High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13991/2016dismissed

Anand Kant Bhatia v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-07-26Mr. Justice Satpal,Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal12 pages

!"##$%&%'()*+ ,

-#.&)&

(/ 01 2222 01 2 21211

!"#$ % 222 , & '()*+,-. & /

$ %%/ $ 0 / %/$ 1 $ $ 1 & $ 23! -.4 ! -5 ,6 +,,, & 1 7 ! $ / &!% &!$ /23! -)47 / 023! -'4 / &!% &!$ / 23! -)47 0 " % 1$ $% 3! -. -' 1! %$% 3! -) -'$ 8 & %%/ $ 0 %8 & %%/ $ //83! -. -'9 $!0:$:!3$% ;

1$ $% 3!

-. -' 1 ! % $% 3! -) -' $ 8 & %%/ $ %8 & %%/ $ % 8 % 0 /0 %

<+= ! %!0/ $ %

/ &!% &!$ / 2>&!$ /?@ 4 / & %A /$& 2/ 1

4" 9 / & !$" ; 0 $ / 89

#/# # !9 $ /$

$; 08//

$/ # #/ ! 0 !$ $ 8 $!% 8 #/# 8// 8 0! $!% $ / %/ &% " ; 0 8// % 0 % #% $80!1 98/1 / % !//" !0 %/ 8 / 1 #/ 8 #9 0 & " %/&% "; 02% #$ !0 %/8$ //10 % # % $! & " B!1

" B!1 2% +4 /% ,( ,* +,-523!

-,4 !0C!/ %!1 ,6 ,5 +,-. 23!

--48%0 B# 2% -4 / 1" % 89!0 /! 09 &!$ /8 $ / /! %% & &!$ /"0 " $ %/ 18 C!

/ 80

$ &! $: 0 1 # !:0 "&D -5*')+,-6$ +.

,) +,-6 $" $ 8 1!0:$ 0 1 &! 3 1 % / 0 % 8#" % 0:$ 0 1 " 8

<6= % 0/ 0%!!%0 $

: 0 1 E$2!%4" 0 /0

$ &! % 9 1 #9 F :! $ &! %$ $// $/ $ / $ $%/ # #/# $" "0 8 # 3% G%$ $// $/ $ /H 80# !"!//" %/ 8

/ 1"8 %!0/ $ 0%! 1" 890

0 /" % $!/ %0 F / 8 $ &! %"$ 8! / $!/ %/ /8 1$ % %!0/ $@% " !" 1 F $ 8 ! 1 &! ! $ $ %/ $ 8 !/

!0/ $F 1 !/"+,-,2> F!/?@ 4 1 8!/!% 8 0:$ 24!/" % 8 8 / $" 8 1 % $/! ) F !/ # $ %" $ $ 8 #9 :! $ &! $!%!0/ $ 8 $" ! % % " % 0:$ 0 1 $ 0 1 " 8 % 0/ 0%!!% 0 $ 8 8#" % 1

!0/ $ F 1 $ / % # 0 %$

<(= !% &! % &//1 # ! &!$ / % $/ &//1 "4

((*"1 0 %!0/ $ / 1 0 ! &!$ / $ 1 1 %! 8 A $ & $// I # "0# !$ I $/ @ 4 8 8! / %/ 1 7

4 "08 7

4 8 ! ! !/1 1 7 #4 0 //1 1 %!0/ $ $! 1 8#"!$ 1 J "8 ! $/ 1 / 1 1 !" !$ ! 1" !/0 //8 1 %!0/ $ 8 $ $$!/ 1 % 9 !0 /! %%

& % $!$ /"0 " C!

