← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1418/2016dismissed

Haryana Waqf Board v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2017-11-06Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mrs. Justice Archana Puri6 pages

       

 !"

#$% &%'()(*+

,  



     

   !+ - .!//  .

- .!/0 /.. 1%)%*$+ !1234&(5/(*678&9'#$% 1 !1!#4(:8&9'#$% 1$7%5%$($(*%1 !1*:31!($$#48&&($(*#4&9'#$%%*%1#48#1;#*#8 !1/7(9%*&1#/<#15#*&!1!#*= 7#*:7#18 ))()$#*$&9'#$%%*%1#4)8#1;#*#  #=%)7 (*&#4 7%51%)%*$5%$($(*7#)>%%* (4%&>;#1;#*##:

#1& '4#(?(*6$7#$#'@3()($(* 4#*&<*%&>;($7#)4#5)%&(*9(%< /%'$(*

"    $7%  (67$  $  #(1  ?5%*)#$(*  #*&  1#*)5#1%*';  (*  .#*& '@3()($(*8%7#>(4($#$(*#*&%)%$$4%?%*$'$8

A 1>1%9($;8-$7%

A'$-"8#)($())$(44(*5))%))(*$7%1% 7%5))%))(*'34&*$>% $#:%*#)'*)$13'$(*<#)%B()$(*6$7%1%*

  .%#1*%&'3*)%4 1$7%5%$($(*%1)3>?($$%&$7#$(*$7%'#)%(* 7#*&8  %9%*  $7367  *$( ('#$(*)  3*&%1  /%'$(*)   #*&      $7%  .#*& '@3()($(*'$8 C  1)71$8-$7% C '$-"<%1%())3%&*A 

#*& 



D8  1%)5%'$(9%4;  *$( ;(*6  D

 #'1%)    4#*&8  7<%9%18 #'@3()($(*5%1$#(*(*6$C :#*#4)#*&,?#14#) 4#*&7#)4#5)%&8#) 5))%))(*$7%1% <#)*$$#:%**$%1?) /%'$(*

A'$

14#5)(*6 #'@3()($(*8%($7%1 $7%$<'*&($(*)8*#?%4;8%($7%1**E 5#;?%*$ '?5%*)#$(*15))%))(* $7%4#*&87#)$>%)#$() (%&8 7%*'%8$7%#'@3()($(*(*$7%51%)%*$'#)%7#)4#5)%& *$7%$7%17#*&84%#1*%&'3*)%4 1$7%/$#$%8*(*)$13'$(*)

1? *35  /(*678#(>  %7)(4&#18 

('%   .#*&  '@3()($(* 

('%18 ())#18)3>?($$%&$7#$3$ $7%$$#44#*&<*%&>;$7%5%$($(*%18<7('7 <#)  *$( (%&  1  #'@3()($(*8    :#*#4)  #*&    ?#14#)    4#*&8  <7%1% )$13'$31%)<%1%%B()$(*6#)<#)1%4%#)%& 1?#'@3()($(*11%)$ $7%4#*&8#<#1&<#)#**3*'%&>;$7%.#*&#'@3()($(*44%'$1 1 )71$8  -$7%  44%'$1-"  * 

,  )  $7%  4#*&  <#)  4;(*6  9#'#*$8 5))%))(*$7%1% <#)$#:%*>;$7%#3$71($(%)9(&%1#5#$ &#$%&

, FA1&  $7%$$#4'?5%*)#$(*#?3*$(*6$  

8,8  FE <#)&%5)($%&(*'31$ &&($(*#4 ()$1('$3&6%8/(1)#<#;>#':(*$7% ;%#1

8#)$7%1%<#)'%1$#(*&()53$%5%1$#(*(*6$#551$(*?%*$

'?5%*)#$(*8 <7%1%#)5#1$ $7#$#?3*$(*6$  ,8A 8, FE()4;(*6 &%5)($%&<($7$7% 44%'$18<7('7$7%5%$($(*%1*%9%1'4#(?%&&%)5($% *$('%1$7%# 1%)#(&#?3*$8$7%5%$($(*%1?#;>%%*$($4%&$1%'%(9% (*$%1%)$*#''3*$ &%4#;%&5#;?%*$ '?5%*)#$(*8(*#''1&#*'%<($7

A 4#<7%5%$($(*%17#&'?54%$%:*<4%&6% $7%#<#1&#)>=%'$(*) <%1% (4%&>;($3*&%1/%'$(* $7% C '$*)?%51$(* $7% #'@3(1%&4#*&83*#3$71()%&'*)$13'$(*<#)1#()%&# $%1#**3*'%?%*$

