High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15798/2014disposed of

The Superintending Engineer And ANR v. The Presiding Officer And ORS

2023-12-22Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger12 pages

# "

"$%& )&*+,+'-

/& 012&3+-%&-)+-4 -4+-&&35 167+* '38, "&2$3%9&-% $-'%/&3 ......

&%+%+'-&3 :&3,1, /& 3&,+)+-4 ((+*&35 -)1,%3+$7 3+61-$7*19;$6'13 '13%5 134$'- '%/&3,

......

&,2'-)&-%, <!;

0 0 !

3&,&-% 3.

.=.0.

!3$35 ))+%+'-$7 ..

$3>$-$5 2&%+%+'-&3,.

$?+ =19$3 +3)/@$75 )?'*$%& 3.

0$-A$> +%%$75 )?'*$%& 3&,2'-)&-% '.

'-& 3&,2'-)&-% '.

. . 0 !

&%+%+'-&3, /&3&+-$(%&3 3&(&33&) $, 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-% /$?& (+7&) +-,%$-% +?+7 3+% &%+%+'- 1-)&3 3%+*7&,

'-,%+%1%+'- -)+$5 ,&&8+-4 @3+%

-$%13& *&3%+'3$3+ B1$,/+-4 +9214-&) @$3) )$%&) .

--&C13& 5 2$,,&) -)1,%3+$7 3+61-$7*19;$6'13 '13%5 134$'- /&3&+-$(%&3 3&(&33&) $, <%/& 3+61-$7<5 @/&3&6> 3&(&3&-*& +-)1,%3+$7 )+,21%& 3&4$3)+-4 %&39+-$%+'- ,&3?+*&, 3&,2'-)&-% '.

@'389$-5 -$9&7>5

$9 !/$A /&3&$(%&3 3&(&33&) $, <3&,2'-)&-%@'389$-< $-,@&3&) /+, ($?'13 /'7)+-4

3&,2'-)&-%@'389$- &-%+%7&) 3&+-,%$%&9&-% ,&3?+*& '- ,$9& 2',% @/+*/ /& /'7)+-4 23+'3 %&39+-$%+'- /+, ,&3?+*&, @+%/ $77 7&4$7 6&-&(+%, $, /& 4&%%+-4 $% %+9& (3'9 )$%& %&39+-$%+'- +.&.

%+77 3&+-,%$%&9&-%.

% (13%/&3 '3)&3&) $(%&3 3&+-,%$%&9&-%5 3&,2'-)&-%@'389$- @'17) 6& &-%+%7&) +-%&3&,% $% 3$%& 2&3 $--19 '- @+%//&7) $9'1-% ,$7$3> (3'9 )$%& ,$9& 6&+-4 )1& %+77 2$>9&-%.

!3+&(7>5 3&,2'-)&-%@'389$- 3$+,&) $- +-)1,%3+$7 )+,21%& 3&4$3)+-4 %&39+-$%+'- /+, ,&3?+*&,.

/& ,$+) )+,21%& 3&(&33&) $)A1)+*$%+'- 3+61-$7 6&7'@.

*7$+9 ,%$%&9&-%5 3&,2'-)&-%@'389$- ,%$%&) /& @'38+-4 '- 2',% 192 2&3$%'3 1-)&3 "5 167+* &$7%/ 134$'- $% %16&@&77 @$%&3 ,1227> !1,%&3 '.

$% ?+77$4& /$93'A5 &/,+7 0'/$-$5 "+,%3+*% 134$'- ,+-*&

*'-%+-1'1,7>5 @+%/'1% $-> 63&$8 ,$%+,($*%+'- 3&,2'-)&-% '.

0$32$-*/ 3$9 $-*/$>$%5 /$93'A 167+* &$7%/ "&2$3%9&-% 1%/'3+%+&,((+*&3,.

