 1:4, ./(4$+'*-
+* # $ %%
%&
%'(#)"
*+
,#) - * + '%
% .)"
,#)
" )%(
/%+0"
%1) '
2(&
%& '(#)"+
%&
"$ %&)"
%.# *+
4)5 /%&
++0"
%1) '
2(&
%& '(#)"+
! ? @ $( *9+- (* , +
( * 4 ''(( 5!! ,*1* ,:
*6 44
24 / A *, 4 4* 9*+ , 0B# $+ 4( C+-* 41 9 ,-, 4 (,9, /2 4- 4 , 9 14( 41 9 / < 4*3 4**3-'
/ 9'2/( + 4A(+ (+ , 4
(25A!
=6! (1 A* 4 -*, + ,* B D(21* + 414(*4 2'+*' 4* 4
56 4***:*, 5/656 AA AA AA ?#@ ,-,(23$+ 4(C+-*50B#6 4 39*9 *, -'( (,/24-3-
4-'( 14(!
B #B B7; * ' :44
(2 5A!
=6 :
+, 41 9/ < /24- ,4*'
9* 4**-4:
*! $ 4
(25A!
=6 '((2-
41* + 414(* 2'+*' 4*4 4***:*, ,0B#!! -'( :4: *1(( 9 414(41 9- , 4 -'( (, 9*9 * 4414( :444: *1(( 94,/ < 4*34(25A!
=6
+,:+(, 1*4+ 414(,+* 94'*,: / 9+ ,*4* !!4' -:4 4, <'(! ?"@ , :4 4 *- , ' 3 (* , * 4 ''(( 5!! ,*1* , :
*6 , 4 0B# 4 *
A- 4 9*((2, ,4414(4,/ < 4*
+*4* , 44 A!=+(,41/ *, 1, (24-'( 50B#64,/ * ,:44
-!
?7@ 4*- ,'( '' ,/2(* ,+
(* * ' , !#=
2/2 , 944 - *
BA- -*(2 -'*1- A *4,*1*E :
* * '* A!= 5!! ! ,, 7!! 7 *9 *, + ,*$
;83##; ,#"B ($ 4+ 3 * 4/, 4/ -'( (,/2 4*4 0B#34 / 9*((2,-,4414( :444-'(
4* :**1(( 94-:4 -:4 , 4,/ < 4*! F* , +
( +*4* , 4 4 - 0B!!$+- 1:4, , G( ' 4 ( 24 - 0B# *
BA- * 4 4**
A- ,4 4: :* :4-+ : ', 4,*1* ,:
*414( H+ ! ? @ 4 -23 4 -'( 50B#6 (, -'( 4/ :44 5A!=6: *9 *,- 9 4* 414( :4442:**1(( 941 9/ < 4*3 , , 2 * :4 1* ** :4 4 :*, '
,/24(* ,%*, (- */+ (A * 94
2 4/ A(+ (+ , 4
(2 5A!
=6! , 3 4 (* , +
( 4 5A!=6 +(, 41 / *, 1, (2 4 -'( 50B#64,/ * ,:44 -3 ,/ *G, 1:4, ./(4$+'*- +* ( 77'
%& '(#)"+ *+
9% ()& /%&
/%+0"
%1) '$:
%;
2 $ ()&
%& '(#)"+ %& -'1 /- <3
%&
))$
%&
'(#)"+ *+
9% ()& /%&
/%+0"
%1) '$:
%;
2(&
%& '(#)"+ *
::)
4'
3 '= " + %.
'0( '= :)1
2) *) )( ( '%
4'
'= 4 **+( 1, ''(/( *- ( *( 3* ''(/( -*, (- ! , 5 6 ./(4$+'*- +*4(,4494 +*: G+ , *G 9 (*2* ,'2 (', ,-*(2 49*+ 4 '*
+ 9 , ,+- : A- , /* 4 */+ (! (1 A* 4 , G: I GG.
5$+'*6 *'*,+, + ,* B
!
"# $ % & '
&'
( &
)* +
! )* ' &*& &)
) , %
& - .)
