High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18242/2013disposed of

Ram Asra And Others v. State Of Haryana Etc

2018-01-08Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu13 pages

! "! # ! $!% & '!( "! # ) ! ! *+,-& ! ./" !*%+)&"! - . !"))++ !&!"&0!- + 1-'!(

23 !(! "/!) !"% /! !!! 4%" %+ "'!( .+&!. .( %+-

"! !! !!" %+/"!5()+( /!, 0 ! 5 /! !0%+! )( + /" %!"! )!(! 4%" " !) /"!/ 0 " 5 !.+0! ") !/"

6 + !! 0!.!( 3 7! "+ 0 + 0 "/!) !"" ) !/!)) & ,!8"! !5 !% .! ! 0 " + ++ +05+ )! 9%+ - % !) 5+ "! /!, 0 ! 5!+5" !0%+!& ,!8"!:

0"!"" 5 )%"! "/! !

*"+ 5( " +!

+ . 1 !+- '!( " " ) ! /!)) !5 !%.! ! 0" + +++05+)! %!"!""4%+ -% !) 5+ ""!/!, 0 !5/" "!0%+!+()) & ,!"!+ )) ") !!% !

; ! )) :

+ )) &%54% )) ! % & ,! 8"! !5 % 0 !.

& ,! 8"! !5 <<= %)

<<<

< 6

5( 0! 0 %( !.

< << %) <<> <<= %) >

<<=

= <<= %)

= ><< >

> 5( 0! 0 %( !. /

= ><< & ,! 8"! !5 =<<= %) ><<

5( 0! 0 %( !.

& ,! 8"! !5 <<= %)

= ><<

6 >

> 5( 0! 0 %( !. > & ,! 8"! !5 <<= %)

6 ><<

/" %( !. / =

23 " 0.!

!)! 0 +!?!! )) !! 0 " < ( + )( @+% !%+)+(/"++ 05(/( /!) +

, -./0123454002$36.( 348"/++/ =

<< "A%0 !)! << &B> "!) !)! 0 " +!?!! )) !! 0")) <(+ " )( 0 + +!( " ) ! "! / +!- % % + !%, / ) "! /! !++/") ! % !.%5A! ?

*&+ % "0!% % %5+(?% !()!

! ? %?5+ )5( ++/ 0"!%+ +

!0 ) /!+!)(+!(") ! "!0%+!)(+/ " "!)) ? 00 3 &C / + 5( " & '!( 0 " " %!

, -4742&%)! . !!!

@%!;/!"+!(!!!5) +( !" )%0 A%0 /"+ +!( 5 ) " 5 !0%+! + / .5!-

!0%+!+(%5A% "&C +. @! !!!!)!%"!% !

; D- "! !- . " ( " ! !+. + 5%! " & / ( 5!. ""& )("+!(!!! +( !" ")%0 A%0 - "!!!++ /

5)/" "! " !(8" " " +!( /++ 5 ) " 5 !0%+! + ! " " .5!-

/! !0%+!+( 8" !! /++ ))+( ++ " &)+ C. + "! "++ 0 A%0 '0"%!8"!! 0 %5A"!%+ "&)+C.) E 2>3 %!% "!-!!& !(F% -'!( -" 0!" %% = =

++!F%

! "&! 0"++ !"!5)+!(5+ !0%+!"!: 0"!")(+ & ,!8"! )!! <<6 /

;

!. >>

! <<6/""/ %!"!!.<

;

1/"

6 ")%!% " "%!+

*#+ " !!!%5("' H5+&%)!%!") !/! 0! !0%+!+ 263 1!. ") !""1.!

'!( "

! %+ 5(.!% %+ -))+5+("! /@+% 4% )) - ! + ! 5 %+ !)!% "!% ! ; 0! 1.!