#<#1&#*&<7%*5))%))(*$7%1% 7#&>%%*$#:%*>;$7%#3$71($(%)8$7% /$#$%()%*$($4%&$1%?9%$7%'*)$13'$(**)3551$ $7%#163?%*$)87% 1%4(%&35*$7%=3&6%?%*$ *->4%$7%/351%?%31$(* !#7#9(1#*& $7%1)9*(* *&(##*&#*$7%18

,D" A  .%#1*%&  '3*)%4  1  $7%  /$#$%  31$7%1  )3>?($$%&  $7#$  $7% 5%$($(*%17#&%#14(%1'7#44%*6%&$7%#'@3()($(**?%1($)>; (4(*6 

C 

8<7('7<#) &()?())%& >; $7()'31$ * ,,

%$($(* 1/5%'(#4.%#9%$55%#4"C

C#6#(*)$$7%)#?% <#)&()?())%&#)<($7&1#<*>;$7%5%$($(*%1*D,

$%*#>4%($$ (4% >=%'$(*))%%:(*64#5)(*6 #'@3()($(*3*&%1/%'$(*

A '$ %#1&4%#1*%&'3*)%4 1$7%5#1$(%)#*&5%13)%&$7%5#5%1 >: *$7%51%)%*$'#)%8*$( ('#$(*)3*&%1/%'$(*) #*& $7%  C '$ <%1%())3%&*A 

#*&



D81%)5%'$(9%4;7% #<#1&<#)#**3*'%&>;$7%44%'$1*

,3$ $7%$$#44#*& <*%&>;$7%5%$($(*%18 :#*#4)#*&?#14#) 4#*&8<7%1%'*)$13'$(* (*$7% 1? %B()$%&51(1$$7%())3#*'% *$( ('#$(*3*&%1 /%'$(*  $7% C '$<#)1%4%#)%& 1?#'@3()($(*# $%1#''%5$(*6$7% >=%'$(*) (4%&>;$7%5%$($(*%1%)$ $7%4#*&8>%(*69#'#*$#$$7#$ )$#6%8  <#)  *$( (%&  1  #'@3()($(*  3$    $7%  $$#4  '?5%*)#$(*8 

8,8  FE<%1%&%5)($%&>;$7%/$#$%<($7&&($(*#4 ()$1('$3&6%8 /(1)#8<#;>#':(*$7%;%#1

8<7%1%#),8A 8, FE#1%4;(*6&%5)($%&

  <($7$7%44%'$17%5%$($(*%1()(*:*<4%&6% $7() #'$#)*$('%<#) &34;  )%19%&  $  ()  %9(&%*$  1?  $7%  #'$  $7#$  $7%  5%$($(*%1  7#&  (4%& >=%'$(*)  3*&%1  /%'$(*      $7%   C  '$  )%%:(*6  %*7#*'%?%*$  

'?5%*)#$(* %)5($%*$('%8$7%5%$($(*%1 #(4%&$<($7&1#<$7#$#?3*$

1?$7%44%'$1$7#))5%'( ('#44;>%%*'4#(?%&>;4%#1*%&'3*)%4 1 $7%/$#$%$7#$5))%))(* $7%#'@3(1%&4#*&<#)$#:%**

,8 1 <7('7%9%*1#5#$ <#)#4)%*$%1%&#)$7%)#?%<#)4;(*69#'#*$8 7<%9%187% #(14;)$#$%&$7#$# $%1$7%#'@3()($(*8*'%1$#(*51$(* $7% 4#*&3*#3$71()%&- -'4#))'*)$13'$(*<#)1#()%&8<7('7$7%/$#$%() %*$($4%&$&%?4()7 *->4%$7%/351%?%31$(*!#7#9(1#*&$7%1)-'#)%)351#" 5(*%&$7#$(*'#)%)<7%1%$7%1%()&%4(>%1#$%#'$ $7%4#*&<*%1)(**$ '44%'$(*6$7%'?5%*)#$(*8/%'$(*

A'$&%)*$'?% $$7%(11%)'3%7%519()(*)'?%$$7%1%)'3% $7)%5%1)*)8<7#1% &%51(9%& '?5%*)#$(*8>3$*$ 1$7)%<7&%4(>%1#$%4;&*$1%'%(9% ($#(431%$&%5)($'?5%*)#$(*(*'31$3*&%1/%'$(*A" $7% '$(*)3'7'#)%)<34&*4;#$$1#'$%&(*$%1%)$8#)%*9()#6%&3*&%1/%'$(* A  $7% C '$#*&$7%519()(*) /%'$(*

