High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15210/2015dismissed

Shri Ganesh Fire Equipment Pvt Ltd v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2016-03-22Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih14 pages

!" !

# $% &"'( ) *$&'+, !

- .+& (+ /012 ( 3* +04+($&5 4$& &4 .+ 6&4

7(0( .&" 8&9& *+(

(1 (

++ 1("'&1&1(2&69&:*(+80*42 ;

++9"*+ 1( ; < +++80*42 (+0*91* +4(;

( ) $ 75.+,*'&,"+1 $ .

0,** &*'& &, 8&9, "+(1 ( ==== +1 +&('+& 4*'&0(

".' 7"+ '+ '& .1'"'& ( " & * *&* !> !- ((0* 96 + (1 ( 49*(""&9'& & *(0116"&20101(" * ("&&(/0( "('21 (, &26,+1021,9 6 " + 2&5( (1'"* +

+ 1021( 2& 0"&'0* 96 + 1 & '0**

+ (1 ( 96 & ' *&* !> !- * 9*( " + "&9'& & * (0116 " 20101( " * :+ & : ( 4+ ( '&1&'6 " ?*(&( 2& &42 " "4+ 4 & * ('0@ 1& ( &0(

:+'+(2104 * +(1 &*(&(0 *)A

!" # $" %

&" ' (") *

#" "

+ ( ,+ - . " " "

") ) "

" ) # #

/ &0(( & *

< (10& + 1"2& ' 1&&2( " +1021 +&(&+'&0((&(+&(10&+((+&+ 1021 :0* 9 (098' ( : 2 * &, + 1 B( 4& '(+& + * ' * (2 + 2&5("+ 1021 9 0C* +( 2 * '&0(

( ' ** +& +( ( *('2 &6,&9&6& *0 "&&(D'0*(+2& 0"&'0(:+( 1021(&/0&6(0&9& *2+/0(1&&2( < + (1 (B 12 &6 98' + ""' +& + 1 ( 2& & &9 &( + 1 ( & 9** ( : "0 ** (0+&2(*'**'&((& 4 *(*&:+ '+& 4(904+96&4& (+9**(1(1'9**( +6& &(904+96 * 49**(' * 4+&+6+&9 : 46 +*9 49& *96+(:+&0 &91&'1& + * 1'((9'&0("+/02 ("+ *' * (+6&0 &9 "0" +&'+& 4+2 + **'02 ((" A && + 40 * +& ( &9&6, 0 &( &9, 0 "& +:( 4& + & 9**( :+ '+& 4 + 496 " + 9**( '** '&(( +& & * (0'+ '+& 4( &0( 40 *( + &0+( (0'+'&((,+:,* 9&+2& & &96"&' ( (0'+ &( + 9" 0( +6 * *& :+ & '&( (0'+ &( + 9"0( 20(,+",*&:++' ( 2(

&0& (0'('& ).1'& " '

" !

& (0 '+"+.0120& (:*+" ' 2&*96+ (* " *&0 *' E<# %"+ (0 " *& 1&&4&1+AF-,:&(+*)A 01

"2 "3 4" "

" 5 " "65

7 " "

" "

""88888889 3 4

" " " " " " 3 0& * 3 0&* " 0&1* '") # ")

" " #

# " 2 "" 3 4

#" ""/

21&&4&1+AF :&*(,+.0120"*+ 2&

:+'+'A E+&*9 *&:+ 9(*+&"+"( '01"*'&*(+?'&(("'& (B:&(&*1*:+'+&:*"& '&(("'& 9: ( &( 4 &( :&( 9&(* & 49 *"" && **(1&6*&& & D0(:++02&98'"+ 1'6 :&(9(*+&&"+80*42 "+.0120

,+G&9& ((B*' :&( *0'* :+'+ *11* & 1*& ' &11&'+ :&*( /0&6 & * +*+2D( '"&9& ((&(&"' E,+: /0& ( &2 & * +& 90* 4 01 + 1 **

6&11&B('&(#(01&%,+&4:&, , !" #$%& ' ( ) * +

,+, *0'* + 1 '1 " &( &9 (( & * +*+&4&6&(:&(1+(1+'&6&( &9 ((,(& (( & 2 "/0&6 A&9& (( +.0120+*)A

;& 0,0* . <

4=0> 3?$ 0,0 < 1=@

""3 4"

!"# "")>&<

+1 * 8?

