← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/31015/2020dismissed

Nisha v. State Of Haryana

2022-05-17Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj22 pages



  



 



! 

"# !   

  %  &'(!" !() ***** 

 

!" #   "



 &"

'" ("

) &*"# + ," "

  %"

!" #   " (-.

/  ***** " !()(( 

  ) 

,% 

2

1*    3% "$ $

41145 6"%

  " 7 3

8 95 "

1%$ ! "

""#  %" # '%

" 2:

3

8 95 *

;. /  " 2 

# 7# :# 7# 

9- .

"

 # 27 3% "$ $

4.145 "   ("

1

 %"

*   -$

$"

"

 *"   *" " 2 3<8 =95 '" *

-( ( #

"

(-.#  ")

-"

%#  %"

'% "

$"  "

"

*

#9 $ * "

>"

( %

2

"

;. "" 

 

'%

%

 $



"

# $   '" $ "" 

' 9"

# "

 % &*"# 

"* $

  "*

  ;(?

  '" 

 

7# 

 %""

*

'

*"% '%  '  < "

#

 "



 "# ! "

"" ; 1"#  %"

9" '  " # "$    $



"" 

9" # ' " ' 

$  1%$ ! "

""#  %"

"

  

 11 " ' %"$ %"

 

1%$ ! "

""#  %"

 

* *

* 

" "%

$$      '

 





 0%

 



'   '" %" 



*"

$

""

$  

(

 . '" "



 $ *" 

1%$ ! "

""

 '" $" # "*%

"" %"

""

   ) *



"" 

'%"

""

6

*



"

 

%"$ * %   

'"

1%$ ! "

"" "

" "

 

   . # %"$#  "

*"

1%$ ! "

""

" $ ) *

 

  % % $ .

# % *"

8"* " "$%# "

8"*



%"

 ""

 

*"

"

"

" 

$%

35 11

 0% ""

$



" 1* "

/ 

@ :



1* 

/ 



' %" % (

! #  %"

' ""

$

 "  ) * " : "

! "

"" ; 1"#  %"

 

  "  "

 

1%$ ! "

""#  %"

"



"'

  ) * " : "

! "

"" ; 1"#  %"

"



) *



 0% '" "  

*"

1%$ ! "

""#  %"

(

! #  %"

  % ) * " 2:

'% 

" ) * " :



1%$ ! "

"" %"

%" "# "

#

%" ""

 

"  $% # '%% %

  

" "

* 



%"$    "' *" '" %"$  

$  1%$ ! "

""#  %"  A 



  

$  1%$ ! "

""#  %" #

'" *

%"$

" =9 -( ( %# =9 (.

/"$ ( % .

" B$$

=97 +") ( %

=92

"

"*"

$%   8"* "



$$"

1A( -" " 



'"

 





 "

"

*

# '"

+ *

1%$ ! "

""#  %"

 

  " 7 , # 

 ?"  ""

%"$

""

  "

1%$ ! "

""#  %"

%"

"

 "





(

! #  %"



 '

$ 



35 ' *"

"

11 . $% *  '" * 

1%$ ! "

""

%" '



)

# %

#

"* $" "# %"



)  

 .

" "

%"

$





8"* " 

 ("% &*" A"% "#  

;

(

B$$#  %" #

'"









   %

)

'%

% "

 "* , '#

* 



'" '



'" *

8"*   

  " 

 0%"$# 

*  

"  ""

%

"

"

%  





"

"*"

"

"

 % % " 

'" "

 # % '# 1%$ ! "

""#  %"

'

'  

  " :2 

%"$ *  %

" 

" . 3.

   5 1

*

*

   " B0

.

  -"



6

% %  "*

 '% " '

  "

%" '% "'

*

#7:#9

$$ " $ * "

  -%" 3,C;5 /'

+"

" #  %" 

7 (* #

"  "

/%"

*"

'" "

*   )

'" $

 

  " 27# 1%$ ! "

""#  %"

*

 "*

"

"

 9 "

$% "

"* **  

11

 

# % ' *"  %

"*

* 

%

7 '% $ "

 *

'

/%"

'" *

 

  " 77 "$



'"

"*

  

2 *" '"  "

$8 $  

  " 27 

# % '# %"$ *  $$%

7

**

/"$ ( %.

" B$$#

%"

""

8"* =9

:

 

* 

 

**

=91

'" '

1%$ ! "

""  

  " :

: .

