High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1065/2017dismissed

Union Of India & Others v. Malook Chand & Another

2017-07-31Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Arun Monga11 pages

$!%&'()* +"

!,$-(.--/%$)+0&)!!%+-%1+ 2-3-&

& 4&(& 0$1-$,3$-

&5,&

!"#$%&!"'(#&%% )"#*+!

!"#$%&!&% )"#*+!

,,,,

0& ,-$.+,%$+ !-5&

66666 &% )"

! ,$ -$& $&&$, - , ,$, *

89( :

; ,, <) - $ ,=&$ <($+ -$,.$-%-8!&->?;+2-<)

7A7@"

,$&>0$1-$,4&(&- !,$3-&?+-$&< $2,

-5!$%!-=$$,.!.!- .$ 55%$$-&$%!&5,

:0$1-$,-$,<-$ "A

+-52$&$55,$& C2&1 8C;

AA-2$&5=,$& 55&18 ;$, -9%-$!5=&2$& !!%/(5,$,:+ !!% /(5, $,:+ ,=&$ !!% $,:+ ,=&$ !!% $,: $, -$! / ,=&$

!!% %%,.-$=&=$,- .$55%$+- $!=, 5=& 2 ., <) - &$() (&+ + 0&)!!%(5DE8 !!%/(5,$,$, !!% /(5,$,; %(= (&+ A##$,-&)-$, <&(<F%$,F(,%$<)$(&%-&!-<($$$& &$.!=-5&! !!%/(5,$,

&.!%$F(,.=,$,

A72$&,,<)- $,=&$<($0$,$&%-4 $$%-$,$4&(&

!,$+!,<) !!%/(5,$,5=,$,-% <$&& * B 5&& ! !!%/(5, $, -$, !$ $%$ <2 A# A# - &$= =$, (!, ,( 2$ !

%(= (& 2+5$=$ ===8!&- ?; 2$& -, A# /%& 2 =$, - $!=, 5%,.&2%-$.,-$-$<$,.-(-5=& -$-2$&.$,&)+2-$&- 5%,.&&-(, -$<-,-<$&&!,$==.$,/) - 2 52$&$2,2-G($&-.- 5%,.&2-$ ,%-$55 <-,!* B$%$%&2-(%-$..- .$,$!-%==$$,)=$, A# 5%,.& -$!+ $- 2$&-, A7 +2-%-2$&$&G($&-,$,-=$2- .$,!.(5-$%$%&%(,

2$&%$&!-$55%$:&5,+0$1-$,+-$- -$, $ 5!,

-5=&+-$ %$ 5&&-,5$=(&,<.!!%$.5=$,- .($<$&&+-)%$=,&) <)%(.&%,, !!%$.%$5$%)-$!=, .$55%$2$&,&5&,

- !,,,$,

*89(:

@ ;+2-,%&2 &&(,-&5,&+-+%&,$55%$:&5,0$1 -$,$, $/.-!5=-5&!/,=&$ !!%(,-$(&$,!!(,!$,&($<+<. <!!5=2-!!%!=-,$&-==,$F(&-$, <.5= -$!=,,2$&$&&$,-&( <)!.

** !"

*,$&> !,$3 -& 4&(& $ ,=&$ <($ 3 -&?+ 2-%- 2$& ,&=&&,<)-&(,,,$,"

*89(:";

&$ &(-!+

B89(:*;$,"#

B89(:B;+ -!!%!%$$8 &;+0$)./%& .::-!E&$%-+=)$,G($&+2-%&,,- %$&!0$1-$,$.2- $/.-!-5(5&!5= -.$,!,=&$ !!%$,:!=-.$,! !!% /(5,$,$,%,-$$&5%==,$&!-

2 +-2$&%-$.-&)5& &&%+ $ /.-2$&5$%,$/

2-$&0$1-$,$ *B - $!=, ,&+ 9(& :* $, :B+ 2 %-$.,<) $/.-<!-<($2-- .$55%$ 2$&,&=&&,

..,<)-,,$,

#+- &$,,2$&$&&$,-&(<)!. ":

! "

7 $, -& %- ! -& ( ,,,$,

89(: ;$2,-25<)G($&-.-, ,$,

#5$&&,<)-<($$&2$&,,$,

89(:

