Sheela Devi v. State Of Haryana And Others
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH CWP-23820-2011 Date of decision: 16.11.2022 SHEELA DEVI
...Petitioner
VS STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
...Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN MONGA
! " "" " ! " # "$ % ! ! % % !
! %!
" !! "! ! " & "! "" ! ! # ! ' " % ()((*++) ,- &./ "" " * *01*2(**++3,-&0/% %
! " " " %
" ! !4"*5++++1
"
! "" ! !
" %""%
! " *01*2(**++3,-&0/ * !
" " " ! " $ % "#" &
*)+.*++5 " ! !" " ! "
! % !
! 6(2(+*++3"* ,- &*/ " 0 "$ % 7- % 4 "*++38 !*2(**++3 "%
! " 9" " ,- &0/ " %
! (*+**++) ,- &:/ " "
! 4"(5.(5*1 % "
" %
! 4 " ! *++3 8 "
*5+**++) ,- &5/ '" " % " " %" " "
%
6*)+:*++) % " " ,-&3/ " " "
" " " % "
" " !
; " ' ! " (+<* 4" * "" % ()((*++) ,- &./ *2(**++3 ,- &0/ "
! 4"*5
$ " ! ! 9 " "
!4"(5.(5*1! 4"*5
$ 0 = " ! " "
"
" -% ! ! 4"*5
$ " " 4"5++
$ +(+)*++3
" %
! ,- &)/ " "
"! !; "
! " ! " !" " " ! % ! ! !
! " & 14 " *++3 8! " !% !
!
: 9 " ! " % % "!
5 8 "
! "" " " -% ! *++0 4 " *++3 4 "> " " %" ! ! - " ! #
" ""*)+.*++5 *++07- 4 " "
% ! %""! " , /! "" ,/ ! - % !
%4"*5
$ ,/ %!
" "" "" % """' !*++3 ! "
" """$ ""
" !
"
! "
!
!
"
" ! " % " ! !
""' !
%
" " " " ! ; %"
?
! " " "#$$% #$$&" !
' ( ) "#$$
* 3 &"
! "
! ! " $
*++34 "" "" ! ""'4 " ! *++3 8 " ! !"
#
" " %" ! " #
" ! ""
" !! *)+:*++) ,- 4*/ %
" % + , + ) # &- . ! ' ' ( , ) " #$$& ! (
%" @" " " *++04 " " ""'
!
$ A " %
" "
! %" ! %
% " !! " " "
% !
; +3(**++3 % () " % (+<* "" ; " ' ! " .
% "9
! """ " "$ %" %% " ! !! "
% " $ "" "
$ "! - "
"" " ! ! ""' ! *++3 !! *0(**++3 ,- &0/ "" ! !
'
"
" "" "!4 5,(/!7- 4 " *++3! !(* "8% "
" " $ "
"
"" " " ) "" "
! % ! !"
! !
"
!
" B ! % ""
"" 1
% " "" ! "
! % ! ""' ! *++3 6 " % ! ! *++3 "" %"? (/ " " % */ " !% "" " " "%
! !
*++3 """ $
" "
- " ! "" 2 9 " " " " " " ! "% ! *++3 % $
" " % " " - " ! "$ % ""
"! "" " "
'
" "
! "" " %
" !
"
" "4"*5
$ "! !! ,-4*/ (+ 9 ! " ! "" "" " " 9 " "" ""
!$ % " %8! % % % - " "$ ""
! " !!
! " " %- " (( / ! !
" % CD% ! "# ((((*+(:
C8; % "
D # &)+()! *+(( " " C D% # &
:+.:*++)
$ %!# " ? " 1 #$$ #$$ )
& #$$&)
" 2 #$$ ) 3
#$$2 0
#$$& ) 1
#$$2 ) #$$ ) %$2 +
#$$ ) 4
5 6 7 2#2&#$$0 .
' .! " 2 #$$2 1
#$$2" ) ) . )
%$2 + "
#$$ ) . ) #$$%#$$&)
. ) " "
,'5 ): ;
< ! 5: = 7 -
" #$$0>3? . 311" #$$ ) 9
1$ "
#$$2 #$$ ) " "
' ! ' ' ( , ) "#$$
1
#$$2 - @ + 4 #$$ ) "
* (* 9 " "
! % ! !
!*++3 "! " % "
! ! " ()((*++) - &.
" "
! !4"*5
$ -% "
(0 9"
!
" ! % !!
!*++3 "! " % %!"
! -% "
()((*++) ! "" ! ! $
%" ! " "
E !
% ! (: " " ! """
% " ' " "
& "
"!*++3
(5 #"' ! " " % ! ' " % ! % %
! " ! "!
% "F5G (3 9 "
" ! ! !
% ! "
"
;"! "
(.
!"
"
!"
#$
% " $ %1 "? H"1 ? H"1