High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10363/2017disposed of

Balbir Singh v. The Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal, Ludhiana And ORS

2023-11-20Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger10 pages

" !

!#$% (%)*+*&, -- #./*0 1*,23 ------ %$*$*&,%0 4%0+5+ 3% 0%+*(*,2

''*)%06 ,(5+$0*#.

0*/5,#.6 75(3*#,# &$3%0+

------

%+8&,(%,$+

0%+%,$ 013#09#, 1%32#.6 (:&)#$% '&0 8%$*$*&,%0-

07&:%80%%$ ;#506 (:&)#$% '&0

01-1- %(*6 (:&)#$%

'&0 0%+8&,(%,$+ &-

- - - - %$*$*&,%0

#./*0 1*,23 3#+ '*.%( *,+$#,$ 90*$ 8%$*$*&, 5,(%0 0$*).%+

&,+$*$5$*&, ,(*# '&0 *++5#,)% # 90*$ ,#$50% )%0$*&0#0*<#,(#<5+ '&0 <&(*'=*,2 9#0( (#$%( ->-

,,%?50% 6 8#++%( ,(5+$0*#.

0*/5,#.6 75(3*#,#

3%0%*,#'$%0 0%'%00%( #+ @$3% 0*/5,#.@6

93%0%/= 0%'%0%,)% 9#+ #,+9%0%( '#:&50 8%$*$*&,%06 3&9%:%06 3% 9#+ 20#,$%( # .5<8 +5<

+- 6 .*%5 0%*,+$#$%<%,$ +%0:*)%-

50$3%0 80#=%0 3#+ /%%, <#(% '&0 (*0%)$*,2 0%+8&,(%,$+ &-

+ 5,A#/ 1$#$% #0%3&5+*,2 &08&0#$*&,

3%0%*,#'$%0 0%'%00%( #+ 0%+8&,(%,$&08&0#$*&, 0%*,+$#$% 9*$3 )&,$*,5*$= +%0:*)%

'5..

/#)B 9#2%+ &0 #.$%0,#$*:%.=6 .5<8 +5< #9#0(%( 0*/5,#.

/%.&9 <#= /% %,3#,)%(- - 0*%'.=6 0#*+%( #, *,(5+$0*#.

(*+85$% +%0:*,2 # (%<#,( ,&$*)% 58&, '#*.50% )&,)*.*#$*&, 80&)%%(*,2+6 (*+85$% 9#+ 0%'%00%( ,(5+$0*#.

0*/5,#.6 75(3*#,#6 5,(%0 1%)$*&, 1%)$*&,

) ,(5+$0*#.

!*+85$%+ )$6

3%0%*,#'$%0 0%'%00%( #+ @

)$@ '&0 #(A5(*)#$*&,-

- $ *+ )#+% $3#$ 3% 9#+ #88&*,$%( #+ # %.8%0 0%+8&,(%,$&08&0#$*&, &, - - 3% 9#+ 2%$$*,2 #:%0#2% <&,$3.= +#.#0=

+- 6- $ 9#+ +$#$%( $3#$ 0%+8&,(%,$&08&0#$*&, 9#+ #, @*,(5+$0=@ 5,(%0 1%)$*&,

)$ 9#+ *..%2#..= $%0<*,#$%( &, -- >6 93*)3 #<&5,$+ 5,'#*0 .#/&50 80#)$*)% #+ 0%+8&,(%,$&08&0#$*&, ,%*$3%0 &''%0%( ,&0 8#*( 3*< ,&$*)% 8#= 0%$0%,)3<%,$ )&<8%,+#$*&,-

$ 9#+ ,%?$ ).#*<%( $3#$ A5,*&0+ +#<% )#$%2&0= 9%0% 0%$#*,%( +%0:*)% 0%+8&,(%,$&08&0#$*&, &$3%0 9&0B<%, 9%0% #88&*,$%( #'$%0 $%0<*,#$*&, +%0:*)%+ 9*$3&5$ +%,(*,2 3*< 80*&0 ,&$*)%6 $3%0%'&0%6 0%+8&,(%,$&08&0#$*&, :*&.#$%( 80&:*+*&,+ 1%)$*&, 1%)$*&, 1%)$*&,

)$ #.+& :*&.#$%( <#,(#$&0= 80&:*+*&,+ &(%.

1$#,(*,2

0(%0+ 05.%+ ,#$50#.