&,2'-)&-%@'389$- *7$+9&) /+, -$9& 9$+-%$+-&) 3&4+,%&3 3$9 $-*/$>$%5 /$93'A *'-*&3-&) 167+* &$7%/ "&2$3%9&-%5 /'@&?&35 /+, ,&3?+*&, @&3& %&39+-$%&) @+%/'1% $-> 3&$,'- '- .

&,2'-)&-%@'389$- *7$+9&) $% %+9& %&39+-$%+'- /+, ,&3?+*&,5 /& 4&%%+-4 ,$7$3>

2&3 9'-%/ $(%&3 %&39+-$%+'- /+, ,&3?+*&,5 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-% $22'+-%&) ,'9& '%/&3 2&3,'- /+, 27$*& /& /$?+-4 -'

,'13*& +-*'9& $(%&3 %&39+-$%+'- /+, ,&3?+*&,.

**'3)+-47>5 /& 23$>&) 3&+-,%$%&9&-% ,&3?+*& @+%/ *'-,&B1&-%+$7 6&-&(+%,.

/& $('3&,$+) *7$+9 3&,2'-)&-%@'389$- *'-%&,%&) 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-%5 +-%&3 $7+$5 '- 27&$ 9$+-%$+-$6+7+%> *7$+9 3&,2'-)&-%@'389$-.

% *$,& 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-% 3&,2'-)&-% @'389$- -&+%/&3 $22'+-%&) '- 2',% 192 %%&-)$-%2&3$%'3 $4$+-,% $-> ,$-*%+'-&) 2',% -'3 /+, -$9& $22&$3&) '- 91,%&3 3'77.

% (13%/&3 ,%$%&) %/&3& 3&,'71%+'- 3$9 $-*/$>$%5 /$93'A 3&4$3)+-4 $-> 2$>9&-% 6&+-4 9$)& 3&,2'-)&-%@'389$-.

% *$%&4'3+* *$,& 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-% %/&3& &C+,%&) -'

3&7$%+'-,/+2 9$,%&3 ,&3?$-% 6&%@&&- %/&9 3&,2'-)&-%@'389$- 3$%/&35 3&,2'-)&-%@'389$- $- &927'>&& 3$9 $-*/$>$%5 /$93'A.

/& *7$+9 3&,2'-)&-%@'389$- )&-+&) 23$>&3 9$)& )+,9+,,$7 *7$+9 ,%$%&9&-%.

% $22&$3, 3$9 $-*/$>$%5 /$93'A )+) -'% $22&$3 6&('3& 3+61-$7 6&7'@ $**'3)+-47> 23'*&&)&) $4$+-,% &C2$3%& '-

3'9 27&$)+-4, 2$3%+&,5 ('77'@+-4 +,,1&, @&3& (3$9&)

! # $ %& .

'3)&3 23'?& /+, *$,&5 3&,2'-)&-%@'389$- $22&$3&) @+%-&,, 6'C $, 5 18&,/ =19$35 $96$3)$3 $,

&C/+6+%&)

*'2+&, $%%&-)$-*& 3&4+,%&3 C.

*'2+&, 3&*&+2% )+,613,&9&-% ,$7$3> C.

- '%/&3 /$-)5 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-% &C$9+-&) 3&9 0+-4/ 0+-4/$75 0" $,

$9&,/ /$-) $-@$3 $, .

/& 3+61-$7 6&7'@ )&*+)&) 3&(&3&-*&5 ?+)& +9214-&) $@$3) )$%&) .

--&C13& .

$('3&9&-%+'-&) *+3*19,%$-*&,5 %/+, 2&%+%+'- /$, 6&&- (+7&) 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-% 6&('3& %/+, '13%5 $77'@+-4 *7$+9 3&,2'-)&-% @'389$-.

