High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15872/2014allowed

Oriental Insurance Company Ltd v. Narender Singh & ANR

2017-12-19Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath3 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

!"# #$%&%'() ) ) )

*#+%#'"!,'&-+!'$#./!'01%.%"#2 #"%"%'#+ 3& !+%'2#+%'4*!'2!'"*#+ #&/'2#'"& 5( 5( 5( 5(6 15 775 6 15 775 6 15 775 6 15 775 +#&#'"( 5+&*8!'%!,8!+92:$!"#9

+"*#/#"%"%'#+ 5++-'7-.!+ !;&*%92:$!"#9

++#&/'2#'" 5&3!'2!'!5!,*"+!92:$!"#9

++#&/'2#'" 775 9 775 9 775 9 775 9 *# /#"%"%'#+9 %'&-+!'$# $./!'09 %& !44+%#:#2 !4!%'&" "*# !8!+2 "*#.<-2&.!'2!"#2 = ' <+%# 9 "*# "+-$; <#!+%'4 >) ))9 8'#2 <0 !+%'2#+%'4*?+#&/'2#'"@98!&%'&-+#28%"*"*#/#"%"%'#+ +"*# /#+%2 +. A " ' A 98*%,#"*#&!%2"+-$;8!& ' %"& 8!0 " +%'!4!+9 $!++0%'4 "*# ,!2 8*#!" +. *,!"*9 !..-

#/" 2 +/+!"%' '2%! BC9 #,, %' ! 4+4# !'2 &-

#+#2 #D"#'&%:#2!.!4#'# 2!"#2 A 8!&"*-&+#4%&"#+#2!" ,%$#&"!"%'9 !.<!'9 ' "*# 2!"# $$-++#'$# 2!"#2 A 9-'2#+ #$"%'&

)E== "*# $$+2%'4 " "*# /#"%"%'#+9 "*# "+-$; 8!& <#%'4 2+%:#' <0 !+/+##"%'4*98*&#'!.#*!&<##'+#$+2#2%'"*#$*!,,!' +.%&&-#2<0

"*# %&"+%$"5!'!4#+9!'2#:#'<0+#&/'2#'"8*#'*#/-"-/"*# $,!%. +"*#,&&$!-&#2""*#:#*%$,#8#:#+9%'"*#$*!,,!'9/+#&#'"#2 <0"*#/,%$#%' 2!"#2 A 9+#&/'2#'"4"*%&'!.# %'$,-2#2!&!'!$$-&#2%'+2#+"$,!%."*#%'&-+!'$#8*#+#!&"*#2+%:#+ !+/+##"%'4*&E !,;!+%'4**!2&-

#+#2%'F-+%#&%'"*#&!%2!$$%2#'"' "*#&!.#2!0!'2'%'F-+08!&&-

#+#2!"!,,<0+#&/'2#'""*-4* "*#"+-$;8!&!""!,,&&!&%"8!&#D"#'&%:#,02!.!4#2*#/#"%"%'#+*!2 !&;#2+#&/'2#'""/+:%2#"*#2+%:%'4,%$#'&# !+/+##"%'4*&E

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

?@ ?%:%,@ ) " $'"#'2 "*!" "*# +#/+" &-<.%""#2 <0 "*# %':#&"%4!"+$!''":#++%2#"*#+#/+" "*#/,%$# *!:# *#!+2 ,#!+'#2 $-'&#, + "*# /!+"%#& !'2 /#+-&#2 "*# +#$+2 *#+#%&!'%'"#+#&"%'4 #!"-+#%'"*%&$!&#8*%$**!&'"<##' '"%$#2<0"*#.<-2&.!'!'2%#"*#%'F-+0$!-&#2""*#2+%:#+*#+#%&

= ' 2#'%!, " "*# !$" "*!" !+/+##" %'4* &E !,;!+ %'4* *!2 &-

#+#2 %'F-+%#&'"*#&!.#2!0%'"*#!$$%2#'"8*#+#!&'%'F-+08!&&-

#+#2!"!,, <0 +#&/'2#'" *# /*"4+!/*& !//#'2#2 8%"* "*# /#"%"%' !& ''#D-+#)!+# "*#.!'4,#2+#.!%'& "*#%'&-+#2"+-$;8*%$*"#,,& !'"*#+&"+0!2+#&/'2#'"<##'2+%:%'4"*#&!%2"+-$;98*%$**!2

!,,#'%'!2##/4+4# !<-" EA "9"*#'*#8-,2*!:#!,&&-

#+#2 &#+%-& %'F-+%#& <-" "*# :#+0 !$" "*!" *# 2%2 '" &-

#+ !'0 %'F-+0 !'2 !+/+##"%'4*&E !,;!+%'4**!2&-

#+#2%'F-+%#&!'28!&"+#!"#2%'"*# *&/%"!,9;'$;&"*#<"". "*#$!&#&#"-/<0+#&/'2#'"98**!& 4" *%& '!.# %':,:#2 %' "*# $+%.%'!, $!&# %' +2#+ " 4#" "*# %'&-+!'$# $,!%. :#' "*#+8%&# !,&9 "*# 2+%:#+ '!.#2 !+/+##" %'4* &E !,;!+ %'4**!&<##'$,#!+,0.#'"%'#2%'"*#$*!,,!' +.%&&-#2<0"*# %&"+%$" 5!'!4#+9 !'2 #:#' <0 +#&/'2#'" %' "*# %'"%.!"%' ,#""#+ 2!"#2

A 8*%$* !+# &-

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

*#"*#+&/#!;%'4E+#!&'#2 #&E *#"*#++#/+"!<,# #&E