High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14947/2015allowed

Anil Bamania v. Managing Director State Bank Of Patiala And ORS

2016-03-16Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain9 pages

! "#$#%&'

(")*

! "#$#%&'

(")*

! "#$#%&'

(")*

! "#$#%&'

(")*+ * + * + * + * %#, - %#

##% ( . ($/$ '

0#%0 #( "(+1 %2 # ,

%!) ($ $3%! %$ '& '& '& '& 45'111 45'111 45'111 45'111 ( $ %& ( $ %& ( $ %& ( $ %& '(1/%#,6/- () (!7 8+!9"

() 3 ##% ( '(.#2 $) ( )+!9"

() ( $3%! %$ :::::

:::::

1+ 1+ 1+ 1+ ##% () $ #, !)#$3 ##%/%! ((#",

) %$#/#% %!# $ 2#%0 7(# #% ) % /(

(#( (# (;/ $)#%0) #-3/0% !(! (!

! < =%% >/( ?@ %!(! (!

!< =%% >/( ? @ (% ! "/%$ , ( ) 3 ##% ( ) $ $/A-# !

) 3 ##% ( 7 $ 7(2#%0 $ , (2 7#) ) ( $3%! %$) (0 ?$) !

! B =%% >/( ?@ $#$$/ !) 3 ##% ( ##% ($/A-# !)#$( 3,C ) $ #! ") (0 ?$) ) (

(+ %;/#(C

#" ( 7

33#% ! /(#%0#%;/#(C3(" !#%0$+3 ##% (-9 !

#%!

! =%% >/( ?B@ (3 (-##%0 )#- %0 0 ) %!?7(##%0 %! #%0 (?3(#% >3 ( %!

, ()#$!

%" #%) ! 3 (- % ,3(" !#%0$ $ 3 ( , /$ ? ) ' -( %!/- 1 , - % !

+ % -3,C "/,!A 3 (-# !A !

%! !

AC , 7C (7#)) 3 (-#$$#% ) %2 7 9 (+) ( ;/ $ ) 3 ##% () $A %! %# !9#! ) #-3/0% !

(! ($%#(( , 9 %"%$#! ( #% (% !"/%$ , () ( $3%! %$+%) ) ( %!) $$/A-# !) ) ( 7 $%""

$#% (3 (-##%0 ) 3 ##% (A !

%! !AC , $) 3( $ %#%0

#" (#$% , 0 ,,C( #% !3 ($% )

"$#%) 3( $ %"

$ ( %#%!#$3/ ##% ( ) $ -9 ! % #% %% >/( ?B ( 3 (-##%0)#- %0 0 ) %!?7(##%0 %! #%0 (?3(#% >3 (

( "($$? > #% ) ) %!?7(##%0 %! #%0 (?3(#% >3 ( > -#% !AC) %2 %! % A, )#- %0 0

, ()#$!

%" ) #%%% >/( ?B( !$ $/%! (&? D) ) ( $ %#%0

#" ( ) %2) 3(!/" ! % ( "(! %;/#(C ) ( 3( 1)(# .#2( - 8 1#%0) ) % %!7(##%0 E #%0 ( (#%>3 (+ # , %!"# !)#$% - $7#% $$ #%) #%;/#(C ) ) ") (0 , 9 , ! #%$) #$

$ (#/$% %!) %2) $ %0 0 !1)(#.#2( - 8 1#%0) ) % %!7(##%0 E #%0 ( (#% >3 (+ # , 3(9 ) ") (0

#-3 ($% #%0 $- % ,$ #% -C 3, " #% ) 7(# % $ $7 ,, $#% (9# 7"%!/" !AC1 % < %!<* ( $3 "#9 ,C ) ) ! $/A-# ! ) ( 3,C !

! *?<?

#%( $3%$ ) ") (0 $) %!- )/-A, 3( C ( ( $/33,C#%0 - ) ",/( !

< )0(

3) ) ,, , ($ #$$/ ! ( 7(# % $F % (9# 7 %! -C $3 "#- % )/-A #-3( $$#%F $#0% /( $ A #% !

AC #%9 $#0 #%0

#" (% <$) - CA

A, $/A-#

"#9 !