  '" "$ %" ""

* 

  

) *



'" "

"

 "* '"  " 

(

! #  %"

*" '" *"

$% 

1%$ ! "

"" , *

"

 $

 '" %"$ * 

# "* '" % ' *  

  " 7:

3

8 95 . '" 

 "

  '

% '



, '" "*

  %"

"

 

1 !  3( A

5#  %"   

"" 

  '" $

$  (

! #  %"  , '# 

'" *  

  " # %

  "

 

 



"" 

  '

*" "



"

:35 11

6

1 72

 '" $

$  ,% 

'" '

,%  "$

 8

 '

1%$ ! "

""



  " 7:

"

* "# 

'" 

1%$ ! "

""#  %"

 

$

"$%  

  "  "

  " 7:# %"

 " #

'"

  "$%

1%$ ! "

""

  " 7 '" " *

 ?"  " "

" 

     "% 

1%$ ! "

""

"98"*

  ""

  



)

*

) 

" - # '%

" ) *



'"  " 

(

!   %" # 

'" $"

 # % '# "  "*#

*

*  , $% * 

% %

*

11# % '#

* " '

*" 

$$

' '"  '% 1%$ ! "

""

35 11# '

%

%"

8

1%$ ! "

""  "

"% 

- $" 

) . "

" 

%"

* 

*"

$ $$

"

#

"

* "

   %

 "

$"

) <

% %  



'

*"

" 

" ) "

# % '# "* %

"

$" %

"

"* $" " .

$

'

$" "



)# 

"'

%



$" "

  $  

"$$ $$

  

"

"

% %% $



) "

* (% % "

$"

"

"*

"

   <

%'# "

# $

# %"



$ ">"

  # " "



"

$" '%

"





 

" % $  $ '" "

*" 

) *

  

  





"

"

" 6*

 ) 

"$ " 

"

*""

   . $% * % % "$ " ) * 

"

' % 

 "



 

"

" " *" " 



   "%

"

"* 

$"



"



)  "

 "

$ "



*" '%

"

*"  8"* "

*""



 $ '" "

"

) *

  !

"

"# $ 





"

'

8 ) "

"*

 *"



'%%  %

"*



 $$ 

. "% %

'    "



"' (% ) 

8 " "



) . * 98"* "

 $

'"  "

"*%  %"

$

 '% # 6

' '% 

$$"#    "

"%



-"

*

 0%

./- # '%%  $



 

"% *

./-  %"



7 .

 ./- 







*

' "$  "*

"*  

*

  -%"

7

 '

$

6



 #  '"   

./-  '"   ./- 

'" 



*" 

"*

D " (" %"

-( ( %  D " (" %"

%"

" *

6

2# 



'% "'

"*

$"  *"

' "% "   - # =97")# =9   -%"# =9("

 &*"#

=9>"

( % " "

%" 

%"

9'

% -"

"# % '#  '"

"""

$

"* ' * "

*  . '" %

 "



"



 - #



) '

$"

'

*

"

98"* 

 98"*

$

%*

"



 

 "" 

#

"* '



" '

* ' 1%$ ! "

""

"  "

.

/ 

"

'

1%$ ! "

""

% *"

"

8"* "

98"* "

# "

"

$%

8

'

 % "$"

'

8 *"

) *

" 



1%$ ! "

""

$  "'"   

" 

"*

8

$"" 1%$ ! "

""



$

%

"

"



 98"* "

 . $% *

"

 %

98"*  " '

6

" '%

""

$   "* "



"

 ""

8"*   '

"

8

$

" "

$

"



""

"

  

! "

"" ; 1"



 ""



 . * -"

%

"# '%

"" =9# '" )

 98"* "

" %

"



%



 

. "







*

-"

#  "

6*

" ' $

'

"* " "

 

*"

 %"

6

"* 0%

"

*  "

" %

" " - # "

 "



# %

"

 $

#

%

"  



$ * 

%"

**

$  '%

  

'" 8

 % $  - # *

"  )$"

" = # # 

7

"

*"  "





%*

-"

%

" "

  # %

"

6

 



" %"

'

*" %"

%"



-"

"

 "* '"

"""

   0%#  "

$



6





*"

% 

%



0%# )$"

  9 8"* "



*" 

  "

"* %"

% $ *



"

$

 '%

 *" '

%"

"

'%

*" %"

8% 

   . $% " 

"

$$ "



6

" "

"

" " #  '



 "

"4

"

%"

 *

< # " %"

* 

*

 "

6





% 

"  ;"

"

"

" "

6

"

" '

11 

.