;&$3-&) 0%$%& *'1-,&7 $22&$3+-4 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-% ,169+%, 3+61-$7 6&7'@ /$, &33&) 7$@ ($*% )&*+)+-4 3&(&3&-*& ($?'13 3&,2'-)&-%@'389$- +4-'3+-4 ($*% %/&3& -'

3&7$%+'-,/+2 9$,%&3 ,&3?$-% 6&%@&&- 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-% 3&,2'-)&-%@'389$-E %/&3&('3&5 23'?+,+'-, 0&*%+'-

-)1,%3+$7 "+,21%&, *%5 /&3&+-$(%&3 3&(&33&) $, < *%< $3& -'% $227+*$67&.

**'3)+-47>5 +% +, 23$>&) +9214-&) $@$3) ,&% $,+)&.

&3 *'-%3$5 7&$3-&) *'1-,&7 $22&$3+-4 3&,2'-)&-%@'389$- /$, '22',&) 23$>&3 9$)& 7&$3-&) 0%$%& *'1-,&7 $22&$3+-4 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-% ,169+%%+-4 3+61-$7 6&7'@ /$, 2$,,&) $ @&77 3&$,'-&) A1,%+(+&) $@$3)5 @/+*/ )'&, -'% *$77 $-> +-%&3(&3&-*& %/+, '13%.

% +, ,169+%%&) 3+61-$7 6&7'@ /$, 2$,,&) $@$3) '- 6$,+, 9$%&3+$7&?+)&-*& 27$*&) 6&('3& +%.

**'3)+-47>5 23$>&3 /$, 6&&- 9$)& )+,9+,,$7 +-,%$-% @3+% 2&%+%+'-.

/$?& /&$3) 7&$3-&) *'1-,&7 3&,2&*%+?& 2$3%+&, /$?&

2&31,&) 2$2&36''8 @+%/ %/&+3 $67& $,,+,%$-*&.

3'9 3&*'3)5 +% +, '6,&3?&) '- 6&/$7( "&2$3%9&-%5 '-& 0/3+ 3&9 0+-4/ 0+-4/$75 0"5 167+* &$7%/ -4+-&&3+-45 "+?+,+'- 0'/-$ &C$9+-&) $, /+, *3',,&C$9+-$%+'-5 /& $)9+%%&) ?+77$4& /$93'A5 %/&3& $3& 2192, 61% /& *'17) -'% %&77 $, /'@ 9$-> '2&3$%'3, @&3& @'38+-4 >&$3

& (13%/&3 ,%$%&) '- 6&/$7( "&2$3%9&-%5

2&3 9'-%/ 2&3 /&$) @&3& )&2',+%&) $-*/$>$% '2&3$%+-4 %16&@&77.

& $)9+%%&) %/&3& &C+,%, $ 7'4 6''8 %16&@&77 @/+*/ +, 9$+-%$+-&) "&2$3%9&-%.

& $)9+%%&) C.

+, $ 7'4 6''85 '- @/+*/ ,+4-$%13&, %/&- ..

$3& &C+,%+-4 $7,'

$%%&-)$-*& 2&%+%+'-&3 3&,2'-)&-% '.

@'389$- /&3&+-.

0%+77 (13%/&35 '-& 0/3+

$9&,/ /$-) $-@$3 &C$9+-&) $,

"&2$3%9&-% 3&7&?$-% &C%3$*% /+, *3',,&C$9+-$%+'- 3&$), $, 1-)&3

' "

( )'

) # %

* +

( %

)

,,-

* +

( ' %

)

,,-

* +/ ( (

( %

( !%

1 (!

!% 1 ! (

( !

$!+

(

,,-%

(

,,- (

(

,,-/ (

(

' %

(

( %

$ 3%4%

( ' ) )(!

* +

3%4%

,,"

3%4%

* +/ (! !

! * % (!

(

! ' %

( *

% * + !(

(

!( (

/ (

! %

$!+

(

* +

%#% ,,

.% % ,,-%

$!+

( %

( '

3'9 2&31,$7 $('3&,$+) *3',,&C$9+-$%+'- @+%-&,,&,

&C$9+-&) 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-%5 %/&3& +, -'

9$--&3 )'16% 3&4$3)+-4 3&7$%+'-,/+2 &927'>&3 &927'>&& 6&%@&&- 2&%+%+'-&3 "&2$3%9&-% 3&,2'-)&-% '.