A5+$*)%-

$ 9#+ +$#$%( $3#$ )&5.( ,&$ +%)50% #,= &$3%0 A&/ *,+8*$% 3*+ /%+$ %''&0$+6 #))&0(*,2.=6 80#=%0 '&0 0%*,+$#$%<%,$ )&,$*,5*$= +%0:*)%+ 9*$3 '5..

/#)B 9#2%+ 9#+ <#(%-

%+8&,(%,$&08&0#$*&, )&,$%+$%( ).#*< '*.*,2 *$+ 90*$$%, +$#$%<%,$ 93%0%*, 80%.*<*,#0= &/A%)$*&, 9#+ 0#*+%( $3#$

0%'%0%,)% 9#+ ,&$ <#*,$#*,#/.% #+ $3%0% 9#+ ,& 0%.#$*&,+3*8 9&0B<#, %<8.&=%0 /%$9%%, 8#0$*%+-

$ 9#+ +$#$%( $3#$ 9#+ ,&$ #88&*,$%( #+ # 9&0B<#, 0%+8&,(%,$&08&0#$*&, &, - - 3% 9#+ ,&$ 2%$$*,2 #:%0#2% <&,$3.= +#.#0=

+- 6-

$ 9#+ #.+& +$#$%( $3#$ 9#+ ,&$ %<8.&=%( &, 0%25.#0 /#+*+6 3&9%:%06 3% 9&0B%( '&0 0%+8&,(%,$&08&0#$*&, #+ # )#+5#.

.#/&50%0 &, 0%C5*0%<%,$ /#+*+ 0%+8&,(%,$&08&0#$*&, (&%+ ,&$ '#..

5,(%0 )#$%2&0= @*,(5+$0=@6 $3%0%'&0%6

,& C5%+$*&, $%0<*,#$*&, +%0:*)%+ #0*+%+D #))&0(*,2.=6 80#=%0 '&0 (*+<*++#.

).#*< 9#+ <#(%-

3% '*.%( 0%A&*,(%0 (%,*%( )&,$%,$*&,+ <#(% 0%+8&,(%,$&08&0#$*&, *$+ 90*$$%, +$#$%<%,$- -

0&< 8.%#(*,2+ 8#0$*%+6 *++5%+ 9%0% '0#<%( 8#0$*%+ .%( $3%*0 0%+8%)$*:% %:*(%,)%-

, &0(%0 80&:% 3*+ )#+%6 #88%#0%( #+ <#(% +$#$%<%,$ $%,(%0*,2 3*+ #''*(#:*$ ?--

% '50$3%0 /0&523$ &, 0%)&0( (&)5<%,$+ ?- ?- 0%.#$*,2 3*+ 9&0B 9*$3 0%+8&,(%,$ &08&0#$*&,-

, /#+*+ <#$%0*#.%:*(%,)% &, 0%)&0(6 0*/5,#.

/%.&9 #,+9%0%( 0%'%0%,)% '#:&50 8%$*$*&,%06 3&9%:%06 9#+ 20#,$%( 0%.*%'

+- 6 .*%5 0%*,+$#$%<%,$-

3% .%#0,%( 0*/5,#.

/%.&9 3%.( #+ 5,(%0

!!"

# "$%

& ' (

)

+,($

% ,

.(% ./ 0

1 / .

+,#$

+,#$2 +,#$

3 "

. &

!& +,#$

3 &

. 4

5 +,#$2

3 4

. '

'5 0

& '

"%6

- *

)

"%7

3 "

!!"

)

"%7

+,#$

+,#$2

# 2$%

6 % ,

.(%./0

& '

!' ' 8

#5$%7

: :

#+;+7 2<

#5$% *

- , #'&0%<%,$*&,%( )*0)5<+$#,)%+6 3#+ '*.%( *,+$#,$ 90*$ 8%$*$*&, /%'&0% $3*+ &50$-

>- 3#:% 3%#0( .%#0,%( )&5,+%.

'&0 0%+8%)$*:% 8#0$*%+ 3#:% 8%05+%( 8#8%0/&&B 9*$3 $3%*0 #/.% #++*+$#,)%- - &,)%(%(.=6 #'&0%+#*( 9#0( (#$%( ->-

,,%?50% 3#+ ,&$ /%%, *<852,%( 0%+8&,(%,$#,#2%<%,$- - '$%0 #025*,2 '&0 +&<% $*<%6 .%#0,%( )&5,+%.

'&0 )&,'*,%+ 3*+ 80#=%0 &,.= 9*$3 0%2#0( %,3#,)%<%,$

#9#0(%( 0*/5,#.

/%.&9 +5/<*$$*,2 $3#$ #9#0(%( 0*/5,#.