/ 8 : 0 1 E$2!%4 8#" 1!0 / 0 0!1 $ 8 % $ / #9 %!0/ $ :! $ &! /" 0%/$ $" $ 1 & $ 8 ! -5 ,6 +,,,& 1 ! $ 1 $"-'.,"

! $ &!$ / / 0 &!$ /7 8#" 1 0 88 $ 01 ! !/1 !$ / 1 " # 1!/ 1/ ! 1 8$ %!/ ! $ 23! -)4

<5= &!$ / 8 ) ! $// 0:$ ! " & 0 / ! // #! $!/ !" 4 / " 0 3$% !0$ % " " /" 1"1 "0C!! %" "09" /$/! $%0 " ! 8 ! K I "B#

4$C!

01 "%!$ "3$ 1"/" 1 8 8#"/"0!

/ 1" %% #0/ K #0/

! $// 0:$ !

4 08 $ / ! 11K % $ #0/K #0/%% $! ! #4 0!

/" $!$ !" !$! 0!

/ 1/"3" %#"% "/1 $/! 1 3 1 0!

/ 1 %# C!

% 8 / 1 "8" 1"! !" 1"

! "%%!%%/ $// $ !8 $ !$ 0!

/ 10%!!% / 2#4 //" 1" " 3$ 1" 11" " //!" % 8 /8 %% 8 # #0/ #0/0/1 1 ! 2# 4 08 8 8 ! $! 11" % $ %/1 # //

<.=

#0/ %% 0/1 1 ! 8 # 2#

4 % % $$! 09 / 8 09 8 # C!

" ! $ 0:$ ! 2#

4%$!$0$ !9 !$ $ ! $ //8 0:$ ! 34 !9 @/ 1 ! 08 ;

$ / ! 24 !/ % % $ ! #/% 9 /8/ ! %# % ! //0 ! J ! $ 0:$ ! // 0 0! 1 0 8#" 1 0%/$ $ 8 $$! &!$ /" 98 ! 8 3%! J

!" #$ % !0 " $" 8 % 0 /0 %

%/$%$ & &!$ " $$ / % $ %///$9 1 / % 0$/

/ &!$ / & % A /$& "2/ 1 " 9 /& !$"; 0470 "$ /89 #/#

# !9 $ /$

$; 08// % 8 $ 1

F $/ & % &!$ /

<)= $ /$ $ 0! 8%!0/ $$! $" 0 $! /%/$$" 8 0 # 8 " !0 / $ / $ # 0 !90 #0 8 : 0 1 ?$2!%4

$ &! / 3% G%$ $// $/ $ /H !" !//" %/ 8 / 1"8 %!0/ $ 0%! 1" 890 0 /" % $!/ %0 F/ 8 $ &! %"$ " $!/ %/ /8 1 $ % %!0/ $@% " !" 1 F "8 / % /$! / %

# 8 " " %! 08 %/ &% // %/ 2% . -(4 /%/ ! 1(5'.C 8///@ /0 8 ! F 2% -54 / $/ "$$ 1 " 8 ! F 2% -54" %!$ / -()-( +- ,- +,-( 0

% " 8! F / #/% .-(# /@ -()6) +- ,- +,-( // 1 % $/ ! 1(5'.C " 8 ! F 2% -54 %%/ $/! / 8 /&/"

<'= 8$ 89" !"; 0 %/ / / 2% 54 # / -) ,+ +,-( 23! -4 8 C! // & " %/ &% " ; 0 2% 64 9 $/! / 8 /&/

(5'.C !; 0 %/ %/&% $/! " % 0 8 9 0

$$ 1/ & "

%/ &% " ; 0 2% 64# /+.

+,-(23! +4 //2% 54 $% /%/

K 8 / &/ ! 1 (5'. C 0//8 0 $% /%/" 8 ! F 2% -54 %%/ !0 %/ #! % . -( +) ,'

+,-( 23! %$ 1 %%/ $ 23! 64" & " %/ &% " ; 0 2% 64 ++ ,* +,-(23! (4 $ 8! F !/ // ! C!

1 1 $ 1 $ $$! 8 %%/ $ !0 %/ 8 ! F 2% -54 % !

