High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15893/2014allowed

Jaivir Singh v. Haryana Urban Development Authority And Others

2024-01-18Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri13 pages

! " !

!#$%&'!%()*)&+, ,

#)-)./)+01

#.2#+#.3#+!%-%4&56%+$7$1&.)$2#+8&$1%.*

9 : , / / /

!"# $$$$

/ / ; , .#4 % & ' (()*((+ , - #. / # ((0+(0%1 2 34 / .

# 5 5 * # 5 6 56 57 8903 %:00 3 . ## # # # ; 6 57 . 5 '

. < 2 39 . = 5 0+*%401%88) #. /

' ( & ' .

.# ' 6 5 7 (109%844& . 5 ' # 5 5 . 5 # # 3 5& #/%0>%& # 6 57 '

?,?

# . /

--- & . # ;100:%88+@ . # 5 +903%(34+93AB3%:38:0*3 - . . '. 5 ' . .# 6 57 '

. # ; 5 5@. . # ' 6 57 '

---# . 6 5 '

- # & 2 31 '

. . # ;

! " #$ % & # '

& ( ) ! ( *+, )( -

- # $

" ( ./0 -1-2-.3 -1

) )) # ( 4 ./ 4/ ( ---56 2# ( ( ) "(6 "676855%85 (&# ) "

2, ,12,%9,,-,*("")" (" *

)

, / -, %:%753;%%.3%%

<78/ .7 .8=> 1 & . ## '

5 .

--- .#' . 5. . # ; %88+ . # ; 6 5. .

- ,6D+4%+(00%#. 5 5 .& . .

0(01(0%12 3+.

55'

# %8%0(0%( , /

# 5# 2 34. ' 5 . . . < 5# . '

@C . # ; 6 5

- # / / '

--- <

- .# .

/ ' # ;

- 5

. ' # # ' 5 . %88+

- . 5 5 E!# . . ' #

---

/ ' 0+01%88)%401%88)' . / /

--- . 5 E !# - . 5# 5##5. # '/5 # --- 5 . 567 @ F 5 # # 5 '/. 67 @ . ' 567. 5# 5 : " #' 5 .# '5

@ '5 . . . ' , A2A# # . 5 . . ' . #. 2 3%:- D( ' 5'

. . D: . .

6 57 .# (109%844 D( 3 5( & #&?

(& *&& #* @,< & 211 1 &)/ #6 * #&& $6

&=&

#* 11 211 &)/ #3 "

(

((& #) >

@ '5 . '

. # C3 . 6 5 7 '. 5 . 5 ' . # 5 . # 5 # ' # @

'5 ' . # '# . # .#

@ '5

. %88('

@C '@ E 5 C. # /# 6 57 52 38 .

, A# @C 5< ! # A# @C , #

2 38* . '

, A# @C 5< . '

. # 57 *5 # 2 ' %( 5 ' 57 @

'5 5. 5'

D%% '

# 5 6 57 6 5

5 . 2 38 38* @ '5 . ' D%% 5 @ '5 . '6 5 7 . # 5 5 < 2 38 38*. .

2 3%9

# 5 5 < . . . # * '

, A# '. # < 5

. < . @C # 5 < 2 3%9 5

' . <

5 5 E!# . '# 5'

. . 6 57 ' . # ; 5 E!# . < 2 3) @

'5 5 . #. 5 E !# < 5

" 2 3%).

5. # '

# &- . # / 6 5 7 . . '

! A# 5 6 57 . #/ 5 . 8903(03%%903AB3(93 %:00/5 . -&- %(003103 %9)03AB3:03(0:0' 0%0%%88)@ '5 #'

# . ' . / '# -&- # . 5. . '

! #A# . '

6 57 / 5 '. / # -&-

' . / '# 6 57 .

& 5# &- 3

8&& ) " "

538)?2 ## / && ) 122? ( & ,* & #

, 5(&# ) "$6

&=&(/ '

") " )

2,,2,%9, 2,A'

") " )*(353

,, 2, %9,, " "/ " ( *"

2,2,2,%9,1, 2A

,,1,%9,, 5( /) "<78&

333-3; " ()(?

" '5 , 0:08(0%8 # 5 @C . # #' 6 5 7 . '5 . . . . ' . '

@C . # 6 '@ A# # 5 . # '

@ '6 5' @ B , , A ' 5 = 3,G ! %884 %9 / 6 57 . -&- *& * A *6 5& @C

! (008. D1: / 6 5 7 '5 -&- & '5 @ '6 5'@ B , , A ' 5 = 3, G ! %884 5 ' # ' '

. . .

5# #5 . ' %884. . # ; %88+ 5 . / # ' ! @C = 3,

(008 5. 55 5. '

'5'. . 5 5 ' . ' 5# 5'

/ . . '

, 5. . .# # ; %88+ .

. ' . / #' . ' ' ' 5 6 57 # . # / @ '5 . &-

2 3%) # /. / '# 6 57 9 7 #' '5

5' . '

@C @ . '5 . # ; %88+ '

(0%: 5 '

5 5' ) - + # . 5. .

.# (109%844 ' # 5 ' ''

& 6 57 ',

--- & %88+

100:%88+2 31 . # ;' 5 5 5 . . . ' 3 @C & . ' '

5 5. 5 %884 . . ' @ '6 5

. . # @C 5.

(008 '5' ! '< '

. # / ' . . -&- ',

--- 6 57 '< '

, A# 5 2 3838*' . # ' '# 5 5 < . < 5#' 2 38* 5 ' &- 5 '

/ '5' ' /-&- ' - . # '5

. .

. / 5 .

'# 6 57 .

# ,

--- 4 5 ' 5

5 E!# < '# ''# 6 57 # . # ; 6 5 < 5## -

5 6 57 # 5 5 . . .# .

. # ; #

6 57 . / # 5

## 5 5 ' 5. . ' , . .

, # . '

. ' '

. ' ' ' 5 '

. 6 57 5. .

.# . 6 57 5 ' # ;#

6 5 7 ' 5 2 31

. ! '< ' 5 5& . . .

/ 6 57 .

5 & '. . 5 . ' .'

5 # &- . '@C 5. . . # ; . . . / 5. . . # 4 -. 5 .& 5# ((0+(0%1 2 34

/ & # ' 5. . # # ' 6 5 7 5 /' '

2# . 5 . . # ; 8 & '

. . ' 145 # # . #. H)I 5 , ,

/ / + ( ! 6 # *D 6 ' *D