High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18130/2013allowed

Dayanand v. Uhbvnl And ORS

2015-06-30Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh4 pages

! ! #"$%$ &'(#)

*"$ +$,

"!#$!%&$'

(" & )&*+ &$$!( , !

-.,/) '

1 !+ #

, !

"!'!

2

-.,/) '

"

!.$,+

,3'

3/ "$ - ."%$*!/0!

1 23

" ."4./!51 23

" *"$,

$ 4 *, ! ! "7$!

! !// ,,!

*,$ $$!$

)!

8 "9:9

*" "7$,"8 *,$

)!

8 !

* " 99 ' 7$ %" *" ,"8 * ,$

$$!$ "8 "

:'$%;* 2/% "!/

$$%3*" !"

*, ! ! "7$,!

/2 3$*8 <

<=% *8% ;" %!

>388% ! , >,

7$ ,!

*!8 '$"2 /;/ !3%,

*"%;**!$3% $/=% $ !// *$87$ ,!

*!8*, ! ! *" ?

" *!$%" 17*"!

1 !3 8 ! 7$!$$% "!$$%!

; !3 8 ! 17"!

$ 8 7$

$$ !

; *"!

* *"$,

$* "/$

" !"/=

! $$3/!8 *, ! ! '72"1 * !8 "/$

*8% "1$%8 ?

>-7$

"8*!$ " !"/=

! $ 33% $*" ; !/

="5; ," $

" "8"$ *,"$ , ! ! *$= "@%$*!

; 3 !

*"$,

$17*"= 1$%8 ?

>-*$=

"8 * " !"/=

! $ *, ! ! " 33% $*" ; !/

="5;

," $ " "8"$

"

%

$!

?

>- * , ! ! " )"

3% $/ "3

$ * *, ! ! 2/% "!/ " !"

"8$"2!37

* !8 *"7$

3*";-$* "!

,

;;!

$ *!8

//=

! $A3, ;" %!

388% ! , 7""/$ "* , ! ! ""/!" ?

" *!$%" 17*"!

7" ;2"8 7$8 *",/ * //=

! $*2=

"/$ '72"17*!/"/$!

; *=

! $$%8 ?

>-*$ 7" ;/

17*"$1 ! *"

"

3*";-$* 7$,

; * !8 $5!

;2/% "

)"

3% $/

%" *"$%=8! $ * $,"+%/ = % B=!2!/"2!3$#/%8 " 1 *" !"/=

! $3 =7! **/ / 3$

!$3!,/!

"

,"3 ;$",

;;!

$ *" !" =% !

*,"$ 3$ ! *"

,"3 ;$ "

7$,

; )"

3% $/*$/$"/!

%, *!2!$! ( 3*B% ;8 $ *!$ %" !

53& ! &$6"6 &',!

"

9 999

3!

1.&-&$6" 6&',!

"

3!

9

&)

&$6" 6&',

"

9 3!

!

$%,," *!$

3

! $ )"

3% $/ " *"$,

$*$ !$,% * $%=8!$$! $8 /"

3% $/ "'*$/$

!$,% 1, "/$

%3 ! 8

"8 *" !"/=

! $)"

3% $/ " *"$,

$$%=8! $ * *

%3 ! 7$8 33% $*" ; " "8"!/

="5; ," $ " "8"$!

2!7 $ "%3 ! $!$$% * !;8*$*" ;7$; 35 7/ ;

%"!

;*!$ $"2!3 %"

**$/$" %"

" "8" 4#3$ !

;

?

?>- ?

, 7$"/$ 2!

3*@%

*38, % *"!

" *"8!

;

8% 1::? 7$ 33% $*" ; ," $

!/

" "8"$ 3)"

3% $/ " *"$,

$/$$%=8! $ * *, ! ! "7$ $%=8! *!$"@%$ *,"$3"!= ," "8 "

7!2!

; $*" ; *38, % *"!

=% *$8*$

= $ "

*8% !$"32"=/ "8 *" !"$,"

"/2 $ "%3 ! $ 9

'"

*";%8 $ 2 /"

3% $/ " * ," !$

*2/$,"%$ 3%8 $2!/=/ !/ 8!

/ 1 * , ! ! " 7$ //7 " !" = * "$,

-!;8

!$/$ !$,% * !

"

3*";-$* 7$,

;;!

$ *, ! ! " * !8 2 *7"!

$ 8

$!

*"/!", ! !

*"7$ 8 ! *

7$ %;!

$ *, ! ! ""

7$,

;$ 8 7$/$8 " *!$%" !

*"/!", ! ! * // *=

! $*2= "/$ =% 7*!/"/$!

;, *8%

7$ % $*" ;

!/

="5; ," $ " "8"$ =% 7*" ! *$ =

? !

7* *"

*$= 3

"

,," %

*"!

;7$

"

"*$!8!/"!$$%7$ *"= "

*!2!$! ( 3* *!$%" !

.&-&$"%&"

7". &847*"!

1/$ // *" !"/=

! $7""/$ "!

3/% ;<1<1 /2 3*$*8

388% ! , =% 8% ? 1 >-7$7! **/ % $*" ; !/

="5; * 3$ /$ $*73%$ !3"3*";-$* > !$3!,/!

"

,"3 ;$7"

! ! ;!

$ *, ! ! "= "85!

;

"32"

" * *$!

, ! ! 7$//7

3 !

%3 !

; ? 1 >-7$@%$* !8!/"3 "2"$ 7$ *"!

3$ &'" &- &)&6" 6&',!

"

? 3!

9

?= //7!

; *B% ;8 ' C=/ * ,A%" !

3$ &396" '3!'!#',3&+9:

? !8!/"2!77$ 5 *!2!$! ( 3*B% ;8 *!$%" !

&) &&3'.&6"6&',!

:+0?

2!7 3 $

/7,$! ! $ !$3%$$ =21 * ,"$ , ! ! !$//7

*!8,%;

3 ! "$,

$!

%3 !

; ?

>- "8 *" !"/=

! $ *, ! ! !$@%$* *"$,

$" !"3 "/$ *$!

"32"

"8 *, ! ! "7! *!

,"! 78 *$ "8 *

"3!, 3" !

3, *"

" 0%

1

7 8 ,B