%
' ( & ( )* ' ' / % 0
&' 1 & *
2 0( (
( - .) &
&'
)*- .) " 3 . ' ( * ''*
& 4 & 5 ''
&'
) %
! ' (0 ' (
& )* - .) 3 . - .) 4 0 && * '
5 & *
& '
( 5 0 ( & 4*!
( 4* % 6 7& *!
8 &- 9 )
: ;! ) 0 5 0
( &
& !
& 4 '
4 ) & . & 5 ' & 0 , 9 % ! 77 ) ' (
!0 (0
&'
!
) ) ! .) < 0 ) +
&'
% )* = +
=
. '
: ;7 '
8 & - '
!
''
) & ! ''
) &
&'
! !
*!$
'
) ) & & ) ' '
' ) )* '
) *
) )0 0 &
6
0 ) !0 ( 0 0 5 )* >( 0 + (
*
?2) '
* ' ?2)
& * ( '
( 0 & & 0
2 & ) - .) .
:;
&
'
&
0
) )*
&
< 0 %'' @
#0 5 % ! >( 0
+
(
&
= ;!7:A#' & )
&&&0 ( 2 )* & = *! 0 & ( - .)
*
(
<
& = !
A#' & )
& 0 & %
&
! !
& != !
A#2 B= !:;!C
A# ?;@ 1:4' ,/13, , 29*+ :4 1* **:44:*,! +( (23''( 5!! !7"# ,7"#; 86(,/24,*1* ,:
**, -
,! ?J@ *9*, !"7 8(,/24(- 34
- '*(2((:,44
2 4((*
-< '2- -'
4 (- , 4 *1* 4
-*-4,*1* ,:
* *- 4,
./(4 $+'*- +* $4-
.
5$+'*6 :(( *- ,*$ 94.
5$+'*6! :1*3
* 4 '*2* * 4 - -'
* ,3(* ,+
(*4(- 4 4 , '*
4 -! (1 A* $4-
.
5$+'*6 :(( *- ,* $ 94.
5$+'*6 * *'*,+, + ,* B
( )
)
)* 5 '( 4 0 ' ) '' '
! ' * 0 (
0 - 2&@
. '
)* .) (
&'
* '
*
&'
&
& !
& & 0 4 !
0 +(& '
)* 0 ( - 2&@
1
!
0! >( ( 0 '
)* .) ( '
*
& 0 . &'( +(& >( (
&'
* & )* ( &
&'
& 0
'
)* .)
3
:
* & & 0
!
&'
*
- @ + ''
;
:
; 0 $3 ''
(
& & ! ) 4 & * ' ( )
?2 (
' ) 0 0 0
)+ & & ) .)
( 0 6 ; ! &'( +(& >(
&
&'
= ;! ;!C
A# &
&'( +(& ( '' &
&'
& 0
''
'
* 0 .
&'
* '
*
&'
'' & (0
&'
*
& & 0 @
C
)* '
*
&'
!0 & 0 5 )* >( = E &'
* )
)* )
&'
!
) ' & = ( . ' 0 ( 0 ( )
(
0
( ''
* ( ' ( ! ( C . & . , ( !. - ! (
'
( ! ' ' F'
*
<
)
&'
* * &!
& &
0 ( ;;
7 C 1 &+ = E &'
* '
* &
&'
D ) ! %'' 0 ' 0 5 & +(& . = E &'
* & 5 & & %'' !0
)
. = E &'
*
& & 0 0 ( ?8@ 4(944' ,/134''(5!! !"7 86(,/24(- '*(2((:,4A
,/1 ,* ' , !#!!
2 ,*, '24-+ -'
4(- ,4 *1**- * ' , ! , !! ,*1* , :
*3 :4*
* 4 4 - -'
* ,3(4+944 ,' 4 / * ,3/+(* ,+
(4 91 +'4 -!
?@ *, 9(23:*,,,7!! 8'
,/24(* , %* , (- */+ (3 * -,, ,
2 ,*, -< '2- -'
( 9 :4 * 4 (- :*,, /2 4 (* , */+ ( 4***1*4 -*-4:
* ,,*1*!2- / *( ,4(- :4 +*:< *-4,*' *,'24*,*!
!0&.)
!"! # F%&< 1 5(A
" A@ 1 '
) " A@