@'389$-.

/& 3+61-$7 6&7'@ /$, $7,'

3&%13-&) (+-)+-4 %16&@&77

@/&3& 3&,2'-)&-% '.

@'389$- @'38+-45 ,$9& 6&7'-4, 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-% &?&- /+, ,$7$3> 6&+-4 3&7&$,&) 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-% $7%/'14/ ,$9& 6&+-4 )+,613,&) %/3'14/ $4&-*> 0$23$-*/ 3$9 $-*/$>$% /$93'A.

/&3&('3&5 (+-)+-4 3+61-$7 6&7'@ %/&3& &C+,%, 3&7$%+'-,/+2 &927'>&3 &927'>&& 6&%@&&- 2$3%+&, +, 12/&7).

13%/&35 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-% /$) -'% 23')1*&) &+%/&3 6&('3& 3+61-$7 6&7'@ '3 6&('3& %/+, '13% $-> 9$%&3+$7 ,/'@ 6&('3& )+,2&-,+-4 @+%/ ,&3?+*&, 3&,2'-)&-% '.

@'389$-5 23'?+,+'-, 0&*%+'- !

*% @&3& *'927+&) @+%/.

$6,&-*& $-> 9$%&3+$7 +-)+*$%& 23'?+,+'-, 0&*%+'-

*% @&3& *'927+&) @+%/ @/+7& %&39+-$%+-4 ,&3?+*&, 3&,2'-)&-% '.

@'389$-5 $**'3)+-47>5 +% /$, 6&&- /&7) %&39+-$%+'- ,&3?+*&, 3&,2'-)&-% '.

@'389$- 6$) -'-*'927+$-*& 23'?+,+'-, 0&*%+'-

*%.

% %/+, ,%$4&5 B1&,%+'- 6& *'-,+)&3&) +, 3&4$3)+-4 3&7+&( @/+*/ 3&,2'-)&-% '.

@'389$- +, &-%+%7&) %'.

% %+9& +,,1$-*& -'%+*& 9'%+'-5 &-('3*&9&-% +9214-&) $@$3) ,%$>&) $4$+-,% 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-%.

2&31,$7 2$2&36''8 @'17) (13%/&3 +-)+*$%& $- $((+)$?+% )$%&)

(+7&) C&*1%+?& -4+-&&35 167+* &$7%/ -4+-&&3+-4 "+?+,+'-5 0'/-$5 "+,%3+*% 13143$95 @/&3&+- +% /$, 6&&- ,%$%&) $, 1-)&3

(! /

(

! ! +!

(! !

! ! *

! %

(

*+ ! !

(( /

9( ! %& .

2$3% (3'9 $6'?&5 %/&3& +, -'%/+-4 '- 3&*'3) ,/'@ @/+7& &-4$4+-4 ,&3?+*&, 3&,2'-)&-% '.

@'389$-5 $-> )1& 23'*&)13& ('77'@&) -'3 +% /$, 6&&- ,/'@- 3&,2'-)&-% '.

@'389$- &-4$4&) $4$+-,% $-> ,$-*%+'-&)3&417$3 2',%.

% +, @&77 ,&%%7&) -'@ @/&3&?&3 %&39+-$%+'- ,&3?+*&, $ @'389$- $3& /&7) 6& 6$)

-'-*'927+$-*& 23'?+,+'-, 0&*%+'-

*%5 43$-% 3&7+&( 3&+-,%$%&9&-% '%/&3 *'-,&B1&-%+$7 6&-&(+%, +, -'% $1%'9$%+* ,$9& )&2&-), 12'- ?$3+'1, ($*%'3,.