) )

!"# )

)

) " # 2" " " " " 7" " " "

" "

!"# " )

) # # )

" " "") "" ) " " " #

") " ""

!"#

" " ) " 2" " 7" " " # "6 " " "

!"#

" "" "

!"# )" " ") ")

!"#

) " ) " " # ) )"" " " "/ "" 4(&+80*42 (,+.0120 +*)A %" "

" "

)

" " "

" " " " " " "

" " "3 4 "

"" 3 ) " ") " ) "

" " " "" ;& 001* . <

,0@

< " " """ 73 4"

" " "

"6 " "6 "

) " #" "

" """ "

" 7

? " "" "

" ) " " ) " 3

""3 4

" 3 4"

"""? / - +2(& *' * ("+ '( 4 *(20( &( (&("6 + 2& *& "' +6 20( 9 &( &9, "& & * & & +620( 90 "&&9&6 +(1&&2(,+:, & ('*+(098'2&" '( 4 *( +620( 9D **& 6+ 4&( 4+"2,&*+ '

' +:+ + .& & * ( (02 &( & + &4( :

( & * 0(( " + & B( (0'( 2&9 & * 22&9, & 49 & * & 49 9( & 6+ 4(,6'C ( *1&'1& + .&('22'& 0(9"1'0 44*(& *('(:+( *(1( 4 " +:( *& 4 :+ ( (0'( 1&'0& 'C '&

9D'0**&9&6&+:+2(& *"& '("+.&( (02 &(+& *( > +( 1 '1 :0* 9 ''02 * " + .& ( (02 &( &12* 2 &9&6 & *:+0 80("'& + 2&5(I9& *( " + 1*0'( & * 2&& +& 4 2&5 01 & * +2& 0"&'0"+" &1*0' (1':+"+9*( & * + .& '&

9 D1'* (1&& 9*( " + (09(*&6& '&61*0'(+&"2&1&"+2& 1*0'/0* 96 *"(0'+(09(*&6& '&61*0'(2&6 ,+", 9((0* "+.&/0*(0'+(09(*&6& '&61*0'((", :0* 9 *D'0*& 61&'0&9**:+0&*&(

( &( + 12 4+.&D'0*+2& 0"&'0(

(011("(0'+(09(*&6& '&61*0'( + *1'(( &*"&'/0 4+2& " &1*0' + &1( B(1*0'( &D'0**"2+("1*0'(0(* '

' :++1*0' ":+'+9*(& *,+4+("+1&6 (* (0'+& '&6 (09(*&6 1*0'( & &6 &""'* .0'+ 1&( &, +", * '+& 4 + &' " + .& &( 9 4 &9&6, 0 "& & * +:(4& + '+& 4 + 2& & &96 " + 1 + 40 *+&+1 ( &9**20(,+","&

+.&(,+:, * ((01 +/0&6"+ 1*0'( & * ('( 9 &'/0* 96 ' "2 4 '& (1'"'& (& *2+(10&*1&&2( +.&( * (0+(96& 6&( &92& (

&5 " (& ', *( " + (0116 " 2&'+ 6 + 2& 0"&'0 " (0'+ 2&'+ 6 /0( + 0( " (& '21 ( :+'+ : +& "* &( (09(*&6 & '&6 1*0'( 1&6 4 *( " (10&( & ( " &11* 2& 0"&'0( & * (011("2:+2(0'+1*0'(&99& *96+9**( (

'((&6 6'&("+1&6 49*(11&&("+ &11*(011( (1'"&'+ * +62&6*( &'&( '&(9&((90+&( &:&6( '((&6 +&(&'&((:+ 1&(11&&("&11*(011( &*& ',"' &'(9 * + "00 +( 9&( *&6 :+ + * " (0'+ 1*0'( ('( &(( + 9*( 2&6 + 9 * 6 "2 (0'+ &11*2& 0"&'0((011( +("/0&6+& 4&&*69 *&5 9611& 4& &11*("2& 0"&'0(& *(011(,+ *&6(9&*:+ +9*(&9 *

. 4&(+((&11* &&( &9& *"&2&

, + (10& +( ""' '&

9 +* 9 &9&6 0 "& + 1&6 4 *(( **2 +2&

:+'++(" &11* (011( 2& 0"&'0( ( 9 &* & + ( ( "20& " + (&2 + 2* & * 2&

:+& 2&6 9 20( ' "2 + ' (0 & 2& *& " &( &9 (( & * "& (( ('+: 4 &9& (( & * 0 "& (( & ' 01 & '22 " D1("+(101(( (0'+2+* +(2+*2&69(* (1'&6:++1*0'(('(&/0*"+1"2& '" :5"0 ' ("&( ( &0

< +.01208'*+(092(( +&+2& *&" ' E(+&& 6*(1(&" &0&(0'("'22'&0(20( 9" 02&D2C& & *+0(96&0'