;2-!(-,%-!!%$&5,&55$ $!&-&)&-5%5-$-&)!-!!%&-

. .$,! !!%/(5,$,:&-$<$!!%,$&.$&-) $$,-<%-=$1!D,E 2$&9%,,-$$!-%5!-,!- .-(+-$55%$&(<=,(=<!5&$&+!, - .$55%$$,$&.$%+2-%-2$%%,, +%&&$.-=! .$55%$ A*@ @"

- +,,,$,A

*89(:;+,&5&,!- .$ 55%$2-$,%-!!%$&5,&$1,%& - .$ % %=5$% ! - $!=, ,%&+ , =5(.,,,$,

B89(:

;+-!!%$&5,& F%,-%$&!-$55%$..%$(&!$%-=!- .$55%$+G(& 0& ,-$.+$, %(&5&. -5:

!,$&(<=,-$%=5$%!-,%&&&(,<)- 0$,$&%--,,$,

A7+-5&&&(,$,$ &)&"A

A77$,#

2 !

A7B 0$1-$, 2$& 5=, $& ,=&$ !!% $,: $,-% <$&& $, -$!-5=2$&.($&,2 !

A7B #

A7#+ $55%$:&5,2$&$&5=,$&,=&$ !!%$,: $,-$!

$& !!%/(5,$,:8$); 2-!!%!=-,$!.$5$&&(,*

A7* .

,&&$&!, 2- - $!=, ,+ &5,

:$55%$ 5!,

"B@ @"

+2-%-2$&,&5&,!<)-, ,,$,

2-$,%-$(-&%&,- 5&$!0$1-$,$55%$:&5,

C$,%(&!5:

!,$!(-&(<=,

-$-,&,$,

B89(:*;$,"#

B89(:

B;2)%-$.,<) $/.-<!-+2-%-2$&,&=&&, #

#+-(.- $/.-2$&&(%%&&!(<!-&(- +<(-&$=<!%$<.$,0$1-$,: &5,

-& & - 5= $& . - , ,$,

B2-F%.-5&$+2-%-2$&$&&$,- .$55%$<!-

0& ,-$.+$,%(&!5:

!,$ $& &(<=, -$ --$& !$, $55%$-!$% -$ - .$55%$2$&<$,<)=$$&-%$=!-$55%$: &5,-$,$)<F%,

B$&-&$,,2$& (5-, <) - - $55%$:&5, 2$& $ 5$) - $!=,25 -1,-!$%-$$55%$:

&5,%$<$2,$55$%--($.$$,$.$!- &$=%$(&!$%+$&-$!=, .$55%$2$&-<)

$,(.,-&(&:$&,-=5(.,,

-$ -$, - $, %(& ! - 5&+ $55$&,-5$5<1+=5(.,,$,$!-2-$-& =$,!%-&(<=&&&!0& ,-$.

(5+-!,.&%,,<)-$<$&, (5 - $55%$ ! - =$+ $1. - , ,$, B

,, ":!"

7%&,$

-5$5$!-&$=$,&-(&':

# $ ! %&

% ' ( ) * '

+ ,-*.

+ , -/% *.-01 . -(

'. '

, %

+ )$+

( +

% + + 2 " 1 % ' + & '

% + ' % $

+ +

% 3 2!-,%&.<)--,&,$,

*+-$(-&5$&&,2,&+ +

89(:*;$,"#

B89(:B;-,.-$-2$& %-$.-&)5& -$!=,,&$$=& ,%$.(,& -&$1!<)+-5$5$!-&$= $,&-(&':

45 !

+ + %

+ %

) )'!

"# )6 , 5 ! + +( ) * $+

( * 0 5.7

2$8#

98: 458$(8;"80 :

& %

)6 +:

)+) '

! ' ( )

* ' '+

! + %:45 %% ' * $+

( * =

0CH$$ /$55%$& /$/.- *# :,:

#7 $C$H$&-)$5

:,:

#A $FH$=$ B"

:,:

(%-$$$&&H$($ :,:

$/.-855%$;

:,:

/$F $2$ /$55%$&

0$1 -$, 855%$;

*B H$($/-(1$$& /$55%$&

0$= $F

=$ F( $55%$&

=/$.$

B# :,:

-$$$&$& /$55%$&

"# HH() :,:

/(<$=$$ :,:

** 0$-$,$ :,:

/-(=$-$,$ :,:

(,$& $=/,-( #* :,:

% * $( ' 9>;#% + % $1$ ;

)'! $1$

,5 !($ !