) $

% :

; 5 ( 2

1 (5

0 '-<67& 0123&9& '13% /&7) <%

(!/ ( =( /

/ !(

(

9( !

+( ( % $

/ 9( !

> ( / /

( (

(

,% 1

9( (

! ?

( (

+( % @) 3 ( ' 8(

% $ 8 %/

,,.# )=1 AA

C ,,. )== .6#D/ :

% !(!/

,,A )=1 A"6 ,,A- )=8;4 "<AD E 2 ' =

% :%=% 3 /

,,A )=1 -.

,,A" )=8;4 -#-D%F .

1 = % = )

) ;%

% )( G( 5

0...

'-<67& 0123&9& '13% /&7) % * /

( % * !

( % 1 ( =(

( ) 8 ( '

(

8/ <#A 9(

(

( % 2

( / /

/ (

/ ( /

H%/ !

( (

(

( !

% 2 ( ! >

(

(! !

! !

!( ! (

)

! ! !

*%:% I $

% $( ) /

,,-" )=1 --< C ,,-- )== -<D/

J6% 1

( (!

( !(

)

-?2 8/ !

( ! %

/ ( / / /

/ /

9( 9( +!

( ! !

! %

/ %

( / ! ( !

! !

% I /

/ !

%% /

(

9( / ( !

% 8

/ 9(

( % (

? (

%J& .

$8+-4 -'%& ($*% 2&%+%+'-&3 /$) *'-%+-1'1,7> @'38&) @+%/ 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-% )3$@+-4 9'-%/7> ,$7$3>

$% %+9& /+, $77&4&) %&39+-$%+'-E ,&3?+*&, 2&%+%+'-&3 /$) 6&&- %&39+-$%&) ?+'7$%+'- 23'?+,+'-, 0&*%+'-

*% $7,'

*'-,+)&3+-4 3&,2'-)&-%@'389$- /$, 6&&- 7+%+4$%+-4 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-% ,+-*&

$9 *'-,+)&3&) '2+-+'- +-,%&$) 3&+-,%$%&9&-% ,&3?+*&5 $ ,19 *'92&-,$%+'- 6& $@$3)&) 3&,2'-)&-%@'389$-.

**'3)+-47>5 *'-,+)&3+-4 %'%$7+%> *+3*19,%$-*&, $7,'

(+-)+-4 ($*% 3&*'3)&) 3+61-$7 6&7'@ %/&3& +, 3&7$%+'-,/+2 &927'>&3 &927'>&& 6&%@&&- 2&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%9&-% 3&,2'-)&-% @'389$- /+, ,&3?+*&, @&3& %&39+-$%&) @+%/'1% *'927>+-4 @+%/ 23'?+,+'-, 0&*%+'-

*%5 3&,2'-)&-%@'389$- +, 43$-%&) $ ,19 *'92&-,$%+'-

&%+%+'-&3"&2$3%&9&-% +, )+3&*%&) 2$> *'92&-,$%+'-

3&,2'-)&-%@'38$- @+%/+- $ 2&3+') %/3&& 9'-%/, (3'9 )$%& 3&*&+2%23')1*%+'- *&3%+(+&) *'2> %/+, '3)&3.

*$,&

-'-2$>9&-% $('3&,$+) $9'1-% 2&%+%+'-&3 @+%/+- ,%+217$%&) 2&3+')5 2&%+%+'-&3 ,/$77 6& &-%+%7&)

*7$+9 ,+927& +-%&3&,% $% 3$%& D 2&3 $--19 %+77 %+9& ,1*/ 2$>9&-% +, -'% 9$)&.

/& +-,%$-% @3+% 2&%+%+'- +, )+,2',&) $('3&,%$%&) %&39,.

2&-)+-4 $227+*$%+'-,5 +( $->5 ,/$77 ,%$-) *7',&).

0 !

,A8, /&%/&3 ,2&$8+-43&$,'-&) #&,

/&%/&3 3&2'3%$67& #&,