Karnail Singh v. State Of Haryana & ANR




    
     

  !"# $%&%!'()*)+

                (!',-.  /)0&%$  )) '2/%  ! !"#$ %&' !! #$ %&  ! (#$$)# 

)) '2/%3) / .

*'#+  

 

-.

'&%&%.( /&  0  1

 % $2  3 &% 4 %. 
* ( 5( $(.  1 -633 '    %&#    &+  (&   (    7   &"

5%(+ & 68 6898 &% 4       &  %&&      7  5%(

$4'&     ' &        1 1681  4     

 &     166                 0  (&  & &  . (
: ;

&#'5 &<

*& + . &(=  

'& & (&. (
:

;

&#'5 &< *#+

 . *+=

& && +   ( !&#

-4 #   '&&'*+=

&0 (%

0  %&  $&&  #       (%

  (  %&    

-  &        ( ( & &% ( (9 &< *
+ #0./&

.

 1

 4#

7 & %( #&   %& (1 -633 1 1681
 *                 75$  (  1 1681   

-4 %"( &  

+  &( + ( & %       &    &&(&#          & (' 
**'  .(  &(# %"

%''( (% (%&4 &%.".  4  %& &%  ( $23 4 #    ..  1   &#    &       9  

.(  $23# 0  & &  & &  % $2, -   &  0%&%.( .  & . (&& & 2( (
: ;

&#'5'& .9 &< : *. '
*( # (( ."''&&<

 '&&< *4 #

  ( 

(.( 75$&

 ;( ( (  & &% ( (9&< *'  .4.  &   .  (&  2(  ( 
  :     ;

&#'52'&< 9 &< 4 #&.< (

- (/ ( (%&&& (  ( 92(&  (  4# $23#  0 #%&  ."  
%%&>(

$? #& % '.

( + .& 2( #'&   9 @ Order which may be passed by appellate authority (i) in the case of appeal against an order under Rule 9 or any penalty specified in rule 4, the appellate authority shall consider : ─ (a) whether the facts on which the order was based have been established;

(b) whether the facts established afford sufficient ground for taking action; and (c) whether the penalty is excessive, adequate or inadequate and after such consideration, shall pass such order as it thinks proper;

Provided that no penalty shall be increased unless opportunity is given to the person concerned to show cause why such penalty may not be increased;"

%        &    &&(&#     

  %   $2  3    '         (  

-.

  
'  '%#( (         2(    &      .   &

.  & .(&2( & &  (    &<    9&<  %   4  

&.2( '   %& &

 . ' ( (   ))

)*)+   / "A BA 2 2 / 4!/ -. (  &5!