Makhan Singh v. Financial Commissioner (Appeals) Punjab And ORS
! "# $%&' ( )* +,!,%& -
!!!!!
"#$ "% & ' (
%&
)& ( +,
"
& ' ( -
."/"(0
&
/ " 1 3232,&/ "
! "##$% &#$#' ( " ( (/(&4 " ,25 23+7 $2 +3 23+9 $5& * 5 25 23+9 8
$,& * 2 +7 3+ 2323 $- " * ++- 232, $6 ( &
"'%" &#$#'(#(
:6%3-
4&;
&<=&
(($8& ( ( (& (
$+( " -9 ( ,$ + ) & ( ( ($( & /' "&> <" (0 / / ( & 4 " -9/
+3 +7 $ '$ & "/"( ( ( ;
36 % 3: (($ &($ > %& ' $ $+ 3:
233- 323+6& * , ( ( /
' ? 37 23+6' $7&( ( @ A/' ( @
A323+7 ("
& +9 23+7 ;& ( @ A& $5& ( @ A '/(( ( "
@ A @ A& , ("&@ A 53 +3 23+9' $5
"'%" &#$#'()( , $( / '$( &
'
5$
' $, 25 23+9 &
( '$ ( * 2$ & $, / ' $- ;(&
' " " +6( 0 ' &+::7 "( B ( +$
( "'( +- 232, $6 "&
( ($ ' C / ' &
- C ' (
/ ( * + , ( -
' (("
0 (
' $ 3:
233- $+&
(% ( ( & '
$7& ($ / ((
( & ((( ( " & ( "
1
' " /
"'%" &#$#'('( >/'& / ( " '$ /$ (" ( (
&/ ("/ /"
( (
&($ ' & "$ (& ' " (%* ( >&
&'
' A& '" ( ( & ( '$ $ &8 (' :
0 (
&(& / 8 $2 $6& (/ ( / 323+6 37 23+6 @ A @ A ( 323+7 25 23+7 (& '& (( ' '&/ (( & "/ / $ (
(@ A& $5& * -9 ($ <" / $&
&' '/(/ $ / '$( & '( ( ; & ' "$ .
"'%" &#$#'(%( ")*** &"**' +, -.!,!/, 00-- !
, 1,!, 25 +996 . #%#%# &#$"% 0 2!34- , &, 1,!,,!5 - +- 23+9 #**% &#$"" , -460, ,!5 - -4 .!,!/, 00-- !
,!5 - +6 23+5
&($ "/
("
. ( ( 323+6 ?
' 37 23+6 ( &( ' " ( &
;& @ A& "@
A&/' 323+7 ( ( "
& ,&' +9 23+7& @
A @ A /@ (
( @ A @ A&@ A '$ ( / ' $2 23+7 ($ ( & '$( ( 8 " ( (?("
4 " +3 ;&(
$' /(&
"'%" &#$#'(7(
/ $ 8 @ A&
$5& & /$/
() (
'$
B ' "(( & ( / ( /
4 "' / ;($( / '( / ? '$ ($
; & ' 'C
/&
/ ' / '$ ?
;(& '" / ( (
D'/& -9 <" ' ',5%32 ( :6% 3- (
$
/"36%3: ( ($ "
' '/( ++ ; '& +, 8-69 ,:& 0 2 !34 8-69 ,: , -460, ,!5 -8-69 ,:& (
( ( ? 4 (( ' E +, 8-69 ,:& ( ' (
"'%" &#$#'(;( / 5 ,/ '@ A / '@ A
/ & @ A $5& ;& 0 2!348-69 ,:& /$(/ %// ((&
( (
( '' (%/ /'& &$%/* +2+ +22 & &"&/ "> <" &//(( //
' 4"
E, -460, ,!5
-8-69 ,:& ' / / (
4" ' &/ & ' &$ &8 /@ A&/ " / %* ( ?
' ( ; &
&
" / ?$( &" &
/ $(
&"(
"'%" &#$#'(<(
4 ($ '/ ( ( " 1 &/( ? (
"&
& " & //0
1/ 232!*4 F <
! " #
$ % "