Gurdeep Singh v. State Of Punjab & ORS
!"
!"
!"
!" #$%&&' ()*+,)-+#,+./ ()*+
&0(0()&$ &$,#, 0.0& #)1.2.)%0+&$,
&,')%&)0, 3 4 3 4 3 4 3 4
3 6
3 6
3 6
3 6 """"
3
3
3
3
$&,&)0 $&,&)0 $&,&)0 $&,&)0 3$ --&/"%78.0&$0+&'&0(0()&$ 3$ .1()%&$9./"%%(0()./%78.0&&)&$./" #)1.2 :;:;:;
:;:;:;
:;:;:;
:;:;:;
"
"
"
" +&(),0.)0<$(0'&0(0()(,%($&80&%.*.(),00+&$%&$ %.0&%= "))&>#$& ?"'.,,&%290+& (,0$(803.).*&$"
#)*$.()" &$@&'#$" $&,')%&)0 () 0&$A, <+(8+ 0+& /.2#$ 8.$0.*& 8)0$.80 .<.$%&% 0 0+& '&0(0()&$ +., 2&&) 8.)8&//&%.)%+&,0.)%,2/.8B/(,0&% )%(,'#0&% .80, .$& 0+.0 0+& '&0(0()&$ +.7()* '.$0(8('.0&%().) 40&)%&$()*'$8&,,<.,.<.$%&%0+&0&)%&$$ /.2#$<$B.0 +(7. %<).)%
%+( %<) ,(0#.0&%.0&)0$&#$#+.$,.+.(" (,0$(80&$@&'#$$0+&9&.$, 4 &'.$.0&.*$&&A&)0,$0+&<$B()$&/.0()00+&0< %<),<&$&&>&8#0&%2&0<&&)0+&'&0(0()&$.)%$&,')%&)0
,'&$8)0$.80.<.$%&%"0+&'&0(0()&$<.,$&,'),(2/&$ .$$.)*()*/.2#$$+.)%/()*.)%0$.),'$0.0()%*$.(),., '&$ $&C#($&A&)0 0+& 8)8&$)&% (,0$(80 3.).*&$ +& '&0(0()&$ <., 2/(*.0&% 0 A.B& )&8&,,.$9 .$$.)*&A&)0 $ /.%()*.)%#)/.%()*$.(/<.9<.*),<(0+()0+&0(A&'&$(% (>&%290+&$.(/<.9.#0+$(0(&,.)%<.,/(.2/&$.)9%&A#$$.*& 0+.0<#/%2&(A',&%290+&$.(/<.9.#0+$(0(&,$/.0&,#''/9 0$.),'$0.0() A&.), $ /.2#$ $ /.%()*D#)/.%()* 0+& $.(/<.9 <.*), $ A7&A&)0 % *$.(), $A 0+& $.(/<.9 '$&A(,&, ?
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
?
.//&*&%%&(8(&)89)0+&'.$00+&'&0(0()&$.,$&*.$%,/.%()* %*$.(),) .)% ()$&/.0()0<+(8+0+& ,+<8.#,&)0(8&,+.%2&&)(,,#&% +&(A'#*)&%$%&$"() (0,&/"<#/%$&7&./0+.00+&/.2#$8)0$.80+.,2&&)8.)8&//&% .)%0+&'&0(0()&$+.,2&&)2/.8B/(,0&%).88#)0+(,+.7()* .//&*&%/9)0.$$.)*&%.%&C#.0&/.2#$)! $/.%()* 0+&$.(/<.9<.*),.03D,
%+(%<) +&(A'#*)&% $%&$$&8(0&,0+.0).88#)0(),#(8(&)0/.2#$")/9! *.00.,F2.*,G<&$&/.%&%)!
.)%0+&2./.)8&<&$& /.%&%)0+&//<()*%.9( & ) )8&%&%/9" ) ,+< 8.#,& )0(8& $ +&.$()* +.% 2&&) .$%&% 0 0+& '&0(0()&$ <(0+ $&*.$% 0 0+& /.%()* %*$.(), ) !
D , $&*.$%, 0+& '$&7(#, ,+< 8.#,& )0(8&, %.0&% E .)% .$& 8)8&$)&%"0+&'&0(0()&$+.%$&,')%&%00+&,.A&"2#00+& 8)0&A'/.0&% .80() 2/.8B/(,0()* +.% )0 2&&) 0.B&) +& .80()" ., ,#8+" (, )0 () 8),).)8& <(0+ 0+& <&// ,&00/&% '$',(0()0+.02/.8B/(,0()*+.,02&'$8&&%&%29.,+<8.#,& )0(8& ).$&8&)0%&8(,()0+&)52/& #'$&A&#$0() $B+. &8#$(09 &$7(8& 7 7&$)A&)0 $B+. &8#$(09 &$7(8& 7 7&$)A&)0 $B+. &8#$(09 &$7(8& 7 7&$)A&)0 $B+. &8#$(09 &$7(8& 7 7&$)A&)0
&/+(
&/+(
&/+(
&/+( .)% .)% .)% .)% 0+&$,"F!GE 0+&$,"F!GE 0+&$,"F!GE 0+&$,"F!GE "(0+.%2&&)+&/%0+.0()$%&$0#/(/ 0+&$&C#($&A&)0 '$()8('/&, ).0#$./1#,0(8& ()0+& 8.,& 2/.8B/(,0()*)0)/9(,.,+<8.#,&)0(8&A.)%.0$9"2#0(0+.% 0#/(/0<$&C#($&A&)0,7(@ (G0+&A.0&$(./D*$#)%,02&,0.0&% <+(8+.88$%()*00+& &'.$0A&)0)&8&,,(0.0&,,#8+.).80() .)%((G'.$0(8#/.$'&)./09D.80()<+(8+(,'$',&%02&0.B&)
7&) 0+&$<(,&" 0+& (A'#*)&% $%&$ (, )&
'&$A.)&)02/.8B/(,0()* ).80()2/.8B/(,0()*$.//0(A&,0 8A&8.))02&,#,0.()&%()7(&<0+&1#%*A&)00+&'&> #$0 () 3D, -#/1. )%#,0$(&, (A(0&% 7 +(& &) 3.).*&$ 3D, -#/1. )%#,0$(&, (A(0&% 7 +(& &) 3.).*&$ 3D, -#/1. )%#,0$(&, (A(0&% 7 +(& &) 3.).*&$ 3D, -#/1. )%#,0$(&, (A(0&% 7 +(& &) 3.).*&$ $1
H0+&$,"!F GE $1
H0+&$,"!F GE $1
H0+&$,"!F GE $1
H0+&$,"!F GE )7(&<0+&.27&"<$(0'&0(0()(,.//<&% $%&$ %.0&%= "))&>#$& ?"(,,&0.,(%& (2&$09"+<&7&$"(, *$.)0&% 0 0+& $&,')%&)04.#0+$(0(&, 0 '.,, .) $%&$ .$&,+ .0&$//<()*%#&'$8&,,/.< = &0(0().//<&% F 6 G F 6 G F 6 G F 6 G F
G F
G F
G F
G
!"
!"
!"
!" 3 3 3 3
0&
0&
0&
0& +&0+&$$&&$$&%0&'$0&$IF &,D G +&0+&$$&&$$&%0&'$0&$IF &,D G +&0+&$$&&$$&%0&'$0&$IF &,D G +&0+&$$&&$$&%0&'$0&$IF &,D G