&!. /"" !%+))+( ; ' ) @@@ @@@ @@@ '") 12423, 2441

.088 609 @@@ '/) 234.4 8 / 0123:

42 01. . -.01 6 ;4 .7 ,/ .< 0142 8 / . 2729302;4 43./

6:<24;4 43 .7.0370;4 4= @@@ "E 2=3 %!% " ! 0 %+- " ! F+ !( F%

!-& )%! ++!/ 0 5%!

!" !& ,!8"!/! +!0%+!)(+ /"!%) ++!/ 0 5%! 0

!%"/% ") ! !! @ )(5(! ( 0, !.!( )( @)( " +"/% % ") !) !>"+ 0/"" /! )

@%! ;

! %5 !)+ " "/ % + + )( !)+(%55( ) ! "+ 0/""/!)

@%!;>

*>+ 2 3 0! 0/""!)+(0. -"!/ 0 5%! 0

!.!( ! " +!( " ) ! ! " ) @ % ) " + 0 /"" "( /!

!" "+(% /%+5 !"!+!()( %) ! "+ 0/""/!)

@%!;6&+! /!%""!) ! 2<3

%+ ( 0!0%+!)(+ !"!+" " !) ! 0 ) @ )( % 0! !0%+! + /"

6 " 5 "++ 0 !;+ " 0!% " " ! % 4%!+( .!5(" ". 7 " "%!

, -4 742 &%)! F. " 503 .<1 54 002 $ ,.?; =<6

@%! ;=- ++ !%+ )) )) 0 !0%+! ) ! % !0 0+ )!"5 "+ +" % " !0%+! )( + " )"+ &+! %+" 5 4%"5( . 7 " "%!

+1 ./23 .<1./0123454002$36../01234

@%!; 8"! !- %+ " %+5+5+5 +! % % + I%!"! " ) ! " 5 0! !0%+! + )+ %!H !!- "! !- /"!/+ 5 0! - " ++0+ % % 5+ 2 3 8" 0 "! " " " %!

-4742/!.!5("' H5+&%)!%! + 002 $ 36. ( 34 54

, - ( .39'"% %) > #>" 5( ) 0")+""!) /! + % " ) !"@)!( ") )! % "(". 05

*@+ )) @!)0)!! 0 8"&C/++/ "+0" "' H5+&%)!%! 2732036 002$ A3.0B(3454 -25 '&)(349'"%%@)# )!!+(4%

+ !%+)) % ") !" @)!( ") )!9%" + !%+)) 50. " % ")(+"!/ ) ++( .!"%0" )!0!)"> "A%0 - + +( /0!5)/04%+"+!( ++/ "/!5 )"!0%+!)+( "!! 0.!

!.-/"

!" !/"""(/!!).+()) /+ /" "! "'0"%! 5(! 0)( /04%+"+!("+/0! )+( "!! "!+8@)! 0.!

!.- !" " A%0 " . 7 " " '0" %! "! ++/ +. @! ! " ! A%0 !)!% "!% !

; C>> ##'0" %! " ! " " 00 +(/0-5)/04%+"+!( ++/ "!5 0)"!0%+!)+( "!! 0.!

!.-/"

! " !/"""(/!!).+()) 8" 5A , / " ! !)(

!" 00 ""'0" %! " +!+( 0 /! 0 ! 0 " ")+(5)+!(4%+"+!( ++/ "!5 0)"!0%+!)+( "!! 0.!

!.-/"

! " !/"""(/!!).+( 00! )) :/ ) "'0"%!) %" 5+0 "&/" ".!(4%

*D+ 5 ! " '0" %! " / /""! " )+( /! + ". 4%+ )( ! 4%+ /!,++ /! + ("!5 8"("+5 00 "" !

!-"! !- "./"-5- " . 7 " " '0" %! "%+ ". ! " /0 4%+ " +!( " 5 )!0%+!)+(5)"+(;/0 )+( /"

! " A%0 ' -")! "! ". 7 " ! " " +(;/0 !

!5)/04%+"+!("+/ 0! )+( "! ! " !+ 8@)! 0.!