%" 7)#") ) 9 % A % $/33,# ! - $ C AC ) #$"#3,#% (C /)(#C ) #%) ,#0) $ (#/$% $$ ) ") (0 $+ $/A-#) #7#,,%A 3$$#A, (- "($$ > -#% 1)(# .#2( - 8 1#%0) ) %+ %!7(##%0 E #%0 ( (#% >3 (+ 7) #$ A 3(!/" ! AC ) %2 $ #$ 7#% $$+

"#9 ,C 7)#")( ;/#( $2#,, ")%#"

,,C;/ ,# # !3 ($% 1! $#( ) $$#$ %" $- %!7(##%0 %!

#%0 ( (#% >3 ( #% ) #%;/#(C ( "($$?

> #% ) %24$7#% $$1)(#.#2( - 1#%0)) %+ %!7(##%0 %!#%0 ((#%>3 (

%! ( 3(!/"#% 9#! %" $/") >3 (#% %" 6#%!,C ""(!- 3 (-#$$#% ( %0 0#%0 ) %!7(##%0 %! #%0 ( (#% >3 ( ( $ #!

3/(3$ ) ( (-) A9 + ,$3( C)

%!7(##%0 %!#%0 ((#%>3 (A %0 0 !

AC - - C A 3 (-# ! #%$3 " ) ( , (#0#% ,!"/- %$7)#") ( %( "(! ) %2 #%-C3( $ %" )#$#$;/# $$ %# , % A, ) "- 3( 3 ( ! (!

%" ) ) 9 % A % A, 0 )

$$#$ %" %C

#" A ( ( ) %#%F $$"# #% %!%% ) , ! () $"%$ % !

( 3( $ %-C"

$ #%) #%;/#(C - ,#%0 %!#"

33 ! %" 7 % %0 0 , ( %!#%0-C$ , #%) #%;/#(C#$$/A-# !)

33(/%#C!

%!)(/0), 7C (#$3(9#! !

9 %"(#-#% ,$#%9,9 !#%) #%/$"(#- AC)

/( 7) ( %% #$ ( !C !

%! %$/( /( ,8/$#" 9 %#%$/")"

$ $'C( ;/ $ ( 3 (-#$$#% %0 0 , 7C (#$$/33( !AC)

,,7#%0 ! "#$#% %4A, ,"/ #0) /( 0#9 %#%) "

$ %2-3,C &?

= @1 <="

,"/ @

= @1 <="

,"/ @

= @1 <="

,"/ @

= @1 <="

,"/ @ 6)##$) ) %!( A#!

$ .$ %#%

6)##$) ) %!( A#!

$ .$ %#%

6)##$) ) %!( A#!

$ .$ %#%

6)##$) ) %!( A#!

$ .$ %#%

%!# E($ %!# E($ %!# E($ %!# E($ #$"#3,#% (C 3(" !#%0$?

) ,3 (?%0 0#%0 , 7C (?33,#"

#% AC 3 ##% ( %2 -3,C $ 2#%0 3 (-#$$#%( 8 " ! 9 %)/0)3(9#$#%

$ , - %3(9#! $$?(-) 3(9#$#%) 0( %#%03 (-#$$#%7/,!( ) (A ) (/, +

%!( /$ , % >" 3#%?) %) 3(9#$#% ! $%$3 "# C) "

$ # (3 (-#$$#%+( ) 0(/%!$ % 7)#") 3 (-#$$#% #$ A ( /$ !+ ) !#$"#3,#% (C /)(#C "

% % ( /$ ##%) A$ %" "-3 ,,#%0( $%$

(( /$ ,?

#( "#%!#$"#3,#% (C /)(#C "%$#! (

( $)) 3( C ( 3 ##% (G ) !$/A-# !-C( ;/ $A ( ) %;/#(C

#" ( (A #%0 ,,7 ! %0 0 ) %!7(##%0

%!#%0 ((#% >3 ( %! ,$) , 7C (A/ 9 A %$/00 $ !AC) %;/#(C

#" ( ) - ( 7#) C/( )%/( ( 0( %#%0 ) 3 (-#$$#% %! # ) ! A % $ ( "(! ! #% ) 3(" !#%0$) ,!%*? ?

""(!#%0,C ( ;/ $ C/( )%/( 2#%!,C 0( % - 3 (-#$$#% %0 0 %!7(##%0 E #%0 ( (#% >3 ( ( "($$ > #% 1)(# .#2( - 81#%0)) % %!(##%0E#%0 ( (#% >3 ( %! (#%$3 "#%0) (#0#% ,( "(!

($/A-#$$#% )#$( 3(#%!

%" %! ,$ ( %0 0#%0) 5 7C (!