A'$ '#**$>%(*9:%&(*)3'7'#)%)7%1%4%9#*$5#1#) 1?$7%# 1%)#(& =3&6?%*$#1%%B$1#'$%&>%4<+E

*  31  5(*(*8  $7%  '#)%)  (*  <7('7  $7%1%  () &%4(>%1#$%#'$(* $7%<*%1) 1*$'44%'$(*6$7% '?5%*)#$(*  #*&  $7%;  &  *$  <#*$  $  1%'%(9%  ($8 )%'$(*

A'$&%)*$'?%$$7%(1 1%)'3%#)519()(*)#1%$7%45$7)%5%1)*)<7#1% &%51(9%&    '?5%*)#$(*  >3$  *$  1  $7)%  <7 &%4(>%1#$%4;  7#&  *$  1%'%(9%&  ($  #*&  4($(6#$%&  1 &%'#&%)  1  @3#)7(*6    51'%%&(*6)  #9(&(*6  $

D 1%'%(9%  '?5%*)#$(*  >; <(44 34  #'$  7%  #(431%  $ &%5)($  (*  '31$  3*&%1  )%'$(*  A"  (*  )3'7  '#)%) <34&#$$1#'$*4;(*$%1%)$#)%*9()#6%&3*&%1)%'$(* A  $7%'$#*&$7%519()(*) )%'$(* '#**$>% )(*9:%&(*)3'7'#)%)

 *$7%(*)$#*$'#)%8$7%'4#(?7#)>%%*?#&%*$ *4;  >%4#$%&4;8  >3$  *%($7%1  $7%  5%$($(*%1)  *1  $7%(1 51%9(3)$71%%6%*%1#$(*)7#&%9%1#551#'7%&#*;

$7%#3$71($(%)(*<1($(*6 1'4#(?(*6'?5%*)#$(*   1%51%)%*$#$(*  7#&  %9%1  >%%*  (4%&  <($7  #*;

#3$71($;8  **%  7#)  >%%*  #**%B%&  #*&  $7%1%  ()  * #9%1?%*$  ?#&%  (*  $7%  5%$($(*  $7#$  #*;  )3'7 1%51%)%*$#$(*7#&%9%1>%%* (4%&7%'4#(?#55%#1) *$*4;)$#4%#*&&%#&>3$%B$1%?%4;'43&%&7()<% #1%?%*$(*(*6#)#&&($(*#41%#)*)8#))3'7'4#(?) *$*4;)3

%1 1?&%4#;#*&4#'7%)>3$'31$)#1%*$ )355)%&$%*$%1$#(*)3'7'4#(?) %)(&%))3'7'4#(?) >%'?%&3>$ 348'#**$>%1%'%(9%& 1'*)(&%1#$(* >%(*6>#11%&&3%$&%4#;#*&4#'7%)

7%(6731$7#)1(67$4;>)%19%&$7#$)3'7 '4#(?)'#**$>%5%1?($$%&$>%1#()%&(*$7%'31$8 #*&'#**$>%#&=3&('#$%&#)$7%;#1%>#11%&7%(67 31$7#)1(67$4;>)%19%&$7#$)3'7'4#(?)'#**$>%# )3>=%'$?#$$%1 (*@3(1;# $%1$7%4#5)% #1%#)*#>4% 5%1(& $(?%#*&>%*% ('(#4519()(*) )%'$(*

A'$#1%*$#9#(4#>4%$)3'7(*'3?>%*$) *315(*(*8/%'$(* '#**$1%9(9%$7)%'4#(?) $7#$#1%&%#&#*&)$#4%H 5%13)#4 $7%1&%15#))%&>;$7()'31$(*%#14(%1(9(41($ %$($(*

C

(4%&>;$7%5%$($(*%1)7<)$7#$5))%))(*

$7%#'@3(1%&4#*&<#)$#:%*>;$7%/$#$%7%# 1%)#(& (*&(*6)7#9%*$ >%%*)%$#)(&%>;*->4%$7%/351%?%31$8#)/5%'(#4.%#9%%$($(* #6#(*)$$7%=3&6?%*$ $7()'31$<#)&()?())%&#)<($7&1#<*

 *)(&%1(*6$7%# 1%)#(& #'$)8(*319(%<8*'#)%()?#&% 3$  1&%'4#1(*6 $7#$ $7%#'@3()($(*(*@3%)$(*7#)4#5)%&7%<1($ 5%$($(*()8#''1&(*64;8&()?())%& #=%)7 (*&#4"

3&6% 319(*&%1/(*67(44"

3&6% 

, ?:F9) 7%$7%1)5%#:(*6F1%#)*%&+

%)F 7%$7%11%51$#>4%+

%)F