!.- !" " A%0 " . 7 " " '0" %! & - "( ! +( +(;/0 !

!- "! /%+5 4% "!++/ 5 0) "E 23 " !0% - +!

% + ! " ) ! ""! %4%!+(.!5(! ' H5+"&%)!%! 002$ ,.?;5<?

0 .<1 '"% D) #! /++ 002 $ ,.?; ( 34 54 $ E 4 1 '1 02 4123)2079"% >'#)&&# 2 3 C!

% + !") !"! !!)!0!)"6 6 " <?

0 .<14742&%)! " ./ " %+) ") !". 05 )) ! 5 ! % .! ! 0 " + ++ +05+ )! - 5- 4%+ - % !) 5+ "! /!, 0 ! 5 5 0 " "! !0%+! + )) & ,!8"!-") !/%+5 + !//0" % ")(+"+/0! "

*!+ !0%+! )(;+ @ !0%+! )+(- "+ 0 " )

+. @! " <?

0 .<14 742 ',83) !)!%% !

; D6 '. 0 !.! " +0+ )!! /" ! ! "))+ ")! )+ D4%+ )( ! 4%+ /!,E- !+ )!!( )+(+(;/0)+(-")) - )+( )) %+ 5- !%+ )+( " +,- " + ! " !4%! %!! -/""!")+( !

5 ! "%!-/! ! ! 0+! % !) 5+ /! 5 0 "!0 5( !0%+! )+("+ 0"?!!) 0)8" @! /%+ !4%! " ))+ )!! " )! )+ D4%+ )( ! 4%+ /!,E%!5(% )!

5.'/.!- !" ) "! !

%+ !%!!" %+) (-5%/ !+(, /+05(" +!

% + !)! 0 " & % A5- " ++ " )!!( )+( " )! 5% " ))+/!)) 0 )/""/!+ .+5+ "!0%+!!?5+" :/+ ) " %! 0 " %! "! )+( - " )!!( )+( !

/! 5 ! +( )% "!0 % !) 5+ /"" ) /! 0 !0%+! )+( C,/- !0%+! )+("+ 0%5 .)/!+) "!0 " /!, /"" / 0 )!!( )+( ! 8"! - "! !- ! ! ( %5- " " % !) 5+"!05(")!!()+( " )! ))+ /! " /!

*F+ 5 0 "!0 5( !0%+! )+( : " " ))++ - " " !) )+( ) " 4%+ )!!5 ! )) !0%+!5I%!"!!- " "&" ( ")!!()+( /%+ 5 + )( )!( ( )! )+ %! 5( % )!

"! 5. 8"! 5 %5-"")! )+ D4%+)(

! 4%+ /!,E /%+ 5 ))+5+ ++ " )!!()+( !

-. " "!0"+/0 )!/"" % " )( + !0%+!+( 00 0.!

)+("+ 0") 6 :

./ " ) @)! 5( %

!0 0)!0!)"-/". " "+ " ++ " )!!( )+( !

- )! 5% " /%+5 +!//0 " % ")(+"+/0!- " !0%+! )( +- @ !0%+! )+( "+ 0")E 23 C!

% + ! " ) ! " + ! !! )!0!)" " "' H5+&%)!%! $ E4 14742 &%)! %))! " )+ " " ) ! 5+ 0 0 + ::: !.! +)! 0 !.!( ")( !0 " %+!0!)" " "' H5+ &%)!%! $ E4 14742&%)!!)!%% !

; D : )5+ )%+ ++ % "!")-/""/%+0.!

)+( "% !.!(-/"!)( "., +(5 5( ")+(!- @ "! + 7" (-5 " ! !!"! 5.-/ (-!(! ! -%!" ++/ /

* %+ % - /"! !.! 5( " )+(!- /%+ 5)!5+ +/ ;

.!( ! )+( 5+ 0 0 +;::: +;:$ !. ! 1!%) JH 1!%) JH !.