& % !+ + %:45 ' $+

( * ?.

;@ " 45 ! %

+ %

; ) )'!

)6 , 5 ! + +$+

( * $+

( *0 5. 7

2$8#

98: 458$( 8;80 :

+ +$+

( *

( *'-) . : + : % ' ' +

) +

% * $( ' ;$';% + % $1$ ;

)'! $1$

,5 !($

% % ' $+

( * '%:45

) )'! "# )6 ,5 ! % ' $+

( *

+ )$+

( % + % + * ) $+

( &

' '+

%+ +( ) * $( +$( $( %:45 0 5. 7

278#"

98: 458$( 8)A6580 45

# 278#"

;8:

458$( 8)A6580 45

# %

7% ,' ?. 5

0 $+

5 '

"($2<

< "8

++ 3 (

9; 4

* !8@ 45!

%0') 0' 5.7 $+%? & 4?B(24

78#"

;8: 458$(8;"8)A6580 45 @

# C -$.

:0/)04 5(2)(C4$04 $20C ( ?0 *:$40 (@ $462):$/0(@@50:*:$40 (2$55(D2(@ :0/0E45$*$2)/$5$250)@(:?0F0$:

2?060)

: ?B

2$8#

98:458$(

8;"80 :

6 %

' +

' $( '

$45 '+ ' $+(* + ' ( ) * 60) "

; ) )' 60) "

<"9<) , 5 + ?.5 $+

5 '

7 >'+

"($2<

< "8

#$ ++

: 45 ' % + 2$8#

98: 458$( 8;"80 :

6 %

!60) "

;

$ 2 + ) )' )5!

)) C )2

+)+ ) ,

)

)2 !

!60) "

<"9<

$ )2 "# + 6 ,5 )5!

5 4 )

2 ""! + )667 )2 "<! " + )C

$G7 4)0!

)0 4 !80 45 0' 5 5% = 6 %4 $

C -".-5.A-@.

$0 70 56)5/!5)5505((:4 0 E5 5:(.(!B6*7:8$4*0?B4*7:84 3

,&5(,)+-,!-&(-%$&! $/.- -$&$$,)<=5=, !$%+-<!2-%--$55%$:

&5,-$,&(.-5(&($%-F(,.=,, $/.-E& %$&8/(5$;2$&-5=&-$0$= $F-$,$&<5=, AA",&5-!$%-$-2$&F(-= 2$&+-(&+%$=,-$ $55%$:&5,2$&$&.<,!((5=$ $& != - ,$ 2- 0$= $F 2$& 5=, -& !$% 2$& %,<)-!!%$&5,&-%$&! $/.-+2-. -<!-)$"

"+2-$&-)-$,%-&&&-%$=! -$55%$:&5, !$%+-5&2G(,%&, -%$&!-$55%$:&5,$5$2--%$&! $/.-

(-+-,&,$,

B$,"#

B25$&&, - %$& ! $ /.- $& 2 $& 0$1 -$, F) &(%- %%(=&$%&+-$&.$&&.,<)-5&-=5(., ,,$,

B89(:

;-$-$55%$:&5,-$, %-$.,-$!=,,&-$&.-)<5,<)-

-<F%$1<)-5&&.$)(&(&$$< -,!

-&(,5$&&. !$,!$(!-$55%$: &5,+2-<)-5&-$<,%,2-%$&! - $55%$:&5, <) $1. %&,$ - , ,$,

89(: ;,,<)-&( ": ! "

- $55%$:&5, 2$& -, , %&G($<!$)$&$2,-%$&! $/.-$,- $%($ $$& -$< &%, -5, %==%. != =-& 5%,. - !. ! 5(& .$ 55%$ A*@ @"

"<)-$55%$

-&!%-&(<=&&!-$,%(&! -5&-$-%$=!-$55%$:&5,2$&&$@<$,<) $2!=$ !$%+-5&2G(,=5=- ,!-.-($,&5%&,.-!$%-$-, ,$,

B5$.<-0$1-$,$, $/.--$,< &:$&,

-$&&$!=,+2,!,$).$) $, 5&) -=5(., , ,, <)- -2 5+2-(5-,.-=5(.,,+&,&=&&,

8"'(#&%% 1 2&% 1 "#*+!

"#*+!

"34-) 56 8 8 79 5: ;<

= '

8 8 5>