! "

# " $ % & '(

%)* +,(

- 8 /&/

<*= $$ 1 % " / /0/ 0 8! F 2% -54% .-( " 8! F $$8 / C! ;! " !0 %/810 8! F "% . -($ % $! %%/ $ %/ -( -, +,-(,+ -+ +,-( %/8$ 0% !0C!/" 8#/ 8 /$ $% " !0 %/ $ 1 %/" %/ &% " ; 0 / //8 %$! $ $% K!0 %/ %/ $ #$ 8 % .

-( 9 1 !1 0 0 % %%/ ! 1 $"+,,5 8#/ % -5 %!$ % $ %/ ! 1(5'.

" % . -( # /@ -()6)+- ,- +,-(8 " 8! F 2% -54 /1/ 1 %%/ $% 8// !0 %/ 1!/ K!80!1 $ / %/ &% " ; 0 " & "

%/ &% " ; 0 2% 64 % /C!

!%8 /

/ 1!0C!/" ! 8$! $ 8 ! F 2% -54 -* -+ +,-(

<-,= 23! .4 % 8$! $23! .4" ! A 2% .4 /%/# /++ -+ +,-( ! %A 2% )4/ /%%/ 8$! $ 1 / #!% . -(8# !$ 98/1 //2% 54 $% -) ,+ +,-("0 " !

%/ &% " ; 0 8 / 8 0! %/ 8 1!

% .-(%%/ !1 / 8 /

8 ! F 2% -54 & "

%/ &% " ; 0 2% 64" 8#" 0 ,) ,5 +,-5 23! *4 #9 % !0 %/ 1 % -5 % . -( 11 # 1 #$ %/ +, ,+ +,-5" / %%/ 0 & "B!1

"B!12% +4 %%/ 8 /,- ,( +,-58 " #$ !0 %/8%!0C!/# ,) ,5 +,-523! *4 & " B!1

" B!1 2% +4 # ,( ,* +,-523! -,48 $ % #$ 0!

/ 1%/!0 %/ 6"("5. 0 & " %/& "; 0# / +, + +,-5881 8#"8 1 /% %%/ $ $ 1 %/&% " ; 0! $ 0!

/ 1%/K %/!0

<--= !0 %/ )'" 8 / $ %8 $# 8 $% %%/K%%/ $ " & "

%/&% "; 0 //$ $ 0!

/ 1%/% 1!0 %/ )'% !/ 8$$ 1/ & "

%/ &% " ; 0 2% 64 /# % 1 ( * +,-5 23! -,4%0 & "B!1

"B!1 2% +4"8 $ $ !% 10 B# K

$ %/ $ B# " I0 F$/

% "& 1 2% -4 % 0 1$ / $ %%$ $ %/$2% -4 / %%/ $ 9 $% # % $$% $!/00!1 98/1% - 8#" $ %/$2% -4$/ 9 $ % # % " $$ 1 % " 8%# %%! 1 $ %/ $2% -4% %!1,6 ,5 +,-5 23! --408 $ %0 & "B!1

"B!12% +4 0!% / % %/$ / $! $ 8 !0 %/ % 0/ $" %/&% "; 0 0%!!

1 $0 1# % 1 ( * +,-523! -,4 % 0 & " B!1

" B!1 2% +40 B# K $ %/$B#

<-+= "I0F$/ % "& 1 2% -4 $" 11 #1 ( * +,-523! -,4 8!/9! $$$8 /8 8#" % $0 011 #0 6 +,-.23! --4 %0 B# 2% -4 /0 $ %%/ 0 & " B!1

" B!1 2% +4 1 #$ %/ +, + +,-58 $ 0%/$$ % ) +,-5 23! *4 8 / "

$ %/% $!/%/ 1 8 % "/ $ @ %!08 // %/ %/&% "; 0 $ $! $"8 % "$$ 1/" 2222 4 212114 !/+."+,-.

> ?K - D %9 1K

LK + D %0/