.!( ! !! )+(- ! )+( /" ! % !! /" (!- " !! !.!(

.!( ! )+(- /" " @ )( " 5 ! )! @ . (!-5 !"!! !.!(% .

.!( /"! )+( " /! %++(5 !4%!"!0% "0"! )- " 5 ) ! 0+(- . "%0" " "%+".!0" %++(5 !4%!/!,0

!!) . :

( "! - /"! " %! !!. " +% - " !.!( ! " )+(- /%+ 5 4%% ! "!" ! !5!!( %" @ -/%+ !%/0""4%5+5+ " )+(!H!0"!.!E 2 3 '/.!- " $ E 4 14 742 &%)! " 5 ! 5( ' H5+ " &%)! %! <1 ,30 $ ,.?; ( 36.54</25 .<1 '"% @) #"@D +! "/"!

!/"")( /" ! !)% 0" " ( )( % ". 5 @ /%+ 5 !4%! 5 ! % - %"

! /%+ 5 5% 5( " % !, 0. 5( " +. @! " ! !)!% % !

; C %:

& % A5. 4"

"%!"+ "/"+ )5+)%+++% "!")/"!)( "., +(5

* + 5( )+(!- " ++/ 0% -!.!( 5(")+(!/%+5)!5+ +/ & )) ;> .!( !)+(5+ 0 0+ ::: +:$!.!1!%) 1!%) !. .!( ! !! )+(- ! )+(/"!%!!/" (!- "!! !.!( .!( !)+(-/" "@ )( " 5 ! )! @

.(!-5 !"!! !.!(% . .!( /"! )+( " /! %++( 5 !4%! "!0 % "0"! )- " 5 ) ! 0+(- . "%0" " "%+ ". !0" %++( 5 !4%! /!,0

!!) .:

("!-/"!"%!!!. " +% - " !.!( ! " )+(-/%+5 4%%!"!"!!5!!( %" @ - /%+ ! %/0" " 4%5+5+ ")+(!H!0"!.! )"%))+ 8")! )+ % !) 5.

))+(% %" ")! :

")! -"

! /" ")( / ! / +!+( )+

" ( )( % ". 5 @ /%+ 5 !4%!5 ! % 8"

" % !, 0 /"+) ! " !. )(+'5% 5("% !, 0 "I!"! -"A%0 "'0"%! /""" !!.!(% % 5+ '/.!-/! "./""!.!("%+ 5 ! 5+ ++ !""

* "+ !.!( 5 4% "+( ++ )!.!)! /(!E 2>3 ". !"%5 +!

% + ./ ") ! !!5.! " !./"

%+ %+

" @ @+% ))+5+( '!( .+&!. .( %+-

")! )) !5+5+5+!% % + 5!%,/ " )+()) !5 !%.! ! 0"+ +++05+)! /"!". 0 4%+ -% !) 5+ "!)) !0%+! & ,!"!"+! 0+( 263 '/.!-!0!"++ 0"!.!(/! "./" )( /") ! ! " !!! "' H5+&%)!%!

, -4742&%)!- ") !

!"!.!( "+0" $ E 4 14742&%)! ./ "+! "' H5+&%)! %! </25 .<14742&%)! 2=3 ! 0+(- ./ " "' H5+&%)!%! <?

0 .<14742&%)!-") ! !%+)+(/%+ 5 +" % ")(+"+/0! "!0%+! )(+@ !0%+!& ,!"!/"

!"% '/.!-@)( ") ! ! " "%!

, -4742&%)! =

<< /%+ 5% !!.!( ! 0+(-) !!5% ! % " @)( !.5(" ./ " !!! "' H5+ &%)!%!

, -4742&%)!+ ))!)! )! " ) ! , !)! "

* &+ %"!

!.!( " @ )( " 4%5+ "+( ++ :

!) ( %" !)! -"!) /%+ ! )))!)!!! !)"! 2 3 !) ++/ " ! ! '

?241 ./ ) '

) ,/<2 ,/<2

""!), 0?! K?

""!!)!5+