%" %" "  "" "

%"

% %

*  """

$ ' ) *  

   -$    $%

  # "



 " 8" %

'

%   

    

  

   

 

  

       



    

 



   

   

     

    







   



  

 

   

     

% &   !

   

  

     "#$% !

          

 

  

                &          

!

 

   

 !

    



   

      

  

#'(    

       

   )  !

   

  "*$% 

  

   

!

   

  

    



"#$   



     

        )  !

  "+$,)  !

       



 &   

      

     

    &

    

             &

   

   7 "

 % '

 *"

"

"

6

"

%    **





8"*



"

98"* 

""

8"* $ % ""



 "

) 

8

) 

11

35 

 '%

'%

"" "

"   $$





1%$ ! "

""#

*    " *

"



8"*



""



" ) * #  

 

% % $

"  "

'% "' 0%#   '% $$ '

"

8"*

 "

"

 " 

  



 "

) 

"

 0%



 

"'

$ '  '# % '# '

8



" "

%

8 '% " "

*

(% '

8 $ 

'

$





"'

- # '% 

%"



"

"

98"* "

 " "

"$" # **

 "

" "  

" ) 

%

'  " %$ *# '% " '%

#  %

" $

$

 

$ ,

(*  $

  "

8

'

) *

) A

 $

"

8" %   -#'  .

             

   

 &       /

  +##        

       

        

         

 & 

&   

 

           

  

      

 ,     /

+## 

   

 

    



     #.0  /1."/  $2 "*'#+$3/45#         

          

 

        



   

  

 /

+##  

     67/

+##  





     

 

    -

8    -    8    -

8    -   

  8    





  

     

      





   



   

 9

   

   

     

   





  

   



 

 ,   

      

    

 

   

 

 

  

  ,

   

 

  





       

 :   



  

     



  

  

    

    

 

      "$ #3,

 

     

   

   

     

   

  

 



 

 

   

      

   

    

    

  

     

          

  

 

    

        

   

    /

+## 

    

 

   

              

     

   

       

 

+

             

  ;

      

        

   

   

   

 /

  



         &       

           

     

  

  

     

 ,    

    /

  +## 

  & 

    

 



          

  

       



 

 

, 

  

 6

66 

8 6   

       6  6  

6    6 



6     

       



 

  



     

  

  ,   

   

                 

   

     ,    

       

<           

     



   

     8 2

  ' "

**">

,

(* 

*"

/ " D /"

)"

&*"

 $ "* "  % #5, 

 /

+##       

 

 

&  



         

 

   

     ,   

      

   

     ,    

  



- 

  

     

  8  .

                     

    

  /

+## 





   

     -        

  

 

   



 8 #3,      

    

/

+##   

  

=  >  = /  9

     *'##"7$/ #+( -#4, /

+## 





  



  

  



  



       

  &  

 ?

   

 

   

       

             

     , 

    

  /

+## 

     

  

  

    

1  

   / )  / @

/ 

  

    :  

       

  

  / )         

    

  

    

  



   8 #(  ,          

        ! /&    A 

 =   /      %

 1     

*'#5"#+$/3B    @ =  )

A 

*'#4"B$/+5'/ >  

  = 

1  .

 *'#B"#5$/+*7,

       /   >   

 "

 $     

 -#',



  

    

   

  

    



   

  

  

    

    "$ 



   



"$ 



   

,

   

 "$     

 ,  

  

     

"$

 "$      



  



 



      ##.

   

    

 

/

+##  & 

 

 

 ,   

 

     

    

 

 

,

      

     

  

   

   

      



 

  

  

&      

 



      ,         

  

          

  

 8 #4, 

 

 

/

+##  

     

     





 

 

  



     

   



  /

+##  

   

 

              

  



 

   

  :  "

  ) * 

,

(*  "

"

% '

%



*

)

8 

" "

'% " "

*

 $"

*"



%"

%"

" 

 "









"'#

8

*  ;%# " 

*

'

$  " "

-



" "

"

" "

"

"

"   ) 

"  . %

'



$" " "

"

"

* "

 

9"

%"



"

"  * $" % '%%  "

) 

"



) 

""

" "% % 6





""

'%%

 %

 

$ " "

 "  "* *# "

"



*

'%

"

%""

%

%#   $"

* "



"

"

'%% " *"



)$"

8

% " . "

 



*

'%% %

%  "

 " $

" 

*"

 %

" $ ""

 

'%% %"

'

"



*

%   * *

)  %

) ""

  $ * ""

%"

)  <8"9   "

' * '% 8* 

 

8 "* " "

"$

) "



8 "* .