:&(+*+&*(1(&" & &0& (0'( +04+ &0' ( & ' (0 & 2& *& #1&&4&1+A !% :&( &( 9(* +& + .012 0 +&* &

029 " ''&( ( ** 80*42 ( *' 4 2& ( " *(1(& "

&0&(0'(++& 96&0'

(& ', ( % %

- *. % /0.,11 +

11,+.0120+*)A , 3 " " " "

" " "

" # " " "

"":" ) 7

"" """ ) ? ") ) "6 "" " " ""#" " " " "

"# " " " "

" " """ " "

" "

" ")

" "

" # ) #" " )

" " "

") 7

" " "2 ) "" ""

: " "

" "# ) #

+.&& *+ (02 &("+.&&,+", *&0*&*1+:

'+ /0("2& &42 "18'( & *:5( +(9(& (& 2*' 2'1'( +6 '& & * ** 20( 9 D ** + (1+( " .& &'( & * &' (&(:51 4 2 *&:&6(+&(0'+&' 20(2+: (&9(+*(( +620(" (& '9&( &9& *"&, &9&6 0 "& " 4 *( +* 4109'&0' ('&

&:&6( 9(&*9&9&6,0 &( &90 "&,":(+&&*'( 1'04*("'& 2&5(9& *(/0&6'&

&:&6(9(&* 9&9&6,0 &( &90 "&

J1 4+((( 2 *: 20( :*2 :++ '&0(

(&( &9,& && *"&& &,&9&6+:( 4& ? #

;&* <

==@

< "

>6 ! 8 ? " " ") ) " "

" AB > " :

" " ""

) " 7

" "6" " " "" " " "2

)" /

- ( + ' 4 9*( (" (&9(+(, + (1 ( * 9*( " + (0116 " 4*(, &26, "&9'& & * (0116 " 20101(" *,:+'+&1"2 621& 90'0'&

"(& 4"0 ' (& *&'( +21& '"" *(/0(

&9&

(("* (4+6 ' **+' &6 * :(+ 2&4 + ' (/0 '( " (0'+ 4*( 2&"0 ' 4 0 *1"2 :&( 6 '((&6 90 (( &"+(1 ( (01'02 "+9(/0&6" *(":+'+1021(&&&'21 &(&("*+&+6 +&* ( &&( &9& *"&2&

"&'&((* "2:+& & (1*&"+(1 :&("*,+(1 (B. %+&9 (&9(+*

: "( " + "&'( &* 4 + (1 (B *'( 2 + 2&5 " + 1021( +( 2& 0"&'0* 96 + 2& 0"&'0( : + *2 (& +: *0 4 + '0( " +( 1'* 4(+1 (:4 & 110 6:++' ( " +(1 ((&9(++/0&6"+1021( :,+&4 '6 (044(*96+1 (+2(((092*& &*(1&90 +1021(

> (+&""*& 16(&(,+20101(" *( 0(*"""4+ 4& *('01& ( + "&2(+&1*0 " + " *( &((29* 96 +2& 0"&'096 0(0' 4+ +(2&'21 (:+'+& (&* +2& 1*0', &26,+ 20 101( " * + 1021 "2( & (( & '21 + :5 4"+2& 1*0' +I"0 ' "+1021('0'& +( (&*2* J1 4+21& '"+1021 2 *,+(1 ( *'** (5 + 1 " D1( '22 :&( "2* " + 10'+&("+20101(" * "&'+& *1'(( &* F

:&( '& '* & * + 1( * 1'(( :&( &*&"+&"(&*D'(:&(0 *&5 "*2 4+9(

/0&6 " 1021( 9 0(* + 2& 0"&'0 " + 20 101( " * +'22:&("2*96& **&* E E"+ 2 " 8&9, 3'& 2 1&2 #0( .'( % + * (&* +& ( 4+ + " 94&* + .& "

8&9F

F!'(+&*9 (& ' *"+10'+&(""('0 /012 & *2&'+ 6 +*(&*+&"+(101(&'22 "+""'(2 *+ :&(' (0* +'22'21(* " + ** & 'A'02A22(( , $0 '1& 1& , $+&,++" 4 #0(%3'& 2 1&2 , 8&9, + .01 4 #'+ '&%, $0 '1& 1& , $+&, +106 ,$0 '1&1& ,$+&,+(((& $& *&

""', $0 '1& 1& , & && & * + (((& ( &

""',$0 '1&1& ,(+&10 +22:&(/0* A&&(1'"6+2&5" + 1021 + /0&6 " + 1021 :0* (0 + /0&6 " + 20101( " * + '22 * (044( ( "2 + '+ '&D1("+*1&2 :+1 *+&+9(1021(&&&9 +2&5:+(2 * '&0(