/%.&9 *+ &, .&9%0 +*(%- -

, &$3%0 3#,(6 .%#0,%( )&5,+%.

'&0 0%+8&,(%,$&08&0#$*&, 3#+ &88&+%( 80#=%0 '&0 %,3#,)%<%,$ +5/<*$$*,2 $3#$ 8%)5.*#0 '#)$+ )*0)5<+$#,)%+ $3*+ )#+%6 #9#0(%( *+ A5+$*'*%( #))&0(*,2.=6 80#=%0 '&0

(*+<*++#.

*,+$#,$ 90*$ 8%$*$*&, 3#+ /%%, <#(%-

- &,@/.% 1580%<% &50$ )#+% 60?; A 6

1 6 3#+ 3%.( #+ 5,(%0 2

(

$ $

- 1

9 #

) 0

B0 C0

8 D- B &<5011<*

- , )#+%

#9 - 1

A F 0

1580%<% &50$ #+%+ 6 #/&:%+$#$%( :*%9 9#+ #''*0<%(- $ 9#+ 3%.( $3#$ 0%*,+$#$%<%,$ *+ ,&$ # 05.%6 *$ (%8%,(+ 58&, :#0*&5+ )*0)5<+$#,)%+6 .*B% ,#$50% 9&0B6 <#,,%0 <%$3&( #88&*,$<%,$6 .%,2$3 +%0:*)% %$)- , :*%9 0#$*& A5(2<%,$+6 0%'%00%( #/&:%6 20#,$ *,+$%#( 0%*,+$#$%<%,$ 9#+ 80&8%0 0%<%(=-

- 3% &,@/.% 8%?

&50$ # 8.%$3&0# )#+%+ 3#+ (*0%)$%(

.*%5 0%*,+$#$%<%,$-

%'%0%,)% )#, /% <#(% .

- ? / F9CB '<011"4" 0 # .

? 7 *

CB '<"0114" F- 8CB '<5011 & -

;%%8*,2 :*%9 #'&0%+#*( .%2#.

8&+*$*&, $#B*,2 ,&$% '#)$ $3#$ 9#+ #88&*,$%( #+ # %.8%0 0%+8&,(%,$ &08&0#$*&, &, - -D 3% 9#+ 2%$$*,2 #:%0#2% <&,$3.= +#.#0=

+- 6D +%0:*)%+ 3#( /%%, $%0<*,#$%( :*&.#$*&, 80&:*+*&,+ 1%)$*&,

)$6 )&58.%( 9*$3 '#)$ $3#$ 0%+8&,(%,$ &08&0#$*&, 3#+ ,&$ .#*( #,= )3#..%,2% #'&0%+#*( 9#0( (#$%( ->-

,,%?50% #.+& )&,+*(%0*,2 $3#$ 3#+ /%%, .*$*2#$*,2 9*$3 0%+8&,(%,$&08&0#$*&, +*,)% D $3%0%'&0%6 #< &8*,*&, $3#$ #9#0(%( *+ &, .&9%0 +*(%- - ))&0(*,2.=6 )&,+*(%0*,2 $&$#.*$= )*0)5<+$#,)%+6 <= )&,+*(%0%( :*%96 *,$%0%+$ A5+$*)% 9&5.( /% <%$ *'

#9#0(%( 0*/5,#.

/%.&9 *+ %,3#,)%( '0&<

+- 6

+- 66-

%+8&,(%,$&08&0#$*&, *+ (*0%)$%( 8#=

%,3#,)%( #<&5,$

#'$%0 #(A5+$*,2

+- 66 *'

#.0%#(= 8#*(6 9*$3*, # 8%0*&( $30%% <&,$3+ '0&< (#$% 0%)%*8$80&(5)$*&, )%0$*'*%( )&8= $3*+ &0(%0-

, )#+% ,&,8#=<%,$ #'&0%+#*( #<&5,$ 9*$3*, +$*85.#$%( 8%0*&(6 +3#..

/% %,$*$.%( ).#*< +*<8.% *,$%0%+$ #$ 0#$%

E 8%0 #,,5< $*..

+5)3 $*<% 8#=<%,$ *+ ,&$ <#(%-

- 3% *,+$#,$ 90*$ 8%$*$*&, *+ (*+8&+%( #'&0%+$#$%( $%0<+- >- ..

8%,(*,2 #88.*)#$*&, +6 *'

#,=6 +3#..

+$#,( ).&+%(-

+AB+ 3%$3%0 +8%#B*,20%#+&,%(

"%+

& 3%$3%0 0%8&0$#/.% "%+