* " "

"



"

%



$

$"

) *"

" $ ) 

8  

"* % "  

* 

"



%

" 98"* "





"

  "

=9 -( ( %#



*""

6

"



*"

.



 . "* % " 



"

*

 " "

$

*

6

% " %"



 . "



 '%   *

"

./- 3.

  -"

&5# '

*

 *# % '#

* 

=9   -%" '" """

$ ;%# 

*

" $ '



% "" A"*

" %6

"

 '" ""

"""

$ '%% 6

%"





. "

"* 

  = # # 

7 " "

%" 

%"

'

-"

"# % '# 

"*

"""

$ ;%# '

 

1A( -" "

"



=9-( ( %  %

 98"*

"*  1%$ ! "

""  %"



' "

'% 

( , 

&     

   

    

     

&          

     

  C&       !

&

1 *4'(*'#5 #'4*'#4          

     &     .01  

 *4'(*'#5     .01   

 



    .

 

 





 %#(@  %#3!

& 1 %#5/> 

%#+D/ 

  

1&!

         .

  



   

?/1 

 

  

         



  

      

/ 4 ,       

 

   

 &    

  

 



 .

&      

           

  





 A  

  

   



        

 !        & C

  





       

      .

 

    

 

   

               ('**'#4          #+'**'#4      

     

    /

  +#+  7  !             



     *''7*'#B

 C /

 ) @ &,     &    



     

  

       

 /

 

   

      

    

    / 0    

           

    /

+*3  

  "



  "



#

" "

%"



=9

6

'%

 ""

$  

  "

 98"* "

 $ 

*"

" - #  "

 %

98"*

6

%* "  %"

'

 *"  

* =

-"

" "

"""

$ . *% 

"

% '

"



$

 "" 

*

"""

$ $"







* '

"'"

)

$ ""  

*

"

  # 8"* "



6

 

* 

"

"

*"

"

) 

" % $

 .

$"  "

6* 

"

  # %

"



 

8"*

6

"*

-"

.





%

"



$   "



$$"

'% 

"

%  "

"

% '

$"

*

" 8

'  "

" 3"5 0%  $"

./- 

% '

  % $

"

%

 %







@ 50%  $"

*

% = ./- 

% '

 % "$$

$ @ 35 0% ""

 ""  %

% '

* % ""

@ 3 5 =%%  "%

*

" 

"

"

" ""

%"

'%" % %"

  @ 35 =%

6

" 

% '

" 6

"





*

" $"

6



"* '

"

$"

)@ 3$5 =%

" 

* 

$ # " "





*" "

  "

 '

  

$ @

 350%

"

"

"

)  "

$"

 6



) *



"

) @ 3%5 A*

"

 98"* "

"*

$ " "

"

$ ">"

  @ 35 ," "

$"



'%% 6

"

$%"

$ ""

" 

 7 / 

* 



% %



* ' "

98"* "

 "

"

 8

'



*"

* *



"

9

%

8 ) 

%

"

% % '

) %"

"

$" $ '

8 

 ?" 

%"

"

%"



D

  "

  '%% "*

 %"



   

, #  '



**

 $ * 

%% $

"

 *"  

 $$

  *"

%"

"

" """

$$"

   /

"

%"

"

"



"

$



* 

  

2 ;%# $"  

35

  # 

% % (

! #  %"

%"

 1%$ ! "

""#  %"

  %

  " 22:#

% ' 

8 ) 

35





$% %

$" 

" 1%$ ! "

""

"

"

98"* #

%" ""

8"*  





*"

1%$ ! "

"" %*$



 

"   

"'





)



'"

"

"

'

$

1%$ ! "

""

35

'"



"

"98"* 



"



"



1%$ ! "

"" : .

'

$"







"'

"

'

,

(* # .

"*

'

)$"

" "

8

$ '

"

'  0%

 # "

$*

* 

) * "

1%$ ! "

""#  %"   / 

"

"

   %

"

*

*

    *

  "* "

8

*

" "

%



"

8

""  %

"

"

$ "$   

% "*

 11

"

"  

* 

" !()     -0

0

// "

%  &<   2 E <0 %  

 2 E <0