+22&''1* +'22 *& ("+:** &( & ""'(*&* !-

+ : ( +&* (04+ + 1 "2 &0( + 4& C& (+&+&*1'0*(2&/012 + 64+3:

((0 021 +&* 1*6 9 0(* + .& " 08&&, +, &6& && *$&+&&(+& +" ""'(+.& ""'( +' .'("+(.&(' "2*+&+6+&*9 0( 4 + 61021((&("&'6

+'22&('22 **++2&5(2 * '&0(

''* 46'&0(

(10&*+&+1021(20(9" + 2&5 2 * '&0(

+ 1 +&( /0( * + /0&6"+2&5((10&* '&0(

+22B(*'( '0*+1021("+2&5( 2 * '&0(

,+",9"&0* +1 +: '+& 4(+D'0( "+1021(2& 0"&'0*96"2'&0(

+ + .& ( (02 &( ( *( & * (1'"(+&11*2&5(,2& 0"&'0((011(,+620(91 ' (* 4+2& 0"&'0(,(011(& *2&5(&(: ( **

1((9"+1&6 4 *(' (*62& 0"&'0, 6 (011 & * 6 2&5 :+ (1'"6 4 + ( " &11* 2& 0"&'0(, (011( & * 2&5( :, " & *2& * ( 2&* 96 & 1&6"+& 4(1*0'(('(&(' (**,+1&6 4 *( 20( & + &11'& & * &0& + (&2 ( :

2( '&

*('2 &6"0(' (*+1 ( +04+ +(2&6 9 '((&61((9"+ * /0( &+&1 "2,:0*9 '((&6"+"00 +(("+&( +&" 22&6 12& &0& &+2" 49*( +: 2& 6'&((926&*"&'(9&5 ' (*& +(D'( ( +1((9 *(&9 02&+2 +"&'(& *+ '29 & +"&(:&(+:4+&494 &'+"+2 :*"""2'&('&(& *&2( "2 * * +( :0**1 *01 ,0(+&++&'5 6*900("01+&(,+"&'( & *''02(& '("&'+'&(

+1 +&(9 4 &"&110 6"+& 4( 1*0' ' (** " + * /0(

( '+ "

:+'+ " 0( #.

7&C"*&, % :&( & 1&6 1&((* + ": 4 **&*!<

" ) " #

" C # " )

" "

"# ?

)

% D E % E

" C

" "

) )" "

% D E

% D E - "

" "

)

#"" "

% D - "

" "

"" " " " #

% D - "

"" "

" 2 "

% D E % E

7 "

: "

" 3 2" " +/

+ +" ""', + (092* & 1 *&*

+ (&2 :&( &

D* 96 + (1 ( & 4:+ + &""*&*&* !

+1 A&&&*(&(0 *)A

" " "4 ) " " F

G" "

" '-( ) #

)

"" " "

" ") " ") # " " # "

" # )2 "

" ") #

" " )" &

" *? "

" >3"#

) "

#" " "")

>6 < <"

% D E % < # * < 3H &E#"D E % < # * . < <2 H

&3""

E % < # * 4< G 9 < &$

# " "" " " """<3<G* +< 9 <

3E%D &$

# "E " ("!"# 2* 1 < G H "

E " &$

# "

" < ! % 7 &*( */ < +& *'0 (&11& 4 9+&""+1 (&* +&+104+98'*&(+1( &"+(1 ( :&( +1& +(092(( ( :"0 ** +' '0* 41& " + 1 (&() ?+ ( :&( ' *0'* 0 * + (01( " ": 41& 229(@ + &2"+(1 (B1( &( '0** :, + (1 (B 1( & ** &0& + +&0& :&(96++" ""'&(/0*96+* *&*!<

+&0& :&( 96900 *+(01( " +(D1( (2 *+

+*09,"& 6, +(&(1'((& (96+"&'+& +(1 (B1( &:&(1( & *+(

&2 &( &11&( + 1 & 4:+ + &2 " + (1 (B 1( &

&'* :+ +(, + 1 6 4 01 (& 1( ' **+&+1"+ ""'( ''& *+&+**

&116+''1&&2(

&&"&*+&( 1((9"0( &1 0 * ' -"+ (0 " *&&*80*'&01 +(2&( +"&'(& *''02(& '("+('&(:&(&("*+&+(1 (

** D'0*+1 (1*0'(&9&60 "&6 **+6 2+2&5(+((1'"* '&0(

0 80(6:+& 69/0 2 +(1 (B*'( :&( +9( ("109'(&"6 - +''02(& '(,+1 (*(2((* #.

7K % .

!< - #

33% G& *B √