%!- $) 8/$#" #$ !% $) ,,A 9 (0(

/,C/()%/( (

$/") " 2#%!% $$G ) $ #! #%-9 !AC) 3 ##% (7 ( 8 " !9#! (! (!

! < =%% >/( ?@ ) #!(! (( !$ $/%! (&? D, $ ( (C/(, (!

!B 9#! 7)#") C/ ) 9 ( ;/ $ ! ( %0 0#%0 %!7(##%0 E #%0 ( 3(#% >3 ( ( "($$ > #% 1)(# .#2( - 8 1#%0) ) %+ %!7(##%0 %!#%0 ((#%>3 ( %! %0 0#%0

7C (!

%!C/ %)#$( 0 (!+C/) 9 ,( !CA % !9#$ !

D % -3,C #$3 (-# !A !

%! !AC

( 3( $ % #9 ( 0#$ ( ! /%#% A %2 -3,C $ 7)#")) #$ - -A ( ) !

#($ %# # ! () "-- %" - % ) %;/#(C#% (-$ ", /$ =#@ =>@ ' -( %!/-

1 , - % % #$"#3,#% (C "#% (" !/( ( (2- %$#0% ! 7 % %!(2- %%#%

'/-A # % ) 3(#,+ $"#("/, !9#!

#" (#("/, ( (F<<!

! $##$ ! 3 (- % , %;/#(C3(" !#%0$+ C/ - C !

%! C/( "

$ )(/0) A %2 /%#% ( 3( $ % #9 %!C/(( ;/ $ (3 (-#$$#% ( %0 0#%0) %!7(##%0E #%0 (3(#% >3 ( ("($$ > #% %!/$#! , 7C (!

%!C/"

%A "%$#! ( !G 33 , #, ! AC ) 3 ##% ( #%$ ) (! ( %% >/( ?7 $!#$-#$$ !9#! (! (!

!< =%% >/( ? @) $ #!(! (( !$/%! (&? D, $ ( (C/( , #%!

* + - ! #%$ ) ! "#$#%

#$"#3,#% (C /)(#C # '? =(C@ !

< +( 0 (!#%0 %0 0#%0 %!(##%0E #%0 ((#%>3 ( %!5 (!

%" #%) ! 3 (- % , %;/#(C ( 0#%0 )(/0) ) "% %$ ,

#% %! ( , !

"$ ) "

$ + - A(#%0C/(%#" ) % #) () %;/#(C

#" ( %( %24$ ( $ %#%0

#" ( ( , 0 ,,C ( #% !

3 ($%$#%) %;/#(C3(" !#%0$+) ( ( +C/(

, ( %0 0#%0 5 $7 ,, $A(#%0#%0 %! (##%0 E #%0 ( (#% >3 ( ( "($$ > #%"

%%A "%$#! ( !#%) #% (% , %;/#(C3(" !#%0$+ $$/")+$ %!$( 8 " ! 7 9 (+C/- C!

%!C/("

$ $3 ( ( =@=#@E=##@ ' -( %!/- 1 , - % % #$"#3,#% (C "#% (" !/( ( (2- % $#0% !A 7 % %!) (2- %%#%$

'/-A #% "#("/, !9#! #("/, ( (F<<!

! %!- C3(!/" %C !"/- %2 3% %24$( "(!F7#% $$( , 9 7#)C/("

$ $ $/")+ + 7)#, /3),!#%0 ) ! "#$#%

'?+ %#3 !

! < ,$( 8 "C/(

, ($ C#%0 %;/#(C3(" !#%0$G , /$ ? = @ ) #3 (# $ , - % !

( !$ $/%! (&? D ) 3(" !/( #% $/") "

$ $ $) ,, A

,,7$&? = @ % -3,C #%$7)-!#$"#3,#% (C "#% #$3(3$ !(,#2 ,CA 2 %$) ,,A 0#9 %

") (0 ?$) ", (,C $ #%0

() "#("/-$ %" $ (#%0 #%$)#- %! !

$) ,, A #> ! ( %;/#(C+ $/

#"# % #- A #%0 0#9 %)#- % A, )#-3( 3 ( %!0#9 )#$ >3, #% $ ,$3(!/" %C 9#! %" )

) - C7#) %! (%)#$!

%" $) ,,A 3 (-# ! (A ( )

#" ("%!/"#%0 ) %;/#(C+ "($$? > -#% %C 7#% $$ % 7)$ 9#! %" ) ") (0 ( $$ %! > 7#% $$ $ %! 3(!/" ) ( 9#! %" #% )#$ %" $) ,, ,$A 3 (-# !A !

%! !H =#@ =>@ AC ( 3( $ % #9 ( 0#$ ( !

( ! I/%#% A %2 -3,C $ 7)#")) #$

- -A ( %) !

#($%# # ! ( ) "-- %" - % ) %;/#(C =C@

7) ( ) -3,C #$ %

- -A ( %C( ! /%#% A %2 -3,C $ %)

( $ #!!

$AC ( 3( $ % #9

( 0#$ ( ! ( ! /%#% -3,C $ ) %2#%7)#")) #$ -3,C !H =##@

) ( ;/ $ ) $ #! /%#% AC

( 3( $ % #9 ) $ ! ( #% ( ,, %!# (0 %#$ #% 7)#") $/") /%#% #$

#,# !H =###@ 7#)) %24$3 (-#$$#%+AC , 7C ( $) ,, ,$A 0#9 % ) (#%0 $( 0 (!$) /( ) 3(3$ ! 3/%#$)- % #% "

%C") (0 #$ $ A,#$) ! #%$)#-G )/$+ $3 () A9 3(9#$#%+ % -3,C "

$ 2 $$#$ %" , 7C ( 7#) %24$ 3 (-#$$#% !/(#%0 #%;/#(C3(" !#%0$ % ) 3( $ %"

$ + !#$"#3,#% (C "#% ) $ A % #%## ! #%$) 3 ##% (%) ,, 0 #%) %) (#0#% , "

,, , ( ( 7(# % > #%+ ) )/-A #-3( $$#% %! $#0% /( $ !#! % - ") 7#) )

$#0% /( $F)/-A #-3( $$#% ) 3 ##% ( /(#%0 !- $#" #%;/#(C+ ( $3%! %$ ) 9 > -#% ! .#2( - 1#%0)) %) %!?7(##%0 %! #%0 (?3(#% >3 ( 1#%"

) >3 ( ) $ A % > -#% ! AC ) ( $3%! %$ !/(#%0 #%;/#(C 3(" !#%0$+ 3 ##% ( 7 $ ,# A, A 0( % !

3 (-#$$#% % A, )#- %0 0 ) %!?7(##%0 %! #%0 (?

3(#% >3 ($ $) "/,!"($$? > -#% .#2( - 81#%0) ) % >3 ( > -#% ! AC ) %2 7/,! % A 3$$#A, ( , C- %"($$? > -#% ) >3 (%9 (#/$ ")%#"

, $3 "$) "

$ ) 3 ##% (7 $) ) 7 /% A, 0 $$#$ %"

#" A ( ( ) %#%F$$"# #% %!%% ) , ! ($) !"%$ % ! ( 3( $ %)#-!/(#%0#%;/#(C3(" !#%0$ / )#$( $%+ ) 7 $ ,#%0) %!#"

33 ! %!7 % ! %0 0 , 7C (

()#$!

%" !/(#%0#%;/#(C3(" !#%0$) $ #! $3 "

) $/A-#$$#% - ! AC ) 3 ##% ( 7 $ )7 9 (+ % "%$#! ( !AC) %27)#, 3 $$#%0) (! (%% >/( ?

1#%" ) #3 (# $ , - %3 (-#$ % -3,C $ 2 $$#$ %" , 7C ( #% !- $#" 3(" !#%0$ 7#) %24$ 3 (-#$$#%+ #% )

"$ %! "#("/-$ %" $ ) 3( $ %"

$ +) %2$)/,!) 9 3 (-# !) 3 ##% ( A !

%! !F( 3( $ % !AC , $#7 $) "

) 3 ##% () %% ) %#%, ! ($) !"%$ % ! ( 3( $ %)#-#%#%;/#(C3(" !#%0$)/$+( $3%! %$ ,, #% (((7)#, ( 8 "#%0) #%=%% >/( ?B@-9 !

AC) 3 ##% (9#! ) #-3/0% !(! ($

""(!#%0,C+ )#$ 3 ##% #$ ,,7 ! -3/0% !

(! ($ !

! < =%% >/( ?@ < =%% >/( ? @ ( $ $#! %$ ;/ %,C+ #% =%% >/( ?B@ -9 ! AC ) 3 ##% ( #$ ,,7 ! #$ )3 ! ) ) 3 ##% ( $) ,, % ! , C ) #%;/#(C 3(" !#%0$ =1@ =1@ =1@ =1@ '

(")*+ * '

(")*+ * - 9#(